On 2/21/2024 10:52 AM, AMuzi wrote:
> On 2/21/2024 9:36 AM, Frank Krygowski wrote:
>>
>> Again, you seem to not have thought about this very deeply.
>>
>> Explain why criminals are penalized by imprisonment.
>>
>> The usual answers are 1) To teach the criminal to obey laws in the
>> future, and 2) to protect people from those who have not (yet?)
>> learned to obey laws.
>>
>> But our system of imprisonment doesn't seem to achieve those goals.
>> See below.
>>
>>>
>>>
https://www.macrotrends.net/countries/ranking/murder-homicide-rate
>>>
>>> Murder Rate- Canada (2017) 1.819
>>> U.S. - 5.244
>> So the U.S. has a much higher imprisonment rate than Canada. If
>> imprisoning so many people taught criminals to obey laws and protected
>> people from crime, the U.S. would have much lower crime rates.
>>
>> It isn't working. Doing the same thing over and over despite failure
>> is insanity.
>>
>
Yes. Wow, who would have imagined that letting every yahoo in America
carry a gun everywhere might lead to so many mass shootings, right?
And did you note the firing rate heard from about 0:13 to 0:15 in that
video? "Let's make sure the idiots can empty a magazine in two seconds!"
As discussed over and over, there are well established legal and
financial reasons for our bail system - like "No new taxes!!!" for example.
You've presented nothing but individual anecdotes about shootings by
those out on bail. I suspect those particular perps are a very small
percentage of the problem.
But as always, you're welcome to present systemic solutions. Perhaps "As
soon as anyone is arrested, imprison him or her until trial. We'll raise
taxes to build the jail capacity. We'll do away with 'Innocent until
proven guilty' and remove judges' discretion."
And perhaps "All convicted felons will receive life sentences. We'll
imprison an even higher proportion of our population."
Never mind the fact that no similar strategy seems to be working. We
imprison more than anybody, and still suffer much higher crime rates
than similar countries.
--
- Frank Krygowski