Job had the same idea, at least about himself:
Suppose I have sinned, what have I done to you,
You tireless watcher of mankind?
Why do you choose me as your target?
Why should I be a burden to you?
-- Job 7:20, Jerusalem Bible translation
> Breaking one of the
> made-up "bedroom rules" of the church is not immoral, although a
> Catholic may consider it a "sin."
The hierarchy consider it to be a sin of "disobedience."
They stretch the commandment "Honor your father and your mother"
to include what they call Holy Mother Church.
> The only sins to my way of thinking are when you wrong another person,
> and then the confession and absolution should be asked of them - not
> the priest, god, or a church.
A little understood part of the repentance that ought to go with confession
is that of making proper restitution to the one wronged. Very few Roman
Catholics pay sufficient heed to it.
> That little difference would probably go a long way to reducing
> recidivism and immorality. You would be bound to fixing your mistakes
> and suffer the humiliation of admitting them.
Yes, but some atheists are equally guilty, including some regulars
in talk.origins. As are some regulars who are very secretive about
what religion they may or may not have. The operative principle of
quite a few people in either category seems to be:
If I don't admit to having indulged in despicable behavior
(e.g. libel) I can go on indulging in it as long as there
are significantly more t.o. regulars who will take my side, than
will take the side of my accusers.
> >> >
> >> >>> Oh no, life was not just about getting to the death bit and leaving a
> >> >>> swathe of selfish destruction behind. There is a just judge to meet.
> >> >>
> >> >> Life is just a rehearsal for death? That is dismal, but fear, gloom
> >> >> and doom is your thing.
> >
> >It is indeed. "Michael Christ" [somehow I don't think he was given
> >that name by his parents] seems to think the main reason God put
> >us on earth was that he could put us on trial the way he put Adam
> >and Eve on trial.
>
> I think Christianity in general is bonkers. I think we all need to
> strive to be better (moral) but that it is an individual journey. All
> the philosophic lip-service in the world won't make you a better
> person. You have to want to be better and to do that you have to see
> your actions in that light and "own them."
>
> I think Christianity is evil because people use it to shift
> responsibility on to a god
I don't see that in Roman Catholicism at all.
> when they should be owning up to their
> responsibility.
> >
> >> >That's atheism. But you can pretend.
> >> >
> >> I will fear no evil - gods.
> >> >
> >> >>>
> >> >>> You scream for justice in this life but why, what's the point?
> >> >>
> >> >> Satisfaction.
> >> >
> >> >Because it is right, but you are wrong and you can't reconcile that.
> >> >
> >> >You're going to get justice though, I promise you, but you ain't going
> >> >to like it because you are going to get exactly what you deserve.
> >
> >That's the Jack Chick attitude also. A good example is Chick's pamphlet
> >that shows a Roman Catholic being condemned to hell for "Not accepting
> >Jesus as his Lord and Savior" -- mere good behavior be damned.
> >
> Projecting their own fear on others.
> >
> >>
> >> You are just projecting your own small cowardly personality on others.
> >> >
> >> >Grace and mercy is what you need but no proud self-righteous bastard to
> >> >date has received it because they are too damned right in their own eyes
> >> >and don't give a fuck about the truth.
> >> >
> >> >Yes, that's you.
> >>
> >> I'm proud, self-righteous? I guess you don't even own a mirror then?
> >
> >Michael seems to be "too damned right in his own eyes," too.
> >
> He is certainly a special case all right.
We used to have one who was somewhat like him in talk.origins: Ray Martinez.
One difference was that he was a lot harder on Christians than he
was on genuine atheists. He justified his behavior by calling someone
an "Atheist" if that person did not believe in the immutability of species.
Since all the Christians he argued with did not go that far in
the direction of creationism, all were stigmatized with that label,
including myself, an agnostic.
Peter Nyikos
Professor, Dept. of Mathematics -- standard disclaimer--
PS In the interests of full disclosure, I should admit that
I have kept up my membership in the Roman Catholic Church
despite being what might be called "90 percent atheist"
[as far as confidence level in there being a God or gods]
because it gives untold millions of people who lead miserable lives a
hope (though not full confidence in most cases) that there will
be an afterlife in which they will finally find relief from their miseries.