Preserve manual sort through cloud sync?

161 views
Skip to first unread message

uh Clem

unread,
Mar 10, 2011, 11:45:49 AM3/10/11
to MyLifeOrganized
It it possible to preserve manual sort order between two PCs when
using the cloud sync?

I know it can't be done when using the iPhone. But I just installed
MLO on my laptop, and the sync worked fine EXCEPT that my manual sort
order was overriden by automatic. (The items in the To-Do tab are the
same, jsut not in the same order.)

Now I'm afraid to sync back to the desktop, for fear of losing my
carefully worked out sort order there.

Does anyone know how this works? (I tried finding it in the forum and
documentation, with no luck)

Ideally, of course, I'd like to be able to drag things around in the
manual sort order on either PC and have them reflected on the other
one after syncing. But I'll settle for not doing any harm.

Andrey Tkachuk (MLO)

unread,
Mar 16, 2011, 6:22:40 AM3/16/11
to MyLifeOrganized
MLO Sync does not support any View settings including manual sorting.
So if you create new views or change default views (including manual
sorting) they are not synced.
Manual sorting supported in Starred view only. So the order entered on
on PC will by synced to other PC or iPhone or BlackBerry or Android or
Windows Mobile.

A.

d00g

unread,
Dec 21, 2016, 3:37:40 AM12/21/16
to MyLifeOrganized
So - here's a use case I encounter all the time: if I am in the Outline view, and I have a folder with, let's say, 3 tasks (Task 1, Task 2, Task 3)... and I check off "Complete Subtasks in order" for the folder -  "Task 1" shows up in my action list as intended.

However, after I sync to another computer, it gets the order mixed up  (Task 2, Task 3, Task 1) - Now I cannot rely on my action list, because it will display "Task 2" as my next action. 

Is there a solution to this or am I stuck?

Roberto Penzo

unread,
Dec 23, 2016, 11:22:40 AM12/23/16
to MyLifeOrganized
I am still dreaming that in the near future MLO features at least one manual sorted view synchronized.
Dreaming is still allowed...

Dwight Arthur

unread,
Dec 25, 2016, 10:42:56 AM12/25/16
to mylifeo...@googlegroups.com

Hi, d00g. Let's start by reviewing the difference between outline order and display order.

Your tasks are saved in your profile in an outline. If you do "collapse all" (f6 on Windows)  you will see the root items (tasks, projects and folders) in their outline order. If you click on the triangle-shaped "twisty" in front of one of the root items it will reveal that item's next layer of subtasks, and so on to the bottom, or you can just hit f7 to fully expand the outline. The order that the tasks are in, in the outline, is the outline order. 

When you do a full synch (as opposed to branch synch) to another device the procedure preserves the outline order (as opposed to the display order, discussed below) across devices. I have never experienced a failure to preserve outline order, I don't recall anyone else reporting such a thing, and if it were to happen it would mark quite a serious bug. I doubt that this is what's happening to you.

Whenever you are looking at a display of your tasks, the formatting and content of the display are defined by a view. You may not have explicitly chosen a view but it's there, controlling your display. In the left sidebar in windows (different methods in Mobile) you can bring up the specifications controlling your current view. One of the sections is called sort and it controls the display order.

The sort section can call for three types of sort order. My names for them are outline order, manual sort, or programmed sort. In outline order the items are displayed in exactly the same order as they are stored in the outline. In manual sort, you drag the tasks into the order you want and they stay in that order until you move them. In a programmed sort, you select some fields within the item, like importance, or context, or due date and the view shows the tasks sorted as you specify. 

If you look at the sort section of your current view definition you will see an on/off selector for manual sort.  If this is on, you are seeing your tasks in manual sort order. If it is off, you are seeing either outline order or programmed sort. There is a list of several sort criteria in the sort section. If manual sort is off and the criteria all say something like (none) then you are seeing outline order. If any of the criteria show anything other than none, then you are seeing a programmed sort.

These sort selections do not get propagated by synch. If you change a sort selection on one device and you want to see it on another device, you have to make the same change on the other device. Or you could export the changed view, copy the export file to the other device and import it.

Also, manual sort is specific to a view. That is, you could have two manually sorted views on the same device, and the tasks could be in an entirely different order in each view. Reordering tasks in one view will have no effect on the task order in the other view. 

Manual task order is synched for only one view, the starred view. There is no way to enamel manual order synching for any other view.

One last wrinkle: it is unfortunately very easy to turn on manual ordering without meaning to do so or knowing that you did.

Ok, the diagnosis: I suspect that your tasks are actually in the same outline order on your two devices but that the sort selection is different, causing a different display order. Second guess: you are displaying your tasks in manual sort order and the manual order is not propagating.

Please look at the sort order on your two devices. If it is different, please change it to be the same. If you are using manual order, did you are doing so intentionally, please consider using the Starred view, which is the only one which synch the manual order.  Otherwise please consider giving up on manual sort. Using the All Tasks view, turn off manual sort and set all of the sort criteria to "none" and you will see the tasks in outline order. Do this on both devices and changes to task ordet made on one device will be synched to the other. When using drag and drop to reorder tasks, if you get a popup asking if you are trying to enable manual sort, say "no".

Hope this helps,

--
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "MyLifeOrganized" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to mylifeorganiz...@googlegroups.com.
To post to this group, send email to mylifeo...@googlegroups.com.
Visit this group at https://groups.google.com/group/mylifeorganized.
To view this discussion on the web visit https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/mylifeorganized/d52a7703-a238-499a-b0eb-f2f3f9fb7836%40googlegroups.com.
For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/d/optout.

d00gus

unread,
Jan 6, 2017, 11:37:59 AM1/6/17
to MyLifeOrganized
Wow, thanks for the detailed response Dwight. I could have sworn that it happened in an outline view - i have a bunch of views that i save to the cloud and then duplicate in my other MLO instances. It's possible that I had 'manual sort' enabled in one of these views. I am going to do some research when I get a chance and see if I can't replicate the problem. Maybe it's like you say and the sort order was manually set :)

Thanks again for the info.

Roberto Penzo

unread,
Nov 25, 2018, 7:06:52 AM11/25/18
to MyLifeOrganized
Hi all folks.
Today I was wondering if the situation is still as it was 7 years ago. I am now using a different ToDo app (GTasks and similar ones) mainly for this unbuilded feature of MLO.
Reply all
Reply to author
Forward
0 new messages