On Thu, Oct 10, 2019, at 7:49 PM Adrian Musceac <
kant...@gmail.com> wrote:
>
> Maybe unrelated here, but the fact that everybody maintains and uses their own version of gr-osmosdr
> (with patches) is a bit worrying and kind of against the very purpose of the library - to integrate support
> for as many devices as possible.
The fragmentation derives from the maintainer of gr-osmosdr ignoring
all the patches sent on the list for years.
BTW the people at
osmocom.org are forcing the contributors to send
patches via email, instead of use GitHub or similar platforms, and
that for sure doesn't encourage contributions or fixes.
Anyway, Alexandru, me and many others sent contributions and fixes but
(almost) everything was ignored; hence the fragmentation.
> There was a recent call for maintainers of gr-osmosdr on the osmocom-sdr mailing list by Harald Welte.
Yes, and no one proposed until now.
> If nobody steps up to take this role, maybe gr-osmosdr should be integrated into the GNU radio main tree,
That is not an option, believe me, they invented all that Out-Of-Tree
machinery just to stay focused on their GR core business.
Just as an example, before OoT was there, I attempted to integrate
Microtelecom support in the GR main tree for years, no joy.
Just to be clear, I am not blaming them for that, evidently, inside
the GR core developer group, there are no resources for such kinds of
jobs.
> perhaps under a different name (gr-multisdr for example, since the Osmocom SDR project is end-lined) to ensure continuous support and updates.
That is a good idea.
> The GNU radio project already has the infrastructure to handle this.
Sure, but IMHO they are not really interested in that; I mean, till
someone else is doing the job, all well, otherwise... (again, no
criticism intended here, see above).
> Since Gqrx is possibly the largest user of gr-osmosdr, I think Alexandru has an important say here.
> Otherwise we risk fragmentation getting worse in the future.
AFAIK reading this mailing list, Alexandru is working to drop
gr-osmosdr support at all in his new SDR software.