Google Groups no longer supports new Usenet posts or subscriptions. Historical content remains viewable.
Dismiss

KoT Spoilers from the NAC in Montreal

26 views
Skip to first unread message

Blooded Sand

unread,
Oct 26, 2008, 3:26:12 AM10/26/08
to
Please?

Pretty please?

With a tied down antediluvian on top?

Brum

unread,
Oct 27, 2008, 7:35:27 PM10/27/08
to

http://www.sabbatinfrance.org/newforum/viewtopic.php?t=1530&start=275

go back n forth if ye can read that. there's the toreador precon

Tiago

librarian

unread,
Oct 27, 2008, 8:53:03 PM10/27/08
to


Here are some spoilers found hunting around for them on Presence mostly.
Preston posted most of them.

Heroic Might
Cost 3
+3 Stealth Action
pot: This vampire gains +1 strength and burn equipment as a strike.
POT: As above except the vampire gains +2 strength and can strike for 2R.

Horseshoe
Action
pot: Do 1 damage to a ready minion
POT: Do 2 damage to a ready minion

Rego Motus
Combat- Cost 1
tha: Prevent 2 damage from the opposing minions strike
THA: As above, but prevent 4 damage.

Rafael de Corazon
Cardtype: Vampire
Clan: Toreador
Group: 4
Capacity: 11
Discipline: AUS CEL DOM OBF PRE
Camarilla Inner Circle Member. Any vampire contesting Rafael's title
must yield during his or her untap phase. +2 bleed.

best -

chris

--
Super Fun Cards
www.superfuncards.com *NEW Website!*
auct...@superfuncards.com

fred_g...@sympatico.ca

unread,
Oct 27, 2008, 10:28:25 PM10/27/08
to

Dunno why no one else replied. Probably all busy going back home or
tired for Montrealers who spent the week there.

Here is a small preview then...

Confirmed reprints in boosters:

Aching Beauty
Approximation of Loyalty
Arms Dealer
Assault Rifle
Aura of Invincibility
Backstep
Camera Phone
Can't Take it with You
Caseless Rounds
Change of Target
Concealed Weapon
Desert Eagle
Diversity
Dragon's Breath Rounds
Elysium: The Arboretum
Empowering the Puppet King
Fast Hands
Fifth Tradition: Hospitality, The
Finding the Path
First Tradition: The Masquerade, The
Forced Vigilance
Fourth Tradition: The Accounting, The
Frontal Assault
Glancing Blow
Graverobbing
Harass
Heart of Nizchetus, The
High Ground
Hostile Takeover
Indomitability
Life in the City
Malkavian Justicar
On the Qui Vive
Powerbase: Chicago
Powerbase: Montreal (in Ventrue Preconstructed)
Reins of Power
Rumors of Gehenna
Scattershot
Second Tradition: Domain, The
Seduction
Sixth Tradition: Destruction, The
Soak
Stutter-Step
Summoning, The
Tension in the Ranks
Third Tradition: Progeny, The
Toreador Grand Ball
Unmasking, The
Uptown Hunting Ground
Ventrue Headquarters
Warzone Hunting Ground
Zillah's Valley


New cards

Library
--------

Agate Tasliman
Equipment
Only usable by a vampire with capacity 4 or more. The vampire with
this equipment may tap it before votes are cast in a referendum to
gain 1 vote in that referendum. A vampire may have only one Agate
Talisman.

Arcane Appraiser
Ally, Toreador
Unique ghoul with 1 life, 0 strength, 1 bleed
Arcane Appraiser may move an equipment card from a vampire in torporl
to a ready minion you control as a +1 stealth (D) action. If a second
copy of a unique equipment card you control woul enter play, it is
burned instead.

The Becoming
2 blood
Action
+1 stealth action. Requires a non-sterile vampire.
Put this card in play. It becomes a 0-capacity vampire of the same
clan as the acting vampire. Move up to 1 blood from the acting vampire
and up to 3 Discipline cards from your hand to this vampire. This
vampire cannot act this turn. If this vampire has no capacity-
increasing Discipline cards, burn him or her.

Dark Influences
2 pool
Master: out of turn.
Cancel a minion card as it is played. No cost is paid. That card
cannot be played again for the remainder of the turn. Put this card in
play. The next card played that would cancel another Methuselah's
minion card as it is played is canceled (no cost) and this card is
burned instead.

Ephor
1 pool
Master, Ventrue
Unique Master. Put this card on a Ventrue with capacity 8 or more.
This Ventrue gets +1 intercept and 1 additional vote. This Ventrue may
force any vampire to yield a contested title as a +1 stealth (D)
action.

Eyes of Argus
Reaction, aus
aus: Only usable during a (D) action directed at you (or a card you
control). +2 intercept
AUS: Only usable by a tapped vampire. This vampire can play reaction
cards and attempt to block as if untapped until the current action is
concluded.

Fleetness
1 blood
Action, cel
+1 stealth action
cel (D) Bleed
CEL (D) Enter combat with a tapped minion. This acting vampire gets an
optional maneuver during this combat.

Force of Personality
1 blood
Action Modifier/Combat, pre
pre: Combat - Strik: combat ends
PRE: Action Modifier - Only usable as the action is announced.
Vampires must burn a blood to attempt to block this action. Non-zombie
allies cannot block this action.

Light Intensifying Goggles
Electronic Equipment
This minion gets an optional maneuver on the first round of combat.
You may move any aim card this minion uses to this card (even if it is
canceled). This minion may play an aim card on this equipment as if
from your hand. Remove that aim card from the game.

Mouthpiece
Action Modifier, dom
dom: +1 bleed. You cannot play another action modifier to increase
this bleed.
DOM: Only usable by a ready vampire other than the acting minion. The
acting minion may play cards that require basic Dominate as a vampire
for the remainder of this action.

Neonate Breach
Political Action, 1 vote
Select one or more Methuselah. Successful referendum means each chosen
Methuselah burns 1 pool plus 3 additional pool if he or she controls a
ready vampire of capacity 4 or less.

Perfect Paragon
1 blood
Action Modifier, pre
pre: Only usable during a referendum. This vampire gains 3 votes.
PRE: Allies and younger vampires get -1 intercept when attempting to
block this action.

Scourge
Political Action, 1 vote
Requires a titled vampire.
Choose a vampire of the same sect. If this referendum is successful,
put this card on the chosen vampire.and untap this acting vampire. The
vampire with this card may enter combat with a vampire with capacity 4
or less or with an ally as a +1 stealth (D) action.

Torrent
2 blood
Combat, cel
cel: Additional strike.
CEL: Strike: combat ends. If this vampire was blocked while performing
an action, the ation continues as if unblocked.

Vampires
----------
Honest Abe
2, Bru, Group 4
pre
Camarilla.

Paul Calderone
4, Bru, Group 5
cel pot pre
Camarilla.

Tara
6, Bru, Group 5
cel POT PRE
Camarilla. Prince of San Diego
Sabbat.

Viktor, The Night General
9, Gan, Group 5
obf ANI CEL PRE PRO
Independant. +1 stealth

Dr. Solomon Grey
2, Pan, Group 5
dom pre
Camarilla. Burn 1 pool when you move Solomon from your uncontrolled
region to your ready region.

Masdela
5, Tor, Group 5
aus cel pre POT
Camarlla.

Allanyan Serata
9, Tor, Group 5
ani AUS CEL OBT PRE
Camarilla. Primogen.+1 strength

Andrew Stuart
5, Tre, Group 4
AUS DOM THA
Camarilla. When Andrew plays a card that required Thaumaturgy, reveal
the top card of your library (before drawing to replace). If it also
required Thaumaturgy, the card is canceled and Andrew burns 1 blood.

Claus Wegener
5, Tre, Group 5
aus for tha DOM
Camarilla.

Gerald Windham
9, Tre, Group 5
AUS DOM FOR THA
Camarilla. If Gerald has no title, he gets an additional vote for each
ready titled vampire controlled by another Methuselah. +1 stealth.

Lord Ephraim Wainwright
6, Tre, Group 5
for pre AUS THA
Camarilla. When Ephraim plays an action card, you may search your
library for another copy of that card and move it to your ash heap. If
the action succeeds, move the card to your hand.

Bulscu
8, Ven, Group 5
dom pot pre AUS FOR
Camarilla. If you control the Edge, Bulscu can steal a loation or an
equipment in play that costs 3 or less pool or blood as a (D) action.

Emily Carson
5, Ven, Group 5
for pre DOM
Camarilla. Primogen. During your discard phase, you may burn the Edge
to untap Emily.

Jack Tredegar
2, Ven, Group 5
pre
Camarilla.

Joseph DiGiaccomo
6, Ven, Group5
aus dom for PRE
Camarilla. Joseph untaps whenever any Methuselah puts a master:
location in play.

Victor Donaldson
6, Ven, Group 5
for pre DOM
Camarilla. Prince of Atlanta. If a Golconda you play is canceled, you
may move that card from your ash heap top your library (shuffle
afterward)

I have a few more, so I'll post more as sooon as I can.

Hope this helps give a glimpse. Good set in my opinion and from the
reactions I saw at the 2 draft events.

librarian

unread,
Oct 27, 2008, 11:10:50 PM10/27/08
to
Thanks Fred!

fred_g...@sympatico.ca wrote:
> On Oct 26, 3:26 am, Blooded Sand <sandm...@gmail.com> wrote:
>>
>
> The Becoming
> 2 blood
> Action
> +1 stealth action. Requires a non-sterile vampire.
> Put this card in play. It becomes a 0-capacity vampire of the same
> clan as the acting vampire. Move up to 1 blood from the acting vampire
> and up to 3 Discipline cards from your hand to this vampire. This
> vampire cannot act this turn. If this vampire has no capacity-
> increasing Discipline cards, burn him or her.

I like.


>
> Dark Influences
> 2 pool
> Master: out of turn.
> Cancel a minion card as it is played. No cost is paid. That card
> cannot be played again for the remainder of the turn. Put this card in
> play. The next card played that would cancel another Methuselah's
> minion card as it is played is canceled (no cost) and this card is
> burned instead.
>

Looks like an anti-DI card, that is also a DI. Sort of like Vessel to
Blood Doll. Suleci is turning in his haven right now, for sure...


> Ephor
> 1 pool
> Master, Ventrue
> Unique Master. Put this card on a Ventrue with capacity 8 or more.
> This Ventrue gets +1 intercept and 1 additional vote. This Ventrue may
> force any vampire to yield a contested title as a +1 stealth (D)
> action.
>

Because the Ventrue needed it. (obligatory: :-)


Haven't looked over the rest, but those were my first impressions.

Jozxyqk

unread,
Oct 28, 2008, 6:14:02 AM10/28/08
to
Did anyone see a new library card that allows a vampire to become
an Inner Circle member? Even DRAFT text to do it?

Or are the new IC members' (at least the Ventrue and Toreador)
special abilities *really* just anti-Group 2/6/8/... Silver Bullets?

(Yes, Hardestadt _could_ make himself Ventrue Justicar or Prince
of an easily-contested city, but in the typical case, that special
might as well be blank.)


Josh
Hardestadt + Anarch Secession + Rise of the Nephtali?

librarian

unread,
Oct 28, 2008, 11:41:48 AM10/28/08
to
fred_g...@sympatico.ca wrote:
>


Heroic Might
Cardtype: Action
Cost: 3 blood
Discipline: Potence
+3 stealth.
A minion can only have one Heroic Might. Burn this card if this vampire
goes to torpor.
[pot]: This vampire gains +1 strength and burn equipment as a strike.


[POT]: As above except the vampire gains +2 strength and can strike for 2R.

HorseshoeCardtype: Action
Discipline: Potence
[pot]: Do 1 damage to a ready minion


[POT]: Do 2 damage to a ready minion


Ponticulus
Cardtype: Ally.
Cost: 2 Pool
Clan: Tremere
Unique Wraith with 1 life, 0 strength, 0 bleed.Ponticulus cannot take
actions or have or use equipment. He gets +1 intercept during (D)
actions against you. He may tap to give any Tremere +1 intercept. He is
immune to non aggravated damage.


Rego Motus
Cardtype: Combat
Cost: 1 blood
Discipline: Thaumaturgy
[tha]: Prevent 2 damage from the opposing minion's strike.
[THA]: As above, but prevent 4 damage.


White Nights Massacre
Cardtype: EventTransient.
During your next discard phase, you must burn this card, and you may
either burn a vampire in torpor or by tapping a ready werewolf ally you
control or discarding a White Nights Massacre from your hand, burn all
vampires in torpor.


Here are a few more I saw on Path of Blood...

zora...@gmail.com

unread,
Oct 28, 2008, 11:46:31 AM10/28/08
to
On 28 okt, 04:10, librarian <aucti...@superfuncards.com> wrote:
> > Dark Influences
> > 2 pool
> > Master: out of turn.
> > Cancel a minion card as it is played. No cost is paid. That card
> > cannot be played again for the remainder of the turn. Put this card in
> > play. The next card played that would cancel another Methuselah's
> > minion card as it is played is canceled (no cost) and this card is
> > burned instead.
>
> Looks like an anti-DI card, that is also a DI.  Sort of like Vessel to
> Blood Doll.  Suleci is turning in his haven right now, for sure...
>

Uhm, I'm not sure how to read this bit: "The next card played that
would cancel *another Methuselah* 's minion card as it is played".
Does that mean:
1 - another Methuselah than the one playing the mentioned "next card",
or
2 - another Methuselah than "you" (you = the person who played the
Dark Influences) ?

1 would cancel anyones DI, 2 would just mess "you" up.


btw, Dark Influences abbreviates into DI as well.. a little joke by
LSJ?

Frederick Scott

unread,
Oct 28, 2008, 12:03:16 PM10/28/08
to
<zora...@gmail.com> wrote in messagenews:81b610c4-c8e0-4990...@b31g2000prb.googlegroups.com...

Well, (2) wouldn't necessarily just mess the original "you" up, no. It
might cancel some other Methuselah canceling yet another Methuselah's
minion card.

But I don't think it matters because I'm pretty sure the answer turns
out to be (1). (Of course, most of the time I guess on something that
seems completely and utterly intuitive to me, I turn out to be wrong,
so take that for what it's worth. IADEFINITELYNLSJ!)

Fred


Thrall of Arika

unread,
Oct 28, 2008, 3:08:41 PM10/28/08
to
On Oct 27, 7:28 pm, fred_ging...@sympatico.ca wrote:
> Malkavian Justicar

I would presume then that the other 5 Justicar title votes are
reprinted as well then. Really hoping that there's an Inner Circle
card ala Regent.

> New cards
>
> Library
> --------


>
> Arcane Appraiser
> Ally, Toreador
> Unique ghoul with 1 life, 0 strength, 1 bleed
> Arcane Appraiser may move an equipment card from a vampire in torporl
> to a ready minion you control as a +1 stealth (D) action. If a second
> copy of a unique equipment card you control woul enter play, it is
> burned instead.

Seems contesting is a big thing for this set. Anti-contesting here,
Inner Circle nuking titles they would otherwise contest ...

> The Becoming
> 2 blood
> Action
> +1 stealth action. Requires a non-sterile vampire.
> Put this card in play. It becomes a 0-capacity vampire of the same
> clan as the acting vampire. Move up to 1 blood from the acting vampire
> and up to 3 Discipline cards from your hand to this vampire. This
> vampire cannot act this turn. If this vampire has no capacity-
> increasing Discipline cards, burn him or her.

Sounds fun! Break out your Kiasyd Absorb the Mind/Mehemet decks!

> Dark Influences
> 2 pool
> Master: out of turn.
> Cancel a minion card as it is played. No cost is paid. That card
> cannot be played again for the remainder of the turn. Put this card in
> play. The next card played that would cancel another Methuselah's
> minion card as it is played is canceled (no cost) and this card is
> burned instead.

An interesting 'fix' for Direct Intervention ... though will it see
much play?

> Ephor
> 1 pool
> Master, Ventrue
> Unique Master. Put this card on a Ventrue with capacity 8 or more.
> This Ventrue gets +1 intercept and 1 additional vote. This Ventrue may
> force any vampire to yield a contested title as a +1 stealth (D)
> action.

Ventrue seem to be coming out from behind their board room desks to
deal with matters personally. Intercept, +strength, Potence and other
combat disciplines ... nice to see!

> Eyes of Argus
> Reaction, aus
> aus: Only usable during a (D) action directed at you (or a card you
> control). +2 intercept
> AUS: Only usable by a tapped vampire. This vampire can play reaction
> cards and attempt to block as if untapped until the current action is
> concluded.

And multi-purpose cards seem to be a theme as well.

> Fleetness
> 1 blood
> Action, cel
> +1 stealth action
> cel (D) Bleed
> CEL (D) Enter combat with a tapped minion. This acting vampire gets an
> optional maneuver during this combat.

Multi-purpose again, with stealth! Brujah bruise/bleed should be
happy.

> Light Intensifying Goggles
> Electronic Equipment
> This minion gets an optional maneuver on the first round of combat.
> You may move any aim card this minion uses to this card (even if it is
> canceled). This minion may play an aim card on this equipment as if
> from your hand. Remove that aim card from the game.

Neat effect, and like how it doesn't wallpaper IR goggles.

> Mouthpiece
> Action Modifier, dom
> dom: +1 bleed. You cannot play another action modifier to increase
> this bleed.
> DOM: Only usable by a ready vampire other than the acting minion. The
> acting minion may play cards that require basic Dominate as a vampire
> for the remainder of this action.

Severe ouch. Bleed with weenie, choose not to block because "it's just
1 pool, and your DOM monster is just waiting", then Mouthpiece +
Condition.

> Neonate Breach
> Political Action, 1 vote
> Select one or more Methuselah. Successful referendum means each chosen
> Methuselah burns 1 pool plus 3 additional pool if he or she controls a
> ready vampire of capacity 4 or less.

A nice damage vote ... conditional for the big hit, but still usable
even if there are no weenies on the table.

> Scourge
> Political Action, 1 vote
> Requires a titled vampire.
> Choose a vampire of the same sect. If this referendum is successful,
> put this card on the chosen vampire.and untap this acting vampire. The
> vampire with this card may enter combat with a vampire with capacity 4
> or less or with an ally as a +1 stealth (D) action.

The untap is nice. The rush is a bit weak, though nice for the
Independents who don't have access to Archon/Alastor/Templar.

> Vampires
> ----------


> Tara
> 6, Bru, Group 5
> cel POT PRE
> Camarilla. Prince of San Diego
> Sabbat.

Missing text? Or is the Sabbat bit just a cut and paste error? A new
Volker, it seems.

> Dr. Solomon Grey
> 2, Pan, Group 5
> dom pre
> Camarilla. Burn 1 pool when you move Solomon from your uncontrolled
> region to your ready region.

A Camarilla Pander?

> Masdela
> 5, Tor, Group 5
> aus cel pre POT
> Camarlla.
>
> Allanyan Serata
> 9, Tor, Group 5
> ani AUS CEL OBT PRE
> Camarilla. Primogen.+1 strength

Fighty Toreadors. Seems like Voting and Combat are the themes of this
set.

> Andrew Stuart
> 5, Tre, Group 4
> AUS DOM THA
> Camarilla. When Andrew plays a card that required Thaumaturgy, reveal
> the top card of your library (before drawing to replace). If it also
> required Thaumaturgy, the card is canceled and Andrew burns 1 blood.

Not sure about this one. Three superior discplines at capacity 5 is
nice, but the drawback makes the Thaumaturgy a bit unusable unless
it's in small doses in the deck. Since I play Tremere for Thaumaturgy,
doubtful he'll see use in my decks.

> Gerald Windham
> 9, Tre, Group 5
> AUS DOM FOR THA
> Camarilla. If Gerald has no title, he gets an additional vote for each
> ready titled vampire controlled by another Methuselah. +1 stealth.

Very nice. Another in the line of Tremere +1 stealthers, potential for
becoming a big voter, and superior Fortitude.

> Lord Ephraim Wainwright
> 6, Tre, Group 5
> for pre AUS THA
> Camarilla. When Ephraim plays an action card, you may search your
> library for another copy of that card and move it to your ash heap. If
> the action succeeds, move the card to your hand.

A neat effect, if a bit of a gamble. The Presence could see him used
in Vote decks, leading to potential double KRC whammies.

> Bulscu
> 8, Ven, Group 5
> dom pot pre AUS FOR
> Camarilla. If you control the Edge, Bulscu can steal a loation or an
> equipment in play that costs 3 or less pool or blood as a (D) action.
>

> Joseph DiGiaccomo
> 6, Ven, Group5
> aus dom for PRE
> Camarilla. Joseph untaps whenever any Methuselah puts a master:
> location in play.

More Auspex for Ventrue, leading to more intercepting deck types.
Certainly gives the potential for a new type of Ventrue deck.

So far, I've been very pleased with the cards, and looking very
forward to the set coming out. The Camarilla has been on the back
burner for too long now, time to take back the night!

Chris, Thrall of Arika

Thrall of Arika

unread,
Oct 28, 2008, 3:26:22 PM10/28/08
to

Some more posted from the above site:

> Villein Master: trifle. Put this card on a vampire you control and move 2 or more blood from that
> vampire to your pool. Minion Tap cards cost an additional pool. Villein costs an additional pool to
> play on this vampire.

The 'vessel' of Minion Tap cards? An interesting card, and can't be
cycled as easily as Minion Taps. Can see it being nice for decks that
like Minion Taps, but only use one or two.

> The Oath
> combat/reaction
> Play when a vampire gains blood from a Taste of Vitae or steals blood from this vampire. Put an
> oath counter on that vampire. This vampire may put another oath counter on that vampire as a (D)
> action. A vampire with 2 oath counters from this vampire cannot block or enter combat with this
> vampire. A vampire can play only one Oath each round.

Interesting for combat defense, if you can survive long enough to Oath
them.

> Mictlantecuhlti
> 10 cap Gangrel
> pre pro ANI FOR POT THA
> Independent: M is immune to damage from weapons. When he commits diablerie, each of your
> other ready vampires gains 1 blood from the blood bank. +1 strength.
>
> Carlak
> 8 cap Brujah
> dom pot CEL PRE
> Prince of Prague. When votes are tallied during any referendum, Carlak gains 1 blood for each
> Methuselah casting no votes in favor and at least 1 vote against the referendum. He gets an
> optional press each combat.
>
> Zelios
> 8 cap Nosferatu
> pre ANI OBF POT
> Camarilla Primogen: If Zelios is ready, you may tap him to pay the pool cost of a location with his
> blood instead. +1 strength.
>
> Harold Tanner
> 6 cap Nosferatu
> ani dom obf POT.
> When Harold is in combat, the controller of the oppising minion plays with an open hand.

Chris, Thrall of Arika

Chris Berger

unread,
Oct 28, 2008, 6:18:34 PM10/28/08
to
On Oct 28, 2:26 pm, Thrall of Arika <christopher.ack...@amec.com>
wrote:

>
> > Villein Master: trifle. Put this card on a vampire you control and move 2 or more blood from that
> > vampire to your pool. Minion Tap cards cost an additional pool. Villein costs an additional pool to
> > play on this vampire.
>
> The 'vessel' of Minion Tap cards? An interesting card, and can't be
> cycled as easily as Minion Taps. Can see it being nice for decks that
> like Minion Taps, but only use one or two.
>
I like this one. I definitely have a deck or two that will use it -
where I only use 2 or 3 Minion Taps because I don't have something
like Renewed Vigor or Voter Cap to fill back up. I think this is much
more effective than DI2 which is interesting and maybe, just maybe,
will decrease the instance of DI in some decks, but doesn't offer that
much benefit for the 2 pool cost.

> > The Oath
> > combat/reaction
> > Play when a vampire gains blood from a Taste of Vitae or steals blood from this vampire. Put an
> > oath counter on that vampire. This vampire may put another oath counter on that vampire as a (D)
> > action. A vampire with 2 oath counters from this vampire cannot block or enter combat with this
> > vampire. A vampire can play only one Oath each round.
>
> Interesting for combat defense, if you can survive long enough to Oath
> them.
>

Absolutely terrible. I can't think of a deck that I would play even 1
or 2 of these in. I'd rather have some sort of combat defense than
rely on them fighting me, *not* torporizing, and then Tasting, and
*then* on another no stealth (D) action or another Taste of Vitae and
another Oath in hand. The resulting effect is strong, but not strong
enough for the unlikely chain of events leading up to it.

Maybe, just maybe, in combo with Legacy of Caine, but something tells
me it's a silly trick that you can only pull off once.

Pullen

unread,
Oct 28, 2008, 6:58:48 PM10/28/08
to

> > Andrew Stuart
> > 5, Tre, Group 4
> > AUS DOM THA
> > Camarilla. When Andrew plays a card that required Thaumaturgy, reveal
> > the top card of your library (before drawing to replace). If it also
> > required Thaumaturgy, the card is canceled and Andrew burns 1 blood.

So right now their are 8 5 cap vamps in group 3-4 that have superior
DOM, this is #9. Auspex is also common among them with 5 of the 9 have
some level of it.

bwross

unread,
Oct 28, 2008, 7:39:10 PM10/28/08
to
On Oct 28, 12:03 pm, "Frederick Scott" <nos...@no.spam.dot.com> wrote:
> <zoramu...@gmail.com> wrote in messagenews:81b610c4-c8e0-4990...@b31g2000prb.googlegroups.com...

Option 1 doesn't make a lot of sense... the Methuselah playing the
"next card" will always be playing it to cancel another Methuselah's
card, so that detail wouldn't be mentioned... it'd just be "the next
card to cancel a minion card is cancelled".

I think it is number option 2. The effect in question comes after
"Put this card in play", so "another Methuslah" would refer to someone
other than the controller of DI2 (which would typically be the player
who played the master card).

But, IDNHCIH and IANLSJ also.

Brent Ross

tim

unread,
Oct 28, 2008, 8:47:46 PM10/28/08
to
>>> Andrew Stuart
>>> > > 5, Tre, Group 4
>>> > > AUS DOM THA
>>> > > Camarilla. When Andrew plays a card that required Thaumaturgy, reveal
>>> > > the top card of your library (before drawing to replace). If it also
>>> > > required Thaumaturgy, the card is canceled and Andrew burns 1 blood.


JFC!!

What the hell is with printing useless Tremere. Why are they even
printing this idiot? Is anyone ever going to use him, that doesn't want
to lose?

I am quite frankly sick and tired of these clown Tremere vampires being
printed that look great when you see their discipline spread, yet have
this retarded gimpoid disadvantage. I am not even going to quote past
examples, as I have no wish to sully my keyboard by typing their names.

I would prefer this guy be Tremere, have not so awesome a discipline
spread, AND NOT BE TOTALLY FUCKING USELESS.

Tremere happen to be my favourite clan, always have been, and yet WW
keep printing these retards.

In the words of the great Lo-Pan "This really pisses me off to no end!"


-Tim W. (recently unretired V:TeS player)

Peter D Bakija

unread,
Oct 28, 2008, 9:07:54 PM10/28/08
to
In article <SoONk.9212$sc2....@news-server.bigpond.net.au>,
tim <ti...@bigpond.net.au> wrote:

> >>> Andrew Stuart
> >>> > > 5, Tre, Group 4
> >>> > > AUS DOM THA
> >>> > > Camarilla. When Andrew plays a card that required Thaumaturgy, reveal
> >>> > > the top card of your library (before drawing to replace). If it also
> >>> > > required Thaumaturgy, the card is canceled and Andrew burns 1 blood.

> What the hell is with printing useless Tremere. Why are they even

> printing this idiot? Is anyone ever going to use him, that doesn't want
> to lose?

He is a 5 cap with AUS, DOM, of which currently zero exist. If you are
making a deck where a 5 cap with AUS, DOM is going to be good (I hear
that both DOM and AUS are pretty strong...), he is going to be gold.

Sure. Don't use him in a deck that uses a lot of Thaumaturgy. Which is
really easy--use him as a 5 cap with AUS, DOM, and he is awesome.

Peter D Bakija
pd...@lightlink.com
http://www.lightlink.com/pdb6/vtes.html

"It's too bad she won't live! But then again, who does?"
-Gaff

Pullen

unread,
Oct 28, 2008, 9:33:48 PM10/28/08
to

As I have already noted, he goes in great with mid cap DOM vamps, this
vampire is a solid 5 cap VAMPIRE, yes he's probably not a great
Tremere, so what. Think outside the box.

1x Banjoko DOM obt pot 5 Lasombra:3
1x Black Lotus DOM aus obf ser 5 Follower of Set:4
1x Catherine du Bois DOM for obf pre 5 Ventrue:3
1x Dame Hollerton DOM OBT myt 5 Kiasyd:4
1x Donatello Giovanni DOM aus pot pre 5 Giovanni:4
1x Ermenegildo, The Rake DOM OBT pot 5 Lasombra:4
1x Esoara DOM aus for pot 5 Tremere antitribu:4
1x Jephta Hester DOM FOR aus 5 Ventrue antitribu:4

Frederick Scott

unread,
Oct 28, 2008, 10:28:26 PM10/28/08
to
"bwross" <bwr...@mail.com> wrote in message
news:46663f27-747d-42a2...@l77g2000hse.googlegroups.com...

> On Oct 28, 12:03 pm, "Frederick Scott" <nos...@no.spam.dot.com> wrote:
> > <zoramu...@gmail.com> wrote in message
> > news:81b610c4-c8e0-4990...@b31g2000prb.googlegroups.com...
> > > On 28 okt, 04:10, librarian <aucti...@superfuncards.com> wrote:
> > > > > Dark Influences
> > > > > 2 pool
> > > > > Master: out of turn.
> > > > > Cancel a minion card as it is played. No cost is paid. That card
> > > > > cannot be played again for the remainder of the turn. Put this card in
> > > > > play. The next card played that would cancel another Methuselah's
> > > > > minion card as it is played is canceled (no cost) and this card is
> > > > > burned instead.
> >
> > > > Looks like an anti-DI card, that is also a DI. Sort of like Vessel to
> > > > Blood Doll. Suleci is turning in his haven right now, for sure...
> >
> > > Uhm, I'm not sure how to read this bit: "The next card played that
> > > would cancel *another Methuselah* 's minion card as it is played".
> > > Does that mean:
> > > 1 - another Methuselah than the one playing the mentioned "next card",
> > > or
> > > 2 - another Methuselah than "you" (you = the person who played the
> > > Dark Influences) ?
> >
> > > 1 would cancel anyones DI, 2 would just mess "you" up.
...

> But I don't think it matters because I'm pretty sure the answer turns
> out to be (1).
...

> Option 1 doesn't make a lot of sense... the Methuselah playing the
> "next card" will always be playing it to cancel another Methuselah's
> card, so that detail wouldn't be mentioned...

Eh? Tangle Atropos' Hand. Red Herring. It's possible to cancel
your own minion card.

> it'd just be "the next
> card to cancel a minion card is cancelled".

Nope. That wording was necessary to acheive a certain effect, even
for #1.

Fred


bwross

unread,
Oct 29, 2008, 3:30:56 AM10/29/08
to
On Oct 28, 10:28 pm, "Frederick Scott" <nos...@no.spam.dot.com> wrote:
> "bwross" <bwr...@mail.com> wrote in message
> > Option 1 doesn't make a lot of sense... the Methuselah playing the
> > "next card" will always be playing it to cancel another Methuselah's
> > card, so that detail wouldn't be mentioned...
>
> Eh?  Tangle Atropos' Hand.   Red Herring.  It's possible to cancel

Those are all "Cancel the action". That action may have involved a
card, or may not have... doesn't matter because these do not cancel
minion cards.

But you are right that there are ways to cancel your own minion cards
now... Andrew Stuart can have that happen, or Blood of Sandman your
own vampire and start canceling Wakes.

I'm still positive that "another Methuselah" means "other than the
controller of this card, now that it's in play", given the wording
we've seen.

Brent Ross

Stone

unread,
Oct 29, 2008, 4:35:16 AM10/29/08
to

<fred_g...@sympatico.ca> a écrit dans le message de
news:41ef04d6-ecaa-46cc...@y79g2000hsa.googlegroups.com...

Here is a small preview then...

Confirmed reprints in boosters:

[snip list of reprints and spoilers]

thanks for the list. Did anyone see a Parity Shift in boosters and /or
starters ?
Stone


Teeka

unread,
Oct 29, 2008, 5:52:01 AM10/29/08
to
On 28 okt, 03:28, fred_ging...@sympatico.ca wrote:
> Vampires
> ----------
> Honest Abe
> 2, Bru, Group 4
> pre
> Camarilla.
>

...Lincoln? What was the art like?

J

unread,
Oct 29, 2008, 6:04:26 AM10/29/08
to
> > >>> Andrew Stuart
> > >>> > > 5, Tre, Group 4
> > >>> > > AUS DOM THA
> > >>> > > Camarilla. When Andrew plays a card that required Thaumaturgy, reveal
> > >>> > > the top card of your library (before drawing to replace). If it also
> > >>> > > required Thaumaturgy, the card is canceled and Andrew burns 1 blood.
>
> > JFC!!
>
> > What the hell is with printing useless Tremere. Why are they even
> > printing this idiot? Is anyone ever going to use him, that doesn't want
> > to lose?
>
> > I am quite frankly sick and tired of these clown Tremere vampires being
> > printed that look great when you see their discipline spread, yet have
> > this retarded gimpoid disadvantage. I am not even going to quote past
> > examples, as I have no wish to sully my keyboard by typing their names.
>
> > I would prefer this guy be Tremere, have not so awesome a discipline
> > spread, AND NOT BE TOTALLY FUCKING USELESS.
>
> > Tremere happen to be my favourite clan, always have been, and yet WW
> > keep printing these retards.
>
> > In the words of the great Lo-Pan "This really pisses me off to no end!"
>
> > -Tim W. (recently unretired V:TeS player)
>
> As I have already noted, he goes in great with mid cap DOM vamps, this
> vampire is a solid 5 cap VAMPIRE, yes he's probably not a great
> Tremere, so what. Think outside the box.

I concur to some extent with Tim...
Yes, he can be played in Aus/Dom or Aus or Dom decks, but his special
makes his superior THA almost completely worthless to the point that
he'll hardly ever be seen in a Tremere deck, which means that he is an
overpriced vampire, because one of his disciplines is negligible.

As to "Think outside the box", it's not that simple. This guy is one
of a very finite set of group 4/5 Tremere. This set is supposed to
cater for Camarilla in the later groups, yet here is a vampire that
really can't be used with their clan, subsequently making the Tremere
in these groups harder to play (they're one down already). His
special is really too counter-productive. It would have been better
if his disadvantage was something like "Thaumaturgy cards cost Andrew
1 extra blood to play". Or limiting his disad to once per turn
instead of EVERY THA card that he plays.

--> J
grail_pbem "at" hotmail.com
http://www.geocities.com/grail_j

Shockwave

unread,
Oct 29, 2008, 6:42:29 AM10/29/08
to
I see a future for Sebastian Goulet & His Black Spiral Buddies! ;)

===========

bluedevil

unread,
Oct 29, 2008, 8:00:45 AM10/29/08
to
On Oct 28, 6:18 pm, Chris Berger <ark...@ugcs.caltech.edu> wrote:

> Absolutely terrible.  I can't think of a deck that I would play even 1
> or 2 of these in.  I'd rather have some sort of combat defense than
> rely on them fighting me, *not* torporizing, and then Tasting, and
> *then* on another no stealth (D) action or another Taste of Vitae and
> another Oath in hand.  The resulting effect is strong, but not strong
> enough for the unlikely chain of events leading up to it.
>
> Maybe, just maybe, in combo with Legacy of Caine, but something tells
> me it's a silly trick that you can only pull off once.

Flesh of Marble comes to mind.

--

David Cherryholmes

Peter D Bakija

unread,
Oct 29, 2008, 8:48:14 AM10/29/08
to
On Oct 29, 6:04 am, J <grai...@hotmail.com> wrote:
> I concur to some extent with Tim...
> Yes, he can be played in Aus/Dom or Aus or Dom decks, but his special
> makes his superior THA almost completely worthless to the point that
> he'll hardly ever be seen in a Tremere deck, which means that he is an
> overpriced vampire, because one of his disciplines is negligible.

Except that he isn't overpriced, as he is a 5 cap with 6 points in
disciplines. And 5 caps only get 5 points in abilities. So he is
getting THA instead of tha, but with a disadvantage to balance it out.
Which means he is a 5 cap with DOM, AUS (which is very strong in and
of itself) who has conditional THA in a pinch. If you put him in a
deck that only uses DOM, AUS (or just DOM--no one ever does well with
mono DOM after all...), he is a really good 5 cap vampire. If you put
him in a deck with a lot of Thaumaturgy, and expect to use the
Thaumaturgy a lot, you probably aren't going to get much good use out
of him.

Sure. He isn't going to go in a lot of traditional Tremere decks. But
an AUS, DOM deck with a couple Thumaturgy cards mixed in (like a few
Magic of the Smith or Rutor's Hand)? He is gold. He's like Beatrice
Oracle Tremblay--she is an Imbued who is horrible in Imbued decks. But
completely freaking awesome in non Imbued decks.

> As to "Think outside the box", it's not that simple.  This guy is one
> of a very finite set of group 4/5 Tremere.

Sometimes you get weird vampires. Ingram Frizer is a really
questionable !Nosferatu (he is the only one in that group pairing with
AUS I'm pretty sure). But a good vampire in general.

> This set is supposed to
> cater for Camarilla in the later groups, yet here is a vampire that
> really can't be used with their clan, subsequently making the Tremere
> in these groups harder to play (they're one down already).  His
> special is really too counter-productive.

Not all Tremere decks have to use tons of Thaumaturgy. I hear Dominate
is strong.

-Peter

Chris Berger

unread,
Oct 29, 2008, 8:56:51 AM10/29/08
to
On Oct 29, 7:48 am, Peter D Bakija <p...@lightlink.com> wrote:
> On Oct 29, 6:04 am, J <grai...@hotmail.com> wrote:
>
> > I concur to some extent with Tim...
> > Yes, he can be played in Aus/Dom or Aus or Dom decks, but his special
> > makes his superior THA almost completely worthless to the point that
> > he'll hardly ever be seen in a Tremere deck, which means that he is an
> > overpriced vampire, because one of his disciplines is negligible.
>
> Except that he isn't overpriced, as he is a 5 cap with 6 points in
> disciplines. And 5 caps only get 5 points in abilities. So he is
> getting THA instead of tha, but with a disadvantage to balance it out.
> Which means he is a 5 cap with DOM, AUS (which is very strong in and
> of itself) who has conditional THA in a pinch. If you put him in a
> deck that only uses DOM, AUS (or just DOM--no one ever does well with
> mono DOM after all...), he is a really good 5 cap vampire. If you put
> him in a deck with a lot of Thaumaturgy, and expect to use the
> Thaumaturgy a lot, you probably aren't going to get much good use out
> of him.
>
How much Thuam do people put in their "lots of Thaum" decks? Like 45
cards, max? Even that seems a bit much, but I don't know. If it's
45, then you have approximately a 50% chance of getting a Thaum card
canceled. Considering he's playing it at superior which he doesn't
really have a right to do, and he has AUS DOM, that seems pretty
fair. How strong do Tremere players want their vamps to be? Does
each one have to be Muaziz?

He'll be great in a Gargoyle deck, since he won't be expected to do
much fighting.

Malone

unread,
Oct 29, 2008, 9:12:06 AM10/29/08
to

> http://www.sabbatinfrance.org/newforum/viewtopic.php?t=1530&start=275
>
> go back n forth if ye can read that. there's the toreador precon
>
> Tiago

I can read French ok and I went thru all 21 pages in the thread and
didn't see the Toreador precon. Can you help me find that (or just
copy and paste it here)? Thanks!

Peter D Bakija

unread,
Oct 29, 2008, 9:19:10 AM10/29/08
to
On Oct 29, 8:56 am, Chris Berger <ark...@ugcs.caltech.edu> wrote:
> How much Thuam do people put in their "lots of Thaum" decks?

I'd figure enough to make it so that if this guy plays a Thaumaturgy
card, he has a reasonable chance of shooting himself in the foot. So I
certainly wouldn't want to use him in a deck with a lot of
Thaumaturgy, no. But in mono DOM, or DOM, AUS? Fantastic. Heck, play
DOM, AUS and have a couple Magic of the Smith to go get, like, the
Bowl or the Ivory Bow? Probably going to be totally worth it.

> He'll be great in a Gargoyle deck, since he won't be expected to do
> much fighting.

Also totally good--a 5 cap in a Slave Gargoyle deck with DOM, AUS?
There isn't going to be much Thaumaturgy. He is great at bouncing. And
getting guys out cheap with Govern. And going to bleed for 6 where if
he is blocked, the blocker gets smushed by Cedric the Entertainer.

-Peter

GreenO

unread,
Oct 29, 2008, 9:35:49 AM10/29/08
to
On Oct 29, 12:47 am, tim <t...@bigpond.net.au> wrote:

> What the hell is with printing useless Tremere.

Indeed.

> Is anyone ever going to use him, that doesn't want to lose?

You need to accept the concept of losing withe th Tremere, I think.

>
> I am quite frankly sick and tired of these clown Tremere vampires being
> printed

I concur. Lets start a petition.

> yet have this retarded gimpoid disadvantage.

...usually denoted by a pentagram in a box.

>
> Tremere happen to be my favourite clan,

There are therapy groups available. Trying building a !salubri deck
and gradually weaning yourself onto more and more playable clans.

>and yet WW keep printing these retards.

They need to stop print tremere, this is true.

> In the words of the great Lo-Pan "This really pisses me off to no end!"
>

Best film ever.


GreenO
-the cheque's in the mail.

Meej

unread,
Oct 29, 2008, 9:35:49 AM10/29/08
to

Sure, that'll keep you alive, but still. If you're going to play The
Oath, you'll want "more than a few" - right? I mean, I can't see this
being very useful as a prayer card... - and then what happens in the
sizeable percentage of games where you never run into Tastes or steals-
blood effects? They're completely dead cards.

Reactive effect that relies on particular specific card plays by an
opponent to even leave your hand = not feasibly playable. IMNSHO.

- D.J.

Jadasc

unread,
Oct 29, 2008, 9:59:52 AM10/29/08
to
On Oct 27, 8:53 pm, librarian <aucti...@superfuncards.com> wrote:

> Horseshoe
> Action


> pot: Do 1 damage to a ready minion
> POT: Do 2 damage to a ready minion

Does not combo well with Grenade. Oh, well. Close enough.

Jason

Peter D Bakija

unread,
Oct 29, 2008, 10:14:58 AM10/29/08
to

Well, almost.

-Peter

Maegnar

unread,
Oct 29, 2008, 10:55:31 AM10/29/08
to
Rego Motus is so gonna be in my !Tremere deck!
No more Agro-poke-go-to-torpor :)

On the other note - no THA reprints, huh? Where's Shotgun ritual,
Blood to Water, Cauldron of Blood, Seeds of Corruption, Mirror Walk,
Rutor's Hand? Where??

XZealot

unread,
Oct 29, 2008, 11:44:31 AM10/29/08
to

> Mouthpiece
> Action Modifier, dom
> dom: +1 bleed. You cannot play another action modifier to increase
> this bleed.
> DOM: Only usable by a ready vampire other than the acting minion. The
> acting minion may play cards that require basic Dominate as a vampire
> for the remainder of this action.

I was thinking Sebastian Goulet/Jacob Femor Renegade with Garou/Ossian/
Black Spiral Buddy who are Govern/Conditioning/Graverobbign deck that
would be fantastic.

What do you guys think?

Comments Welcome,
Norman S. Brown, Jr
XZealot
Archon of the Swamp

Shockwave

unread,
Oct 29, 2008, 12:12:09 PM10/29/08
to
I think I've already posted exactly that idea in the Spoilers thread,
Norman. :)
(Yes! For once I got there first!)

- Dave

bluedevil

unread,
Oct 29, 2008, 12:13:04 PM10/29/08
to
On Oct 29, 9:35 am, Meej <dj...@comcast.net> wrote:

> Reactive effect that relies on particular specific card plays by an
> opponent to even leave your hand = not feasibly playable.  IMNSHO.

Very much metagame dependent. Perhaps in blind tourneys where combat
is very much the poor cousin to the other two legs of the triangle, it
can look like a dicey proposition. But in my weekly games? Or (last
I checked) the blood bath that is Australia or [insert fighty metagame
here]? Op-cost looking pretty low to me. And the payoff is rather
large: can't block me, can't rush me, take *that*, combat deck. I'm
not trying to overplay the usefulness of the card, but I guess I don't
think it stinks.

--

David Cherryholmes

Chris Berger

unread,
Oct 29, 2008, 12:14:43 PM10/29/08
to
On Oct 29, 10:44 am, XZealot <xzea...@cox.net> wrote:
> > Mouthpiece
> > Action Modifier, dom
> > dom: +1 bleed. You cannot play another action modifier to increase
> > this bleed.
> > DOM: Only usable by a ready vampire other than the acting minion. The
> > acting minion may play cards that require basic Dominate as a vampire
> > for the remainder of this action.
>
> I was thinking Sebastian Goulet/Jacob Femor Renegade with Garou/Ossian/
> Black Spiral Buddy who are Govern/Conditioning/Graverobbign deck that
> would be fantastic.
>
> What do you guys think?
>
Won't work with Govern and Graverobbing, because Mouthpiece is an
action modifier.

Mouthpiece seems alright, and it has some flexibility at inferior, but
I can't think of a good situation where I'd rather use it over
Empowering the Puppet King. Conditioning is okay - takes 2 cards and
moves the blood cost to the acting minion for an extra +1 bleed, but
not spectacular or anything. Most of the time, I'd rather use
Empowering and take the combo reliance out of it. Any other dominate
modifiers that would make it better? Maybe Sleeping Mind, but I don't
feel like it's worth a blood and 2 cards if you can't also use
Seduction.

sta...@hotmail.com

unread,
Oct 29, 2008, 12:16:57 PM10/29/08
to
On Oct 29, 11:44 am, XZealot <xzea...@cox.net> wrote:
> > Mouthpiece
> > Action Modifier, dom
> > dom: +1 bleed. You cannot play another action modifier to increase
> > this bleed.
> > DOM: Only usable by a ready vampire other than the acting minion. The
> > acting minion may play cards that require basic Dominate as a vampire
> > for the remainder of this action.
>
> I was thinking Sebastian Goulet/Jacob Femor Renegade with Garou/Ossian/
> Black Spiral Buddy who are Govern/Conditioning/Graverobbign deck that
> would be fantastic.
>
> What do you guys think?

That was my basically storyline deck in Montreal Norm. It's a fun
deck, well it'll be more fun now with Mouthpiece of course, because it
was basically just Empowering the Puppet King.

cheers
shawn

Chris Berger

unread,
Oct 29, 2008, 12:21:41 PM10/29/08
to
On Oct 29, 11:16 am, stan...@hotmail.com wrote:
> On Oct 29, 11:44 am, XZealot <xzea...@cox.net> wrote:
>
> > I was thinking Sebastian Goulet/Jacob Femor Renegade with Garou/Ossian/
> > Black Spiral Buddy who are Govern/Conditioning/Graverobbign deck that
> > would be fantastic.
> >
> That was my basically storyline deck in Montreal Norm.  It's a fun
> deck, well it'll be more fun now with Mouthpiece of course, because it
> was basically just Empowering the Puppet King.
>
Explain how. I'm legitimately curious. A lot of people seem excited
with Mouthpiece, and I want to know what I'm missing.

Shockwave

unread,
Oct 29, 2008, 12:24:01 PM10/29/08
to
> Mouthpiece seems alright, and it has some flexibility at inferior, but
> I can't think of a good situation where I'd rather use it over
> Empowering the Puppet King.  Conditioning is okay - takes 2 cards and
> moves the blood cost to the acting minion for an extra +1 bleed, but
> not spectacular or anything.  Most of the time, I'd rather use
> Empowering and take the combo reliance out of it.  Any other dominate
> modifiers that would make it better?  Maybe Sleeping Mind, but I don't
> feel like it's worth a blood and 2 cards if you can't also use
> Seduction.

How about just stack more copies of Mouthpiece, because having two
makes them inherantly cycleable? Play Mouthpiece at superior, use that
to play it on the acting minion at inferior? With the added bonus of
not requiring Untapped like Empowering does, and dropping the Blood
cost in exchange for potentially needing two cards. That to my mind is
more than worth it.

I was thinking Sebastian Goulet / Charisma / Black Spiral Buddies /
Mouthpiece / maybe Camera Phones, with a side order of maybe a package
of Quick Jab / Fake Out / to discourage blocking. Jacob Fermor should
also get a look in, and you've got plenty of Werewolves potentially
bleeding for 3. Hell, chuck a couple of pro Masters in and Form of
Mist it up just to really hit it home.

Janne Hägglund

unread,
Oct 29, 2008, 12:43:15 PM10/29/08
to
Chris Berger <ark...@ugcs.caltech.edu> writes:

> On Oct 29, 10:44 am, XZealot <xzea...@cox.net> wrote:
> > > Mouthpiece
> > > Action Modifier, dom
> > > dom: +1 bleed. You cannot play another action modifier to increase
> > > this bleed.
> > > DOM: Only usable by a ready vampire other than the acting minion. The
> > > acting minion may play cards that require basic Dominate as a vampire
> > > for the remainder of this action.
> >
> > I was thinking Sebastian Goulet/Jacob Femor Renegade with Garou/Ossian/
> > Black Spiral Buddy who are Govern/Conditioning/Graverobbign deck that
> > would be fantastic.
> >
> > What do you guys think?
> >
> Won't work with Govern and Graverobbing, because Mouthpiece is an
> action modifier.
>
> Mouthpiece seems alright, and it has some flexibility at inferior, but
> I can't think of a good situation where I'd rather use it over
> Empowering the Puppet King. Conditioning is okay - takes 2 cards and
> moves the blood cost to the acting minion for an extra +1 bleed, but
> not spectacular or anything.

Remember that if you're using the garou to bleed, they regenerate the cost of
Conditioning right back. And if they're blocked, well, they're garou and
combat monsters. Bruise'n'bleed with cardless rush. Mmm, sounds tasty.

HG

GreenO

unread,
Oct 29, 2008, 12:52:36 PM10/29/08
to

In shoeboxes under beds where they rightly belong. In mint condition,
Gathering dust.

GreenO
-lovin' the reprint strategy

Thrall of Arika

unread,
Oct 29, 2008, 12:58:52 PM10/29/08
to
On Oct 27, 4:35 pm, Brum <tiago.br...@gmail.com> wrote:
> On 26 Out, 07:26, Blooded Sand <sandm...@gmail.com> wrote:
>
> > Please?
>
> > Pretty please?
>
> > With a tied down antediluvian on top?

>
> http://www.sabbatinfrance.org/newforum/viewtopic.php?t=1530&start=275
>
> go back n forth if ye can read that. there's the toreador precon
>
> Tiago

Again, from the above forum, the Ventrue Precon:

Deckname: Ventrue Starter Deck
Author: L. Scott Johnson

Crypt
2 Jackson Asher 2 dom (4)
2 João Bilé 5 pre DOM FOR When João has no title, he cannot block
titled vampires. He gets +1 stealth on actions to put vampires into
play. (4)
2 Johannes Castelein 9 DEM DOM FOR PRE Prince of Amsterdam: If a
political action card Johannes plays or a referendum he calls is
canceled, the Methuselah canceling it burns 2 pool. (4)
2 Gustav Breidenstein 10 aus cel pot DOM FOR PRE Prince of Berlin:
Gustav may tap during a referendum to gain 5 additional votes. +1
bleed. (4)
2 Gotsdam, the Tired Warrior 9 ani AUS DOM FOR PRE Gotsdam may end
combat as a strike that costs 1 blood. He treats aggravated damage as
normal damage in combat. He is immune to frenzy cards. (4)
2 Hardestadt 11 cel pro DOM FOR POT PRE Ventrue Inner Circle: Any
vampire contesting Hardestadt's title must yield during his or her
untap phase. +1 bleed. +2 strength. (4)

Library
1 Social Ladder
2 Esgrima
2 Instability
2 Special Report
2 Vessel
1 Golconda: Inner Peace
1 Powerbase: Montreal
1 Presence
1 Dominate
1 Fortitude

1 Martinelli's Ring

3 Fourth Tradition: The Accounting
1 Dominate Kine

5 Murmur of the False Will

5 Conditioning
3 Aura of Invicibility
4 Seduction
3 Freak Drive

5 Honor the Elders
1 Praxis Seizure: Atlanta
1 Praxis Seizure: Miami
3 Can't Take it with You
6 Kine Resource Contested
1 Reins of Power
2 National Guard Support

4 Majesty
4 Armor of Vitality
6 Soak
2 Haymarker

3 Second Tradition: Domain


Chris, Thrall of Arika

Shockwave

unread,
Oct 29, 2008, 1:04:00 PM10/29/08
to
> 3 Freak Drive

Not having my playgroup upset they can't get hold of the damn things
because they started in 3rd Edition? Priceless.

I have to say, over here in sunny, sunny Manchester (sic) we're really
quite psyched about KoT based on what we've seen. I'm just still
shaking my fist at Malks being yet ANOTHER Starter, and the rumours of
no Gargoyles for the poor Trem. I wonder if there are any bloodline
Vampires in the set (even a token !Lasombra?)

Chris Berger

unread,
Oct 29, 2008, 1:17:16 PM10/29/08
to

I wonder if there's any chance, what with no Tremere starter and a
seemingly small amount of thaum reprints, that we might see a small
set themed around blood magic next. Something like Tremere, !Tre,
Gargoyles, possibly some Assamites, Giovanni, Harbingers, Tzimisce,
maybe some other bloodlines, with random token vamps from other
clans. Maybe with Rituals? Would be an interesting theme set, and I
would like seeing things broken down into functional groups that are
not based solely on sect.

Thrall of Arika

unread,
Oct 29, 2008, 1:34:28 PM10/29/08
to

Well, don't take the list of reprints presented earlier in this thread
as the definitive list. There are pleny more cards to go on that list
(i.e. only Malkavian Justicar was listed as a reprint, but I'm sure
there are the 5 other Justicar vote cards as well). I'm sure there'll
be some Tremere goodness. Well, there'd better be, at any rate ...

Chris, Thrall of Arika

James Coupe

unread,
Oct 29, 2008, 1:21:45 PM10/29/08
to
In message <f9312131-0f9d-49ac...@y71g2000hsa.googlegroup

s.com>, Peter D Bakija <pd...@lightlink.com> writes:
>> He'll be great in a Gargoyle deck, since he won't be expected to do
>> much fighting.
>
>Also totally good--a 5 cap in a Slave Gargoyle deck with DOM, AUS?
>There isn't going to be much Thaumaturgy.

Point of pedantry: a quick scan in ARDB suggests that 10 of 11
Visceratika cards have Thaumaturgy fallbacks. Using him to cycle cards
in a pinch is possibly going to get nasty.

Not that I disagree with your overall point, which is that a 5 cap with
AUS/DOM and THA in a pinch is potentially good. My first thought was
whether the !Ventrue might like to play.

--
James Coupe
PGP Key: 0x5D623D5D YOU ARE IN ERROR.
EBD690ECD7A1FB457CA2 NO-ONE IS SCREAMING.
13D7E668C3695D623D5D THANK YOU FOR YOUR COOPERATION.

Thrall of Arika

unread,
Oct 29, 2008, 1:42:48 PM10/29/08
to

It was in the forums, just another thread .. here's the Toreador
Precon, from a post on the above site:

2 Sean Andrews 2 cel (4)
2 Tho;as De Lutrius 4 aus cel pre Primogen If Thomas goes to topror,
burn 1 pool. (4)
2 Kateline Nadasdy AUS CEL PRE 7 During a political action, Kateline
may burn 1 blood to force a non-acting vampire to abstain. (4)
2 Eugene AUS CEL FOR PRE 8 Primogen Once each combat, Eugene may dodge
as a strike. (4)
2 Rafael de Corazon AUS CEL DOM OBF PRE 11 Toreador Inner Circle Any
vampire contesting Rafael's title must yield during his or her untaps
phase. +2 bleed (4)
2 Epikasta Rigastos cel AUS DOM PRE 8 Prince of New York You may move
an action card Epikasta plays from your ash heap to your library at
the end of the Action (shuffle afterward) (4)

2 Contingency Planning
2 Vessel
1 The Rack
2 Fame
1 Auspex
1 Celerity
1 Presence

6 Pubilc Trust
1 Entrancement

4 Approximation of Loyalty
4 Crocodile's Tongue
3 Suppressing the Fire

4 Kine Resource Contested
1 Praxis Seizure: Houston
1 Praxis Seizure: Washington DC

1 Bowl of Convergence
1 Mark V
5 Beretta
3 Desert Eagle
1 ivory Boz ((Assuming Ivory Bow ... but hey, maybe there is a
Charlie's Angels connection going on here ...))
2 IR Googles
3 Sniper Riffle

6 Pursuit
2 Concealed Weapon
3 Psyche!
3 Taste of Vitae

3 Eagle's Sight
4 Minor Irritation
2 On the Qui Vive
4 Telepathic Misdirection


At first, I thought Rafael, the new IC, would be a Gwendolyn .. then
saw the superior DOM and OBF. And it seems Toreador really like their
guns ... who knew?
Chris, Thrall of Arika

Merlin

unread,
Oct 29, 2008, 1:55:55 PM10/29/08
to
On Oct 27, 10:28 pm, fred_ging...@sympatico.ca wrote:

> On Oct 26, 3:26 am, Blooded Sand <sandm...@gmail.com> wrote:
>
> > Please?
>
> > Pretty please?
>
> > With a tied down antediluvian on top?
>
> Dunno why no one else replied. Probably all busy going back home or
> tired for Montrealers who spent the week there.
>
> Here is a small preview then...
>
> Confirmed reprints in boosters:
>
> Aching Beauty
> Approximation of Loyalty
> Arms Dealer
> Assault Rifle
> Aura of Invincibility
> Backstep
> Camera Phone

> Can't Take it with You
> Caseless Rounds
> Change of Target
> Concealed Weapon
> Desert Eagle
> Diversity
> Dragon's Breath Rounds
> Elysium: The Arboretum
> Empowering the Puppet King
> Fast Hands
> Fifth Tradition: Hospitality, The
> Finding the Path
> First Tradition: The Masquerade, The
> Forced Vigilance
> Fourth Tradition: The Accounting, The
> Frontal Assault
> Glancing Blow
> Graverobbing
> Harass
> Heart of Nizchetus, The
> High Ground
> Hostile Takeover
> Indomitability
> Life in the City
> Malkavian Justicar
> On the Qui Vive
> Powerbase: Chicago
> Powerbase: Montreal (in Ventrue Preconstructed)
> Reins of Power
> Rumors of Gehenna
> Scattershot
> Second Tradition: Domain, The
> Seduction
> Sixth Tradition: Destruction, The
> Soak
> Stutter-Step
> Summoning, The
> Tension in the Ranks
> Third Tradition: Progeny, The
> Toreador Grand Ball
> Unmasking, The
> Uptown Hunting Ground
> Ventrue Headquarters
> Warzone Hunting Ground
> Zillah's Valley
>

Hmmm. No Deflection listed there. I hope it gets reprinted in KoT
boosters, since it's been out of print for some time (Camarilla
edition). It would be nice for newer players to not need a benefactor
to get their hands on one of the most powerful commons in the game.

-Merlin

Thrall of Arika

unread,
Oct 29, 2008, 2:25:35 PM10/29/08
to
On Oct 27, 4:35 pm, Brum <tiago.br...@gmail.com> wrote:
> On 26 Out, 07:26, Blooded Sand <sandm...@gmail.com> wrote:
>
> > Please?
>
> > Pretty please?
>
> > With a tied down antediluvian on top?
>
> http://www.sabbatinfrance.org/newforum/viewtopic.php?t=1530&start=275
>
> go back n forth if ye can read that. there's the toreador precon
>
> Tiago

Compiled from the above cited thread, with a few zomg! cards at the
end that make me wonder if these are true card texts.

> Library Cards:
>
> Deep Song
> ani Bleed at +1 bleed.
> ANI Frenzy. (D) Tap a ready vampire controlled by another Methuselah and enter combat with that
> vampire. In that combat, that vampire is considered the acting minion.

Animalism bleed is nice, and an odd rush to further add to the multi-
action type cards.

> Scourge of the Enochians
> Event.
> During your discard phase, you may burn a vampire of capacity 2 or less, and your predator takes > control of this card (even if you do not burn a vampire).

More weenie hate.

> Crypt Cards:
>
> Aidan Lyle
> 7 cap Tremere
> dom AUS CHI THA
> Camarilla: Aidan gets an optional press each combat.

Superior THA and a built-in press .. yum!

> Dr. John Dee
> 9 cap Tremere group 4
> chi ANI AUS DOM THA
> Camarilla Prince of London: Ventrue in combat with John may not end combat as a strike. During
> a referendum, John may burn a card that requires Thaumaturgy from your hand to gain two votes.

"Majesty out of this, Ventrue scum!"

Of course, with the new "doing the job themselves" Ventrue like
Hardestadt ...

> Gabrielle di Righetti
> 10 cap Tremere
> obf pot ANI AUS DOM THA
> Camarilla Tremere Justicar: Gabrielle may steal 2 blood (or life) from a ready minion as a +1
> stealth (D) action.
>
> Graham Gottesman
> 7 cap
> obf pre tha DOM FOR prince of Miami.
>
> Miguel Cordovera
> 6 cap Tremere
> AUS DOM POT THA
> Camarilla: During your predator's minion phase, your predator may burn a pool to untap and take
> control of Miguel until the end of the minion phase. +1 bleed.

Could be just as dangerous to you as your prey. I don't think he'll be
one to bring out first. Look to see what your Predator is playing
first .. the last thing you need is to help them power-bleed you out.

> William Thorbecke
> 10 cap Tremere
> AUS DOM PRE PRO THA
> Camarilla Primogen: During your discard phase, William may burn 2 blood to untap a minion you
> control.
>
> Zane
> 5 cap Tremere
> aus dom THA
> Camarilla Primogen: If Zane is not a prince, he can call a referendum to receive (and contest) the
> title held by a prince in play as a +1 stealth political action.

Definitely seeing Contesting being brought back into the game.

> Lodin (Olaf Holte)
> 8 cap
> aus pro DOM FOR PRE prince of Chicago can prevent 1 damage from opposing minion's strike
> once per combat.

Assuming this is a Ventrue

> Josef von Bauren
> 11 cap Nosferatu
> cel ANI DEM OBF POT
> Camarilla Nosferatu Inner Circle: You may use a discard phase action to discard a card at random > from your predator or prey's hand. +1 bleed. +1 stealth.
>
> Bela
> 3 cap Malkavain
> ani obf pro DEM
> Independent: Bela cannot attempt political actions. -1 stealth.
>
> Blood Mary
> 8 cap Malkavian
> pre AUS DEM OBF
> Camarilla primogen: +1 bleed.
>
> Gem Ghastly
> 6 cap Malkavian
> aus DEM OBF
> Camarilla Primogen: You and Gem may play cards that require Ventrue as if Gem were a Ventrue.

Not seeing a lot of useful cards at the moment for this ability.
Ventrue Headquarters, of course, and Political Ally .. as if Malks
needed more bleed potential.

> Kalila
> 3 cap Malkavian
> aus obf
> Camarilla: Kalila gets +1 strealth when performing a (D) action that targets locations.
>
> Keller Thiel
> 4 cap Malkavian
> aus dem
> Camarilla: While Keller is ready and untapped, any minino who successfully bleeds you burns 1
> blood or life.

A nice little deterrent to being bled.

> Lord Fianna
> 8 cap Malkavian
> cel pro AUS DEM OBF
> Camarilla. Red List: Allies cannot block Lord Fianna. +1 stealth.

Bleed fast, little Malk, you've got a huge bullseye painted on your
chest.

> Reiner Stoschka
> 7 cap Malkavian
> obf AUS DEM THA
> Camarilla: While Reiner is ready, master: Discipline cards may be played as trifles.
>
> Don Cerro
> 7 cap Brujah
> aus dom for pre pro CEL POT
>
> Honest Abe
> 2 cap Brujah
> pre
>
> Lynn
> 3 cap Brujah
> cel pot
> Camarilla: Lynn cannot have a haven. Any haven that she would receive is burned instead.
>
> Vidal Jarbeaux
> 8 cap Toreador
> aus cel obf pot PRE
> Camarilla: Vidal can meet the clan, sect, or non-infernal vampire trait (e.g. anarch) requirement to
> play any card. He can meet a given requirement only once each game. +1 bleed.

Neat ability. Not sure how entirely useful it would be in the long
run, but I can see the potential in some ally themed decks.

> Count Zaroff
> 4 cap Caitiff
> cel obf
> Camarilla: Once each turn, you may burn a pool to cancel a blood hunt called on Zaroff and return
> him to the uncontrolled region.
>
> Donald Cargill
> 1 cap Caitiff
> aus
> Camarilla: When a referendum called by your predator passes, Donald burns 1 blood.
>
> Iris Bennett
> 1 cap Caitiff
> pro
> Camarilla: When an older vampire blocks Iris, his or her controller may look at your hand (before
> combat, if any).
>
> Johan Wrede
> 1 cap Caitiff group 4
> tha
> Camarilla: While Johan is bleeding, any older vampire can burn 1 blood to reduce the bleed
> amount by 1.


Alrighty then ... sit down, don't drink, and have a gander at the
following:

> Ashur Tablets
> Master.
> Put this card in play. If you have three copies in play, remove all copies in play (even controlled by
> other Methuselahs) from the game to gain 3 pool and choose up to thirteen cards from your ash
> heap. Move one of those cards to your hand and shuffle the others into your library.

Pool gain and massive recursion ... with a race to see who can get the
effect off first.

> Blood of Sandman
> costs 2 blood
> tha +1 stealth action. (D) Burn an ally.
> THA +6 stealth action. (D) Put this card on a ready younger tapped vampire. Reaction cards this
> vampire plays while tapped are canceled as they are played. Burn this card if this vampire goes to
> torpor.

+6 stealth?? I'm really thinking this is a typo or misreading.
Virtually no way to block, and makes waking pointless. Yowzers.

> Waiting Game
> event Transient.
> Put this card in play with 10 counters. Whenever a non-anarch vampire takes an action, burn a
> counter from this card. Burn this card when it has no counters. During your untap phase, each
> anarch burns 1 blood or becomes Camarilla, and each ally burns 1 life.

Overrun by Anarchs? Imbued cramping your style? Have no fear! Just
hole up for a little while and your problems will disappear!

> Mistress Fanchion
> 11 cap Tremere
> AUS CEL DOM OBF THA VIC
> Camarilla Tremere Inner Circle: Mistress Fanchion may search your library (shuffle afterward) for
> any minion card and move that card to your hand as a +1 stealth action. +2 bleed.

Hard to decide just what way to go with Mistress here ... stealth
bleed? Check. Blur theft? Check. Agg Blood Fury/Rage? Check. Nevermind
being able to fish for your set up cards right away. Arika may have
just lost her Thrall.

> Alonso Petrodon
> 10 cap Nosferatu
> for tha ANI DOM OBF POT
> Camarilla Nosferatu Justicar: When Alonso bleeds successfully, each anarch controlled by the
> target takes 1 unpreventable damage. +1 bleed.

A lot of Anarch hit back in this set, what with Alonso here and
Waiting Game. Which isn't a bad thing, as a lot of decks I've seen
recently use Anarch Converts just to cycle through crypts, and throw
in a bit of anarchy into the decks. Now we'll have to think twice
about randomly going anarch.

> The Ankou
> 10 cap Malkavian
> AUS DEM OBF
> Camarilla: When any vampire succesfully hunts while The Ankou is ready and untapped, the
> Ankou may burn that vampire as a (D) action that turn (even on another Methuselah's turn).

I can see some nasty blood drain decks coming out in the near future.

> Santaleous
> 9 cap Malkavian
> AUS CEL DEM OBF
> Camarilla. Santaleous gets +1 bleed for each unique hunting ground in play. He may burn 3 blood
> to cancel a master card as it is played

Rather interesting special, but I think that's going to be
overshadowed by the built-in Sudden and anti-DI.


Chris, currently still Thrall of Arika

Blooded Sand

unread,
Oct 29, 2008, 2:30:11 PM10/29/08
to
On Oct 29, 6:42 pm, Thrall of Arika <christopher.ack...@amec.com>
wrote:

>
> 2 Rafael de Corazon AUS CEL DOM OBF PRE 11 Toreador Inner Circle Any
> vampire contesting Rafael's title must yield during his or her untaps

> At first, I thought Rafael, the new IC, would be a Gwendolyn .. then


> saw the superior DOM and OBF. And it seems Toreador really like their
> guns ... who knew?
> Chris, Thrall of Arika

Mind Rape with TGB's. Nasty! In fact, MR with Aching Beauty...

Blooded Sand

unread,
Oct 29, 2008, 2:33:40 PM10/29/08
to

Howzabout a wall deck with AUS, DOM, Ivories, snipers, and some other
stuff like Rutors or name forgotten?

Chris Berger

unread,
Oct 29, 2008, 2:54:12 PM10/29/08
to
On Oct 29, 1:25 pm, Thrall of Arika <christopher.ack...@amec.com>
wrote:

> > Santaleous
> > 9 cap Malkavian
> > AUS CEL DEM OBF
> > Camarilla. Santaleous gets +1 bleed for each unique hunting ground in play. He may burn 3 blood
> > to cancel a master card as it is played
>
> Rather interesting special, but I think that's going to be
> overshadowed by the built-in Sudden and anti-DI.
>
I'm already thinking of deck ideas with this guy. Calvin Cleaver,
multiple hunting grounds (possibly with Mata Hari - but maybe there's
someone else who can give Santa blood like Calvin can? You probably
don't need more than 3 or 4 unique hunting grounds in the deck),
Anarch Free Press and Hospital Food and Aaron's Feeding Razor,
Perfectionist, Final Loosening, Twilight Camp, maybe Forgery, maybe
Rave... You get a big stealth bleeder that can cancel master cards
like crazy and gain all the blood back.

Jozxyqk

unread,
Oct 29, 2008, 3:01:06 PM10/29/08
to
Thrall of Arika <christoph...@amec.com> wrote:
> > Vidal Jarbeaux
> > 8 cap Toreador
> > aus cel obf pot PRE
> > Camarilla: Vidal can meet the clan, sect, or non-infernal vampire trait (e.g. anarch) requirement to
> > play any card. He can meet a given requirement only once each game. +1 bleed.

Sounds like an accounting nightmare.
"Was I an anarch yet this game? Was I a Malkavian yet this game?"

Also, can we have a definition of what is a "non-infernal vampire trait"?
Is a title a trait?
Do "anarch" and "baron" count as different traits?
Is flight a trait? (If not, what is it?)
Is "ready" a trait (as in "requires a ready vampire")? [probably not]
Is "untapped" a trait (as in "requires an untapped vampire")? [probably not]

If titles don't count, then I can think of:
anarch
black hand
seraph
inquisitor
slave
red list
flight(?)

Any others?

Thrall of Arika

unread,
Oct 29, 2008, 3:02:05 PM10/29/08
to
On Oct 29, 5:56 am, Chris Berger <ark...@ugcs.caltech.edu> wrote:
> On Oct 29, 7:48 am, Peter D Bakija <p...@lightlink.com> wrote:
>
>
>
> > On Oct 29, 6:04 am, J <grai...@hotmail.com> wrote:
>
> > > I concur to some extent with Tim...
> > > Yes, he can be played in Aus/Dom or Aus or Dom decks, but his special
> > > makes his superior THA almost completely worthless to the point that
> > > he'll hardly ever be seen in a Tremere deck, which means that he is an
> > > overpriced vampire, because one of his disciplines is negligible.
>
> > Except that he isn't overpriced, as he is a 5 cap with 6 points in
> > disciplines. And 5 caps only get 5 points in abilities. So he is
> > getting THA instead of tha, but with a disadvantage to balance it out.
> > Which means he is a 5 cap with DOM, AUS (which is very strong in and
> > of itself) who has conditional THA in a pinch. If you put him in a
> > deck that only uses DOM, AUS (or just DOM--no one ever does well with
> > mono DOM after all...), he is a really good 5 cap vampire. If you put
> > him in a deck with a lot of Thaumaturgy, and expect to use the
> > Thaumaturgy a lot, you probably aren't going to get much good use out
> > of him.
>
> How much Thuam do people put in their "lots of Thaum" decks?  Like 45
> cards, max?  Even that seems a bit much, but I don't know.  If it's
> 45, then you have approximately a 50% chance of getting a Thaum card
> canceled.  Considering he's playing it at superior which he doesn't
> really have a right to do, and he has AUS DOM, that seems pretty
> fair.  How strong do Tremere players want their vamps to be?  Does
> each one have to be Muaziz?

>
> He'll be great in a Gargoyle deck, since he won't be expected to do
> much fighting.

My Thaumaturgy decks average about 30 thaum cards .. so it would be a
1 in 3 chance of having the card negated. And burn a blood on top of
it? Nah, I'll pass, for my regular Tremere/Thaumaturgy decks. Though I
can certainly see the potential in decks oriented towards Auspex/
Dominate, with perhaps a smattering of Thaum.

Chris, Thrall of Arika

Jozxyqk

unread,
Oct 29, 2008, 3:04:02 PM10/29/08
to
Jozxyqk <jfeu...@eecs.tufts.edu> wrote:
> If titles don't count, then I can think of:
> anarch
> black hand
> seraph
> inquisitor
> slave
(and "non-slave")
> red list
> flight(?)

> Any others?

Another question I have about this guy:
Does his "He can meet a given requirement only once each game" include
requirements he already meets (like "requires a Toreador")?

James Coupe

unread,
Oct 29, 2008, 3:08:19 PM10/29/08
to
In message <fa68eb54-b481-4d1c...@m44g2000hsc.googlegroup

s.com>, Thrall of Arika <christoph...@amec.com> writes:
>> Gem Ghastly
>> 6 cap Malkavian
>> aus DEM OBF
>> Camarilla Primogen: You and Gem may play cards that require Ventrue as if Gem were a Ventrue.
>
>Not seeing a lot of useful cards at the moment for this ability.
>Ventrue Headquarters, of course, and Political Ally .. as if Malks
>needed more bleed potential.

Well, I think Ventrue HQ is pretty good on its own. Between that and
Telepathic Vote Counting, you could have some fun, without requiring
Presence.

But, you missed one. Hostile Takeover. Kindred Spirits to fuel pool
gain with some Dem vampires, and a scattering of Hostile Takeover. You
don't need loads, just one or two could be fine.

If there are any new Ventrue with dem/DEM to help out, you might have
interesting times.

John Flournoy

unread,
Oct 29, 2008, 3:16:07 PM10/29/08
to
On Oct 29, 2:01 pm, Jozxyqk <jfeue...@eecs.tufts.edu> wrote:

Sterile
Scarce

Key possibility: "(Chicago/MC/etc) Circle"

-John Flournoy

James Coupe

unread,
Oct 29, 2008, 3:23:24 PM10/29/08
to
In message <geabti$95n$1...@aioe.org>, Jozxyqk <jfeu...@eecs.tufts.edu>
writes:

Thrall of Arika <christoph...@amec.com> wrote:
> > Vidal Jarbeaux
> > 8 cap Toreador
> > aus cel obf pot PRE
> > Camarilla: Vidal can meet the clan, sect, or non-infernal vampire trait (e.g. anarch) requirement to
> > play any card. He can meet a given requirement only once each game. +1 bleed.
>Sounds like an accounting nightmare.
>"Was I an anarch yet this game? Was I a Malkavian yet this game?"

Since your ash heap is unordered, keep a separate ash-heap for him.

>If titles don't count, then I can think of:

...
>red list

I don't know what "vampire trait" means. Is it "any trait a vampire can
have"? Or is it "vampire only"?

Ossian is Red List, for example.

John Flournoy

unread,
Oct 29, 2008, 3:39:31 PM10/29/08
to
On Oct 29, 2:02 pm, Thrall of Arika <christopher.ack...@amec.com>
wrote:

Of course, there are some ways to know what the top card(s) on your
deck are so that you'll know if you can do it or not. Scrounging, for
instance, or Thin-Blooded Seer, or Tapestry of Blood could all work,
or in a mix-crypt with several possibilities opened up that way.

> Chris, Thrall of Arika

brandons...@yahoo.com

unread,
Oct 29, 2008, 3:55:23 PM10/29/08
to
On Oct 29, 12:04 pm, Jozxyqk <jfeue...@eecs.tufts.edu> wrote:

It would be really funny if other players could play clan hosers on
him as if he had any trait.

As he is, that is a really strong power.

Thrall of Arika

unread,
Oct 29, 2008, 4:00:49 PM10/29/08
to
On Oct 29, 12:01 pm, Jozxyqk <jfeue...@eecs.tufts.edu> wrote:

> Thrall of Arika <christopher.ack...@amec.com> wrote:
>
> > > Vidal Jarbeaux
> > > 8 cap Toreador
> > > aus cel obf pot PRE
> > > Camarilla: Vidal can meet the clan, sect, or non-infernal vampire trait (e.g. anarch) requirement to
> > > play any card. He can meet a given requirement only once each game. +1 bleed.
>
> Sounds like an accounting nightmare.
> "Was I an anarch yet this game? Was I a Malkavian yet this game?"
>
> Also, can we have a definition of what is a "non-infernal vampire trait"?
> Is a title a trait?
> Do "anarch" and "baron" count as different traits?
> Is flight a trait? (If not, what is it?)
> Is "ready" a trait (as in "requires a ready vampire")? [probably not]
> Is "untapped" a trait (as in "requires an untapped vampire")? [probably not]
>
> If titles don't count, then I can think of:
> anarch
> black hand
> seraph
> inquisitor
> slave
> red list
> flight(?)
>
> Any others?

My guess would be based on the card you wanted to play, which would
say "Requires a XX vampire ..."

So would include all the clans, Sabbat, Independent, and Laibon, then:

Anarch, Black Hand, Inquisitor, Seraph, Red List, as well as Slave,
Templar and Sterile (of which there are no cards requiring them).

I don't see Titles as being traits, though I have no basis for that
currently. Flight wouldn't be a trait, references to Flight make it
akin to a Discipline, i.e., "this vampire gains Flight". Ready,
Untapped, Uncontrolled, etc. are not traits, they are states that
apply to any card, not an inherent key-word associated with a
particular vampire. I would also conclude that his ability does not
cover those instances of lack of a trait, "non-sterile" for example.

As to accounting, well, can see which cards are in play, and maybe
make a little secondary discard pile to put in all the used/burned
from play cards that his ability was used for.

Chris, Thrall of Arika

On Oct 29, 12:04 pm, Jozxyqk <jfeue...@eecs.tufts.edu> wrote:
> Another question I have about this guy:
> Does his "He can meet a given requirement only once each game" include
> requirements he already meets (like "requires a Toreador")?

His ability says "can", so you don't have to use his ability to play
cards.

On Oct 29, 12:23 pm, James Coupe <ja...@zephyr.org.uk> wrote:
> >If titles don't count, then I can think of:
> ...
> >red list
>
> I don't know what "vampire trait" means.  Is it "any trait a vampire can
> have"?  Or is it "vampire only"?
>
> Ossian is Red List, for example.

I would think that the wording is to prevent the use of Imbued and
Creed cards. And while Ossian is indeed a Red List minion, this
doesn't preclude the fact that there are Red List vampires.

Chris, wavering Thrall of Arika

Chris Berger

unread,
Oct 29, 2008, 4:30:42 PM10/29/08
to
On Oct 29, 3:00 pm, Thrall of Arika <christopher.ack...@amec.com>
wrote:
>

> I don't see Titles as being traits, though I have no basis for that
> currently. Flight wouldn't be a trait, references to Flight make it
> akin to a Discipline, i.e., "this vampire gains Flight". Ready,
> Untapped, Uncontrolled, etc. are not traits, they are states that
> apply to any card, not an inherent key-word associated with a
> particular vampire. I would also conclude that his ability does not
> cover those instances of lack of a trait, "non-sterile" for example.
>
I'm divided on Titles - I think they might be considered a trait. If
I . Flight is definitely a trait. It is emphatically not a
discipline, even though it is treated in most ways as though it were.

The other things above, I agree with.

Chris Berger

unread,
Oct 29, 2008, 4:36:44 PM10/29/08
to
On Oct 29, 3:30 pm, Chris Berger <ark...@ugcs.caltech.edu> wrote:

>
> I'm divided on Titles - I think they might be considered a trait.  If
> I .  Flight is definitely a trait.  It is emphatically not a
> discipline, even though it is treated in most ways as though it were.
>

"If I" above was the start of a thought... ;) Was interrupted by some
important business and when I came back, forgot where I was. I was
just going to say "if I were a judge at a tournament and asked to make
a ruling, I would say titles count", though of course that means that
LSJ will say the opposite... ;)

Kushiel

unread,
Oct 29, 2008, 4:43:08 PM10/29/08
to
On Oct 29, 12:21 pm, Chris Berger <ark...@ugcs.caltech.edu> wrote:
> Explain how.  I'm legitimately curious.  A lot of people seem excited
> with Mouthpiece, and I want to know what I'm missing.

It's not really that difficult to figure out. Would you rather have
your allies bleeding for one or for three? And Buddies will regenerate
the cost of playing Conditioning every turn...

John Eno

Frederick Scott

unread,
Oct 29, 2008, 4:58:27 PM10/29/08
to
"Merlin" <hallofha...@sbcglobal.net> wrote in message
news:3742b184-84d2-4285...@t54g2000hsg.googlegroups.com...

> Hmmm. No Deflection listed there. I hope it gets reprinted in KoT
> boosters, since it's been out of print for some time (Camarilla
> edition). It would be nice for newer players to not need a benefactor
> to get their hands on one of the most powerful commons in the game.

I don't disagree with your sentiments about Deflection. It's an important
card that should be reprinted often. But it was in the Black Hand Tremere
precon. Four copies, according to the "Card Text Updates" link on the
WW website. Hopefully, it will be a reprint in KoT boosters.

Fred


brandons...@yahoo.com

unread,
Oct 29, 2008, 5:24:45 PM10/29/08
to
> I don't disagree with your sentiments about Deflection.  It's an important
> card that should be reprinted often.  But it was in the Black Hand Tremere
> precon.  Four copies, according to the "Card Text Updates" link on the
> WW website.  Hopefully, it will be a reprint in KoT boosters.

It's been a big issue with me since I started up a little more than a
year ago. If I stayed with only LotN and TR, the two sets released
since I started, I would have only MotfW and Lost in Translation
bounce, each of which require fatties to get much use out of. So far
I've managed to scrounge 4-5 out of a used box of Jyhad (about 1
booster box), some from trading, and some from charity. I probably
don't have more than 12 copies as of today. I'd love it if they
printed some in boosters, so that I could more easily trade for them
if nothing else.

librarian

unread,
Oct 29, 2008, 6:35:14 PM10/29/08
to
Jadasc wrote:
> On Oct 27, 8:53 pm, librarian <aucti...@superfuncards.com> wrote:
>
>> Horseshoe
>> Action
>> pot: Do 1 damage to a ready minion
>> POT: Do 2 damage to a ready minion
>
> Does not combo well with Grenade. Oh, well. Close enough.
>
> Jason

That's hilarious. Will still have to run that deck, if only for giggles
on JOL.

12 Horseshoes
6 Grenades
4 Smoke Grenades
4 White Phosporous Grenades

I'm thinking weenie pot/obf...

Close enough to count...

best -

chris

--
Super Fun Cards
www.superfuncards.com *NEW Website!*
auct...@superfuncards.com

Peter D Bakija

unread,
Oct 29, 2008, 7:07:42 PM10/29/08
to
In article <x2u4FWIp...@gratiano.zephyr.org.uk>,
James Coupe <ja...@zephyr.org.uk> wrote:

> Point of pedantry: a quick scan in ARDB suggests that 10 of 11
> Visceratika cards have Thaumaturgy fallbacks. Using him to cycle cards
> in a pinch is possibly going to get nasty.

Sure. So you don't do that :-)

Peter D Bakija
pd...@lightlink.com
http://www.lightlink.com/pdb6/vtes.html

"It's too bad she won't live! But then again, who does?"
-Gaff

Pullen

unread,
Oct 29, 2008, 9:59:29 PM10/29/08
to
> Mistress Fanchion
> 11 cap Tremere
> AUS CEL DOM OBF THA VIC
> Camarilla Tremere Inner Circle: Mistress Fanchion may search your library (shuffle afterward) for
> any minion card and move that card to your hand as a +1 stealth action. +2 bleed.

She can be my mistress any day. The ability to go get a Rutor's Hand
and maybe a Helicopter as soon as she pops out allows her to do some
nasty thing, Perfect Clarity and Soul Decoration is a nice combo to
come to mind, in combat she should put some hurt on, man, theirs so
much I want to do with her I'm just pissed there's no starter for me
to pick up to get her.

bwross

unread,
Oct 29, 2008, 10:56:15 PM10/29/08
to
On Oct 29, 2:33 pm, Blooded Sand <sandm...@gmail.com> wrote:
> Howzabout a wall deck with AUS, DOM, Ivories, snipers, and some other
> stuff like Rutors or name forgotten?

Sounds pretty much like my idea for an Old Clan Tzimisce deck (ani/aus/
dom and most importantly: absolutely no vic on any vampire in the
crypt... it's that final restriction which keeps out all but two
weenies from the Tzimisce currently printed). Andrew Stuart is the
most cost effective non-weenie printed to date for such a deck.

Brent Ross

brandons...@yahoo.com

unread,
Oct 30, 2008, 12:29:36 AM10/30/08
to

I thought that Old Clan Tzimisce had Protean instead of Vic and that
Vic is a disease

bwross

unread,
Oct 30, 2008, 2:34:06 AM10/30/08
to
On Oct 30, 12:29 am, brandonsantac...@yahoo.com wrote:
> I thought that Old Clan Tzimisce had Protean instead of Vic and that
> Vic is a disease

Nope. Just plain old Dominate (which makes sense, since both Tzimisce
and Gangrel are part of the 13 clans... Protean being a clan
discipline is tied to Gangrel and thier offshoot Bloodlines). Old
Clan Tzimisce are the ones with Kodunic Sorcery (which is their exotic
feature).

And, yep, they believe that Vicissitude isn't a proper blood power but
a disease or parasite that's eventually going to enslave and/or
destroy all vampires with it. And they're probably right, unless your
GM decides not to use that.

Brent Ross

Chris Berger

unread,
Oct 30, 2008, 8:00:30 AM10/30/08
to
I guess it *is* difficult to figure out. There are already ways to
have allies bleed for 3 that don't cost life. Sure, it's good for
Black Spiral Buddy, if you want to make an ally bruise-and-bleed with
a clan that has exactly 2 vampires (3 if you count Sebastien advanced
as separate from basic) with superior dominate. For me, when I play
my Renegade Garou decks, they usually teter on the edge of not having
enough life, and I'd also rather have them rush than bleed most of the
time. Without the in-built rush, yes, it's better for the Buddy than
the Garou, but it still involves bolting on a discipline, and for all
your work is it *that* much better than Empowering? For most allies,
which don't regenerate, they can't afford the blood cost as well as
your vampire can. I guess I can see that it makes one very specific
deck slightly better by using 2 cards to get +2 bleed instead of one
card for +1 bleed. But I don't see much use in any other deck, nor
any reason to get particularly excited.

Blooded Sand

unread,
Oct 30, 2008, 10:48:25 AM10/30/08
to

!Trem and Succubi.....

Rhavas

unread,
Oct 30, 2008, 10:57:00 AM10/30/08
to
>
> > The Ankou
> > 10 cap Malkavian
> > AUS DEM OBF
> > Camarilla: When any vampire succesfully hunts while The Ankou is ready and untapped, the
> > Ankou may burn that vampire as a (D) action that turn (even on another Methuselah's turn).
>
> I can see some nasty blood drain decks coming out in the near future.


The timing of this guys ability (take an action during someone else's
turn) makes me wonder. Not to mention, thats REALLY powerful. Yes,
he has to be untapped, but that isn't too hard to work around.

Chris Berger

unread,
Oct 30, 2008, 11:10:41 AM10/30/08
to

He does look nasty. But as a 10 cap with no title, 6 points of
disciplines and no untap discipline, I don't think it's too crazy.
Not to mention you have to actually stealth the burn action through
(not difficult for him, but just another thing to think about). He
can use Eluding the Arms of Morpheus to untap, but not if it's cross-
table. Theoretically, he could Wake, Eagle's Sight, Eluding, then
fail to block, but that seems overly complicated. Instances where he
desperately wants to burn cross-table seem like they'll be somewhat
uncommon anyway (as in, it'll happen occasionally, but is it worth
working into your deck for those circumstances?). Metro Underground
will be awesome, of course. Powerbase: LA too, if you want to work in
an Anarch angle.

Shockwave

unread,
Oct 30, 2008, 11:19:56 AM10/30/08
to
> !Trem and Succubi.....- Hide quoted text -
>
> - Show quoted text -

!Trem and damned Nephandus (Hugh must be giggling like an idiot)

As I noted Chris, I think just stacking Mouthpiece is worth it. Your
Vampire doesn't need to be untapped, and it costs nothing. Fine, it's
only +1 Bleed, but it means now the BSB's are *hurting* rather than
sitting there.

Kushiel

unread,
Oct 30, 2008, 11:21:58 AM10/30/08
to
On Oct 30, 8:00 am, Chris Berger <ark...@ugcs.caltech.edu> wrote:
> I guess it *is* difficult to figure out.  

Not really. People get excited when cards are printed that let them
bleed for more. That isn't to say that their analyses of those cards
are necessarily correct, but I don't think it's tough to see why
people are excited.

> But I don't see much use in any other deck, nor
> any reason to get particularly excited.

It certainly cycles more easily than Puppet King, if nothing else.
But, yeah, I'm mostly with you on this one in terms of how good the
card is.

John Eno

Merlin

unread,
Oct 30, 2008, 12:06:47 PM10/30/08
to
On Oct 29, 4:58 pm, "Frederick Scott" <nos...@no.spam.dot.com> wrote:
> "Merlin" <hallofhadesco...@sbcglobal.net> wrote in message

Right on. I was checking Monger for my "sets printed" info. I didn't
remember if it was in the older starters, though i was positive it
wasn't in the 3E !Tremere starter or the LotN Gio starter, and none of
the LoB or KMW starters.

I'm hoping that it's just so ubiquitous that those who have seen the
KoT boosters glossed it over without thinking about it, and that it's
a common in the set.

-Merlin


Chris Berger

unread,
Oct 30, 2008, 12:08:30 PM10/30/08
to
On Oct 30, 10:21 am, Kushiel <invisibleking...@gmail.com> wrote:

(Regarding Mouthpiece)


>
> It certainly cycles more easily than Puppet King, if nothing else.
> But, yeah, I'm mostly with you on this one in terms of how good the
> card is.
>

Okay, fair enough. I guess I've been set right on some points in that
it's not *terrible*, which was my first reaction. It's just something
that I would replace with Puppet King in most decks that *I* would
play. It's probably the same reason I don't like Shared Strength. I
just don't like a 2 card combo where either card by itself is utterly
useless, unless the 2 card combo is really strong.

That said, after all the discussion, I will now probably try out the
Philippe Rigaud Black Spiral Mouthpiece deck. I'm just not sure you
could find somewhere on there that you'd want to put your mouth.

James Coupe

unread,
Oct 30, 2008, 12:21:37 PM10/30/08
to
In message <41ef04d6-ecaa-46cc...@y79g2000hsa.googlegroup
s.com>, fred_g...@sympatico.ca writes:
>Mouthpiece
>Action Modifier, dom
>dom: +1 bleed. You cannot play another action modifier to increase
>this bleed.
>DOM: Only usable by a ready vampire other than the acting minion. The
>acting minion may play cards that require basic Dominate as a vampire
>for the remainder of this action.

Assuming the DOM card text is approximately correct, could a Bima with
an Obtenebration card on it play Shroud of Absence at inferior? Or,
more generally, can "May play cards that require <Discipline> as a
vampire" specials stack up, or does each one function independently?

LSJ

unread,
Oct 30, 2008, 12:30:07 PM10/30/08
to
James Coupe wrote:
> In message <41ef04d6-ecaa-46cc...@y79g2000hsa.googlegroup
> s.com>, fred_g...@sympatico.ca writes:
>> Mouthpiece
>> Action Modifier, dom
>> dom: +1 bleed. You cannot play another action modifier to increase
>> this bleed.
>> DOM: Only usable by a ready vampire other than the acting minion. The
>> acting minion may play cards that require basic Dominate as a vampire
>> for the remainder of this action.
>
> Assuming the DOM card text is approximately correct, could a Bima with
> an Obtenebration card on it play Shroud of Absence at inferior? Or,
> more generally, can "May play cards that require <Discipline> as a
> vampire" specials stack up, or does each one function independently?

You guessed correctly here:

http://groups.google.com/group/rec.games.trading-cards.jyhad/msg/3d4aa6e913ee7940

Anthony Coleman

unread,
Oct 30, 2008, 12:57:22 PM10/30/08
to
On Oct 30, 3:19 pm, Shockwave <d_knowles...@hotmail.com> wrote:
(Hugh must be giggling like an idiot)

This is a NewsGroup Dave, and that is NOT news.

Anthony

James Coupe

unread,
Oct 30, 2008, 12:46:08 PM10/30/08
to
In message <9glOk.2532$8_3...@flpi147.ffdc.sbc.com>, LSJ
<vte...@white-wolf.com> writes:

>James Coupe wrote:
>> Assuming the DOM card text is approximately correct, could a Bima
>>with
>> an Obtenebration card on it play Shroud of Absence at inferior? Or,
>> more generally, can "May play cards that require <Discipline> as a
>> vampire" specials stack up, or does each one function independently?
>
>You guessed correctly here:
>
>http://groups.google.com/group/rec.games.trading-cards.jyhad/msg/3d4aa6
>e913ee7940

Curses. :-(

Thrall of Arika

unread,
Oct 30, 2008, 2:08:03 PM10/30/08
to
On Oct 30, 8:10 am, Chris Berger <ark...@ugcs.caltech.edu> wrote:
> On Oct 30, 9:57 am, Rhavas <Anthony.Lun...@gmail.com> wrote:
>
> > > > The Ankou
> > > > 10 cap Malkavian
> > > > AUS DEM OBF
> > > > Camarilla: When any vampire succesfully hunts while The Ankou is ready and untapped, the
> > > > Ankou may burn that vampire as a (D) action that turn (even on another Methuselah's turn).
>
> > > I can see some nasty blood drain decks coming out in the near future.
>
> > The timing of this guys ability (take an action during someone else's
> > turn) makes me wonder.  Not to mention, thats REALLY powerful.  

Timing does seem to be an issue. I'm going to assume he can act on
other methuselah's turns as if he had the Madness Network going. Now
the question becomes, it's not written as a "During X, do Y", so can
he attempt burn multiple vampires that hunted successfully, provided
he can untap?

> > Yes,
> > he has to be untapped, but that isn't too hard to work around.

Babble.

> He does look nasty.  But as a 10 cap with no title, 6 points of
> disciplines and no untap discipline, I don't think it's too crazy.
> Not to mention you have to actually stealth the burn action through
> (not difficult for him, but just another thing to think about).  He
> can use Eluding the Arms of Morpheus to untap, but not if it's cross-
> table.  Theoretically, he could Wake, Eagle's Sight, Eluding, then
> fail to block, but that seems overly complicated.  Instances where he
> desperately wants to burn cross-table seem like they'll be somewhat
> uncommon anyway (as in, it'll happen occasionally, but is it worth
> working into your deck for those circumstances?).  Metro Underground
> will be awesome, of course.  Powerbase: LA too, if you want to work in
> an Anarch angle.

Actually, going anarch looks like a way to go. Baronize, Free States
Rant and start burning blood off vampires, targeting valuable vampires
of your prey. When they hunt, you can start burning if untapped, if
not, XTC Lace Blood them, or Elude and fail to block. Final Loosening
to make sure their hunts or other blood gains don't give them much.
Thirst to keep weenies in the danger zone. Maybe a splash of
Thaumaturgy to put in CrimethIncs. Some potential anyway.

As to burning cross-table, I can't see that being a large focus.
You'll want to use The Ankou on your prey, or possibly on your
predator to control bleeding. If you're that concerned, well, stock up
on Babble.

Chris, Thrall of somebody

Thrall of Arika

unread,
Oct 30, 2008, 2:51:24 PM10/30/08
to

Hmm, still not sure. I would think that if titles are covered, that
they would have been specified, just as Clan and Sect were. I think
the fact that they are termed "titles" removes them from also being
traits, even though a title is a defining characteristic. Also, if
titles were considered traits for this card, could we not then use
more specific titles? Play one Second Tradition as the Prince of New
York, then a second as Prince of London, etc.

I would disagree on Flight being a trait. While it's not a discipline,
true, it also isn't a defining characteristic. You can say "Jack Drake
is an Anarch (vampire)", you couldn't say "Fidus is a Flight
(vampire)". You can say "Fidus has Flight, which allows him to use
these flight cards", much like you can say "Fidus has Fortitude, which
allows him to use these fortitude cards".

My assumption would be that traits are only covered by bold text,
though this brings titles back into the spotlight. But then, Clan and
Sect are also bold text, and are handled distictly.

Chris, Thrall of Arika

Thrall of Arika

unread,
Oct 30, 2008, 3:37:04 PM10/30/08
to
On Oct 27, 4:35 pm, Brum <tiago.br...@gmail.com> wrote:
> On 26 Out, 07:26, Blooded Sand <sandm...@gmail.com> wrote:
>
> > Please?
>
> > Pretty please?
>
> > With a tied down antediluvian on top?
>
> http://www.sabbatinfrance.org/newforum/viewtopic.php?t=1530&start=275
>
> go back n forth if ye can read that. there's the toreador precon
>
> Tiago

Another recent post from the above thread.

> Childling Muse
> Cardtype: Retainer
> Cost: 1 pool
> Clan: Malkavian
> Changeling with 1 life. The minion with this retainer gets +1 bleed.

Was wondering at the cost of this one, then noticed the distinct lack
of "Unique".

Chris, Thrall of somebody

Chris Berger

unread,
Oct 30, 2008, 3:13:25 PM10/30/08
to
On Oct 30, 1:08 pm, Thrall of Arika <christopher.ack...@amec.com>

wrote:
>
> > > > > The Ankou
> > > > > 10 cap Malkavian
> > > > > AUS DEM OBF
> > > > > Camarilla: When any vampire succesfully hunts while The Ankou is ready and untapped, the
> > > > > Ankou may burn that vampire as a (D) action that turn (even on another Methuselah's turn).
>
>
> Timing does seem to be an issue. I'm going to assume he can act on
> other methuselah's turns as if he had the Madness Network going. Now
> the question becomes, it's not written as a "During X, do Y", so can
> he attempt burn multiple vampires that hunted successfully, provided
> he can untap?
>
To me, since he doesn't say "at the end of the turn" or "after that
methuselah is done acting", it's used immediately, i.e. "When" that
vampire hunts successfully, per card text. One could argue that the
acting methuselah has the impulse and can continue to take actions
until he passes, and that *may* be the correct ruling, but I think
that his ability happens in the timing window when the action is
successful, and thus before the acting methuselah has the chance to
take a new action. I presume there will be a ruling on it at some
point.

> Hmm, still not sure. I would think that if titles are covered, that
> they would have been specified, just as Clan and Sect were. I think
> the fact that they are termed "titles" removes them from also being
> traits, even though a title is a defining characteristic. Also, if
> titles were considered traits for this card, could we not then use
> more specific titles? Play one Second Tradition as the Prince of New
> York, then a second as Prince of London, etc.
>

Well, like I said, I'm not certain on this. You may be right. I
don't think there's a strict definition of "trait", and so I think
title might qualify. On the other hand, it does open up a lot of
questions on what counts as the same requirement that he can only meet
once.

> I would disagree on Flight being a trait. While it's not a discipline,
> true, it also isn't a defining characteristic. You can say "Jack Drake
> is an Anarch (vampire)", you couldn't say "Fidus is a Flight
> (vampire)". You can say "Fidus has Flight, which allows him to use
> these flight cards", much like you can say "Fidus has Fortitude, which
> allows him to use these fortitude cards".

Searching Google Group for flight+trait yields several results. Most
of them say that Flight *is* a trait, and one from LSJ implies
otherwise, but doesn't, IMO, necessarily say that it is not. I'm not
sure what it *is* if not a trait.

James Coupe

unread,
Oct 30, 2008, 7:00:33 PM10/30/08
to
In message <8cc99f44-500e-4c9e...@u57g2000hsf.googlegroup

s.com>, Thrall of Arika <christoph...@amec.com> writes:
>On Oct 30, 8:10 am, Chris Berger <ark...@ugcs.caltech.edu> wrote:
>> > > > The Ankou
>> > > > 10 cap Malkavian
>> > > > AUS DEM OBF
>> > > > Camarilla: When any vampire succesfully hunts while The Ankou is ready and untapped, the
>> > > > Ankou may burn that vampire as a (D) action that turn (even on another Methuselah's turn).
>
>Timing does seem to be an issue. I'm going to assume he can act on
>other methuselah's turns as if he had the Madness Network going. Now
>the question becomes, it's not written as a "During X, do Y", so can
>he attempt burn multiple vampires that hunted successfully, provided
>he can untap?

Leaving aside the exact timing issue, my inclination would be to
disallow it multiple times.

A minion cannot perform an action with the same action card or via the
same card in play (including from the minion's own card text) more
than once each turn, even if he untaps. [6.1.6]

Action, check. Card in play, check.

Message has been deleted

mat...@gmail.com

unread,
Oct 31, 2008, 12:27:33 AM10/31/08
to
> Leaving aside the exact timing issue, my inclination would be to
> disallow it multiple times.

> A minion cannot perform an action with the same action card or via the
> same card in play (including from the minion's own card text) more
> than once each turn, even if he untaps. [6.1.6]

> Action, check. Card in play, check.

It is still a strong ablity. Cards I like for the deck
lunatic eruption
vampiric disease
path of death and the soul
freak drive
FSR not that hard to pass
cryptic rider
Malk rider clause
babble
steath

WTF? Final Loosening
Requires an anarch. [aus] Play when the acting vampire would gain 1 or
more blood. The acting vampire and this reacting anarch each gain 1
blood instead. [dem] Gain 4 votes. [for] Only usable when an ally is
acting. The action fails and the ally takes 1 damage. Tap this
reacting anarch.

bwross

unread,
Oct 31, 2008, 12:41:25 AM10/31/08
to
On Oct 30, 7:00 pm, James Coupe <ja...@zephyr.org.uk> wrote:
[The Ankou]

> Leaving aside the exact timing issue, my inclination would be to
> disallow it multiple times.
>
>   A minion cannot perform an action with the same action card or via the
>   same card in play (including from the minion's own card text) more
>   than once each turn, even if he untaps.  [6.1.6]
>
> Action, check.  Card in play, check.

Action alone doesn't matter... it's "Action card". A vampire can hunt
with the default action as often as they like in a minion phase... but
they can't use a specific hunt action card more than once.

What matters here is the fact that it's an action given by a card in
play (in this case it is the minon's own card text). That's what
limits it to once a minion phase.

And I'm pretty sure that you don't have to do it right away (it says
"that turn" not "immediately")... the sequencing rule tells us exactly
how to deal with that.

Brent Ross


James Coupe

unread,
Oct 31, 2008, 4:49:55 AM10/31/08
to
In message <67007613-fd56-41d4...@e38g2000prn.googlegroup

s.com>, bwross <bwr...@mail.com> writes:
>On Oct 30, 7:00 pm, James Coupe <ja...@zephyr.org.uk> wrote:
>[The Ankou]
>> Leaving aside the exact timing issue, my inclination would be to
>> disallow it multiple times.
>>
>>   A minion cannot perform an action with the same action card or via the
>>   same card in play (including from the minion's own card text) more
>>   than once each turn, even if he untaps.  [6.1.6]
>>
>> Action, check.  Card in play, check.
>
>Action alone doesn't matter... it's "Action card". A vampire can hunt
>with the default action as often as they like in a minion phase... but
>they can't use a specific hunt action card more than once.
>
>What matters here is the fact that it's an action given by a card in
>play (in this case it is the minon's own card text). That's what
>limits it to once a minion phase.

Uh, yes. That's what I said.

It's an action provided by a card in play. It's important that it's an
action, because non-action minion specials aren't restricted by default.
So action: check. It's important that it's provided by a card in play.
So card in play: check.

In the quoted rules text, I'm referring to:

  A minion cannot perform an ACTION with the same action card or via the
  same CARD IN PLAY (including from the minion's own card text) more


  than once each turn, even if he untaps.  [6.1.6]

For some reason, you seem to think I'm referring to:

  A minion cannot perform an action with the same ACTION card or via the

I don't know why you think that, since it clearly isn't an action card,
and I never implied it was.

John Flournoy

unread,
Oct 31, 2008, 11:06:44 AM10/31/08
to

Another possibility: Shambling Hordes bleeds you for zero. Would you
like to get blocked and fight the Horde, or bled for 2? Either way
might be wrong..

mat...@gmail.com

unread,
Oct 31, 2008, 11:19:41 AM10/31/08
to

The Ankou, 10, AUS DEM OBF, Malkavian

Camarilla: When any vampire succesfully hunts while The Ankou is
ready and untapped, the
Ankou may burn that vampire as a (D) action that turn (even on
another Methuselah's turn).

Ankou special is clearly during X do Y. If you do not burn the vampire
the turn it hunted, you can not burn them.

Another good mechanic for him

Eurayle Gelasia Mylonas, 6, for pre AUS OBE, Salubri, 4
Independent. Eurayle may untap any minion as an action. If you
control the minion, this is a +2 stealth action. Scarce.

Spirirt Marionette Heidelberg Castle

James Coupe

unread,
Oct 31, 2008, 11:45:08 AM10/31/08
to
In message <29b78af8-253c-4bbc...@c22g2000prc.googlegroup

s.com>, mat...@gmail.com writes:
>The Ankou, 10, AUS DEM OBF, Malkavian
> Camarilla: When any vampire succesfully hunts while The Ankou is
>ready and untapped, the
> Ankou may burn that vampire as a (D) action that turn (even on
>another Methuselah's turn).
>
>Ankou special is clearly during X do Y. If you do not burn the vampire
>the turn it hunted, you can not burn them.

"During X do Y" refers to using the *specific* style of wording "During
your minion phase, you may do..." which limits the allowed thing to be
done once during the giving time. It clearly isn't that (if you
disagree, point out the word "during" in the above text), which is what
other people have been discussing.

It's also pretty clear that it happens during a specific turn ("that
turn") and not later.

bwross

unread,
Oct 31, 2008, 12:04:47 PM10/31/08
to
On Oct 31, 4:49 am, James Coupe <ja...@zephyr.org.uk> wrote:
> Uh, yes.  That's what I said.

Yep, I know that... I was agreeing with the conclusion, but not the
approach.

> It's an action provided by a card in play.  It's important that it's an
> action, because non-action minion specials aren't restricted by default.
> So action: check.  It's important that it's provided by a card in play.
> So card in play: check.

The thing is that it's also not important that it's an action...
because actions aren't restricted by default either. Action cards are
what's restricted. The check is: "Action card: check". My point is
that the checked item is atomic and shouldn't be separated.

Brent Ross

bwross

unread,
Oct 31, 2008, 12:08:15 PM10/31/08
to
On Oct 31, 12:04 pm, bwross <bwr...@mail.com> wrote:
> The check is: "Action card: check".

Oops... that should be "Card action: check" in this case.

Brent

Jozxyqk

unread,
Oct 31, 2008, 12:11:38 PM10/31/08
to
zora...@gmail.com wrote:
> btw, Dark Influences abbreviates into DI as well.. a little joke by
> LSJ?

I would like to come forward as the first advocate of calling this
card "DarkEye". As in "You play Govern the Unaligned? Well, I give
you the DarkEye."

It is loading more messages.
0 new messages