Step 1 ? (all a (all x ((eq (+ a x) e) => (eq a (inv x))))) > ftp.revsk ============================= Step 2 ? ((~ (eq (+ c47815 c47814) e)) v (eq c47815 (inv c47814))) > supp- ============================= Step 3 ? (eq c47815 (inv c47814)) 1. (eq (+ c47815 c47814) e) > paramodulate ============================= |Step 4 | |? (eq c47815 (inv c47814)) | |1. (~ (eq c47815 (inv c47814))) |2. (eq (+ c47815 c47814) e) | |> paramodulate right |============================= |Step 5 | |? (eq c47815 Var96) | |1. (~ (eq c47815 (inv c47814))) |2. (eq (+ c47815 c47814) e) | |> paramodulate |============================= ||Step 6 || ||? (eq c47815 Var96) || ||1. (~ (eq c47815 Var96)) ||2. (~ (eq c47815 (inv c47814))) ||3. (eq (+ c47815 c47814) e) || ||> paramodulate left ||============================= ||Step 7 || ||? (eq Var108 c47815) || ||1. (~ (eq c47815 Var109)) ||2. (~ (eq c47815 (inv c47814))) ||3. (eq (+ c47815 c47814) e) || ||> ((eq (+ e X) X) <--) ||============================= |Step 8 | |? (eq (+ e c47815) Var109) | |1. (~ (eq c47815 Var109)) |2. (~ (eq c47815 (inv c47814))) |3. (eq (+ c47815 c47814) e) | |> paramodulate |============================= ||Step 9 || ||? (eq (+ e c47815) Var109) || ||1. (~ (eq (+ e c47815) Var109)) ||2. (~ (eq c47815 Var109)) ||3. (~ (eq c47815 (inv c47814))) ||4. (eq (+ c47815 c47814) e) || ||> zeroing on term ... ||============================= ||Step 10 || ||? (eq (+ e c47815) Var127) || ||1. (~ (eq (+ e c47815) Var127)) ||2. (~ (eq c47815 Var127)) ||3. (~ (eq c47815 (inv c47814))) ||4. (eq (+ c47815 c47814) e) || ||> zeroing on terms ... ||============================= ||Step 11 || ||? (eq (+ e c47815) Var127) || ||1. (~ (eq (+ e c47815) Var127)) ||2. (~ (eq c47815 Var127)) ||3. (~ (eq c47815 (inv c47814))) ||4. (eq (+ c47815 c47814) e) || ||> paramodulate left ||============================= ||Step 12 || ||? (eq Var145 c47815) || ||1. (~ (eq (+ e c47815) Var127)) ||2. (~ (eq c47815 Var127)) ||3. (~ (eq c47815 (inv c47814))) ||4. (eq (+ c47815 c47814) e) || ||> ((eq (+ X e) X) <--) ||============================= |Step 13 | |? (eq (+ e (+ c47815 e)) Var127) | |1. (~ (eq (+ e c47815) Var127)) |2. (~ (eq c47815 Var127)) |3. (~ (eq c47815 (inv c47814))) |4. (eq (+ c47815 c47814) e) | |> ((eq (+ e X) X) <--) |============================= Step 14 ? (eq (+ c47815 e) (inv c47814)) 1. (~ (eq c47815 (inv c47814))) 2. (eq (+ c47815 c47814) e) > paramodulate ============================= |Step 15 | |? (eq (+ c47815 e) (inv c47814)) | |1. (~ (eq (+ c47815 e) (inv c47814))) |2. (~ (eq c47815 (inv c47814))) |3. (eq (+ c47815 c47814) e) | |> paramodulate right |============================= |Step 16 | |? (eq (+ c47815 e) Var163) | |1. (~ (eq (+ c47815 e) (inv c47814))) |2. (~ (eq c47815 (inv c47814))) |3. (eq (+ c47815 c47814) e) | |> paramodulate |============================= ||Step 17 || ||? (eq (+ c47815 e) Var163) || ||1. (~ (eq (+ c47815 e) Var163)) ||2. (~ (eq (+ c47815 e) (inv c47814))) ||3. (~ (eq c47815 (inv c47814))) ||4. (eq (+ c47815 c47814) e) || ||> zeroing on term ... ||============================= ||Step 18 || ||? (eq (+ c47815 e) Var176) || ||1. (~ (eq (+ c47815 e) Var176)) ||2. (~ (eq (+ c47815 e) (inv c47814))) ||3. (~ (eq c47815 (inv c47814))) ||4. (eq (+ c47815 c47814) e) || ||> zeroing on terms ... ||============================= ||Step 19 || ||? (eq (+ c47815 e) Var176) || ||1. (~ (eq (+ c47815 e) Var176)) ||2. (~ (eq (+ c47815 e) (inv c47814))) ||3. (~ (eq c47815 (inv c47814))) ||4. (eq (+ c47815 c47814) e) || ||> paramodulate left ||============================= ||Step 20 || ||? (eq Var194 e) || ||1. (~ (eq (+ c47815 e) Var176)) ||2. (~ (eq (+ c47815 e) (inv c47814))) ||3. (~ (eq c47815 (inv c47814))) ||4. (eq (+ c47815 c47814) e) || ||> ((eq (+ X (inv X)) e) <--) ||============================= |Step 21 | |? (eq (+ c47815 (+ Var201 (inv Var201))) Var176) | |1. (~ (eq (+ c47815 e) Var176)) |2. (~ (eq (+ c47815 e) (inv c47814))) |3. (~ (eq c47815 (inv c47814))) |4. (eq (+ c47815 c47814) e) | |> ((eq (+ X (+ Y Z)) (+ (+ X Y) Z)) <--) |============================= Step 22 ? (eq (+ (+ c47815 Var208) (inv Var208)) (inv c47814)) 1. (~ (eq (+ c47815 e) (inv c47814))) 2. (~ (eq c47815 (inv c47814))) 3. (eq (+ c47815 c47814) e) > paramodulate ============================= |Step 23 | |? (eq (+ (+ c47815 Var208) (inv Var208)) (inv c47814)) | |1. (~ (eq (+ (+ c47815 Var208) (inv Var208)) (inv c47814))) |2. (~ (eq (+ c47815 e) (inv c47814))) |3. (~ (eq c47815 (inv c47814))) |4. (eq (+ c47815 c47814) e) | |> zeroing on term ... |============================= |Step 24 | |? (eq (+ (+ c47815 Var208) (inv Var208)) (inv c47814)) | |1. (~ (eq (+ (+ c47815 Var208) (inv Var208)) (inv c47814))) |2. (~ (eq (+ c47815 e) (inv c47814))) |3. (~ (eq c47815 (inv c47814))) |4. (eq (+ c47815 c47814) e) | |> paramodulate right |============================= |Step 25 | |? (eq (+ c47815 Var208) Var229) | |1. (~ (eq (+ (+ c47815 Var208) (inv Var208)) (inv c47814))) |2. (~ (eq (+ c47815 e) (inv c47814))) |3. (~ (eq c47815 (inv c47814))) |4. (eq (+ c47815 c47814) e) | |> hyp |============================= Step 26 ? (eq (+ e (inv c47814)) (inv c47814)) 1. (~ (eq (+ (+ c47815 c47814) (inv c47814)) (inv c47814))) 2. (~ (eq (+ c47815 e) (inv c47814))) 3. (~ (eq c47815 (inv c47814))) 4. (eq (+ c47815 c47814) e) > ((eq (+ e X) X) <--) =============================