RESULT: soc.culture.occitan passes 245:30
Jani Patokallio
RESULT
unmoderated group soc.culture.occitan passes 245:30
There were 245 YES votes and 30 NO votes, for a total of 275 valid votes.
There was 1 abstain.
For group passage, YES votes must be at least 2/3 of all valid (YES and NO)
votes. There also must be at least 100 more YES votes than NO votes.
There is a five day discussion period after these results are posted. If no
serious allegations of voting irregularities are raised, the moderator of
news.announce.newgroups will create the group shortly thereafter.
Newsgroups line:
soc.culture.occitan Occitan-langue d'oc culture.
The voting period closed at 23:59:59 UTC, 21 Feb 1997.
This vote was conducted by a neutral third party. Direct questions
about the proposed group to the proponent. Do not distribute this CFV or the
information contained in it in any form without the votetaker's permission.
Proponent: Jean-Jacques Maurette <maur...@cict.fr>
Votetaker: Jani Patokallio <jpat...@alpha.hut.fi>
RATIONALE: soc.culture.occitan
Among the Romance languages issued from Latin, Occitan (also known as
Langue d'Oc or Provencal) is the most widespread of those not having a
status as a state or autonomous region language. An occitan
mailing-list of more than 100 subscribers is working, but some users
are bothered by the automatic reception of such mail in their work
mailbox, as the postings are rather frequent, and by the fact some of
these messages are not in their field of interest.
CHARTER: soc.culture.occitan
Soc.culture.occitan is a newsgroup for the discussion of the
langue d'oc area, its culture, language, politics, history, and all
topics normally discussed in "soc.culture" newsgroups.
The "Occitan" culture is the culture of the occitan-langue d'oc
speaking area, covering the southernmost third of France, the Aran
valley in the Catalonia autonomous community (Spain), the upper alpine
valleys of Piedmont and the Calabrian city of Guardia Piemontese (Italy).
The occitan culture is a culture of its own, which gained a flattered
reputation during the middle-ages with the trobadors (troubadours)
poetry and the catharian heresy.
These two topics, and the present attempts of revival of the occitan
language and traditions, would be the most often topics. We strongly
recommend, as this group would not be moderated, to include a topic
keyword in the Subject of the postings, such as History, Language,
Culture, Politics and so on.
The languages of the postings would be, Occitan-Langue d'Oc (without
restriction on the choice of the orthography), Catalan, French, English.
END CHARTER.
soc.culture.occitan Final Vote Ack
Voted Yes
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
10070...@compuserve.com Albert Pijuan
aba...@innet.meta.fr Louis Abadie
aba...@Starbase.NeoSoft.COM abass alamnehe
acas...@acad.ursinus.edu ANTONI CASTELLS I TALENS
agt...@pitt.edu Antonio Teixeira
and...@ix.netcom.com A. Chilton Lannen
apla...@micronet.fr Pierre Laures
as1...@cus.cam.ac.uk Artur SIXTO i TAPIA
ava...@ibm.net Alejandro Varela S=E1nchez
avel...@unico.udc.es Alberto Veleiro
az...@lafn.org B. Thober=20
BA...@skywalker.udg.es Lola Badia
bb...@freenet.carleton.ca Monique Latremouille
bete...@bart.fr Beteille Guy
bon...@www.mns.fr Jean-Luc Donnadieu
bo...@fconyx.ncifcrf.gov Lluis Boque
bo...@mda.ca Michael Borek
bot...@culture.fr Michel Bottin
br...@irit.fr bras
Brigitte...@cict.fr Brigitte Bonhoure
br...@spider.ece.cmu.edu Marcelo Bruno
calv...@irsamc2.ups-tlse.fr Florent Calvayrac
c...@club-internet.fr ANDREO
car...@mail.jovenet.fr Maxime Boisset
carlos....@alc.servicom.es Carlos Arribas Ugarte
car...@ysi.es Carles Montoto
cco...@gpu.srv.ualberta.ca Charles Conway
CDE...@skywalker.udg.es Centre de Documentacio Llengues d'Europa
cesposito%si...@cal.fr Christian Esposito
cf...@sahaja.demon.co.uk Christopher J. Fynn
cha...@indy.net Charla Walker
chengx...@innet.meta.fr Cheng Xiaolin
chir...@lirmm.fr Michel CHIROUZE
chne...@mail.dotcom.fr Charles Nepote
ch...@via.at Christian Pree
c...@thomson-lcr.fr Christophe Guettier
cie9...@lustudat.student.lu.se Stephane Di Cesare
Claudine...@cict.fr Claudine Mederic
coll...@arrakis.es Daniel Collados
curr...@www.lrcser.it Michela Costanzo
dan...@laas.fr Daniel Sidobre
desc...@msdos.ensam.inra.fr Dominique DESCLAUX
dg...@mindspring.com D Gary Grady
DI...@umac.pressimage.fr Jan Lafita
Domenec_S...@fecsa-halcon.ccmail.sicyd.es Domenec Sos Valles
dr...@MicroNet.fr Yoram Perez
dubr...@spmail.com Jean-Marc DELTEIL
dur...@irsamc1.ups-tlse.fr Philippe Durand
e...@world.std.com Hope Ehn
ejno...@xs4all.nl Eric-Jan Noomen
el...@worldnet.fr GOSSE Eric
ENRI...@umac.pressimage.fr Henri Pin
eo...@infonie.fr Nicolas Haegelsteen
e...@eurobretagne.fr JY Le Touze
Eric....@FSE.DG5.cec.be
eso...@strascom.fr Eric Soulie
espo...@strascom.fr Alain Esposito
F.Crompto...@qmw.ac.uk Francois Crompton-Roberts
f.si...@ulg.ac.be Frederic SIMONS
fa2r...@usc.es Ramon Flores Seijas
fcar...@toulouse.inra.fr Francis Carbonne
fcoubes%si...@cal.fr Francois Coubes
fek...@cyberpass.net Zoli Fekete
fjl...@eco.uc3m.es Francisco J. Lores
Frances....@xmail.org Francois Hourcadet
fred...@strascom.fr Frederic Galy
frh...@strascom.fr Fran‡ois HOMS
gail...@panix.com Ed Gaillard
gali...@strascom.fr Claude Galibert
gal...@ksu.edu Pedro L. Muiño
garc...@pilot.msu.edu Josep Garcia Sirera
gel...@cict.fr gellis m.h.
gen...@efrei.fr Solange GENTIL
Gerard.D...@Chambery.ENSAM.fr Gerard DELAFOLLIE
giann...@infonie.fr Anna Vacca
Gildas....@hol.fr Gildas Le Gouic
gilles...@francetelecom.fr CLUZON
GI...@UCONNVM.UCONN.EDU Evarist Gine
gno...@global.co.za Graham Noble
gri...@arrakis.es Constante Alvarez
gtas...@mail.cgocable.net Gilles Tastayre
Henri_J...@uow.edu.au Henri Jeanjean
Herve....@imag.fr Hervé Mathieu
hvh...@hzsbg01.nl.lucent.com Huub van Helvoort <hhel...@lucent.com>
ign...@gps.tsc.upc.es Ignasi Esquerra
ilc...@skywalker.udg.es Marta Payero
inaki....@Lancelot.unirioja.es Inaki \"Ekaitz\" Agirre
Ingo.S...@cern.ch Ingo Schwarze
ir...@rempt.xs4all.nl Irina Rempt
iu...@cc.uab.es Claude Balaguer
J...@etsiig.uniovi.es Jose Antonio Corrales
jac...@strascom.fr Jacques Abadie "Jacolet"
jam...@st.upc.es Javier Amador
jar...@pratique.fr ARQUEY jacques
jcad...@sigma.eafit.edu.co Juan H. Cadavid-Restrepo</DT>
jcan...@jeeves.ucsd.edu Jaume M. Canaves
j...@rahul.net John David Galt
jdwo...@ucsd.edu Jason Dworkin
jean-pierre.l...@univ-pau.fr Jean-Pierre LALANNE CASSOU
Jean....@inlandsys.com Jean Urroz
Jeanne...@download.tm.fr Jeanne IMOND
jfblanc%si...@cal.fr Jean-Francois BLANC
jim...@pipeline.com Jim Riley
j...@qnet.com J. McAulay
jmdu...@strascom.fr Jean Michel DUPRAT
jmpujol%si...@cal.fr Jean-Marc Pujol
JNES...@phil.uni-erlangen.de jnes...@phil.uni-erlangen.de <Juergen Eschma
jo...@irsamc1.ups-tlse.fr TROTARD Joel
jor...@bpo.hp.com Jordi Iparraguirre
jo...@fib.upc.es Jose Manuel Dieguez Perez
josep....@solmelia.es Josep Buades i Payeras
Joseph.Sa...@cict.fr Joseph Saint Pierre
josepu...@redestb.es JOSE PUENTES RAMOS
jos...@lander.es =?ISO-8859-1?Q?Jos=E9_Ben=EDtez_Perez?=
jpo...@magic.fr Jacques POGGIO
jrei...@abaforum.es Josep Maria Reixach i Cubi
jsh...@indiana.edu Jonathan Shull
j...@idiom.com Michael Craft
Juan.M...@univ-savoie.fr Juan Martinez
jul...@fwb.gulf.net Jules Dubois
just...@spmail.com Justin LAPUJOULADE
kar...@innet.meta.fr Karine DELAHAYE
kutz...@goofy.zdv.Uni-Mainz.de Ulf Kutzner
kwat...@sas.upenn.edu Kirk Wattles
laba...@spmail.com Florent LABARTHE
lab...@partesa.it Serge Labatut
lak...@inforoute.cgs.fr =?ISO-8859-1?Q?Carsten_L=E4kamp?=
lal...@strascom.fr Francis Lalande
la...@oasis.uab.es Eul`alia de Bobes i Soler
LAM...@skywalker.udg.es F. Xavier Lamuela
lar...@svmnet.meta.fr Louis Larrey (Tarbes)
l...@lix.intercom.es Antoni Luj=E1n
li.li...@innet.meta.fr Francois Li Liu Feng
lie...@berlin.netsurf.de Otfried Lieberknecht
li...@darkwing.uoregon.edu Lisa Menachof
liz...@svmnet.meta.fr Lizondo
ll...@aars.mit.edu Lluis Ribas
ll...@minitel.refer.org Lluis SAVATER
lou.l...@minitel.refer.org Louise Lafont
l...@turing.upc.es Lluis Perez Vidal
lss...@lix.intercom.es SALA, Xavier
ma...@polen1.polito.it Mauro Bertolino
man...@grn.es Ramon Prior
manue...@dragonet.es Manuel Gato Pena
marc...@innet.meta.fr Marc Albert BRUN
mar...@len7.enseeiht.fr Baptiste
Marie-Laur...@RP-RORER.FR Marie-Laure MAZODIER
mari...@innet.meta.fr Paul Marieton
Mariilis....@xmail.org Marilis Hourcadet
mar...@hrz1.uni-oldenburg.de Mark Obrembalski
mar...@cs.chalmers.se Martin Weichert
ma...@prostar.com Marya DuMont
mat...@milou.mpipks-dresden.mpg.de Mathias Van Den Bossche
maur...@cict.fr Jean-Jacques MAURETTE
max...@mbox.digsys.bg Ivan Marinov
mc3...@mclink.it Luca Giuliano mc3133mclink.it
mcc...@best.com Todd Michel McComb
m...@pi.net Miguel Carrasquer Vidal
me...@bcn.servicom.es
mer...@worldnet.fr Thierry Merger
mest...@rectorat.uab.es Marta Estella (Gabinet de Llengua Catalana)
mfa...@puc.cl Miguel Farah F.
Michael...@cl.cam.ac.uk Michael Norrish
michel...@innet.meta.fr Michel QUINT
mlafon...@strascom.fr Marie Laffont
mr...@faraday.clas.virginia.edu Roy Harris
mrod...@stdspub.ieee.org Michel Rodriguez
nber...@guetali.fr BERNE Nicolas
nda...@interlog.com Nigel Allen
nesposito%si...@cal.fr Nathalie Esposito
ni...@inferno.fc.hp.com Nick Ingegneri
nop1...@mail.telepac.pt Alvaro Augusto de Carvalho Borges Fernandes
nou...@minitel.refer.org Bertrand Nouvel
omar...@redestb.es Omar Alos Font
pab...@polen1.polito.it Pablo Arena
pa...@osnome.che.wisc.edu Ignasi Palou-Rivera
paub...@strascom.fr Paul Boyer
pau...@astro.ocis.temple.edu Pam Austin
pbre...@hol.fr Peire BRECHET
p...@megaiweb.com Josep Andreu Amorós
pe...@Starbase.NeoSoft.COM Peter Norton
Philipp...@sophia.inria.fr Philippe Balse
phu...@innet.be Patrick Hublou - Silent Factory -
pictoric...@net64.es xesus oscar fernandez
pie...@rahul.net Pierre Uszynski
pj...@leicester.ac.uk Pete Humble
p...@inm.es Joan Cuxart Rodamilans
prad...@spmail.com Maurice Pradali=19Be
pren...@imag.net Lionel Prentice
r.de....@minitel.refer.org Rosalia de Castro
ramo...@logiccontrol.es Ramon Sala.
raoul....@minitel.refer.org Raoul DUMONT
ref...@lpbc.jussieu.fr Matthieu Refregiers
Remi.B...@Chambery.ENSAM.fr Remi BLANCON
ri...@bcm.tmc.edu Richard H. Miller
rodo...@minitel.refer.org Rodolphe GOBERT
Roger.Pissa...@imag.fr Roger Pissard-Gibollet
ros...@cafeinternet.es Rossend Sanglas Ramon
roui...@acm.org Jacques Rouillard
rou...@albert.cad.cea.fr Jean-Claude Roussel
ro...@u.washington.edu Joseph P. Roza
r...@innet.meta.fr Raymond
rus...@argo.urv.es Jordi Riu
sall...@math.u-bordeaux.fr Cedric SALLABERRY
sa...@ch.unito.it Dr A.Ya. Polishchuk
sau...@pratique.fr Patrick Sauzet
sco...@galaxy.galstar.com Scott Fridenberg
sec...@imft.fr SECHET Philippe
ser...@arrakis.es Sergi V. Oliver
se...@mbcrr.harvard.edu Carles Serra-Pages
Sime...@xmail.org Lucien Simeonin
sim...@hotmail.com Joan de Simorre
slo...@franklin.com Peter Slomanson
sou...@irsamc1.ups-tlse.fr SOULET Yves
spa...@ccr.jussieu.fr Sunny PARIS
sp...@sierra.net Jack Durst
st-p...@banquepopulaire.fr Jacques SAINT-PIERRE
ste...@dil.univ-mrs.fr Christophe Stecoli
Stephan...@ensem.u-nancy.fr
st...@balogh.demon.co.uk steve balogh
Stev...@GoodNet.Com Steve MacGregor
sylvai...@minitel.net Sylvain Gerard
tab...@ccr.jussieu.fr Juan J TABOADA
ta...@redestb.es Sato
tarr...@redestb.es Vicent Tarrazona i Rubio
t...@mail.dotcom.fr Teo VIDAL i SOL
tfi...@umbc.edu Thomas T. Field
Thetr...@aol.com Bradford Brown
TO...@gen4.pressimage.fr Antoine OULLES
tos...@hotmail.com Thomas Souilhac
tre...@redestb.es Josep Payo
TREN...@aol.com Jessica Bonzon
tricio...@aix.pacwan.net Tric=ECo Dupuy
trin...@irsamc1.ups-tlse.fr Trinquier
u1...@abdn.ac.uk Salvador
va...@velizy.inst.slb.com Gianni Vacca
ver...@lix.intercom.es R. Poveda & E. Verheul
ver...@univ-aix.fr Jean Veronis
vilalonga%si...@cal.fr Frances DE VILALONGA
vin...@wotan.ens.fr Pierre VINCENS
vino...@redestb.es david
w...@comfirst.fr Sophie Poujade
Xavier...@crpp.uhd.epfl.ch Xavier Llobet
XU...@gen4.pressimage.fr Jean-Michel Leblanc
ZAMB...@gen4.pressimage.fr Jean-Michel Mouly
Voted No
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ac...@freenet.toronto.on.ca Allan Jenoff
afa...@umich.edu Andrew Fabbro
bo...@datasync.com Martin H. Booda
cbs...@phoenix.Princeton.EDU Christopher B. Stone
d...@panix.com David W. Crawford
dead...@one.net DeadLock the Feral
dene...@deepthot.cary.nc.us Jay Denebeim
dev...@alsys.com Olivier Devuns @pulsar
e...@marenos.com Antonio Pardos Hernando"
gcha...@irus.rri.uwo.ca Greg Chapman
gpr9...@uconnvm.uconn.edu G.P. Ryan
je...@cam.ac.uk James Broughton
jlow...@pwa.acusd.edu John Lowther
jtim...@internoc.net John Timaeus
kat...@uclink4.berkeley.edu Katrina Templeton
ki...@netcom.com Kim DeVaughn
l...@zk3.dec.com Larry Smith
mar...@pacbell.net Aaron Marquez
mh...@raven.phs.com Mike Hatz
nat...@col.hp.com Natalie Ramsey
ni...@cimio.co.uk Nick Waterman
ol...@viking.mv.com Olav Nieuwejaar
pa...@byu.edu Robert Craig Harman
pa...@lcs.mit.edu Patrick J. LoPresti
pime...@ultranet.com John Pimentel
stai...@bga.com Dwight Brown
sta...@stamper.com Chris Stamper
stu...@cosc.canterbury.ac.nz Stuart Yeates
tla...@amug.org Todd C. Lawson
to...@wt.net Tony Storz
Abstained
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
j...@sfbooks.com Joe Bernstein
DISTRIBUTION:
In addition to the groups named in the Newsgroups: header, the CFV
and the eventual RESULT posts will be mailed to these mailing lists:
list-oc <lis...@cict.fr>
--
Jani Patokallio <jpat...@alpha.hut.fi>
Voting address: <vot...@hut.fi>