J.M. Garg
unread,Sep 12, 2011, 8:08:34 AM9/12/11Sign in to reply to author
Sign in to forward
You do not have permission to delete messages in this group
Sign in to report message
Either email addresses are anonymous for this group or you need the view member email addresses permission to view the original message
to efloraofindia, katarina stenman, dvija...@gmail.com, chriso...@yahoo.co.uk, SP.Kh...@gmail.com, jatinde...@gmail.com, mrin...@yahoo.co.in, Aniruddha Mookerjee, prasad dash, pudji...@gmail.com, tanay bose, Dr. Pankaj Kumar
A reply:
"M. crenata is not a native of India, but of Australia and the Philippines. M. quadrifolia is also not a native of India (not even of Kashmir) but of Europe. This plant is surely going to be the common Indian native, M. minuta, as also recorded by Dixit & Sinha in their "Pteridophytes of the Andamans & Nicobars" (correctly!). However, as anyone will tell you, the floating plants are sterile, and Marsilea species cannot be identified in the absence of sorocarps. Sorocarps are produced when plants are on dry land at the edges of ponds.
Yes, there are two other good species in India, M. aegyptiaca and M. coromandelina - but then some dozen other "species" were described from India which mostly appear to be more in the way of just forms of M. minuta (but anyway, still need investigating further and re-assessed as to what their status really is, some are definitely forms of minuta and not species by more usual concepts of species).
Cheers,
Chris Fraser-Jenkins, Kathmandu."
Thanks, Dr. Chris Fraser-Jenkins.