Six years ago tomorrow, the first prisoners arrived at the prison at Guantánamo Bay. Since then, we’ve seen revelations of horrible abuses, the Military Commissions Act signed into law and people stripped of their most fundamental rights. Most recently, we learned that the CIA destroyed tapes of “harsh interrogation techniques” -- what you and I would call torture.

It is time to reclaim our nation’s place as a standard bearer for justice and human rights.

You can start by taking two immediate actions:

Demand your members of Congress pressure Attorney General Mukasey to appoint a special counsel -- someone independent who can expose the full truth behind the destruction of the CIA tapes.

Remember to wear orange tomorrow, January 11, to demand an immediate end to the injustice at Guantánamo Bay.

Dear Friend,

Last week, Attorney General Michael Mukasey opened a narrow investigation into the CIA's destruction of videotapes depicting the "harsh" interrogation of detainees in its custody. But half-steps don't get at hard truths.

Like most Bush administration actions, this limited investigation will only prevent vital questions from being asked -- it will not get key answers that America needs. Michael Mukasey has decided to keep control of his prosecutor, and only allow a narrow probe into the destruction of evidence, not the illegal activities by our government that reportedly were filmed on the CIA’s torture tapes in the first place. Because the Attorney General won't investigate the shameful conduct that is at the heart of the matter on his own, Congress needs to turn up the heat.

Tell your members of Congress: Mukasey must appoint a special counsel -- someone with real independence and transparency.

It's a sign of progress that the Attorney General felt enough pressure that he was forced to take some action. But, hopes for a fair and thorough investigation have been thwarted by Mukasey’s insistence that the investigation remain within the control of the Bush administration.

The administration cannot investigate itself! The prosecutor he appointed reports directly to the Deputy Attorney General.  The current nominee for Deputy Attorney General refuses to say that waterboarding is illegal.  The Deputy Attorney General reports to Mukasey, who also refuses to say that waterboarding is illegal. And, Mukasey can stop the prosecutor from filing charges.

Not only that, but by limiting the investigation only to the destruction of the tapes, Mukasey can stop the prosecutor from addressing other questions that must be asked, including whether what was being videotaped was a crime or whether failing to disclose the existence of the tapes to the 9/11 commission or the courts violated the law.

Tell your members of Congress: Mukasey must appoint a special counsel.

With our nation’s reputation and the rule of law at stake, we need a complete and independent investigation not only of who destroyed CIA tapes of interrogations, but also of who authorized, ordered and carried out any criminal acts of torture and abuse.

That’s why the ACLU has called on Mukasey to appoint a special counsel -- one with real independence and transparency. Mukasey hasn’t listened yet. But if enough people write their members of Congress, he will be forced to pay attention. And if enough of our senators and representatives keep the pressure on, Mukasey will be forced to act.

Thank you for your voice in this critical fight.

Thank you,

Anthony D. Romero, ACLU
Anthony D. Romero
Executive Director, ACLU

P.S. Friday, January 11th is the sixth anniversary of the opening of the prison at Guantánamo Bay. That’s why the ACLU has joined with dozens of other organizations and is asking all our members to wear orange to protest this stain on America’s reputation. Closing the prison and ending torture and indefinite detention without charge is a first step towards restoring our reputation in the world. Please remember to wear orange this Friday.


© ACLU, 125 Broad Street, 18th Floor New York, NY 10004