Is the API reliable enough to build a production app at the moment?

33 views
Skip to first unread message

nic

unread,
Jun 18, 2011, 5:23:40 PM6/18/11
to Etsy API V2
I've been integrating the Etsy API into my app for the last month, but
watching the latest issues with changes and seeing discussions in this
group not being as effectively handled as they should probably be I
now have some major concerns about building an application that relies
on this API.

I understand and appreciate that there seems to be a lot of hard work
being done behind the scenes to improve the API and infrastructure,
and that's great - however I think the ways that these changes and
improvements are communicated need to be improved in order for us as
ecosystem developers to continue to have patience and faith in the
quality and reliability of the API.

Maybe I've just come in at the wrong time, and before this month
everything has been quite stable and reliable, and will return to this
state after you sort out the teething problems with the new
environments. I'm totally happy to go along with that if that is the
case, and I'll think about changing my app's release date to
accommodate this bumpy patch if need be.

I guess I'm just asking for a straight-up answer to what is happening
with the API at the moment and what your current estimates are to
having it back to being stable and reliable enough to build against.

Many thanks,
Nicole

micahbrich

unread,
Jul 6, 2011, 5:03:05 PM7/6/11
to Etsy API V2
Nicole,

I realize that your original message was almost a month ago, and I'm
sure you've decided by now whether or not you're gonna work with it.
But I have to say, if you can avoid it, I would. They've drastically
changed and deprecated things without notification or warning, or
sometimes with just an announcement on this Google Group, which is
difficult to keep up with just by the nature of it.

I have respect for the team, and I have no doubt they're working hard,
but support in my experience has taken weeks for a response, and
sometimes without response at all.

It's been extremely frustrating, and I'm hoping to opt out soon and
not deal with it anymore. I'd recommend you avoid it if you can.

Good luck,
micah

Marc Abramowitz

unread,
Jul 6, 2011, 6:50:05 PM7/6/11
to etsy-...@googlegroups.com
I have also been frustrated with the recent changes, which broke my app which was working fine a few weeks ago. I am giving serious thought to not using the API and abandoning my project. My project was done as a favor for my sister who sells on Etsy and I had entertained the thought of someday opening it up to a wider audience and charging for it, but now I have serious doubts about the viability of this idea, because I can't charge someone money for something that breaks frequently. Heck, I can't even offer it for free if the maintenance is going to eat up a bunch of my time. When I first started using the Etsy API a long time ago, I was pretty impressed with how well-thought out it was. There seemed to be a period where things were relatively stable and there were little or no change. Lately, the pendulum seems to have swung the other way and Etsy seems to have taken on a much more cavalier attitude about the API. They are doing some cool stuff that people have asked for, like improving the sandbox, but they also are making backwards-incompatible changes (without changing the API version number no less) and deploying things that are broken for days.

Is there an alternative to the Etsy API (besides screen-scraping, which I did in the past; also not fun)? I don't think so. Which is why this might curtail my Etsy project altogether. I'd hate to tell my sister I can't do it anymore, but I also can't afford to spend a lot of time on maintenance and support. Luckily, Etsy is just one of the channels that she sells through.

Marc

-- 
Marc Abramowitz
Sent with Sparrow
--
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "Etsy API V2" group.
To post to this group, send email to etsy-...@googlegroups.com.
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to etsy-api-v2...@googlegroups.com.
For more options, visit this group at http://groups.google.com/group/etsy-api-v2?hl=en.

Justin Kerr Sheckler

unread,
Jul 7, 2011, 6:34:21 PM7/7/11
to etsy-...@googlegroups.com
Hi Guys,

We're sorry that the recent changes have caused problems with some
apps. As you can imagine, changing platforms completely is something
that just can't be done in incremental steps. Now that Etsy is in
complete control of our API infrastructure, we look forward to
bringing you new API features.

best,

Justin Kerr Sheckler
Developer API Lead
Etsy.com
jus...@etsy.com

micahbrich

unread,
Jul 8, 2011, 4:19:49 PM7/8/11
to Etsy API V2
I appreciate the response, Justin. I'm glad you guys are taking
control of it, and I'm hoping all this feedback will help instead of
hurt. I think more than new features, we're looking for reliability &
consistency, and it certainly sounds like that was the goal of the
last big change. We're all developers, too, and I'm sure most would
join me in saying we'd help however we can. For now, we're cautious,
but I think we're all rooting for success.

Keith

unread,
Jul 14, 2011, 10:34:10 AM7/14/11
to Etsy API V2
On a similar topic... is there any sort of public roadmap of new
features Etsy plans on deploying? Or a road map accessable to 3rd
party developers?

I'm just trying to think long term here.. .I realize Etsy probably
does not want to reveal a full roadmap for competitive reasons, but
does not knowing the roadmap make the investment a 3rd party developer
makes in their apps, some what risky?

I would think that there are three ways in general that people would
be developing apps for Etsy using the API.

1) Apps that add useability/functions to Etsy that it currently lacks.
I would group mobile apps, seller tools, renewing apps etc. and the
like in this group.
2) Apps that create new ways to shop/utilize products on etsy... ie.
"Handmade Top 10", Heartsy etc.
3) An app that interfaces/mashes with other APIs like Metricly,
Facebook apps and the like.

It would seem like the the first group of apps (and maybe the second)
would be at risk of losing their business if/when Etsy deploys
features that makes their app obsolete. For example the new mobile
friendly check out pages... at what point will all of Etsy become
mobile friendly (or if etsy ever comes out with a free app for
browsing internally) it would render a number of apps in the app store
more or less obsolete. I am sure those developers would love to know
if anything like that is on the roadmap for etsy. And if not, what
other mobile features does Etsy plan on deploying?

Likewise, I have plans for further developing my Uncle Gravy app, but
I am hesitant to do so. It was originally an app I developed for my
own shop, so no harm if Etsy comes out with an auto renew tool. But if
I invest the time/money to add on features and make it more robust for
users, and hypothetically, 3 months later, about the time I am ready
to deploy, Etsy deploys features that basically do the same thing.
doh!

One final thing to ponder, what about innovations that 3rd party etsy
developers create that become successful, what prevents Etsy from
integrating these innovations into the core site?

-Keith

Justin Kerr Sheckler

unread,
Jul 14, 2011, 10:38:50 AM7/14/11
to etsy-...@googlegroups.com
Hi Keith,

We don't have a public road map, unfortunately, but I hear what you're
saying about Etsy launching new features at about the same time you
launch an improvement to your app. Unfortunately, that's an inherent
danger in running any API program.

I think that in general, it's best to develop apps that extend the
Etsy platform by, for instance, integrating with other web services
and products. We're investing a lot of time and resources in
improving the main Etsy site, and so any apps that extend core Etsy
site features will probably run into conflict with new Etsy features
at some point down the road.

best,

Justin Kerr Sheckler
Developer API Lead
Etsy.com
jus...@etsy.com

Julian L.

unread,
Jul 15, 2011, 3:54:56 AM7/15/11
to etsy-...@googlegroups.com

http://www.avc.com/a_vc/2010/04/the-twitter-platform.html

"I think the time for filling the holes in the Twitter service has come and gone. It was a great period for Twitter and its third party developers."

FW is also an investor in Etsy.

Keith Phillips

unread,
Jul 15, 2011, 9:32:42 AM7/15/11
to etsy-...@googlegroups.com
Julian and Justin , thanks for your replies. Definitely helps me put things
in perspective going forward.

Keith

Reply all
Reply to author
Forward
0 new messages