The Winners...

[plusminus]

What about collecting the winners (only the winners) to get a nice
overview even before May 12th ?

Regards, plusminus
http://anddev.org
# Worlds largest Android Development Community / Tutorials

[Alex Pisarev]

Commandro.

http://commandro.net

On 9 май, 22:06, plusminus <stoeps...@gmx.de> wrote:
> What about collecting the winners (only the winners) to get a nice
> overview even before May 12th ?
>

> Regards, plusminushttp://anddev.org

[Chris]

+1 Emergency preparedness

On May 9, 11:06 am, plusminus <stoeps...@gmx.de> wrote:
> What about collecting the winners (only the winners) to get a nice
> overview even before May 12th ?
>

> Regards, plusminushttp://anddev.org

[Biosopher]

I hesitate to announce that we've won because we don't want to sound
like we're bragging.

But then again, we know people are curious to hear what's going on.

So...Pocket Journey was one of the winners: www.pocketjourney.com.

Best of luck to everyone (winner or not) as we could never have made
it this far without the contributions from everyone that's posted to
this community. We've tried to give back through the tutorials at
blog.pocketjourney.com though and plan to post many more over the
coming months.

Cheers! I'm heading off for a much anticipated jumbo-sized margarita.

Anthony

[cadlg]

It's good to know that pocket journey was one of the winners !!
Congratulations to you and your team !

cadlg

[mickrobk]

+1 painting program (fingerprint)

On May 9, 4:47 pm, Biosopher <biosop...@gmail.com> wrote:

[luckydroid]

Yay! Pocket Journey! That was one of my favorites.
That will definitely be on my gphone when the time comes.
I was just in Toronto and had one day to explore the city and was
wishing I had Pocket Journey to help!
Nice job!
Mary Ann ('mac')

[Jeffrey Sharkey]

I received my congratulations E-mail at 11:33AM MDT, and a phone
message from Stephanie later this afternoon.

http://scan.jsharkey.org/

Scan is an Android application that finds pricing and metadata for
anything with a barcode. Can't wait to meet up with others at Google
I/O. :)

[jacek]

Congrats to PocketJourney: I wished PJ victory :-)

[Birra]

Congratulations. But, I still want to see an app that hasn't been
done to death. GPS locations, fingerprints, barcodes, where's the
originality. That's what I'm after.

[Birra]

Bump ...

[GodsMoon]

Did all of the winners have nice videos explaining what their app was?
Is that was I was missing?

On May 9, 9:49 pm, Dave <dwcr...@gmail.com> wrote:

> I'd really like to see any of the winners tell me why they think their
> app is original.

[GodsMoon]

oh Congratulations to PocketJourney! I think its one of the best apps
out there.

[Kris Woodbeck]

Well it's a tradeoff, too original can be bad too. I entered a
submission that does a real-time search of > 1 million product images
(crawled from Google Products) using a cluster of GPUs to find the
closest matching shapes...(all based on my thesis)...

But barcodes are where it's at. Wish I'd know that sooner!

[Peli]

+1 for SplashPlay

http://www.splashplay.co.uk/
http://www.openintents.org/en/node/11

Peli

On May 9, 8:06 pm, plusminus <stoeps...@gmx.de> wrote:
> What about collecting the winners (only the winners) to get a nice
> overview even before May 12th ?
>

> Regards, plusminushttp://anddev.org

[dr123]

ours was. the most crazy idea there is. i cannot reveal it yet, sorry.
our UI sucked because of lack of time.
we lost. seems like moderate ideas that have all 10000 features of the
android were selected. i wish i've done a calculator that subtracts
when you hit the phone on the wall.

[vetch]

1. Originality
2. Effective Use of the Android Platform
3. Polish and Appeal
4. Indispensibility

Not every application meets these conditions. I see, that some do not
meet most of them.

Now, I know, why I lose. I focused to meet all of them. All judgement
process is unclear, closed and I think, very unfair.

Unless we (loosers) get official stats, ranking results, and "4
points" personal score for each application, we can treat this
challenge as mockery.

greets,
peter

[FengForky]

Yes. Agree with your opinion.

[ConAim]

I thought I was mention of the UNFAIR rite at the beginning of their
review?
I wonder if anyone was listenning? lol...

So there is 5 apps out of 50? where is the other 45? Google's internal
employees?

Duane,
NioPoker Online Demo
http://www.screencast.com/t/d5KkBPcuX

[Shamim]

is there any one outside of USA and UK? Since there were about 70
country's people who took part in the competion. I would love to see
some one from different country other than USA and UK

On May 10, 12:06 am, plusminus <stoeps...@gmx.de> wrote:
> What about collecting the winners (only the winners) to get a nice
> overview even before May 12th ?
>

> Regards, plusminushttp://anddev.org

[jalopy]

One of the 50 winning applications is called Locale:

http://www.crunchgear.com/2008/05/09/mit-students-demonstrate-their-android-applications/

MIT submitted 7 applications and they got one.

On May 10, 3:39 am, ConAim <duane.ngu...@gmail.com> wrote:
> I thought I was mention of the UNFAIR rite at the beginning of their
> review?
> I wonder if anyone was listenning? lol...
>
> So there is 5 apps out of 50? where is the other 45? Google's internal
> employees?
>
> Duane,

> NioPoker Online Demohttp://www.screencast.com/t/d5KkBPcuX

[ajd]

All winning applications I have seen so far are the kind of
applications that nobody can complete if the original deadline was not
changed (For those of you who forgot, the original deadline was not
April 14 but more than a month earlier). We did not pursue our entry
because we felt we selected an application that cannot win. We
selected an application based on the original deadline because we
assumed the original deadline will be strictly followed. When the
extension was announced, it was too late for us to change our entry to
a more sophisticated application.

I felt, and I still feel, that before the orignal deadline some
entries under development were already disclosed to OHA. If you'll
notice, the winning entries are really great (I can say WOW! to say
the least) and I think OHA thought those apps were so great that it
would be a pity if those apps could not make it just because of a
short deadline. Hence, the extension.

I am happy about our decision not to pursue (we'll surely lose), and I
am excited of me using the winning applications when gphone finally
arrives. In the meantime, I'm having feast in getting ideas from the
winning apps and see what I can use to develope my next iphone/windows
mobile application.

On May 10, 3:08 am, vetch <OldPete...@gmail.com> wrote:

[Muthu Ramadoss]

I did a team submission with Mary Ann from SF. We worked together remotely all by chat. I'm from Chennai, India.

--
take care,
Muthu Ramadoss.

http://mobeegal.in
find stuff closer.

[Alex Pisarev]

And we're from Russia :)

On May 11, 9:43 am, "Muthu Ramadoss" <muthu.ramad...@gmail.com> wrote:
> I did a team submission with Mary Ann from SF. We worked together remotely
> all by chat. I'm from Chennai, India.
>

[SungSuh Park]

> Did all of the winners have nice videos explaining what their app was?
> Is that was I was missing?

Nope

I made video manuals and I didn't write document for usage.
But only 3 of 12 judges played it. That three guys played 5%, 10% and
50% of manual.
Actually they didn't like to play long video.

Mine is Social Network Application.

[keashF]

+1 for Mobeedo

You can check it out on the winner's list, other than we're not
prepared to release anything just yet.
Unforunately.

Congrats to all participants! Keep it up, whether you won or not!!

Cheers,
F

[Shamim]

I was trying to find out is there any one who is in top 50 list and
staying out side USA and UK? Just to see the pattern of winning ,
whether any one received any winning mail except USA and UK?

> > find stuff closer.- Hide quoted text -
>
> - Show quoted text -

[Alex Pisarev]

We did, and we're from Russia.
Muthu also did and he is from India.
I know that Zorg has received one and he is from France.

> > - Show quoted text -- Скрыть цитируемый текст -
>
> - Показать цитируемый текст -

[qvark]

+1 BioWallet

A biometric authentication system that currently supports iris
recognition. It can act as a password manager with strong encryption
capabilities all without any password. It can also provide single sign-
on services for other applications in the Android platform.

Just to share my experience, and to answer some comments I have read
on these forums, my application was not very polished, it didn't
offered 10000 features or had a nice web site or video (that doesn't
mean I didn't work on it, in fact, it took me hundreds, probably
thousands, of hours of researching and coding). I think I just won
because it was a really innovative idea with lots of future
possibilities and the judges appreciated that (that's my opinion).

Best regards and good luck for winners and non-winners.

Jose Luis.

[javqui]

Congratulations Jose Luis.
Finally a Spaniard name!!!

You have a great idea.
I try a similar strategy with high innovation, low polish in ADC1, but
not was enough.
Are you from Spain?
Javier Quintana

> > #  Worlds largest Android Development Community / Tutorials- Hide quoted text -

[keashF]

Shanim,

We are from Austria, Europe.

Cheers,
F

[qvark]

Hi Javier! Yep, I'm from Spain (Caceres). I have started a new thread
to see if there are any other Spaniard besides us:

http://groups.google.com/group/android-challenge/browse_thread/thread/da703b24b1c82b86

Sorry you didn't win, but I hope you will keep working and participate
again in ACD II !

Best regards,

José Luis.

[Globetrotter]

+1 for GolfPlay

from Spain

Two project made in Spain. It's fantastic.

Cheers

[javqui]

Viva España!
Telefonica is one of the biggest phone carriers in the world, and it's
a corporation from Spain.
I sent a formal letter to the King of Spain (Su Majestad) some months
ago about my last project Blicopter. (It isn’t my ADC submission) and
I receive an answer with excellent feedback and the necessary roads to
drive.
I hope will receive something similar from OHA.

I will make my best effort to win some position into ADC2 to add one
more point to this fabulous country.

My special congratulations Globetrotter for your rewarded work!!.

[Nardo]

On 11 mayo, 22:05, javqui <blicop...@gmail.com> wrote:
> Viva España!

Hehe. I wouldn't call that out too loud.

I read you're from Florida, not that I want to start an off-topic, but
in case you didn't know, patriotism in Spain is not as strong as in
other places like U.S. for example, moreover in Spain that specific
expression is more on the political conservatism side than anything
else, something opposite I think to freedom, free software, open-
anything etc.
Just to let you know. :-)
Cheers.

[javqui]

Thank you for your comment.

This is a song name, that play in many countries over the world, maybe
you heard without the lyrics, sorry if you misunderstood, that was not
my intention.

To continue on track on this discussion, the winners come from all
across the world. This is wonderful, equal opportunities for everyone,
like Android. Open challenge, these words are powerful.

Real winners with merits, no politics (only terrorist were
disqualified), that’s excellent. This challenge shows the real sense
of Google over the world. When I switch from Yahoo to Google as my
search engine several years ago (it was not easy for me), one reason
was the impartiality of result searches and first quality info.

Congratulations again to all winners worldwide, and to Google to make
it happen.

> > > Two project made in Spain. It's fantastic.- Hide quoted text -

[luckydroid]

+1 (cooking utility) from Mary Ann in San Francisco and Muthu in
Chennai, India
:-)

[luckydroid]

oops- I double posted....didn't see this, sorry!
:-)
mary ann

[efon...@gmail.com]

This thread is a very good read! Now I know why people won.

Thank you for this thread (and congratulations).

Ed

> > - Show quoted text -- Hide quoted text -

[Zorg]

Yes Alex,
Marvin as been selected.
Z

[Amos]

+1 for BreadCrumbz - a different kind of navigation application.

Best wishes to all participants (if you did not win don't despair -
the real world is a different challenge altogether) and to the
wonderful developer community that's mushroomed here over the last few
months.

Amos (from Israel :-)

[Michael]

Is there a project website for BreadCrumbz? I'm putting together an
overview of the winning apps that have gone public already, so some
more info would be great.

Cheers.

[jalopy]

Here is a video of BreadCrumbz. Cool stuff!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZIlCH3txUcU

[Michael]

Thanks you.

> > > Amos (from Israel :-)- Zitierten Text ausblenden -
>
> - Zitierten Text anzeigen -

[Taneem]

Hey everyone,

We are a group of 4 Canadian students and our winning application is
called Eco2go.

Find out more about it at http://www.eco2go.org/

Feedback is welcome and appreciated.

Cheers,

Taneem Talukdar

[Free Tibet]

impressive, but how many people will use it?

[Free Tibet]

May I recommend that ADC be renamed to ABC (Android Bizarre
Challenge)?

On May 12, 1:23 pm, Taneem <tan...@eco2go.org> wrote:
> Hey everyone,
>
> We are a group of 4 Canadian students and our winning application is
> called Eco2go.
>

> Find out more about it athttp://www.eco2go.org/

[joos]

Austria here as well.

On 11 Mai, 19:47, keashF <kea...@gmx.net> wrote:
> Shanim,
>
> We are fromAustria, Europe.

[jalopy]

Eco2go is a nice application. But to be honest, I am not sure why this
application got chosen as one of Top 50 while other great apps I have
seen were not. I think all the great apps losers must be missing
something judges were really looking for. Hope Google can explain
those.

On May 12, 2:23 pm, Taneem <tan...@eco2go.org> wrote:
> Hey everyone,
>
> We are a group of 4 Canadian students and our winning application is
> called Eco2go.
>

> Find out more about it athttp://www.eco2go.org/

[ajd]

On May 12, 2:48 pm, jalopy <cooljal...@gmail.com> wrote:
> Eco2go is a nice application. But to be honest, I am not sure why this
> application got chosen as one of Top 50 while other great apps I have
> seen were not. I think all the great apps losers must be missing
> something judges were really looking for. Hope Google can explain
> those.

I agree. An application that basically estimates carbon emission as on
of the Top 50?

> > > > - Zitierten Text anzeigen -- Hide quoted text -

[Cow Bay]

i am sure very few submitted apps are NOT nice.

most are just not weird enough.

i very doubt 4th Judging Criteria -- Indispensability

[Free Tibet]

What does one pound of carbon mean to 99.999% of mobile phone users?

Doesn't everybody know that going to any place by his feet produces
the least carbon?

[Biosopher]

I have to come to the defense of Eco2Go. Or at least take the
conversation a little deeper to understand everyone's complaints.

Maybe all the younger kids participating in the Challenge have yet to
realize their impact on the globe, but I for one find Eco2Go a
refreshing idea. Whether it is required as a mobile app is another
question so let me address that next.

I'm currently consulting full-time in the past year, I drove roughly
15,000 miles, fly internationally at twice, flew coast-to-coast at
least 7 times a year plus a 5 flights around the West coast. However
I buy organic, recycle, compost, & use compact fluorcent lights. If
EcoToGo could also track how much I lightage I use, magazines I
subscribe to, & such then it would be useful to know what my total
contribution to the carbon footprint would be for the last year.

That said, I could probably get the same info by making a rough
estimate via some website calculator rather than starting up Eco2Go
everytime I start my car...

All that aside, Eco2Go is one of only a few apps I've seen that
attempt to address a ecological & social issues so I must commend them
on their effort. If they simply won because they looked beyond social
gaming & SMS twittering then I'm glad at Google honored their
commitment to creating a better planet for longer than just our
lifetimes. Perhaps Eco2Go will inspire people to look beyond their
mobile device as a toy to entertain them & start using it as a tool
for improving the planet.

If people are going to condemn Eco2Go, then please tell us about other
eco-applications submitted to the Challenge that should have won
instead.

Anthony

[Cow Bay]

i wish i had submitted a lbs app to inform the judges to rush into my
backyard to put off burning charcoals after my birthday party.

what a joke!!

----- Original Message -----
From: "Biosopher" <bios...@gmail.com>
To: "Android Challenge" <android-...@googlegroups.com>
Sent: Monday, May 12, 2008 2:30 PM
Subject: [android-challenge] Re: The Winners...

>

[Chris]

I second Anthony. Google was looking for humanitarian uses for
Android, and this one fell in a very trendy socially responsible
niche. And it was very novel - I hate to say it but a lot of the apps
I've seen have been very "me too". It might not have as much "meat"
to it as some of the others, but it seems to do its intended job well.

[Cow Bay]

i wonder what your "novelty" means???

with LBS added, most "me too" apps submitted to adc are practically novel.

with LBS removed, most "novel" apps submitted to adc are actually me too.

your judgement on winning positoon sounds kinda biased.

----- Original Message -----
From: "Chris" <crh...@gmail.com>
To: "Android Challenge" <android-...@googlegroups.com>
Sent: Monday, May 12, 2008 2:56 PM
Subject: [android-challenge] Re: The Winners...

>

[Biosopher]

Hi CowBay,

I forgot. What application did you submit to the Challenge? Could
you provide us a link to the website or describe it for us?

Thanks,
Anthony

[Cow Bay]

my app was to monitor hundreds of cows grazing around a bay and rush the
owner to save any cow that falls into the bay. (every cow is tied with an
android phone)

is it novel enough?

cow!!

----- Original Message -----
From: "Biosopher" <bios...@gmail.com>
To: "Android Challenge" <android-...@googlegroups.com>
Sent: Monday, May 12, 2008 3:31 PM
Subject: [android-challenge] Re: The Winners...

>

[Biosopher]

Damn...you should have stayed with your original idea of monitoring
nitrous oxide generated by cow farts & decomposing heffer dung to
determine what carbon offsets Californians needed to purchase to
offset their cheese eating habits.

Oops. Hope I didn't spill the beans about your Challenge Round 2
entry. Of course, be sure to to change your username to Cow Poo.
It's not too late as that username's still available!

You'll be making California's cows very happy.

Anthony

[nick]

I don't like tooting my own horn, as they say, but since you asked for
applications that deal with social issues...

My application (which didn't win) is called Fluid Nexus and is
designed for activists or relief workers to communicate amongst each
other independent of a centralized cellular network. More
information, including source code, is available at http://fluidnexus.net
.

I entered the competition based on their desire for applications that
addressed "humanitarian and social issues". I know that there were
some other applications in this area, including one for ad-hoc, JIT
volunteering applications. I'll be very interested to see if any of
these other applications made the winner list. If not, then Google's
calling for these types of applications feels somewhat disingenuous.

nick

[Cow Bay]

bullshxt, if i were to change username, it is FY.

----- Original Message -----
From: "Biosopher" <bios...@gmail.com>
To: "Android Challenge" <android-...@googlegroups.com>
Sent: Monday, May 12, 2008 4:02 PM
Subject: [android-challenge] Re: The Winners...

>

[Biosopher]

Actually thanks for bringing your Fluid Nexus into this discussion as
an excellent example of the social technologies we need to consider.

I watched your video & read viewed your ReadMe images when you first
announced last month. I liked the idea, and if you don't mind my
commenting, can only guess that you lost points (at least from the
website screenshots) on effective use of Android technologies (none
that I saw) and perhaps polish of the app conceptual design overall
(e.g. security & authentication as you can't trust ad-hoc Bluetooth
networks).

There's always Round 2 though where you can showcase the location-
awareness & mapping benefits that would better utilize Android
capabilities and allow people to better coordinate spatially.

As you say though, maybe one of the other JIT collaboration apps won.

[Biosopher]

Great idea, Cow Bay.

From the majority of the posts I've seen for you, that name would be
an appropriate fit.

Up with cows....down with whiners.

Ok...I'm done messing with the bovines on this discussion group as
we're now way off topic. Sorry guys...let's hope they announce the
winners soon so we can get down to more fruitful discussions again.

[Steve Oldmeadow]

+1 Rayfarla "Learn, Make & Play - Music"

from Australia (the one WITH the kangaroos)

[Cow Bay]

yep!

you cannot find bio sulfur from cow poo, just as i cannot find fruit from
bullshit.

----- Original Message -----
From: "Biosopher" <bios...@gmail.com>
To: "Android Challenge" <android-...@googlegroups.com>
Sent: Monday, May 12, 2008 4:56 PM
Subject: [android-challenge] Re: The Winners...

>

[keashF]

I have to agree with Biosopher and Chris.

I think Eco2go is a real innovation:
For me, reducing my carbon footprint is desirable, but -lazy as I am-
hard to achieve. When i have to go somewhere or have to choose between
something or another, there are a lot of aspects to consider, and I
don't take the time to judge things from a "green" point of view, even
though i know i should. If Eco2Go can assist in this matter, I'll be
more than glad to use it. A well deserved Top 50.

Cow bay,
I understand you're frustrated 'cause you didn't win, but what's the
point in flaming? Just because your app wasn't chosen for the Top50
doesn't mean it's bad. Believe in your idea and get over it.

Biosopher,
this "discussion" leads nowhere. Let it go.

Cheers,
F

[nick]

Don't want to hijack the thread, but I wanted to respond to your two
points...thanks for the comments.

With regard to effective use of Android technologies, there weren't
many for me to use. Bluetooth support was basically nonexistent, so I
had to write my own simulated version. The Bluetooth stack as it
exists doesn't even interface with the host computer's Bluetooth
interface; I had to write that layer myself. As for WiFi, well, there
isn't even an interface given (while for Bluetooth they seem to be
basing it own bluez). So I didn't even want to write my own simulated
WiFi interface before one exists. I didn't need/want to make my
interface flashy; the application is very basic to use from a UI point
of view so no animations are needed. As for other technologies, since
the whole point is to provide communication without using a
centralized network, I didn't want to use any technologies that
required access to a centralized network :-) Creating a "mapping"
layer or LBS would require contacting Google's servers which, given
the censoring of information in China, is a cause for concern...

As for conceptual design, well, security has been at the forefront of
my thought from the beginning. The application works much much better
if there are many nodes in the "network"; adding a security layer
decreases its effectiveness dramatically. In other systems of this
type (i.e., an application like txtmob) an entirely open message board
actually found wide use even though there wasn't any authentication or
"trust". On the other hand, having some means of limiting
transmission of messages is certainly necessary at times, and within
the README I wrote some text that mentioned this area as a place of
future improvement.

With that said, I hope that at least one of the winners was something
in this space. I guess we'll hopefully find out tomorrow.

nick

[Cow Bay]

you misunderstood my intent.

i just want to learn the difference among a winning app and a losing one,
based on adc's four criteria.

it is not about win vs loss. it is about truth, especially about how the
judge exercised 4th criteria.

[keashF]

Maybe you should've used OpenIntents

:-D

[Cow Bay]

cannot figure out relationship between 4th criteria and openintents.

[keashF]

dude, it was suppose to be a joke on you saying:

> you misunderstood my intent.

(just to be clear, i meant no offence to you or OpenIntents)

anyway, i wonder what you'll say about our app. be sure to let me know
once the list is out.
It's late and i'm drunk and i don't make sense.. so i'll go to bed.

cu guys

[ajd]

On May 12, 8:29 pm, "Cow Bay" <nmlg...@gmail.com> wrote:
> you misunderstood my intent.
>
> i just want to learn the difference among a winning app and a losing one,
> based on adc's four criteria.
>
> it is not about win vs loss. it is about truth, especially about how the
> judge exercised 4th criteria.

Agree. I don't think those criteria were followed. They can change the
rule in the middle of a contest.

> > > > winners soon so we can get down to more fruitful discussions again.- Hide quoted text -

[Cow Bay]

did google change the rule???

better get a screen shot of the four criteria before its too late......

[Braden Napier]

dude - wow ... let's be more of a sore loser.

What's sad is all of these people that 100% expected to win.. I know
you are proud of the applications you made... just because you didn't
win $25,000 doesn't mean you have to cry about it... find a way to
make $25,000 yourself instead of it simply given to you! I have five
Android applications I haven't announced or didn't enter into the
contest... I am not interested in $25,000 being given to my
company ... I want to effectively showcase my work and see it through
to completion without worrying about deadlines... but the fact is -
$25,000 is NOTHING if you know you truly have an innovative program..

If you really do.. and I mean REALLY have something amazing that can
benefit people - put a price on it... get on the road... and sell it
to those clients (We developed applications that are B2B related and
use EVERY aspect of Android). $25,000 is ONE SALE of our program...
so find a way to make $50,000 from your program... then use that
$50,000 to program a ton more... then you should feel REAL
satisfaction that you have really made something people LOVE to use...

Android is revolutionary and will allow a complete innovation amongst
our societies. Stop fighting, work together, and let's really build
something strong and influential..

Bottom-line... we are all developers and we all want to build business
from development of Android products. In order to do this, we need to
have an extremely strong bottom-line reason to spend the money on an
Android phone over things such as Blackberry... the average consumer
could give a SHIT about the phone being open-source... but when I can
say "Oh, your into environment? Buy Android and get Eco2Go" "Oh, your
a farmer? Get Cow Bay and you will be able to benefit big time!"

As a network of developers, instead of competitors, we can see this
change ... stop crying about losing and talking about going to
iPhone... You go to iPhone and THEY OWN YOU! It doesn't have even
close t the potential or the possibilities (you limited to FUCKING
AT&T in USA which has NO data network what-so-ever (even their 3G
sucks))

So stop crying and let's start working together!

[RSTanvir]

For eco2go
hey carbon tracing team
i have one point that you can add:

1) Also trace the carbon which comes from human body by breathing.
   benefit:
      people will know how much they release carbon by breathing.
   not-benefit:
      some time people will stop breathing to reduce carbon. :=))

come'on people how the 4th term was really judged????
i gave more importance in indispensability in my app.