εξι (●〈◎) Hwang Woo Suk( Taiwan Style )

[frank]

 

韓首爾大學黃禹錫( Hwang Woo-Suk)教授事件中,有一件事非常值得深刻思考!

Phenomenon of Collective Nobel-Prize Paranoid    vs   Phenomenon of  Nobel-Prize Hunger

Phenomenon:

1.the country do the legislative work for the researcher

2.support as much money as the researcher request

3.even deviation,to be patriotic,people take it as granted,

4.people donate everything the researcher need

5.people take it as a glory to serve the researcher,

   even researcher commit crime,

   the people   protect the researcher   with any excuse they can imagine

6.take the researcher as a national hero

7.to reveal the scandal, people would offend you in patriotic fervor

   for the truth,to inspect,you must act as Sherlock Holmes,as cool as a cucumber,

   perhaps you must prepare to sacrifice

---

 

Who is Hwang Woo-Suk

 

Hwang Woo-Suk born 29,January 1953,Buyeo gun,Chungnam province, (South Korea)

a South Korean biomedical scientist.

He is a fan of the 17th century Italian physicist Galileo Galilei

Hwang commented : 

"Galileo dared to take on the powerful church authorities of the day

to prove that the planets orbit the sun. At the risk of losing his life,

he was brave enough to make a stand for science."

 Hwang first caught media attention in South Korea when he announced

he successfully created a cloned milk cow,  in February 1999.

and In the year 2004, rose to international fame after claiming

a series of remarkable breakthroughs in the field of stem cell research,

 

World take him as:

1.one of the pioneering experts in the field of stem cell research

Korean people considered the researcher  :

1.a national hero

2.a best candidate for Nobel Prize

3.Pride of Korea,

they organized a group "I love Hwang woo-suk" to support him

Goventment support him with state funds

1.annual stipend of US$ 3 millions and other research plan fee

   From 1998 to 2005 up to US$ 39.9 million

2.the post office made a commemorative stamp on Hwang's research

3.make the bioethics law for Hwang Woo-Suk

4.launches the World Stem Cell Hub ,an international network

 

what's wrong with his research?

1.Hwang conspicuously failed to provide any supporting paper for the research,

   Scientist can not find any data that can probe the validity of the research.

2.He denied coercing his researchers into donating eggs and claimed that he found out about the

   situation only after it had occurred.He added that he had lied about the source of the eggs donated to

   protect the privacy of his female researchers, and that he was not aware of the Declaration of Helsinki,

   which clearly enumerates his actions as a breach of ethical conduct.

   Evidence:

   December 8, 2005. Hwang's claim of not having known about the donation of eggs by his own female

   researchers was also denied by the panel; in fact, it was discovered that Hwang himself had distributed egg

   donation consent forms to his researchers and personally escorted one to the MizMedi Hospital to take the egg

   extraction  procedure.

3.December 23,2005,  Hwang apologized on that day and admitted he fabricated results

   in stem-cell research .

4.   On December 29, 2005, the university determined that all 11 of Hwang's stem cell lines were fabricated.

   The university announced on January 10 ,2006 that Hwang's 2004 and 2005 papers on Science were both

   fabricated. Following on the confirmation of scientific misconduct.

 

Why can this terrible thing  keep that long time?

ie,How Hwang woo-suk  protect himself?

1.revelation:On November 22, "PD Su-cheop" (Producer's Notebook), a popular MBC investigative reporting show,

                   raised the possibility of unethical conduct in the egg cell acquiring process.

   defense:Despite the factual accuracy of the report, news media as well as people caught up in nationalistic

                fervor in their unwavering support for Hwang asserted that criticism of Hwang's work was "unpatriotic,"

                so much so that the major companies who were sponsoring the show immediately withdrew their support.

2. Hwang actively sought to establish every possible tie to political and economic institutions in the country.

    Hwang especially tried to win favor from the Roh Moo-hyun government,

3.some lawmakers revealed that Hwang made several campaign donations to them and other lawmakers.

 

The description above is

 the Phenomenon of Collective Nobel-Prize Hunger 

and if they don't introspect they would become

                                    Collective Nobel-Prize Paranoid

but they got the ability to introspect , and follow the pace of the world to become a developped country,

they said:

 [Seong added:

  "Researchers of our country were newly awakened to the fact that we have to take every precaution

    to ensure we don't fall behind international ethics (guidelines) while researching." ]

they got the national confidence

 .

 

 

What would happen in taiwan,a nation that feel inferior?

Let's think about the situation below :

 IF:  [

1.a  Member of Academia Sinica who violated the human right  ,

2.even more he commit crime,

3.he doesn't  think  the human norm should be followed,

4.he cooperated with the rascals   to maliciously intrigue against a poor family to reach a situation 

this situation just like 

[the bruno bettelheim said  :

   the experience in dachau & buchenwald concentration camp]

 

  Hannah Arendt said about the situation:

"the psyche (or character) can be destroyed even without the destruction of the physical man."

To survive the family have no choice,but do the immoral thing.

5.the Member of Academia Sinica  didn't feel sorry

6.he is an officer before,so he has good relation with the authority to cover the crime,

7.some colleague even  do some terrible thing worse than the Huang-woo-suk

  coercing his colleague to  take the egg extraction procedure 

 

What would happen in Taiwan?

'Patriotism,'

'Criticism of Member of Academia Sinica 's work was "unpatriotic," '

'The officers using every possible intrigues to blackmail the guy who revealed the facts '

 

What a country that's why people said  'an abnormal country'

no self-confidence,malicious intrigued people who is against them.

Collective Nobel-Prize Paranoid-----

The old Member of Academia  Sinica and the guys who intrigue

"Kaohsiung2459926" <go...@yahoo.com> wrote in message news:e0grdt$f5o$4...@netnews.hinet.net...

Taiwan-made Hwang Woo Suk is not only one guy but also include the guys who play the part of Pinocchio,

the bundles of guys construct the Collective Nobel Prize Paranoid.

These Collective Nobel Prize Paranoid suppress the poor man ,

don't feel sorry,they even try to drive a  man  crazy,

but the  man pretend crazy ,when those Paranoid didn't' pay that much attention,

the  man escape ,and tell everybody the terrible story,

let everybody know how worse these once-respected Guys are these paranoid.

Who are these guys?

Some of the Medicine Field.

A country want to progress,

to become a developped country,

the  researcher must be honest,admit a mistake,like the korean researcher Seong said:

 [  "Researchers of our country were newly awakened to the fact that we have to take every precaution    

 to ensure we don't fall behind international ethics (guidelines) while researching." ]

they got the national confidence ,

but in Taiwan ,these attitute toward mistakes doesn't work,

they get used to cheat ,they are used to be  liars.

 

"Yunlin679890.Conrad" <go...@yahoo.com> wrote in message news:e0s4pb$ooh$4...@netnews.hinet.net...

 In Taiwan,In the Medicine Field, they got their own profession ethics,

 through training of companionship, they got two attributes,so called

     1.  the feeling of honor(the honor to cover for each other,

          not the honor of honesty like admiting a mistake President George Washington did)

          Marcia Millman in her research tells us

         (the doctors don't critisize each other  in the formal group   because

          ㄅ.a fear of reprisal

          ㄆ.recognition of common interests

          ㄇ.gentlemen's agreement).

           They keep covering their companion's faults,sharing the feeling of honor.     

 2.the facism,(they  can not face the reality ,too.)

          the facism ruins their courage to admit their mistakes

          The social culture factor of the Medicine Field ---Bigheadia makes it worse

          So ,the Dr. Lin becomes Pinocchio.Lin  easily.

 Who should be blamed?

     The social culture factor of the Medicine Field ---Bigheadia

 

Why don't they feel shameful?

    Erving Goffman in his book

     "The Presentation of Self in Everyday Life"  tells us about  the "India thug"  story  can explain more.

     The "india thug" do the cruel thing ,cruelly rob,kill  the innocent people,

     How can they not feel guilty?

     Because,their "in-group solidarity through the rite"  had given them "the moral support" .

     The same situation   "Dr. Lin"      becomes      "Pinocchio.Lin"    so naturally!

  "Taichung2370479.UCB.Conrad" <go...@yahoo.com> wrote in message news:e15ebr$63d$2...@netnews.hinet.net...

 Dr.Lin devotes to the pursuing of The Prize and the ruining of the family norm!

For a Member of Academia Sinica,doesn't Dr.Lin feel shameful?

In Chinese ,"斯文掃地" ,Dr.Lin  should be not only shameful but also shameful to death!

Dr.Lin  is  the Taiwan-edition  Hwang Woo Suk,

what made him  Taiwan-edition  Hwang Woo Suk

he violated the human right,

the man whose human right was violated by him protests,

he libels the man a psycho,violated again,also cheated,and committed a crime.

In the procedure he violated the human right ,

we can examine what he has done in his research to understand who he is.

However this is a crazy country,

Alain Touraine

in his book  "Le retour de l'acteur:essai de sociologie"  Chapter11

New Social  Conflict,

it said

 [

 every place we can see the trend to medicalize social problem,........

they marginalized social problem,

extremely,if anyone who is against the authority would be taken as crazy.

 ]

In a country that has so much conflict and get used to cheat ,what do you expect ?

Especially ,when those guys are in the nobel-prize-fever!Those paranoid!

I don't  think this is the only case,he has done,

If he can intrigue to make a

situation that make the people have the kinds of experiences ----

[the bruno bettelheim said  :

   the experience in dachau & buchenwald concentration camp]

 

  Hannah Arendt said about the situation:

"the psyche (or character) can be destroyed even without the destruction of the physical man."

To survive the family have no choice,but do the immoral thing.

 

What's more ?

 

How many case do you think the Hwang Woo Suk(Taiwan-edition ) has done?

 it must be like the iceberg ,you can only see an angle,

but the most serious crime is just like the iceberg under the water that you cannot see!

But in an underdevelopped country,

can they investigate these crime deeply like the korean people did ?????????

Let's check

how he committed these kinds of crime!

 Doctor  Lin:

Hot summer,

Sit  by the side,

Get away from the circles of fighting.

Suddenly ,the world calms down!

Wind whistles ,

Butterflies fly,

Kitten crawls through,

Bird singing,

Travellers whistles.

 

 

Doctor  Lin:

                   Be Honest!

                   Never ruin the reputation of  Member of Academia Sinica!

 

What a bad example for the newcomers,the worst example people can find !

To make the innocent researchers guilty!

Like a dead dog being dragged!

This is the faults of the leader!

Why don't the leader admit the mistakes?

Let the followers free!

The Medicine Violence is on Taiwan Style Hwang Woo Suk  side,

that's why he libels but not punnished!

Do you know how miserable the guy lives

 ,because he was libeled by Taiwan Style Hwang Woo Suk   

 

20060509am0905 his father  died,

20060605 his father was burned to ashes,

20060612 his father was put into the tomb and sealed.

20061112His father died 188 days.

 

What's going on?

whose mouth was shut up?

Who shut the mouth?

Dr.Lin, dare you say the man who was libeled by you is not related to you?

Dr.Lin, dare you say his father was not related to you?