RESULT: rec.arts.furry moderated fails (by eight votes)
Bob Guthrie
RESULT
moderated group rec.arts.furry fails 130:38
There were 130 YES votes and 38 NO votes, for a total of 168 valid votes.
There were 2 abstains.
For group passage, YES votes must be at least 2/3 of all valid (YES and
NO) votes. There also must be at least 100 more YES votes than NO
votes.
There is a five day discussion period after these results are posted.
Unless serious allegations of voting irregularities are raised, the
group may not be voted on again for six months.
Newsgroups line:
rec.arts.furry Funny Animal fandom discussions. (Moderated)
The voting period ended at 23:59:59 UTC, 5 Jul 2000.
This vote was conducted by a neutral third party. Questions
about the proposed group should be directed to the proponent.
Proponent: Kay Shapero <kay.s...@salata.com>
Proponent: M. Mitchell Marmel <marm...@drexel.edu>
Votetaker: David Bostwick <bost...@cas.chemistry.gatech.edu>
Voted Yes
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
71611.2330 <at> compuserve.com Michael Burlake
AllanGldmn <at> aol.com Al Goldman
allenk <at> blkbox.com Allen Kitchen
atara <at> raex.com Sarah Brannan
auctionNO <at> furfestSPAM.org Tom Rogers
bahumat <at> telusplanet.net Patrick Rochefort
baloo <at> ursine.dyndns.org Paul E. Johnson
bgold <at> nyx.net Barry Gold
bgrant <at> furhold.ifb.co.uk Bruce Grant
blbergman <at> earthlink.net Bruce Bergman
bmarcum <at> iglou.com Bill Marcum
bob_guthrie <at> fastpointcom.com Robert Guthrie
bouvin <at> daimi.au.dk Niels Olof Bouvin
briana <at> iea.com Brian W. Antoine
catwoman <at> iglou.com Cath Wolffe
charlie <at> eql14.caltech.edu Charlie H. Luce, Jr.
charon <at> cs.tu-berlin.de Sebastian F. Mix
cheetah <at> tigress.com Sven Tegethoff
cluebat <at> earthlink.net Karl A. Krueger
dave <at> frackit.com Dave Ratcliffe
dave <at> konig.demon.co.uk David Cooke
dcooksey <at> mustelid.com David Cooksey
dcthornton <at> lvcm.com Dar Thornton
delcis <at> bellsouth.net Theo Wiegman
devaki <at> mindspring.com Megan Lowry
dformosa <at> dformosa.zeta.org.au David Platypus Formosa
dgs <at> argonet.co.uk dgs
dietz <at> interaccess.com Paul F. Dietz
doolittl <at> tbcnet.com Jim Doolittle
Dorra <at> meerkat.org Dora Martinez
doug <at> fastpointcom.com Doug Winger
drs <at> majornet.com DeWayne Stuart
dsand101 <at> future.dreamscape.com Don Sanders
eesiv <at> gte.net ERNEST E SHUMAKER IV
ehillman <at> iamdigex.net Edward Lloyd Hillman
elynne <at> WOLFENET.com Erin Lynn
feren <at> kittyfox.net JASON OLSEN
ferret <at> enteract.com Karl Meyer
FitchDonS <at> aol.com Don Fitch
forban <at> hal-pc.org William Earl Haskell
fungus <at> OCF.Berkeley.EDU Hank Fung
Gauri <at> mindspring.com Belinda Kiefer
gbreshears <at> activevoice.com Gene Breshears
GGMongo <at> aol.com David Rathbun
graf1 <at> home.com Tygger L. Graf
grizelda <at> vianet.on.ca Ron Orr
gvp1 <at> cornell.edu Grace V. Palazzolo
hartreef <at> concentric.net Kyle L. Webb
hmiller <at> io.com Herman Miller
hwesson <at> ipa.net Hayley Wesson
jayshell <at> earthlink.net Jay Shell
jon <at> thomson2273.freeserve.co.uk Jon Thomson
jrk <at> sys.uea.ac.uk Richard Kennaway
kagur <at> aol.com Kagur
kayshapero <at> earthlink.net Kay Shapero
kendall <at> his.com Kendall P. Bullen
kevinpease <at> worldnet.att.net Kevin Pease
khromat <at> my-Deja.com Lisa Jennings
khym <at> bga.com Dave Huang
kiewicz <at> mw.mediaone.net Pat Kiewicz
kimdv <at> best.com Kim DeVaughn
LncrAdvncd <at> aol.com Ian Williams
lummer <at> ix.netcom.com Louis Richards
lynx <at> fysh.org Conrad Wong
marmelmm <at> drexel.edu M. Mitchell Marmel
mathue <at> illiop.org Vaughn Hangartner
mauser <at> kendra.com Richard Chandler
mayfurr <at> attglobal.net Terry Knight
mccauley <at> davesworld.net Joe McCauley
mcclenon <at> erols.com Bob McClenon
mellorya <at> yahoo.com Joseph Richmond
mgk <at> ecs.soton.ac.uk M <at>
mike_ferret <at> altavista.com Michael Santy
mra <at> pobox.com Mark Atwood
mshaw <at> resourcephoenix.com Matt Shaw
naddy <at> mips.inka.de Christian Weisgerber
naiath <at> worldnet.att.net Kiara Selwa
nebulosa <at> marmorata.vulpine.org David Green
nebusj <at> rpi.edu Joseph Nebus
nevis <at> squeep.com Nevis
nfitz <at> sentex.net Nicholas Fitzpatrick
Nyehba <at> aol.com Patrice Garn
ocelot <at> phocat.com Andrea L. Adams
ostrich <at> fysh.org Marshall A. Woods
Otrstf <at> aol.com Daniel Kimball
owolf <at> poboxes.com Joerg Reuter
pan <at> syix.com Pan
petercat <at> furry.fan.org PeterCat
pflorian <at> netwiz.net Paul Floriani
porter.clark <at> msfc.nasa.gov J. Porter Clark
puma <at> catbox.com Gary Breuckman
qpanda <at> iwaynet.net Mark D. McKean
r.vanette <at> pink.nl Robert-Jan van Ette
rb211 <at> nelson.tds.net Q Tip
RebelSqurl <at> aol.com Jeffrey Pierce
red_jack <at> mad.scientist.com Joseph Harrison/ Red Jack
rjuliano <at> cfl.rr.com Bob Juliano
robertalley <at> earthlink.net Robert Alley
rufinus <at> mbe.ece.wisc.edu J Rufinus
rwpikul <at> idirect.com Rick Pikul
skorzy <at> mindspring.com Jeff Rogers
solarfox <at> texas.net Gary Akins
source <at> netcom.com David Harmon
squitaur <at> net-gate.com R.F. Hardman
stef <at> cat-and-dragon.com Stef Maruch
Steve <at> fastpointcom.com STEVEN C. MARTIN
swilkinson <at> escape.ca Sean Wilkinson
tabrady <at> concentric.net Thomas Brady
tashta <at> mediaone.net Kishma Danielle
tbates <at> krl.org Tom Bates
TedSchller <at> aol.com Theodore X. Schiller
thetalkingfox <at> mailandnews.com Richard de Wylfin
the_guy_at_node3 <at> my-Deja.com B. Kendall
tmorgan <at> primenet.com Tad Morgan
tmorgen <at> centralcity.net Ted Morgen
tomt <at> bpal.com Tom Turrittin
tremaine <at> execpc.com Randy Entinger
trevort <at> vianet.on.ca Trevor Tymchuk
twoolfe <at> mediaone.net T. Woolfe
ucalegon <at> aol.com Philip M. Cohen
umnovot1 <at> cc.UManitoba.CA J. J. Novotny
vikthor <at> mindspring.com Vik-Thor Scott Rose
vixy <at> cybergal.com Perri Chiasson
vote-8 <at> kholdan.in-berlin.de tobias erle
WFORTIER <at> umassd.edu William Fortier
wmittens <at> techie.com Woolly Mittens
wolter <at> theo.physik.uni-bremen.de Mark-Oliver Wolter
wulfraed <at> dm.net Dennis Lee Bieber
wwwwolf <at> iki.fi Urpo Lankinen
xydexx <at> smart.net Karl Xydexx Jorgensen
Voted No
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
beebe <at> scd.hp.com Mike Beebe
eewf <at> mindspring.com E. Wahrheit
James <at> jimx.clara.co.uk Jim Allen
sowi <at> uu.net Sonny Windstrup
billo <at> Radix.Net William Oliver
brandi <at> dcn.davis.ca.us Brandi Weed
cartisan <at> pacwestracing.net Newton
chriseb <at> ukshells.co.uk Chris Ebenezer
Davesta99 <at> aol.com Dave Leighton
david <at> farrar.com David Farrar
desj <at> math.berkeley.edu David desJardins
dougob55 <at> go.com D. David OBrien
Ekkehard.Uthke <at> gmx.de Ekkehard Uthke
ellis <at> ftel.net Rick Ellis
farmerie <at> interfold.com Todd A. Farmerie
gprrspw <at> mindspring.com G.P. Ryan
jabizri.wt.net <at> sys32.hou.wt.net B. Roget
julesd <at> erols.com Jules Dubois
kamlet <at> infinet.com Art Kamlet
lostpuppy3 <at> hotmail.com Bradley Pitt
mmontcha <at> OregonVOS.net Matthew Montchalin
olav <at> viking.mv.com Olav Nieuwejaar
pubadd2 <at> wt.net Roger Muttchinson
r5555c <at> email.sps.mot.com Alan Chapman
rainfield <at> mindspring.com Andy Elfway
simpson <at> netcom.com Bob Simpson
slr1bpz <at> mindspring.com George McCoy
stainles <at> bga.com Dwight Brown
sthoenna <at> efn.org Yitzchak Scott-Thoennes
tarq <at> columbus.rr.com Friar Tarq
tgm <at> netcom.com Thomas G. McWilliams
tjmc <at> enteract.com tjmc
toejam_78 <at> hotmail.com ToaeJamnn Mann
twytch <at> mail1.aaahawk.com Chet Saberhagen
yan <at> storm.ca Yves Bellefeuille
zalamber <at> mindspring.com Paul Willis
zen0n <at> klub.chip.pl Zenobiusz Zimny
zeroisms <at> aol.com Zero
Abstained
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
aahz <at> netcom.com Aahz
silly <at> well.com Thomas Armagost
-----------------------------------------------------------------
"By the way, anyone who takes any of this seriously, deserves to."
Donna Barr.