Some thoughts from a PL 5.2 user.
I have installed and latest beta code from Frans and really like the detailed chs vs time plot as well as the count down feature for the arm time. Thanks Frans.
Given accurate chs vs time one might be able to make technique changes to increase chs at impact with this data.
As for the arm count down: We all know how many "good swings" clients have made just after the arm light went out. So Frans's arm count down is really helpful.
I did check the beta software reported LA value after using a laser pen to check where the PL base was pointing, then I measured
the height of the hit on the net minus the tee up height of the center of the ball and then calculate
LA = tan(ball gain in height/ 144"). The result was within 1/2 degree. Trackman spec for LA is + - 0.2 deg
I have a casio EX-F1 so I hope to help Frans check chs vs time, bs, and could calculate Azmith given a net hit point and some trig calculation. Club Face angle could be captured vs time as well with a camera in the swing plane pointing down at the ball.
Would have to deal with camera distortion with some calculations to remove line scan skew. reference:
http://www.tutelman.com/golf/measure/focalPlaneDistortion.phpCould also put the camera at a few inches above ground level and aim at the ball/club head and get AoA and DL (messy due to scan line distortion) Key is these could be plotted vs time instead of just having 1 value at impact that you get from Trackman or other LMonitors. It would really be nice to know how fast a players hands are rotating through impact and when the hands
try to hold the face square and how much of this rotation change effects chs in the last few msec before impact.
All of these camera measurements would required software to manually digitize the video or some auto tracking software.
The also suffer from the low sample rate and digitizing error. For example Trackman staff says that AoA and the Club path can can change by .8 deg while the ball is in contact the the club face. Trackman spec is + - .5 deg for AoA and CPath or Horizontal angle. Another interesting number from Trackman research team analysis is that the Dynamic loft and face angle can change by 1 deg through impact. Dave Tutelman says that the gear effect result that people once used in analysis was under estimated and future programs like Trajectoware will take the new data into account.
By using using Vernier
http://www.vernier.com/soft/lp.html I was able to plot items like AoA and I think 1 deg accuracy
is most likely best case for the Casio setup given manual digitizing noise.
I also have tested the freeware Kinovea video analysis tool.
http://www.kinovea.org/en/ . I use v1home premium
http://www.v1golfacademy.com/ but v1home only allows static measurement of angles and annotation.
One also needs to have reference lines in the video image to set the horizon line and target line as needed.
I wish the PL had a way to auto level and maybe a sighting device for the target line. I use a laser pen in my garage
for checking horizontal level but would like a user input control to set the PL target line given slight miss alignments
of the unit or the sensors. Trackmans auto leveling and build in camera to get the target line are what one really needs.
So what key
measured values are missing: Spin axis and spin value. Maybe possible with a camera shooting down the target
line but I have never tried it with a marked ball. One would have to deal with 3d correction as the ball moves away
from the camera. Side view could see the backspin value easier while the target view could see the axis.
Just dreaming on how one could measure these values without spending $20000 or even $8000. I paid $1000 for the EXF1.
But for $20k you can get the spin rate measured + - 15 rpms.
Maybe some day Frans can give users measures spin values from the PL again.
So how accurate do these measurement need to be?
Trackman staff thinks the following. (User conference report). All launch monitor manufactures should spec
even their calculated value accuracy.
Action possible if accuracy of the following is
chs < 2mph
club path < 1 deg
attack < 1 deg
spin < 200rpm
carry < 2meter
Unacceptable error
chs > 5mph
club path > 3 deg
AoA > 3
Spin > 1000 rpm
carry > 6 meters