@Anon Kun
For the record you've dropped the following arguments
> People like you shouldn't post.
> There's a big WARNING right on the top of the story
>Reading something that you already know that you won't like only to complain right after it's stupid.
>Especially since your criticism is 100% about your tastes (which is not of help) and 0% constructive.
>You basically show up here to say the equivalent of "lol it's shit" without giving anything else.
>I hope you won't take it personally. (Contradiction)
I'm not entirely sure if I should even bother, (since you probably
won't read any of it)
> If you want to break my post in single words, analyze them one by one and playing semantics it's cool...
Notice, you're oversimplifying. I broke it up line by line, point by
point. Also, I pointed out grammar mistakes because they made me
scratch my head. Regardless, it wasn't merely semantics since you've
ignored my arguments. I'd appreciate less patronizing, or preferably
condescension more humorous.
>but it's enough to consider the point of my post instead, which is: the story wasn't intended for your tastes, the author had already stated it repeatedly and you still come here to complain.
Stated it repeatedly? The author did not given sufficient warning. I
stated my opinion once, and you immediately tried to shut me down. As
for 'wasn't for my tastes' please see the next block.
My 'complaining' is an attempt to have a discussion, which you seem to
passionately dislike.
>It's not my fault if you didn't knew about any previous thread: common sense would like a new user to read a little around before posting, instead of creating an account just to tell someone that he despise his story.
... This post is confusing. First of all... I'm not blaming you for
anything. Secondly, I know enough about yukkuris to object to a
person's interpretation of them, but my criticism is invalid because
in another thread he mentioned the story? So before I read every story
and give my two cents I need to conduct meticulous research behind the
author to figure out what sort of story he's going to write?
I can't just say I like it or dislike it?
> A new guy shows up and the first thing that he says on the site is "I
> sincerely despise this story".
> He doesn't go to comment the stories that he likes, he doesn't greet
> anyone, he doesn't make any contribution.
> No, the first thing he does is criticizing.
Ad hominem attack. Moreover, shouldn't the author appreciate criticism
no matter who it comes from? Does my lack of contribution mean I'm
unworthy of commenting? Also criticizing does not equal complaining;
try sticking to one.
> That's you, I hope you can see my point.
Okay, your point is that I should not have posted my response even
though I don't like it. Don't post abuse comments in family friendly,
vica versa. True. However, this isn't just my opinion; I found the
amount of plot armor illogical, even more considering typical yukkuri
tropes.
Simply put; I hated this story for my own reason, and I ought to be
able to express my hate in a reasoned manner. Simply telling people to
shut the fuck up if they have different opinions, Anon Kun, is not
productive.
To sum up, I was hoping for a better discussion, to learn something,
but it appears you're not willing to listen or care about my point of
view.
Thus, I will show my listening, and I hope you can learn. I imagine
you will send another block of ignorance my way, but have no fear,
after this I will go back to lurking.
I'm not butthurt enough to argue with someone who simply wishes to be
'right' over knowing the truth.
@MET
Abe's "THE FICTIONAL RULES SAY OTHERWISE"; I never once said I was the
prophet of yukkuri wisdom. If I came across like that, my apologies,
but I still believe there are tropes that should not be subverted
without good reason.
Otherwise, I have no quarrel with what you say.
@Zzz...
I agree with your posts and I admit I should have reined in my hatred.
However much I personally despise this story, I don't and I can't
claim to say yukkuris are one way or another. If Yukkuris evolve to
be human-killers in the fictional context, then so be it; I'll haul my
ass out of this community crying all the way.
On a side note; to my knowledge, American pieces of yukkuri fiction
have had little impact on the japanese community. Most of our
'inventions' have not gone upstream (platinum badges, DOS in the
city), and there is a lot more that come downstream (like House Yu's,
and well everything).
Orthodoxy may change (or may even be an illusion), but until we're
either more integrated or separated from the japanese fandom, it is
hard to say.
tl;dr a certain someone won't listen to me, and I learned something
new today.