Google Groups no longer supports new Usenet posts or subscriptions. Historical content remains viewable.
Dismiss

Problem with WinRar

23 views
Skip to first unread message

cd69

unread,
Aug 19, 2004, 1:13:30 AM8/19/04
to
Hi there!I'm using WinRar 3.30 and lately,when trying to unrar multiple
files in order to regroup a main file,I get a lot of corrupt files
messages.The thing is,often,when I try again,it goes fine or I get a message
showing different files being corrupted than the ones that were supposedly
corrupted the first time.Any idea or solution to this issue.It seems to be
happening more often lately and it is annoying.Thanks for you help!


__SPooKY__

unread,
Aug 19, 2004, 1:43:00 AM8/19/04
to
if you are getting them off IRC, or using a downloader to get the multiple
files - that is sometimes the problem. When the download breaks and restarts,
the rar gets corrupt - you need to make sure you have a good rollback on IRC,
or a downloader that joins multiparts with a strong overlap

i had that problem onces, but the rollback helped lots.

Also, try using the 'Extract Files...' option in the right click menu. When
the window shows up asking for the destination, make sure you have the 'Keep
Broken Files' option checked.

If they are true 'rar' files, you can always just click on the first rar file,
and do a 'fix archive' option - rars have limited par facilities on them.

If it's a new problem you could also have corrupted your winrar file (if it's
keygen'd or evaluation, this happens lots) so get it again and see if it still
happens.

WinACE sometimes misses some of the errors and lets it work fine when you
extract i have found in the past

(i use winrar about 800 times a day, lol - but i'm on 3.30 presently too and
this all sounds very familiar)

cd69 wrote:

--
whiners are just annoying....
if YOU need posters to disclaim every possible post as to if it is genuine,
speculation, rumour, unresearched-bullshit, sarcasm, or clearly a joke, then
you really shouldn't be reading ANY posts....

The lynchmob do no service other than to promote how ignorant they themselves
are :-)

i think i'm supposed to make a cup of tea now - in my KETTLE !!

Message has been deleted

cd69

unread,
Aug 19, 2004, 9:47:43 AM8/19/04
to

"William" <wrhig...@hot-spam-mail.com> wrote in message
news:8o79i0hjhu8ia7j1l...@4ax.com...
> On Thu, 19 Aug 2004 05:13:30 GMT, "cd69" <cd...@NOSPAMshaw.ca> typed and
> posted
> to wpg.computers.help:
>
> If you are getting them from newsgroups and notice they have extra files
> with a
> PAR extension download these as well and google for PAR2 for the tool and
> FAQ's
> on it.
>
> Will
These files have been downloaded mostly from newsgroups and looked fine
after downloading them.I tried the PAR fix but I'm still getting error
messages,and it varies from time to time.Puzzling!


cd69

unread,
Aug 19, 2004, 9:52:01 AM8/19/04
to

"__SPooKY__" <spamandr00t...@seraphicator.com> wrote in message
news:D5XUc.4907$bJ2....@news1.mts.net...

> if you are getting them off IRC, or using a downloader to get the multiple
> files - that is sometimes the problem. When the download breaks and
> restarts, the rar gets corrupt - you need to make sure you have a good
> rollback on IRC, or a downloader that joins multiparts with a strong
> overlap
>
> i had that problem onces, but the rollback helped lots.
>
> Also, try using the 'Extract Files...' option in the right click menu.
> When the window shows up asking for the destination, make sure you have
> the 'Keep Broken Files' option checked.
>
> If they are true 'rar' files, you can always just click on the first rar
> file, and do a 'fix archive' option - rars have limited par facilities on
> them.
>
> If it's a new problem you could also have corrupted your winrar file (if
> it's keygen'd or evaluation, this happens lots) so get it again and see if
> it still happens.
>
> WinACE sometimes misses some of the errors and lets it work fine when you
> extract i have found in the past
>
> (i use winrar about 800 times a day, lol - but i'm on 3.30 presently too
> and this all sounds very familiar)
These files have been downloaded mostly from the newsgroups with Agent but
that is a recent problem.In the past,when I was getting corruption message,I
would usually fix the problem with the PAR files and redo the extraction
with no problem.This time,even after a PAR fix,I'm still getting error
messages,but not always for the original files that were supposedly
corrupted which is weird.I will try the solutions you talked about and
reinstall my WinRar.Thanks for the post!


cd69

unread,
Aug 19, 2004, 10:46:10 AM8/19/04
to

"cd69" <cd...@NOSPAMshaw.ca> wrote in message
news:5g2Vc.150557$J06.20318@pd7tw2no...
Well,I followed your instructions and reinstalled WinRar but got error
messages still.I was able to extract the completed file but I worry it can
create problem in the long run when burning the program and installing it
later.I hope I can find a way to resolve this as even Quick Par didn't help
fixing the supposedly corrupted files even if PAR said they were fixed.Oh
well!


__SPooKY__

unread,
Aug 19, 2004, 10:49:52 AM8/19/04
to
is it related to a single poster on the newsgroup too, or are other downloaders
having the same problems? it's possible that they are corrupt when they upload.

Some stuff that's multi-part rar'd together will show as a checksum error when
un-raring, but infact, are perfectly okay and useable, so with the 'Keep
Corrupted Rars' option checked, they still work fine.

Also, make sure it's not a yEnc posting being downloaded by a client that
doesn't support them, that causes many problems too

good luck


cd69 wrote:

>
> These files have been downloaded mostly from the newsgroups with Agent but
> that is a recent problem.In the past,when I was getting corruption message,I
> would usually fix the problem with the PAR files and redo the extraction
> with no problem.This time,even after a PAR fix,I'm still getting error
> messages,but not always for the original files that were supposedly
> corrupted which is weird.I will try the solutions you talked about and
> reinstall my WinRar.Thanks for the post!
>
>

--

__SPooKY__

unread,
Aug 19, 2004, 11:06:51 AM8/19/04
to

cd69 wrote:

>
> Well,I followed your instructions and reinstalled WinRar but got error
> messages still.I was able to extract the completed file but I worry it can
> create problem in the long run when burning the program and installing it
> later.I hope I can find a way to resolve this as even Quick Par didn't help
> fixing the supposedly corrupted files even if PAR said they were fixed.Oh
> well!
>
>

if it's a bin/cue, it won't burn if it is actually corrupt (assuming you use a
proper burner like CDR-Win or Nero - that's always a secondary check (which i
sometimes use when i get told every file is corrupt. Sometimes it is just the
packer has no idea how to use winrar really and it just says each file is
corrupt when they clearly aren't, lol

Message has been deleted

The Tech Guy

unread,
Aug 19, 2004, 4:12:08 PM8/19/04
to
winrar has/had an issue with files over 2gb, try WinZip
the next time u get this error, as i deleted many gb of data
before i found this out, it should be fixed in the newest version or in the
best

--
Jason

Adware Spyware Removal - Scan your PC Absolutely FREE
http://www.supportcave.com/

"Will" <wi...@crime.ctf.edu.remove> wrote in message
news:N85Vc.4997$bJ2....@news1.mts.net...
> -----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
> Hash: SHA1

> Any credible release will have a SFV File attached which will allow you
> to check the RAR file for corruption (ISO/DVD Images) or for RIP's you
> can easily verify the integrity of each zip. Do Not trust releases that
> are not in there original packaging.
>
> - --
> Do yourself a favor, don't use IE!
> www.mozilla.org/products/firefox/
>
> PGP is Preferable for Email, Public
> key available off PGP Key Server.
> GPG Key ID: 0x787AD6A9
> -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
> Version: GnuPG v1.2.5 (FreeBSD)
> Comment: Using GnuPG with Thunderbird - http://enigmail.mozdev.org
>
> iQCVAwUBQSTeqgx4IHh4etapAQLbugP/eug0hTcsx216ltdBP5bwp/m4gvVizu+K
> 3oHaHGHbSIl4xwYJ/cR1iEkof07Sv9Ky7aaSBvldoseNvZ5UghTI44W/cqMoiyqd
> v4sXObjTMGt2Yn3Mt6/6gp5cc/mCVDFWH216AEWD53Qws44NeUb9AwuhkTz2SxwI
> UR41LA0BmKE=
> =3sOf
> -----END PGP SIGNATURE-----


S.Heenan

unread,
Aug 19, 2004, 8:02:15 PM8/19/04
to

Check your RAM with Memtest. If the RAM passes, reseat or replace IDE ribbon
cables. If you're overclocking, back off to stock speeds.
http://www.memtest.org/


__SPooKY__

unread,
Aug 19, 2004, 8:53:39 PM8/19/04
to
lol

--

cd69

unread,
Aug 19, 2004, 10:07:33 PM8/19/04
to

"__SPooKY__" <spamandr00t...@seraphicator.com> wrote in message
news:j63Vc.4974$bJ2....@news1.mts.net...

> is it related to a single poster on the newsgroup too, or are other
> downloaders having the same problems? it's possible that they are corrupt
> when they upload.
> Some stuff that's multi-part rar'd together will show as a checksum error
> when un-raring, but infact, are perfectly okay and useable, so with the
> 'Keep Corrupted Rars' option checked, they still work fine.
>
> Also, make sure it's not a yEnc posting being downloaded by a client that
> doesn't support them, that causes many problems too
>
> good luck
I'm not sure if other people are having the same issue.I just realized this
issue when after getting a corruption message,I tried it again and it went
fine.Then later,I had another corruption message with another set of files
and when I tried again,I got again a corrupted message but for different
files so it got me thinking there was a problem,possibly with WinRar.But
even after reinstalling WinRar,I still get funny reporting so I don't know.I
never had this issue before a couple months ago so I will have to
experiment.Thanks for your input!


cd69

unread,
Aug 19, 2004, 10:09:01 PM8/19/04
to

"__SPooKY__" <spamandr00t...@seraphicator.com> wrote in message
news:em3Vc.4978$bJ2....@news1.mts.net...

>
>
> cd69 wrote:
>
>>
>> Well,I followed your instructions and reinstalled WinRar but got error
>> messages still.I was able to extract the completed file but I worry it
>> can create problem in the long run when burning the program and
>> installing it later.I hope I can find a way to resolve this as even Quick
>> Par didn't help fixing the supposedly corrupted files even if PAR said
>> they were fixed.Oh well!
>
> if it's a bin/cue, it won't burn if it is actually corrupt (assuming you
> use a proper burner like CDR-Win or Nero - that's always a secondary check
> (which i sometimes use when i get told every file is corrupt. Sometimes
> it is just the packer has no idea how to use winrar really and it just
> says each file is corrupt when they clearly aren't, lol
I usually use Nero,of course depending on the type of file I may use
something different.This was just a new type of problem for me.


cd69

unread,
Aug 19, 2004, 10:09:30 PM8/19/04
to
Good point!Thanks for the reply!

"Will" <wi...@crime.ctf.edu.remove> wrote in message
news:N85Vc.4997$bJ2....@news1.mts.net...
> -----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
> Hash: SHA1
>
> cd69 wrote:

cd69

unread,
Aug 19, 2004, 10:11:08 PM8/19/04
to

"The Tech Guy" <jf.nospam.r...@ao.com> wrote in message
news:tQ7Vc.5020$bJ2....@news1.mts.net...

> winrar has/had an issue with files over 2gb, try WinZip
> the next time u get this error, as i deleted many gb of data
> before i found this out, it should be fixed in the newest version or in
> the
> best
>
> --
> Jason
Well,this one doesn't apply for me as it was way under 2 GB and it is a
problem with the inconsistency of the reporting of the corrupted files that
is the issue for me,as I get a different report when trying to do the
unrar.Thanks for your reply!


cd69

unread,
Aug 19, 2004, 10:12:00 PM8/19/04
to

"S.Heenan" <she...@wahs.ac> wrote in message
news:bcbVc.155898$gE.85953@pd7tw3no...
You can be quite funny sometimes.That was a nice break from reality!Have a
good evening!


__SPooKY__

unread,
Aug 19, 2004, 10:27:52 PM8/19/04
to
one last thought...

if like some people you unrar 20 files at the same time, that can cause issues.
Most computers/HDD's can cope with it, but occasionally they interfer with
each other. I rarely use the winrar window myself and just use the shell
options from the rightclick in explorer, i find that to be the most effecient
way - and always make sure i only do one at a time, rather than multiple (also
cuts down on defragging problems in the longrun, lol)

i think everyone pretty much covered most of th eproblems. If the images still
work though, don't panic - if other people complain in the group you're getting
it from, it's most likely the poster f-in up (happens lots in alt.bin groups)


cd69 wrote:

--

cd69

unread,
Aug 19, 2004, 11:31:08 PM8/19/04
to
Thanks for your input!

"__SPooKY__" <spamandr00t...@seraphicator.com> wrote in message
news:GkdVc.35$MR2...@news1.mts.net...
Message has been deleted

__SPooKY__

unread,
Aug 20, 2004, 2:29:32 AM8/20/04
to
indeedy... 9gb ones recently for the dual layer ones
forgot i take ones that size myself, lol
and 3.3 pretty much is the latest 'bug free' version (if there is such a thing)


Will wrote:

> -----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
> Hash: SHA1
>

> The Tech Guy wrote:
> | winrar has/had an issue with files over 2gb, try WinZip
> | the next time u get this error, as i deleted many gb of data
> | before i found this out, it should be fixed in the newest version or
> | in the best
>

> Any recent version of WinRAR has np with 2 GB files (3+), 4.5GB DVD
> Images are packed with WinRAR and have been for years.


> - --
> Do yourself a favor, don't use IE!
> www.mozilla.org/products/firefox/
>
> PGP is Preferable for Email, Public
> key available off PGP Key Server.
> GPG Key ID: 0x787AD6A9
> -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
> Version: GnuPG v1.2.5 (FreeBSD)
> Comment: Using GnuPG with Thunderbird - http://enigmail.mozdev.org
>

> iQCVAwUBQSWZFgx4IHh4etapAQJl4wQAmU19MLJ5AW+gzZLBVljFmlIMsUEWLFJk
> gMVleTOpNr36n06i8E8AkywC9Nl1rrePwR1by3d72R2cBCBoVrKFEw+tSGzcxjh8
> opaEIjkwNfWE4ZmqdppWNT5X/pdkfdPBpgnIGJTNp1YNQlx7Tuf5hkuotZrR/H7Y
> TMUsAJX3EwU=
> =VWjJ
> -----END PGP SIGNATURE-----

S.Heenan

unread,
Aug 20, 2004, 5:42:46 AM8/20/04
to

If you find my post funny, you must know the cause of file corruption. Care
to share ?

__SPooKY__

unread,
Aug 20, 2004, 8:26:55 AM8/20/04
to
i also found it amusing
he may not know the cause of his particular pre-rar'd files corruption, but it
has nothing to do with his memory, ribbons or overclocking - he knows that
much, lol


S.Heenan wrote:

--

cd69

unread,
Aug 20, 2004, 2:33:17 PM8/20/04
to
Exactly,but her post was still appreciated as it brought a smile to my
face.I'm easy!

"__SPooKY__" <spamandr00t...@seraphicator.com> wrote in message
news:g6mVc.332$MR2....@news1.mts.net...

den.hut...@gmail.com

unread,
Dec 29, 2013, 8:05:55 PM12/29/13
to
Solve given trouble by using winrar repair brought to you by Recovery Toolbox for RAR

Know more from http://www.winrarrepair.recoverytoolbox.com/
0 new messages