RE: Re: RE: [3rd msg] Organizing session A1 @ Korea-EU Workshop

[이병준]

Dear Dr. Barani,

Thanks a lot for the kind clarification.  On the Korean side, three of the proposed speeches - (1), (2) and (4) shown below - represent the 

on-going projects, while the other two - (3) and (5) - are in the making.  (1) and (2) also represent two different topics from the same project,

so we can adjust the presentation time and the following interaction between respective EU and Korean projects accordingly.

  

(1) ID-based Communication (Dr. HeeYoung Chung, ETRI)

(2) A Trustworthy Communication Framework based on Insulated Domains (Dr. Woojik Chun, ETRI)

(3) NDN routing (Prof. Ted Kwon, Seoul National University)  
(4) Network-aware video services with MPEG DASH and MMT over ICN  (Prof. Dukyoung Suh, Kyunghee University) 

(5) Modeling ICN performance for feasibility and engineering insight (Prof Yung Yi, KAIST and Byoung-Joon Lee, Samsung)

 

I hope your concerns are addressed by the above explanation.

Best regards,

BJ

------- Original Message -------

Sender : Bernard...@ec.europa.eu<Bernard...@ec.europa.eu>

Date : 2013-08-20 16:37 (GMT+09:00)

Title : RE: Re: RE: [3rd msg] Organizing session A1 @ Korea-EU Workshop

 

Dear BJ,

As explained to the Korean colleagues during the VC, we are trying to accommodate your request, i.e to shift the focus of session A1  from SDN/NFV towards ICN/NDN and content routing types of issues. I am still working on it and I guess that at this  stage, 3 speakers on our side are fully confirmed. I do not want to comment on the Korean selection, as it is your full prerogative to select the speakers, but we are trying to match your speeches. There are though two issues thatr may be worth clarifying:

- during our early exchanges with the Korean delegation (MSIP, ETRI representatives) it was indicated that the workshop would be useful to identify "twinning projects". This implies that projects running in Europe could interface and liaise more closely with projects running in Korea. On this basis, we have identified speakers as representatives of European projects (these projects are indicated in the draft programme circulated by Carlos with the VC minutes). On Korean side, it seems that speakers would present papers, but not really projects. Can you let us know if the intended Korean speeches are in fact related to running projects in Korea? This would ease later contacts between our respective constituencies;

- At the previous VC, it was indicated that the target number of speakers per session would be in the order of 4. 5 speakers may be a bit challenging to accommodate, so we'll have to find a solution to manage the time and the interactions.

Kind regards,

Bernard

*********************************************************
Mr Bernard Barani
Deputy Head of Unit
European Commission DG CONNECT
Unit E1, Network Technologies
********************************************

From: 이병준 [mailto:bj33...@samsung.com]
Sent: Tuesday, August 20, 2013 3:54 AM
To: BARANI Bernard (CNECT); works...@googlegroups.com
Cc: OLIVEIRA Carlos (CNECT)
Subject: Fwd: Re: RE: [3rd msg] Organizing session A1 @ Korea-EU Workshop

 

Dear Dr. Barani,

 

According to the 8/13 video call meeting minutes, it looks the following list of proposed topics and speakers from Korea

side is still valid.  Your further comments and topic/speaker proposal would greatly be appreciated.

 

(1) ID-based Communication (Dr. HeeYoung Chung, ETRI)

(2) A Trustworthy Communication Framework based on Insulated Domains (Dr. Woojik Chun, ETRI)

(3) NDN routing (Prof. Ted Kwon, Seoul National University)  
(4) Network-aware video services with MPEG DASH and MMT over ICN  (Prof. Dukyoung Suh, Kyunghee University) 

(5) Modeling ICN performance for feasibility and engineering insight (Prof Yung Yi, KAIST and Byoung-Joon Lee, Samsung)

 

Best regards,

BJ 

PS: Please, you can call me BJ.

 

------- Original Message -------

Sender : 이병준<bj33...@samsung.com> 전문연구원/Communication & Networking그룹(기술원)/삼성전자

Date : 2013-08-20 08:24 (GMT+09:00)

Title : Re: RE: [3rd msg] Organizing session A1 @ Korea-EU Workshop

 

Dear Dr. Barani,

 

My sincere apology for missing your earlier email reply.

I will take a look and follow up with the video-conference results.

 

With best regards,

BJ

 

------- Original Message -------

Sender : Bernard...@ec.europa.eu<Bernard...@ec.europa.eu>

Date : 2013-08-19 17:04 (GMT+09:00)

Title : RE: [3rd msg] Organizing session A1 @ Korea-EU Workshop

Dear Dr Lee,

 

In fact, I replied to your mail on 9 august, see attached. We have discussed the issue further at the last video conference with your Korean colleagues, and explained that we are trying to accommodate your request. The latest version of the tentative agenda is attached, minutes of the video conference will be circulated by my colleague Carlos in copy.

 

Best regards,

 

Bernard

 

 

 

From: 이병준 [mailto:bj33...@samsung.com]
Sent: Monday, August 19, 2013 2:17 AM
To: BARANI Bernard (CNECT)
Cc: dy...@cnu.kr
Subject: Fwd: [3rd msg] Organizing session A1 @ Korea-EU Workshop

 

Dear Dr. Barani,

I hope you had a good vacation.  Since I am afraid you haven't seen my previous emails, I am

resending the last one.

I look forward to hearing from you at your earliest convenience.

With best regards,

BJ 

 

------- Original Message -------

Sender : 이병준<bj33...@samsung.com> 전문연구원/Communication & Networking그룹(기술원)/삼성전자

Date : 2013-08-07 13:49 (GMT+09:00)

Title : [3rd msg] Organizing session A1 @ Korea-EU Workshop

 

Dear Dr. Barani,

 

Please find below a revised list of candidate speakers for our session A1.

 

   (1) ID-based Communication (Dr. HeeYoung Chung, ETRI)

   (2) A Trustworthy Communication Framework based on Insulated Domains (Dr. Woojik Chun, ETRI)

   (3) NDN routing (Prof. Ted Kwon, Seoul National University) 
  (4) Network-aware video services with  MPEG DASH and MMT over ICN  (Prof. Dukyoung Suh, Kyunghee University) 

   (5) Modeling ICN performance for feasibility and engineering insight (Prof Yung Yi, KAIST and Byoung-Joon Lee, Samsung)

I look forward to hearing from you at your earliest convenience.

With best regards,

 

Byoung-Joon (BJ) Lee

Samsung Electronics

 

------- Original Message -------

Sender : 이병준<bj33...@samsung.com> 전문연구원/Communication & Networking그룹(기술원)/삼성전자

Date : 2013-08-02 18:59 (GMT+09:00)

Title : [2nd msg] Organizing session A1 @ Korea-EU Workshop

 

Dear Dr. Barani,

Since you are on vacation for quite some time, I decided to send you a tentative list of candidate speakers from Korea

side for the session A1.  Please note that this list assumes your accepting the change of the discussion topic for the

session A1, i.e., focused on the "generic architecture including ICN issues"

 

   (1) ID-based Communication (Dr. HeeYoung Chung, ETRI)

   (2) Forget OSI: Network Now Has Two Layers - Application and Connection Layer (Prof. Sueng Park, Yonsei U) TBD

   (3) NDN routing (Prof. Ted Kwon, Seoul National University)

   (3) Modeling ICN performance for feasibility and engineering insight (Prof Yung Yi, KAIST and BJ Lee, Samsung)

 

I hope you have a great vacatoin, and look forward to hearing from you soon

With best regards,

Byoung-Joon (BJ) Lee

Samsung Electronics, Advanced Institute of Technology

 

------- Original Message -------

Sender : 이병준<bj33...@samsung.com> 전문연구원/Communication & Networking그룹(기술원)/삼성전자

Date : 2013-07-30 11:33 (GMT+09:00)

Title : Organizing session A1 @ Korea-EU Workshop

 

Dear Dr. Barani,

 

I am your counterpart for the session A1. It is a great honor to work with you.

 

Before we start discussing the agenda and speaker selection for session A1, I would like to propose

reorganization of the session A topics first. I think it would help streamline the discussion flow of the

workshop, by focusing the topic of session A1 on the generic architecture issues including ICN, while

moving the virtualization and SDN issues to session A2 as follows.

 

    A1: Virtualization, ICN     -->  A1: Architecture (including ICN)

    A2: SDN/Optical/(NFV)   -->  A2: SDN (incl. NFV/Optical)

    A3: Converged/Integrated NW and Mgmt     -->    A3: FI for 5G (incl. access n/w)

 

This proposal also reflects the majority opinion of the Korean organizers.

I look forward to hearing your opinion.

 

With best regards,

Byoung-Joon (BJ) Lee

Samsung Electronics, Advanced Institute of Technology

 

 

-------Original Message--------
 Sent: <Bernard...@ec.europa.eu>
 Date: Fri, 9 Aug 2013 15:17:58 +0000
 Subject: RE: [3rd msg] Organizing session A1 @ Korea-EU Workshop

<!--[if mso 9]--> <!--[endif]-->

Dear Dr Lee,

Many thanks for your kind messages and for your proposal. Please, also accept my apologies for this delayed feedback due to the vacation period.

I can confirm that ICN, content routing technologies and architectures are topics of interest in Europe, though this is a controversial issue. It is not completely easy for me to fully accommodate your request, because ICN, CCN, DAN, NDN… stuff was not originally emphasized as a topic for joint activity. As a matter of fact, our June discussion with the Korean delegation identified the following topics as priorities, with significant emphasis on NFV/SDN:

<!--[if !supportLists]-->i)                    <!--[endif]-->Next gen unified access (Including Optical)

<!--[if !supportLists]-->ii)                   <!--[endif]-->Smart Node, NFV, SDN Core Tech. & Inter SDN

<!--[if !supportLists]-->iii)                 <!--[endif]-->IoT (including Networked-CPS, U-City)

<!--[if !supportLists]-->iv)                 <!--[endif]-->5G System (Including Radio technology, Unified Access, Management System)

<!--[if !supportLists]-->v)                  <!--[endif]-->Clouds

Therefore, if we go along your proposal, we have to find a full new set of speakers and related projects. I believe that your approach would also need to redimension stream A2, because handling SDN, NFV and the optical intercarrier application of SDN in the same session would lead to a very crowded session. Also, there are some discussion to implement ICN with NFV, so the topics are not fully uncorrelated.

I will try to find a solution, but it will require some imagination. Maybe we need to go for a shorter A1 stream, and larger A2 one.

I guess we'll discuss this at the next video conference,

Best regards,

 

 

From: 이병준 [mailto:bj33...@samsung.com]
Sent: Wednesday, August 07, 2013 6:49 AM
To: BARANI Bernard (CNECT)
Cc: dy...@cnu.kr
Subject: [3rd msg] Organizing session A1 @ Korea-EU Workshop

 

Dear Dr. Barani,

 

Please find below a revised list of candidate speakers for our session A1.

 

   (1) ID-based Communication (Dr. HeeYoung Chung, ETRI)

   (2) A Trustworthy Communication Framework based on Insulated Domains (Dr. Woojik Chun, ETRI)

   (3) NDN routing (Prof. Ted Kwon, Seoul National University) 
  (4) Network-aware video services with  MPEG DASH and MMT over ICN  (Prof. Dukyoung Suh, Kyunghee University) 

   (5) Modeling ICN performance for feasibility and engineering insight (Prof Yung Yi, KAIST and Byoung-Joon Lee, Samsung)

I look forward to hearing from you at your earliest convenience.

With best regards,

 

Byoung-Joon (BJ) Lee

Samsung Electronics

 

------- Original Message -------

Sender : 이병준<bj33...@samsung.com> 전문연구원/Communication & Networking그룹(기술원)/삼성전자

Date : 2013-08-02 18:59 (GMT+09:00)

Title : [2nd msg] Organizing session A1 @ Korea-EU Workshop

 

Dear Dr. Barani,

Since you are on vacation for quite some time, I decided to send you a tentative list of candidate speakers from Korea

side for the session A1.  Please note that this list assumes your accepting the change of the discussion topic for the

session A1, i.e., focused on the "generic architecture including ICN issues"

 

   (1) ID-based Communication (Dr. HeeYoung Chung, ETRI)

   (2) Forget OSI: Network Now Has Two Layers - Application and Connection Layer (Prof. Sueng Park, Yonsei U) TBD

   (3) NDN routing (Prof. Ted Kwon, Seoul National University)

   (3) Modeling ICN performance for feasibility and engineering insight (Prof Yung Yi, KAIST and BJ Lee, Samsung)

 

I hope you have a great vacatoin, and look forward to hearing from you soon

With best regards,

Byoung-Joon (BJ) Lee

Samsung Electronics, Advanced Institute of Technology

 

------- Original Message -------

Sender : 이병준<bj33...@samsung.com> 전문연구원/Communication & Networking그룹(기술원)/삼성전자

Date : 2013-07-30 11:33 (GMT+09:00)

Title : Organizing session A1 @ Korea-EU Workshop

 

Dear Dr. Barani,

 

I am your counterpart for the session A1. It is a great honor to work with you.

 

Before we start discussing the agenda and speaker selection for session A1, I would like to propose

reorganization of the session A topics first. I think it would help streamline the discussion flow of the

workshop, by focusing the topic of session A1 on the generic architecture issues including ICN, while

moving the virtualization and SDN issues to session A2 as follows.

 

    A1: Virtualization, ICN     -->  A1: Architecture (including ICN)

    A2: SDN/Optical/(NFV)   -->  A2: SDN (incl. NFV/Optical)

    A3: Converged/Integrated NW and Mgmt     -->    A3: FI for 5G (incl. access n/w)

 

This proposal also reflects the majority opinion of the Korean organizers.

I look forward to hearing your opinion.

 

With best regards,

Byoung-Joon (BJ) Lee

Samsung Electronics, Advanced Institute of Technology