Flattening the World or Falling Flat?
http://www.epw.in/editorials/flattening-world-or-falling-flat.htmlThe rhetoric during the boom years was about “moving up the value chain”
from simple outsourcing, but, sadly, this has remained a mere
aspiration. At the lower end, automation is now doing much of the work
of the call-centre employees, and a lot cheaper. But more importantly,
the large western software services transnational corporations (TNCs)
like IBM, Capgemini, Accenture and EDS have rapidly moved in to
successfully emulate the cost-arbitrage business model pioneered by TCS,
Infosys, Wipro and HCL Technologies. What the Indian IT-ITeS industry
is witnessing is the advance of the large software services TNCs into
the market niches where the Indian majors have established themselves
based on the cost-arbitrage business model. IBM’s acquisition some years
ago of Daksh, one of India’s notable BPO providers, comes to mind. IBM
has even been able to bag a major domestic deal with India’s largest
telecommunications company, Bharti, awarding the firm a contract to run
its IT services and a lot of its business processes.
...
Presently, the India’s IT majors seem to be focusing on foreign
direct investment abroad in the form of acquisitions in the major export
markets and the setting up of delivery centres in other emerging
markets. Government policy also perhaps needs to provide greater
incentives to make inroads into export markets other than the Triad.
Additionally, given the cost advantage that the Indian majors have,
domestic demand, including government procurement, needs to be given
greater weight at this point in time when the markets of the Triad are
faltering.
Will the Indian IT-ITeS industry with its significant export
orientation – spearheaded, until now, by nationally-owned firms – move
up the value chain or will it remain at the lower end of the market and
emerge as the back office of the world through the agency of the
captives?