The Way of the Samurai
1 view
Skip to first unread message
Mr. Gill
Oct 22, 2009, 9:04:05 AM10/22/09
to WMHS World History
*** Please remember to ONLY respond to this post by clicking "Reply",
NOT "Reply to author" or else I won't get your post... Also, make sure
you don't start a new topic/post***
http://web.archive.org/web/20001205024800/http://www.humanities.ccny.cuny.edu/history/reader/ASAM.htm
Read the following primary source and give your personal reponse to
the excerpt. Use the following questions to help you with your
response:
1.) How does a samurai define his (yes, female samurai were not
permissible) priorities?
2.) What does this tell you about life as a samurai?
3.) How is this different from the military dogma (belief system) of
Western societies?
NOT "Reply to author" or else I won't get your post... Also, make sure
you don't start a new topic/post***
http://web.archive.org/web/20001205024800/http://www.humanities.ccny.cuny.edu/history/reader/ASAM.htm
Read the following primary source and give your personal reponse to
the excerpt. Use the following questions to help you with your
response:
1.) How does a samurai define his (yes, female samurai were not
permissible) priorities?
2.) What does this tell you about life as a samurai?
3.) How is this different from the military dogma (belief system) of
Western societies?
Samantha DiChiara
Oct 25, 2009, 2:29:17 PM10/25/09
to WMHS World History
A samurai defines his priorities by knowing what death is and
accepting it. This particular samurai says that if one does not
accept this and dies, it will not even be worth it. He says you have
to live each day separately and know that death is worth it. This is
because otherwise there is no point in being a samurai. In other
words, if you don’t accept that death is inevitable, then you cannot
be live up to your potential as a samurai and when you die your life
will be meaningless. Once you accept this you need to focus on three
things: intelligence, courage, and humanity. Focus in intelligence
because you need to talk to other people in order to gain knowledge on
your own. Also, samurais need courage because when facing dangerous
tasks they cannot think of the risks they are taking. They just have
to do what is asked of them. Also, humanity is important because
samurais need to remember that they are putting themselves in danger
for the sake of other people’s wellbeing. This tells me that life as
a samurai is not easy. I know after reading this that even if I
wasn’t a girl I couldn’t handle this job. They take it very seriously
and they have to come to terms with some difficult material. This is
different from Western society because the samurais seem to embrace
death as another part of life but in America everyone is so afraid of
dying, sometimes even if it means they are dying so that someone else
can live. It does relate to the military in Western society as well
though because the military here is also very strict and the soldiers
do have the courage to fight for their country. However it is still
different because the samurais recognize that it is their job to fight
and they are committed to it for life.
On Oct 22, 9:04 am, "Mr. Gill" <ryanpg...@gmail.com> wrote:
> *** Please remember to ONLY respond to this post by clicking "Reply",
> NOT "Reply to author" or else I won't get your post... Also, make sure
> you don't start a new topic/post***
>
paige
Oct 25, 2009, 2:33:29 PM10/25/09
to WMHS World History
A samurai defines his prioities by the way of life that he is suppose
to live and the sarifices he makes. You can choose life or death, but
if you choose life, that is "cowardice" to the samurain people. It'
cowardice because everyone wants to live but if you don't gain
anything from living then what is the point? If you choose death,
then you sacrifice yourself to the people of your religion and it's
"fanaticism" to the samurain people. This tells me that the samurai
people don't really have choices they can make because in their
religion like all religions you want to please your gods. In order to
please your gods you have to make sacrifices in order to do so. That
means you choose death over life because it's the right way to show
that one cares and devotes himself to the samurain religion. This is
different than the military dogma because you have choices you can
make and your god will respect your choice. Also you don't believe in
one god, you can believe and follow whatever path you choose. Your
dog won't be angry or anything because you have choices you can make.
to live and the sarifices he makes. You can choose life or death, but
if you choose life, that is "cowardice" to the samurain people. It'
cowardice because everyone wants to live but if you don't gain
anything from living then what is the point? If you choose death,
then you sacrifice yourself to the people of your religion and it's
"fanaticism" to the samurain people. This tells me that the samurai
people don't really have choices they can make because in their
religion like all religions you want to please your gods. In order to
please your gods you have to make sacrifices in order to do so. That
means you choose death over life because it's the right way to show
that one cares and devotes himself to the samurain religion. This is
different than the military dogma because you have choices you can
make and your god will respect your choice. Also you don't believe in
one god, you can believe and follow whatever path you choose. Your
dog won't be angry or anything because you have choices you can make.
On Oct 22, 9:04 am, "Mr. Gill" <ryanpg...@gmail.com> wrote:
> *** Please remember to ONLY respond to this post by clicking "Reply",
> NOT "Reply to author" or else I won't get your post... Also, make sure
> you don't start a new topic/post***
>
> http://web.archive.org/web/20001205024800/http://www.humanities.ccny....
> NOT "Reply to author" or else I won't get your post... Also, make sure
> you don't start a new topic/post***
>
Kerriann Macdonald
Oct 25, 2009, 3:10:31 PM10/25/09
to WMHS World History
A samurai defines his priorities based off of courage, intelligence,
and humanity. This tells me that the life of the samurai was never a
selfish one. The samurai used these three characterisitcs in their
daily lives, and each action was used to help others throughout
society. Intelligence was used to communicate with others to gain
wisdom, humanity was used to put others before themselves, and courage
was used to do the right thing without worrying about the
consequences, even if it possibly meant being killed. The samurai's
way of life is different from the belief system of Western societies
because many Western societies did not follow the ways of the samurai.
They believed more in taking care of themselves than in taking care of
others in the community. While the samurai appear to have lived in an
unselfish way of life, Western societies lived in quite the opposite.
In history, it is rarely heard of Western socities being based off of
such ideas as courage or humanity. If they were, humanity and courage
were defined differently than how the samurai defined them. If Western
societies were based off of the ideas of the samurai, then maybe
Western societies could have lived more peacefully because then their
ideas would be based more off of taking care of one another, instead
of constantly fighting over religion or land for selfish reasons.
Although it is human nature to be selfish, it is obvious from the
samurai that they were able to put aside selfishness, instead of
constantly living in it like Western societies did.
and humanity. This tells me that the life of the samurai was never a
selfish one. The samurai used these three characterisitcs in their
daily lives, and each action was used to help others throughout
society. Intelligence was used to communicate with others to gain
wisdom, humanity was used to put others before themselves, and courage
was used to do the right thing without worrying about the
consequences, even if it possibly meant being killed. The samurai's
way of life is different from the belief system of Western societies
because many Western societies did not follow the ways of the samurai.
They believed more in taking care of themselves than in taking care of
others in the community. While the samurai appear to have lived in an
unselfish way of life, Western societies lived in quite the opposite.
In history, it is rarely heard of Western socities being based off of
such ideas as courage or humanity. If they were, humanity and courage
were defined differently than how the samurai defined them. If Western
societies were based off of the ideas of the samurai, then maybe
Western societies could have lived more peacefully because then their
ideas would be based more off of taking care of one another, instead
of constantly fighting over religion or land for selfish reasons.
Although it is human nature to be selfish, it is obvious from the
samurai that they were able to put aside selfishness, instead of
constantly living in it like Western societies did.
> *** Please remember to ONLY respond to this post by clicking "Reply",
> NOT "Reply to author" or else I won't get your post... Also, make sure
> you don't start a new topic/post***
>
> http://web.archive.org/web/20001205024800/http://www.humanities.ccny....
> NOT "Reply to author" or else I won't get your post... Also, make sure
> you don't start a new topic/post***
>
Aline Chaprazian
Oct 25, 2009, 7:51:35 PM10/25/09
to WMHS World History
A samurai defines his priorities by many different things, all leading
up to the way man holds his place with his master. There are many
specific priorities a samurai must carry out, in order to conceive a
better life. Those priorities range from loyalty, intelligence,
courage, humanity, and devotion. When you think about a life of a
samurai, I personally thought they are savage beast all out for
themselves and just killing others, maybe they still are...but there's
more to it. It's all about loyalty with oneself and his master. It's
about faith in one another. All these priorities are made to protect
each other under a loyal circumstance. And if these loyalties are not
followed through, then it is bad for that one person. Death is another
thing that comes into place, it is said that if one chooses to deal
with death in the beginning rather than in the end, it will be better
of that samurai. Because death should not stop a samurai from
completing his duty. It definitely is a hard sacrificial life for a
samurai, but also being a samurai seems honorable. This is way
different from the military dogma of the Western societies. For
Western societies it's every man for himself. I guess i could say the
system is more selfish than the samurai's way. Western societies don't
necessarily have this rule of priorities for their men. People may
carry them out on their own naturally, but with the samurai's this is
a way of life you are suppose to follow these set priorities.
up to the way man holds his place with his master. There are many
specific priorities a samurai must carry out, in order to conceive a
better life. Those priorities range from loyalty, intelligence,
courage, humanity, and devotion. When you think about a life of a
samurai, I personally thought they are savage beast all out for
themselves and just killing others, maybe they still are...but there's
more to it. It's all about loyalty with oneself and his master. It's
about faith in one another. All these priorities are made to protect
each other under a loyal circumstance. And if these loyalties are not
followed through, then it is bad for that one person. Death is another
thing that comes into place, it is said that if one chooses to deal
with death in the beginning rather than in the end, it will be better
of that samurai. Because death should not stop a samurai from
completing his duty. It definitely is a hard sacrificial life for a
samurai, but also being a samurai seems honorable. This is way
different from the military dogma of the Western societies. For
Western societies it's every man for himself. I guess i could say the
system is more selfish than the samurai's way. Western societies don't
necessarily have this rule of priorities for their men. People may
carry them out on their own naturally, but with the samurai's this is
a way of life you are suppose to follow these set priorities.
> *** Please remember to ONLY respond to this post by clicking "Reply",
> NOT "Reply to author" or else I won't get your post... Also, make sure
> you don't start a new topic/post***
>
> http://web.archive.org/web/20001205024800/http://www.humanities.ccny....
> NOT "Reply to author" or else I won't get your post... Also, make sure
> you don't start a new topic/post***
>
jennifer booker
Oct 25, 2009, 8:47:20 PM10/25/09
to WMHS World History
Samurai's priorities lie soley in devoting ones' sole to his master.
For a samurais whole life, he will live as if his body is already dead
unless he accomplishes his aim of pleasing his god. In order to
accomplish his goals and make a better life for himself, a samurai
must live of the basis of intelligence, humanity, and courage.
Samurais are involved not only in their own lives, but in the lives of
others as well. Samurais listen to others and gain wisdom from this
knowledge. They realize they have to put their lives in danger for the
sake of others, and never think twice about it. A samurai's courage is
what leads them through life. When pushing themselves to accomplish
the task at hand, they never think about what horrible consequences
might occur. Samurai's are unselfish, willing and honorable. Life as a
samurai is no easy task, but for them it seems as if they were raised
knowing how they must live and never thought twice about it. Samurai's
lived everyday wanting to please their god. This tells me that a
samurai's life was based on sacrafice, as well. Samurai’s are
different from those of Western civilations because of their views on
death. A samurai’s philosophy stated that if they were going to live
without accomplishing their aim, what would be the point of living?
They were put on life to accomplish a goal. If that accomplishment was
not met, life would be useless and it was okay for them to consider
death in this circumstance. On the other hand, Western belief systems
were afraid of dying and lived off ofe belief systems of religion and
selfishness, in my opinion. They wanted to live, no matter what.
Samurais were committed and chose to live in a different aspect than
most Western civiliations.
For a samurais whole life, he will live as if his body is already dead
unless he accomplishes his aim of pleasing his god. In order to
accomplish his goals and make a better life for himself, a samurai
must live of the basis of intelligence, humanity, and courage.
Samurais are involved not only in their own lives, but in the lives of
others as well. Samurais listen to others and gain wisdom from this
knowledge. They realize they have to put their lives in danger for the
sake of others, and never think twice about it. A samurai's courage is
what leads them through life. When pushing themselves to accomplish
the task at hand, they never think about what horrible consequences
might occur. Samurai's are unselfish, willing and honorable. Life as a
samurai is no easy task, but for them it seems as if they were raised
knowing how they must live and never thought twice about it. Samurai's
lived everyday wanting to please their god. This tells me that a
samurai's life was based on sacrafice, as well. Samurai’s are
different from those of Western civilations because of their views on
death. A samurai’s philosophy stated that if they were going to live
without accomplishing their aim, what would be the point of living?
They were put on life to accomplish a goal. If that accomplishment was
not met, life would be useless and it was okay for them to consider
death in this circumstance. On the other hand, Western belief systems
were afraid of dying and lived off ofe belief systems of religion and
selfishness, in my opinion. They wanted to live, no matter what.
Samurais were committed and chose to live in a different aspect than
most Western civiliations.
jennifer booker
Oct 25, 2009, 8:58:08 PM10/25/09
to WMHS World History
didn't mean to send that first one!
Samurai's priorities lie solely in devoting ones' sole to his master.
For a samurai’s whole life, he will live as if his body is already
dead,
different from those of Western civilizations because of their views
Samurai's priorities lie solely in devoting ones' sole to his master.
For a samurai’s whole life, he will live as if his body is already
dead,
unless he accomplishes his aim of pleasing his god. In order to
accomplish his goals and make a better life for himself, a samurai
must live of the basis of intelligence, humanity, and courage.
Samurais are involved not only in their own lives, but in the lives
of
others as well. Samurais listen to others and gain wisdom from this
knowledge. They realize they have to put their lives in danger for
the
sake of others, and never think twice about it. A samurai's courage
is
what leads them through life. When pushing themselves to accomplish
the task at hand, they never think about what horrible consequences
might occur. Samurai's are unselfish, willing and honorable. Life as
a
samurai is no easy task, but for them it seems as if they were raised
knowing how they must live and never thought twice about it.
Samurai's
lived everyday wanting to please their god. This tells me that a
samurai's life was based on sacrifice, as well. Samurai’s are
accomplish his goals and make a better life for himself, a samurai
must live of the basis of intelligence, humanity, and courage.
Samurais are involved not only in their own lives, but in the lives
of
others as well. Samurais listen to others and gain wisdom from this
knowledge. They realize they have to put their lives in danger for
the
sake of others, and never think twice about it. A samurai's courage
is
what leads them through life. When pushing themselves to accomplish
the task at hand, they never think about what horrible consequences
might occur. Samurai's are unselfish, willing and honorable. Life as
a
samurai is no easy task, but for them it seems as if they were raised
knowing how they must live and never thought twice about it.
Samurai's
lived everyday wanting to please their god. This tells me that a
different from those of Western civilizations because of their views
on
death. A samurai’s philosophy stated that if they were going to live
without accomplishing their aim, what would be the point of living?
They were put on earth to accomplish a goal. If that accomplishment
death. A samurai’s philosophy stated that if they were going to live
without accomplishing their aim, what would be the point of living?
was
not met, life would be useless and it was okay for them to consider
death in this circumstance. On the other hand, Western belief systems
were afraid of dying and lived off the belief systems of religion and
not met, life would be useless and it was okay for them to consider
death in this circumstance. On the other hand, Western belief systems
selfishness, in my opinion. They wanted to live, no matter what.
Samurais were committed and chose to live in a different aspect than
most Western civilizations.Samurais were committed and chose to live in a different aspect than
melissa mogauro
Oct 25, 2009, 9:06:50 PM10/25/09
to WMHS World History
A samurai defines his priorities by what they personally think is
morally right, which all leads up to a samurai looking to their master
for advice. Also, if a samurai feels what they do is right from each
passing day, they are truly happy as long as they live like they are
already dead. What this means is as long as they aren't scared to take
risks, than a samurai's life is successful. When having their lives
abide by the logic of thinking that they are already dead, a samurai
lives their life by intelligence and doing something worthwhile for
others. With this in mind, it is clear that even though Samurai's are
thought of as bad people they really aren't. Samurai's are more
extreme people which makes them scary in society. However, if they
live their lives to the fullest then they can be rolemodels for
others. The most significant part of living life as a samurai is using
humanity. This is important because they love to do things for others
regardless of the consequences. Life as a samurai must be hard since
they think solely of others around them which is a hard task to
undertake. With samurai's living their life based on the idea that if
they don't do things for others than there is no point in living, they
are extremely different then Western societies. In western societies
they were very scared at the idea of dying . Also, Western Societies
didn't feel the need to help others. These socities felt that they
only needed to take care of themselves, which is what they based their
lives on. This is the polar opposite from samurai's since they lived
their lives on helping others.
Carlislle Lima
Oct 25, 2009, 9:26:07 PM10/25/09
to WMHS World History
a samurai's priorities were to be smart, holy to people, devote his
body and soul to his leader and to not fear death. Samurai must have
been great warriors that accomplished any task's given to them by
their leader's even if it would cost them their lives they would do
the task. I think a samurai must have had an adventuras life they
probably went all over japan and beyond if they needed to finish a
job. There must have bin alot of action they would get to take on
enemy's with no fear. They probably stayed away from there family's
alot since they must have done alot of missions, and it was most
lickly physicaly tiring. Samurai probably did not live to be old
unless they were lucky enough not to die in battle. Samurai most
lickly enjoined a more lexturios life then japanese civilians and they
probably had more authority. Samurai are not afraid of death while
most Western society's are and our military works similar and
differently from the samurai. US military is concerned with keeping
our troops safe and most millitary personnel are concerned with death,
while the samurai were not worried about dieing. The US millitary are
trainned to be brave devoted to his country and smart, I do not think
that most US millitary personnel are willingly to give his or her life
for the US some im sure are, most I think are brave though being brave
does not mean you are willing to die.
body and soul to his leader and to not fear death. Samurai must have
been great warriors that accomplished any task's given to them by
their leader's even if it would cost them their lives they would do
the task. I think a samurai must have had an adventuras life they
probably went all over japan and beyond if they needed to finish a
job. There must have bin alot of action they would get to take on
enemy's with no fear. They probably stayed away from there family's
alot since they must have done alot of missions, and it was most
lickly physicaly tiring. Samurai probably did not live to be old
unless they were lucky enough not to die in battle. Samurai most
lickly enjoined a more lexturios life then japanese civilians and they
probably had more authority. Samurai are not afraid of death while
most Western society's are and our military works similar and
differently from the samurai. US military is concerned with keeping
our troops safe and most millitary personnel are concerned with death,
while the samurai were not worried about dieing. The US millitary are
trainned to be brave devoted to his country and smart, I do not think
that most US millitary personnel are willingly to give his or her life
for the US some im sure are, most I think are brave though being brave
does not mean you are willing to die.
Rachel Poli
Oct 26, 2009, 3:46:58 PM10/26/09
to WMHS World History
A samurai defines his priorities by intelligence, courage, and
humanity. If a samurai did not do this, then they weren't considered
a good samurai or not a samurai at all. They also had to have loyalty
to the lord and the retainer. Life as a samurai seemed to be a
difficult life, however, that was what they were used to and it was
what they chose to do. They had to put everything else that mattered
to them aside and pretend that being a samurai was the one and only
thing they could do and have done in their life. They had to be okay
with death and they had to make major sacrifices and risks.
Basically, even if death gets in the way, a samurai still has to carry
out his duty no matter what. The samurais had to put everyone else
before them. They were the last people that were on their minds.
This makes the samurais different from Western society because they
cared for only themselves and didn't help people out. The samurais
were all about helping and Western society didn't make nearly as much
sacrifices as the samurais did. The samurais also seem to take their
job a lot more seriously than Western society did. Especially since a
samurai wasn't afraid to take risks even if that meant that they would
die.
humanity. If a samurai did not do this, then they weren't considered
a good samurai or not a samurai at all. They also had to have loyalty
to the lord and the retainer. Life as a samurai seemed to be a
difficult life, however, that was what they were used to and it was
what they chose to do. They had to put everything else that mattered
to them aside and pretend that being a samurai was the one and only
thing they could do and have done in their life. They had to be okay
with death and they had to make major sacrifices and risks.
Basically, even if death gets in the way, a samurai still has to carry
out his duty no matter what. The samurais had to put everyone else
before them. They were the last people that were on their minds.
This makes the samurais different from Western society because they
cared for only themselves and didn't help people out. The samurais
were all about helping and Western society didn't make nearly as much
sacrifices as the samurais did. The samurais also seem to take their
job a lot more seriously than Western society did. Especially since a
samurai wasn't afraid to take risks even if that meant that they would
die.
> *** Please remember to ONLY respond to this post by clicking "Reply",
> NOT "Reply to author" or else I won't get your post... Also, make sure
> you don't start a new topic/post***
>
> http://web.archive.org/web/20001205024800/http://www.humanities.ccny....
> NOT "Reply to author" or else I won't get your post... Also, make sure
> you don't start a new topic/post***
>
Bobby Smith
Oct 26, 2009, 5:38:42 PM10/26/09
to WMHS World History
A Samuari defines his priorities through life and death, how he lives
his life, and who he serves. A Samuari understands death and accepts
it. His priority is the way he lives his life through attaining his
goals and going to bed each night knowing he set his heart right for
the day. This makes me realize that a Samuari is loyal to his Lord and
will succeed in his calling by not being a selfish person. A Samuari
discusses things with others (intelligence) and is willing to learn.
Two other virtues a Samurai strives fir are putting others before
themselves (humanity) and ignoring negative circumstances by gaining
courage to succeed against adversity (courage). Through daily constant
practice of these virtues, a Samurai gains tremendous strength to not
fear death because they attained their goal in life. The way of life
for a Samurai was quite different than the belief system of Western
Civilization. Samurai were unselfish and cared for others with the
western societies aimed more to take care of themselves than others.
While civilizations in the west fought over land and religion, the
Samurai focused more on humanity and courage fighting through
adversity and not being selfish. Also, Samurai embraced and accepted
death, whereas I feel westerners often feared death and often lived
their life thinking their God will not punish them for their evil
doings. In a military sense, our western civilization cares for
others, has courage, and aims to keep our troops safe. In the lives of
the Samurai, as Japanese warriors, they would rather die than be
captured or be defeated. However, similar to their western
counterparts, they were loyal, respectful and practiced self-
discipline
his life, and who he serves. A Samuari understands death and accepts
it. His priority is the way he lives his life through attaining his
goals and going to bed each night knowing he set his heart right for
the day. This makes me realize that a Samuari is loyal to his Lord and
will succeed in his calling by not being a selfish person. A Samuari
discusses things with others (intelligence) and is willing to learn.
Two other virtues a Samurai strives fir are putting others before
themselves (humanity) and ignoring negative circumstances by gaining
courage to succeed against adversity (courage). Through daily constant
practice of these virtues, a Samurai gains tremendous strength to not
fear death because they attained their goal in life. The way of life
for a Samurai was quite different than the belief system of Western
Civilization. Samurai were unselfish and cared for others with the
western societies aimed more to take care of themselves than others.
While civilizations in the west fought over land and religion, the
Samurai focused more on humanity and courage fighting through
adversity and not being selfish. Also, Samurai embraced and accepted
death, whereas I feel westerners often feared death and often lived
their life thinking their God will not punish them for their evil
doings. In a military sense, our western civilization cares for
others, has courage, and aims to keep our troops safe. In the lives of
the Samurai, as Japanese warriors, they would rather die than be
captured or be defeated. However, similar to their western
counterparts, they were loyal, respectful and practiced self-
discipline
> *** Please remember to ONLY respond to this post by clicking "Reply",
> NOT "Reply to author" or else I won't get your post... Also, make sure
> you don't start a new topic/post***
>
> http://web.archive.org/web/20001205024800/http://www.humanities.ccny....
> NOT "Reply to author" or else I won't get your post... Also, make sure
> you don't start a new topic/post***
>
Lauren Graham
Oct 26, 2009, 5:45:38 PM10/26/09
to WMHS World History
The samurais’ main priority was to be loyal and put others first.
They were expected to do their job even if it was a life or death
situation. They went on the theory that death was inevitable and in
order to be a good samurai you must accept impending death. This
tells you that samurais may not have valued their lives as
individuals; but more so valued their position as a samurai because of
how nonchalantly death was embraced. In Western societies people
think more about themselves and tend to run from danger. The samurais
confronted danger because that was their duty and that was all they
knew.
They were expected to do their job even if it was a life or death
situation. They went on the theory that death was inevitable and in
order to be a good samurai you must accept impending death. This
tells you that samurais may not have valued their lives as
individuals; but more so valued their position as a samurai because of
how nonchalantly death was embraced. In Western societies people
think more about themselves and tend to run from danger. The samurais
confronted danger because that was their duty and that was all they
knew.
larry wood
Oct 26, 2009, 6:11:28 PM10/26/09
to WMHS World History
The way of the samurai is acknowledging and making peace with the fact
that you might be killed any day. Once a samurai does this he can die
a good death. For those that cannot do this, they will fall very
short of thier true potencial. After you accept your mortality, you
need to focus to three things; intelligence, courage, and humanity.
The life of a devoted samurai is a life of endless self improvement
and strict displin. This is different than the ideas of western
militaries of the period and of today. In the west, the life of a
solgier is useally a temporary one. When the war is over, the ideal
western warrior rides off into the sunset to the life he had before.
The sumurai is a warrior for life. Once you become a samurai, you are
a samurai until you meet your death. There is no sunset to ride off
into; just another conflict or back to the life of strict displine.
that you might be killed any day. Once a samurai does this he can die
a good death. For those that cannot do this, they will fall very
short of thier true potencial. After you accept your mortality, you
need to focus to three things; intelligence, courage, and humanity.
The life of a devoted samurai is a life of endless self improvement
and strict displin. This is different than the ideas of western
militaries of the period and of today. In the west, the life of a
solgier is useally a temporary one. When the war is over, the ideal
western warrior rides off into the sunset to the life he had before.
The sumurai is a warrior for life. Once you become a samurai, you are
a samurai until you meet your death. There is no sunset to ride off
into; just another conflict or back to the life of strict displine.
Hannah Magee
Oct 26, 2009, 6:36:29 PM10/26/09
to WMHS World History
The main priority of the samuri was to conquer the natural fear of
death and ultimately die with honor. The samuris had to fight for
their freedoms, and by preparing themselves for death they could live
freely. With the acceptance of death the samuri could fight without
fear, knowing if he were to die in battle it would be the death of a
noble warrior. Samuri were well trained fighters and prepared for
anything. The samuri lived to please his lord in battle, and if that
meant dying, then the samuri would die. Western societies try to
avoid death in battle, while samuris embraced this type of death.
western societies also, for the most part fear death, and do not
accept it the way the samuris did. With a fear of death westerners
are usually more vulnerable in battle.
death and ultimately die with honor. The samuris had to fight for
their freedoms, and by preparing themselves for death they could live
freely. With the acceptance of death the samuri could fight without
fear, knowing if he were to die in battle it would be the death of a
noble warrior. Samuri were well trained fighters and prepared for
anything. The samuri lived to please his lord in battle, and if that
meant dying, then the samuri would die. Western societies try to
avoid death in battle, while samuris embraced this type of death.
western societies also, for the most part fear death, and do not
accept it the way the samuris did. With a fear of death westerners
are usually more vulnerable in battle.
> *** Please remember to ONLY respond to this post by clicking "Reply",
> NOT "Reply to author" or else I won't get your post... Also, make sure
> you don't start a new topic/post***
>
> http://web.archive.org/web/20001205024800/http://www.humanities.ccny....
> NOT "Reply to author" or else I won't get your post... Also, make sure
> you don't start a new topic/post***
>
Connor Flynn
Oct 26, 2009, 7:01:23 PM10/26/09
to WMHS World History
A samurai defines his priorities by being loyal and courageous. A
samurai's loyalty is very important to its master and the samurai is
devoted to him. A samurai lives each day by setting one's heart right
and also by living as if there body was already dead. The samurai in
this excerpt believed that courage is gritting one's teeth. They also
believed that they should keep pushing forward no matter what happens
next to just keep pushing forward and fight for what they were after
without hesitation.This excerpt shows that the samurai is not about
themselves they sacrifice their lives without hesitation. They believe
that to die without gaining one's aim is a dog's death and fanaticism.
The samurai believe that they should be more concerened about other's
and not focus on themselves. This is different from the military dogma
because they care about others rather than the Western dogmas caring
about themselves. The samurai strictly care about one another but the
other dogmas in the Western socities watched out for themselves rather
eachother. And also the samurai were a more courageous people. As the
samurai's would keep fighting and pushing through for what they needed
they Western socities would not do so much and probably retreat while,
the samurais would fight to the death even when they know that they
are going to lose the battle.The way of the samurai is also different
because they believed in sacraficing one's live to save another. In
the dogmas in the Western socities it was very unlikely for that to
happen because they did not believe in sacrifice.
samurai's loyalty is very important to its master and the samurai is
devoted to him. A samurai lives each day by setting one's heart right
and also by living as if there body was already dead. The samurai in
this excerpt believed that courage is gritting one's teeth. They also
believed that they should keep pushing forward no matter what happens
next to just keep pushing forward and fight for what they were after
without hesitation.This excerpt shows that the samurai is not about
themselves they sacrifice their lives without hesitation. They believe
that to die without gaining one's aim is a dog's death and fanaticism.
The samurai believe that they should be more concerened about other's
and not focus on themselves. This is different from the military dogma
because they care about others rather than the Western dogmas caring
about themselves. The samurai strictly care about one another but the
other dogmas in the Western socities watched out for themselves rather
eachother. And also the samurai were a more courageous people. As the
samurai's would keep fighting and pushing through for what they needed
they Western socities would not do so much and probably retreat while,
the samurais would fight to the death even when they know that they
are going to lose the battle.The way of the samurai is also different
because they believed in sacraficing one's live to save another. In
the dogmas in the Western socities it was very unlikely for that to
happen because they did not believe in sacrifice.
> *** Please remember to ONLY respond to this post by clicking "Reply",
> NOT "Reply to author" or else I won't get your post... Also, make sure
> you don't start a new topic/post***
>
> http://web.archive.org/web/20001205024800/http://www.humanities.ccny....
> NOT "Reply to author" or else I won't get your post... Also, make sure
> you don't start a new topic/post***
>
Andrew Kergo
Oct 26, 2009, 7:27:50 PM10/26/09
to WMHS World History
A samurai defines his priorities by understanding death and being able
to sacrifice life. A samurai must also be courageous. A samurai
lives for courageousness and must face death when it comes. If the
samurai does not accept death and backs down from a challenge then
that is cowardice. When a samurai becomes a coward then there is no
point in life (in the view of samurais). Intelligence and humanity
are also in the way of a samurai and must understood by a samurai.
The life of a samurai is a very noble one. Samurais’ lives are based
around intelligence, courage, and humanity. Samurai’s must be very
dedicated to their work and their work involves their whole lives.
Being a samurai is a lifelong commitment, all the way up until death.
A soldier in the Western world or US would normally do anything for
their lives. Western civilization does not embrace death as the
samurais do.
to sacrifice life. A samurai must also be courageous. A samurai
lives for courageousness and must face death when it comes. If the
samurai does not accept death and backs down from a challenge then
that is cowardice. When a samurai becomes a coward then there is no
point in life (in the view of samurais). Intelligence and humanity
are also in the way of a samurai and must understood by a samurai.
The life of a samurai is a very noble one. Samurais’ lives are based
around intelligence, courage, and humanity. Samurai’s must be very
dedicated to their work and their work involves their whole lives.
Being a samurai is a lifelong commitment, all the way up until death.
A soldier in the Western world or US would normally do anything for
their lives. Western civilization does not embrace death as the
samurais do.
> *** Please remember to ONLY respond to this post by clicking "Reply",
> NOT "Reply to author" or else I won't get your post... Also, make sure
> you don't start a new topic/post***
>
> http://web.archive.org/web/20001205024800/http://www.humanities.ccny....
> NOT "Reply to author" or else I won't get your post... Also, make sure
> you don't start a new topic/post***
>
nicole deane
Oct 26, 2009, 8:03:07 PM10/26/09
to WMHS World History
A samurai defines himself by his choice between life and death. He
believes it is much better to die brave than to live the rest of your
life as a coward. You needed to do your job everyday, ready to
sacrifice yourself. you needed to be a hard worker with lots of
perseverance. Unless you accept this belief you are not a samurai. A
samurai's next priority is his freedom. A samurai's freedom is earned,
unlike our freedom, a right of all american citizens today. The life
of a samurai was lived day to day, taking full advantage of each day
because you never know if it will be your last. A samurai cannot have
regrets, there is no time to regret something. As a samurai you must
work hard and regret nothing. By earning your freedom and accepting
sacrifice, you succeed and become a retainer. The retainer supports
their lord and remains loyal. A samurai is composed of loyalty,
devotion, intelligence, and courage. the beliefs of the samurai are
much different from the beliefs of the Western societies. the samurai
glorify and embrace death. however, the Western societies mourn death
and see death as a negative part of life.
believes it is much better to die brave than to live the rest of your
life as a coward. You needed to do your job everyday, ready to
sacrifice yourself. you needed to be a hard worker with lots of
perseverance. Unless you accept this belief you are not a samurai. A
samurai's next priority is his freedom. A samurai's freedom is earned,
unlike our freedom, a right of all american citizens today. The life
of a samurai was lived day to day, taking full advantage of each day
because you never know if it will be your last. A samurai cannot have
regrets, there is no time to regret something. As a samurai you must
work hard and regret nothing. By earning your freedom and accepting
sacrifice, you succeed and become a retainer. The retainer supports
their lord and remains loyal. A samurai is composed of loyalty,
devotion, intelligence, and courage. the beliefs of the samurai are
much different from the beliefs of the Western societies. the samurai
glorify and embrace death. however, the Western societies mourn death
and see death as a negative part of life.
> *** Please remember to ONLY respond to this post by clicking "Reply",
> NOT "Reply to author" or else I won't get your post... Also, make sure
> you don't start a new topic/post***
>
> http://web.archive.org/web/20001205024800/http://www.humanities.ccny....
> NOT "Reply to author" or else I won't get your post... Also, make sure
> you don't start a new topic/post***
>
Beth McCarthy
Oct 26, 2009, 8:09:03 PM10/26/09
to WMHS World History
Samurais define their priorities based on death. If they can accept
the fact that they will die in honor of their lord, it's easier to
live their lives. If you can't accept that you could be killed at any
time you are considered a coward and wouldn't be a samurai. Their
three basic principles of life are: intelligence, humanity, and
courage. A samurai needs intelligence so they can gain knowledge and
wisdom through other people and themselves. Humanity is described as
putting others before yourself. Rather than being selfish, samurais
were willing to protect their people and community. Courage is
knowing that you may not make it out of a situation alive, but you are
willing to do it anyway without worrying about consequences. A
saurai's life seems rather difficult because they had to give up
everything, including their life, so they could please their god. I
personally wouldn't be able to handle being a samurai, besides being a
girl, but because it's a very difficult decision to make. Should you
give up your family and risk your life to please your god or should
you live the life you choose, but not die with the honor you could
have as a samurai? I think just making the decision to become a
samurai takes a lot of courage, but also accepting the fact that you
could die at any possible time. A samurai's way of living is by being
unselfish, which seems to be quite the opposite for Western
societies. Western societies are more concerned with gaining new
territory by winning a battle rather than living peacefully with one
another. A samurai is willing to sacrifice themselves for their god
and can accept the fact of death, but Western societies seem to fear
the idea of death. They (Western societies) didn't see death as a
sacrifice for their god, but a sacrifice for their country and
believing that every man was for himself. This is the complete
opposite of the samurai's theory of live, which is to sacrifice
themselves for their community as well as their god.
the fact that they will die in honor of their lord, it's easier to
live their lives. If you can't accept that you could be killed at any
time you are considered a coward and wouldn't be a samurai. Their
three basic principles of life are: intelligence, humanity, and
courage. A samurai needs intelligence so they can gain knowledge and
wisdom through other people and themselves. Humanity is described as
putting others before yourself. Rather than being selfish, samurais
were willing to protect their people and community. Courage is
knowing that you may not make it out of a situation alive, but you are
willing to do it anyway without worrying about consequences. A
saurai's life seems rather difficult because they had to give up
everything, including their life, so they could please their god. I
personally wouldn't be able to handle being a samurai, besides being a
girl, but because it's a very difficult decision to make. Should you
give up your family and risk your life to please your god or should
you live the life you choose, but not die with the honor you could
have as a samurai? I think just making the decision to become a
samurai takes a lot of courage, but also accepting the fact that you
could die at any possible time. A samurai's way of living is by being
unselfish, which seems to be quite the opposite for Western
societies. Western societies are more concerned with gaining new
territory by winning a battle rather than living peacefully with one
another. A samurai is willing to sacrifice themselves for their god
and can accept the fact of death, but Western societies seem to fear
the idea of death. They (Western societies) didn't see death as a
sacrifice for their god, but a sacrifice for their country and
believing that every man was for himself. This is the complete
opposite of the samurai's theory of live, which is to sacrifice
themselves for their community as well as their god.
> *** Please remember to ONLY respond to this post by clicking "Reply",
> NOT "Reply to author" or else I won't get your post... Also, make sure
> you don't start a new topic/post***
>
> http://web.archive.org/web/20001205024800/http://www.humanities.ccny....
> NOT "Reply to author" or else I won't get your post... Also, make sure
> you don't start a new topic/post***
>
william rochon
Oct 26, 2009, 9:03:12 PM10/26/09
to WMHS World History
A samurai defines his priorities by when death will be and the respect
he has for his people. When the priorities are not found by a samurai,
the life is pointless. When the samurai don't find their aim they die
a cowardice death of a dog. The samurai was very wise and did not fear
death. the samurai was very loyal to his people and his lord. When
fighting until death is always part of life, it is not as difficult to
face death. The soul and heart of the samurai were completely devoted
to their way of life. The samurai is fit with intelligence, humanity,
and courage. These three characteristics are all necessary for one to
devote himself to a cause as the samurai did. The belief of the
samurai is different from that of Western societies militaries.
Western societies fear death and will do all they can to protect
themselves for it. Western societies have many people willing to give
their life for their people and their lord but most people will hide
from death and protect themselves only. This may seem selfish compared
to the samurai but in reality it is a wise choice.
he has for his people. When the priorities are not found by a samurai,
the life is pointless. When the samurai don't find their aim they die
a cowardice death of a dog. The samurai was very wise and did not fear
death. the samurai was very loyal to his people and his lord. When
fighting until death is always part of life, it is not as difficult to
face death. The soul and heart of the samurai were completely devoted
to their way of life. The samurai is fit with intelligence, humanity,
and courage. These three characteristics are all necessary for one to
devote himself to a cause as the samurai did. The belief of the
samurai is different from that of Western societies militaries.
Western societies fear death and will do all they can to protect
themselves for it. Western societies have many people willing to give
their life for their people and their lord but most people will hide
from death and protect themselves only. This may seem selfish compared
to the samurai but in reality it is a wise choice.
> *** Please remember to ONLY respond to this post by clicking "Reply",
> NOT "Reply to author" or else I won't get your post... Also, make sure
> you don't start a new topic/post***
>
> http://web.archive.org/web/20001205024800/http://www.humanities.ccny....
> NOT "Reply to author" or else I won't get your post... Also, make sure
> you don't start a new topic/post***
>
danielle perkins
Oct 26, 2009, 10:02:37 PM10/26/09
to WMHS World History
Samurai's priorities are devoting and giving his soul to his leader or
master. A Samurai understands death and accepts it. This particular
samurai is saying that you must devote your entire life to your master
and you will be happy. In simple terms, they put everyone else
before themselves. They strongly believe in courage and loyalty as
well. With such great fear of losing their lives, the westerners
were usually more susceptible to death in battle.
master. A Samurai understands death and accepts it. This particular
samurai is saying that you must devote your entire life to your master
and you will be happy. In simple terms, they put everyone else
before themselves. They strongly believe in courage and loyalty as
well. With such great fear of losing their lives, the westerners
were usually more susceptible to death in battle.
Dan Doherty
Oct 26, 2009, 10:20:20 PM10/26/09
to WMHS World History
Devotion is how a samurai defines his priorities. By sacraficing to
serve
a higher power, a samurai already lives as if he is dead. His freewill
and personal life no longer exist. He follows the orders of authority
without any personal thoughts or opinion. This mindset of focusing
on service and completing objectives without any regard to himself
makes the acceptance of death easier. A samurai realizes his
fate will ultimately be death, which allows him to live without fear.
He lives his life with intelligence, humanity and courage. These
qualities allow a samurai to work with determination for his higher
power. His goal is to wisely serve others without hesitation. A
samurai is willing to sacrafice his life, if necessary, to accomplish
his mission. In Western societies, death is not embraced and
easily accepted. People fear death and its uncertainty. The
military beliefs of the West usually try to avoid casualties and save
as many lives as possible. Many soldiers have families they care
and think about, unlike a samurai. The militaries of Western
societies do not surrender to the fate of death like the samurai.
serve
a higher power, a samurai already lives as if he is dead. His freewill
and personal life no longer exist. He follows the orders of authority
without any personal thoughts or opinion. This mindset of focusing
on service and completing objectives without any regard to himself
makes the acceptance of death easier. A samurai realizes his
fate will ultimately be death, which allows him to live without fear.
He lives his life with intelligence, humanity and courage. These
qualities allow a samurai to work with determination for his higher
power. His goal is to wisely serve others without hesitation. A
samurai is willing to sacrafice his life, if necessary, to accomplish
his mission. In Western societies, death is not embraced and
easily accepted. People fear death and its uncertainty. The
military beliefs of the West usually try to avoid casualties and save
as many lives as possible. Many soldiers have families they care
and think about, unlike a samurai. The militaries of Western
societies do not surrender to the fate of death like the samurai.
> *** Please remember to ONLY respond to this post by clicking "Reply",
> NOT "Reply to author" or else I won't get your post... Also, make sure
> you don't start a new topic/post***
>
> http://web.archive.org/web/20001205024800/http://www.humanities.ccny....
> NOT "Reply to author" or else I won't get your post... Also, make sure
> you don't start a new topic/post***
>
Steven Prestejohn
Oct 26, 2009, 10:25:21 PM10/26/09
to WMHS World History
A samurai's main focus is the complete elimination of the fear of
death, and the complete dedication of the samurai's heart, mind, and
body to his master. His goal is to allow death to become irrelevant,
and to not allow it to interfere with his judgement. The samurai must
commit himself to the three virtues of wisdom, self-sacrifice, and
courage. He must set his "aim" straight every day, in order to live a
life of maximum potential, honor, and freedom. A samurai must
completely suppress any motivations towards his own self-interest, in
favor of the interests of his master. His life is one of complete
dedication to others, mainly to his master. A samurai must not allow
circumstance to impede his progress, and he must tolerate any
conditions he is subjected to in order to keep going. In the West,
the military tries very hard to avoid it's soldiers being killed, and
most are completely afraid of death. Despite many of the virtues
upheld by the Samurai being valued in western armed forces, such as
sacrifice and courage, death is seen as something to be feared, and to
stop at all costs.
death, and the complete dedication of the samurai's heart, mind, and
body to his master. His goal is to allow death to become irrelevant,
and to not allow it to interfere with his judgement. The samurai must
commit himself to the three virtues of wisdom, self-sacrifice, and
courage. He must set his "aim" straight every day, in order to live a
life of maximum potential, honor, and freedom. A samurai must
completely suppress any motivations towards his own self-interest, in
favor of the interests of his master. His life is one of complete
dedication to others, mainly to his master. A samurai must not allow
circumstance to impede his progress, and he must tolerate any
conditions he is subjected to in order to keep going. In the West,
the military tries very hard to avoid it's soldiers being killed, and
most are completely afraid of death. Despite many of the virtues
upheld by the Samurai being valued in western armed forces, such as
sacrifice and courage, death is seen as something to be feared, and to
stop at all costs.
> *** Please remember to ONLY respond to this post by clicking "Reply",
> NOT "Reply to author" or else I won't get your post... Also, make sure
> you don't start a new topic/post***
>
> http://web.archive.org/web/20001205024800/http://www.humanities.ccny....
> NOT "Reply to author" or else I won't get your post... Also, make sure
> you don't start a new topic/post***
>
Nick Busa
Oct 27, 2009, 4:10:16 PM10/27/09
to WMHS World History
A samurai's main priority is the knowledge of death, and doing as much
good in a lifetime to make the death not as bad. The helping of
others is necessary for a samurai to achieve a death that is not
miserable. If a samurai died without helping out others, then it is
as if the samurai died as an animal(life without contributing to
society). The life of a samurai depended much on the success towards
others, intelligence, humanity, and courage. To a samurai being
intelligent was to discuss issues with others. This discussing was
important towards samurais because it allowed the people to stay at
peace with each other. To be humane a samurai would always have to
put other people before them. This courtesy also helped contribute to
the respect and peace between samurais. Courage to a samurai is just
to get through the tough times and keep moving forward. Intense
courage from the samurais allowed them to get through very difficult
situations. Once all of these qualities were achieved, then would a
samurai be able to gain more knowledge on other subjects. Compared to
the military dogma of Western societies at the time this way of life
was very different. All that the Western societies cared about was
that the soldiers were strong and tough, while only needing the
leaders to be intelligent.
good in a lifetime to make the death not as bad. The helping of
others is necessary for a samurai to achieve a death that is not
miserable. If a samurai died without helping out others, then it is
as if the samurai died as an animal(life without contributing to
society). The life of a samurai depended much on the success towards
others, intelligence, humanity, and courage. To a samurai being
intelligent was to discuss issues with others. This discussing was
important towards samurais because it allowed the people to stay at
peace with each other. To be humane a samurai would always have to
put other people before them. This courtesy also helped contribute to
the respect and peace between samurais. Courage to a samurai is just
to get through the tough times and keep moving forward. Intense
courage from the samurais allowed them to get through very difficult
situations. Once all of these qualities were achieved, then would a
samurai be able to gain more knowledge on other subjects. Compared to
the military dogma of Western societies at the time this way of life
was very different. All that the Western societies cared about was
that the soldiers were strong and tough, while only needing the
leaders to be intelligent.
> *** Please remember to ONLY respond to this post by clicking "Reply",
> NOT "Reply to author" or else I won't get your post... Also, make sure
> you don't start a new topic/post***
>
> http://web.archive.org/web/20001205024800/http://www.humanities.ccny....
> NOT "Reply to author" or else I won't get your post... Also, make sure
> you don't start a new topic/post***
>
Brandon McGrath
Oct 27, 2009, 7:32:26 PM10/27/09
to WMHS World History
A samurai defined his priorities as being ready for death when his
time has come. A samurai does not fear death they understood it and
if they were not ready when it happened then they were looked down
upon. Also samurai were very at one with themselves. The samurai
talks about setting his heart right every day so that he can live
free. This tell me that samurai were very spiritual. Also they most
likely did not see death as the end because they were unafraid and
were ready to die. This is different then in the West because in the
West the people simply did whatever the pope or their king told them
to do and they followed the religion for no reason it was just what
they believed. The samurai however were very much in control of them
selves they didn't blindly follow they were ready for death.
time has come. A samurai does not fear death they understood it and
if they were not ready when it happened then they were looked down
upon. Also samurai were very at one with themselves. The samurai
talks about setting his heart right every day so that he can live
free. This tell me that samurai were very spiritual. Also they most
likely did not see death as the end because they were unafraid and
were ready to die. This is different then in the West because in the
West the people simply did whatever the pope or their king told them
to do and they followed the religion for no reason it was just what
they believed. The samurai however were very much in control of them
selves they didn't blindly follow they were ready for death.
> *** Please remember to ONLY respond to this post by clicking "Reply",
> NOT "Reply to author" or else I won't get your post... Also, make sure
> you don't start a new topic/post***
>
> http://web.archive.org/web/20001205024800/http://www.humanities.ccny....
> NOT "Reply to author" or else I won't get your post... Also, make sure
> you don't start a new topic/post***
>
Stephen Dunn
Oct 27, 2009, 8:37:34 PM10/27/09
to WMHS World History
A samurai's main purpose in life is to live and honorable life and if
necessary die honorably. The samurais believe in absolute
unquestioning loyalty to their masters. Samurais were the ultimate
warrior that not only devoted his life honor and courage in battle,
but also outside of battle. They are revered men in Japanese society
like celebrities are in today's society. In truth though samurais
seem to lead a boring life outside of battles and fighting. But when
you truly think about it everybody's life during that time period all
over the world seems boring to me, so it's hard to tell if they
enjoyed what they did or not. The most probable answer is yes,
considering how they would fight to the death no matter what. When
you compare samurais and the westerners there is a huge difference
when it comes to military dogma. Westerners believed in surrender and
would not commit suicide if they lost a battle. Also samurais were
the only men that fought in battles. It was different in the West as
knights fought along side peasants and commoners. Samurais not only
valued war, but every aspect of life because they knew that their life
could end suddenly in a battle and looked at death as inevitable.
Instead of fearing death the samurais embraced death.
necessary die honorably. The samurais believe in absolute
unquestioning loyalty to their masters. Samurais were the ultimate
warrior that not only devoted his life honor and courage in battle,
but also outside of battle. They are revered men in Japanese society
like celebrities are in today's society. In truth though samurais
seem to lead a boring life outside of battles and fighting. But when
you truly think about it everybody's life during that time period all
over the world seems boring to me, so it's hard to tell if they
enjoyed what they did or not. The most probable answer is yes,
considering how they would fight to the death no matter what. When
you compare samurais and the westerners there is a huge difference
when it comes to military dogma. Westerners believed in surrender and
would not commit suicide if they lost a battle. Also samurais were
the only men that fought in battles. It was different in the West as
knights fought along side peasants and commoners. Samurais not only
valued war, but every aspect of life because they knew that their life
could end suddenly in a battle and looked at death as inevitable.
Instead of fearing death the samurais embraced death.
> *** Please remember to ONLY respond to this post by clicking "Reply",
> NOT "Reply to author" or else I won't get your post... Also, make sure
> you don't start a new topic/post***
>
> http://web.archive.org/web/20001205024800/http://www.humanities.ccny....
> NOT "Reply to author" or else I won't get your post... Also, make sure
> you don't start a new topic/post***
>
Anthony Nocella
Oct 27, 2009, 8:42:34 PM10/27/09
to WMHS World History
A Samurai defines his priorities through life and death, and who he
serves. A Samurai was trained to do what they were supposed to do
even if it meant life or death. They believe that death is inevitable
and if you do not believe this than you can't live up to your
potential as a Samurai because they would rather die trying to fight
than to run away and live. This tells me that life as a Samurai was
different than life as we have it today. Samurai's also embraced and
accepted death, and western people tend to fear death. A Samurai did
what would be the best for the Samurain people and now we do what
would be the best for us. Also, the Samurai's would stand up to
danger and people of western societes tend to usually run from
danger. The military of western civilizations is similar to the
Samurai. The military in western civilizations is also strict and the
soldiers have courage to fight for what they believe in. It is also
different because the Samurai devote themselves to fighting.
serves. A Samurai was trained to do what they were supposed to do
even if it meant life or death. They believe that death is inevitable
and if you do not believe this than you can't live up to your
potential as a Samurai because they would rather die trying to fight
than to run away and live. This tells me that life as a Samurai was
different than life as we have it today. Samurai's also embraced and
accepted death, and western people tend to fear death. A Samurai did
what would be the best for the Samurain people and now we do what
would be the best for us. Also, the Samurai's would stand up to
danger and people of western societes tend to usually run from
danger. The military of western civilizations is similar to the
Samurai. The military in western civilizations is also strict and the
soldiers have courage to fight for what they believe in. It is also
different because the Samurai devote themselves to fighting.
Danielle Dyer
Oct 27, 2009, 8:58:58 PM10/27/09
to WMHS World History
A samurai defines his priorities by fulfilling duties given by his
Lord. A samurai's life purpose is to serve his master. During his
life, he gains courage, wisdom, and a unimaginable sense of loyalty.
To truly be a successful samurai, one must have no fear of death.
Although it is true that no one is eager to die, a samurai will
sacrifice his life for his master. A samurai is hale in body and
mind, and focuses on nothing other than maintaining his order. Life
as a samurai was challenging, but granted honor and freedom in the
afterlife. Unlike Western societies, samurais fight for the benefit
of their master. Western soldiers fight to maintain their countries'
freedom, and to protect the citizens of their nation. Samurais have
strict beliefs of how they are to live, where Western society is
mainly optional.
Lord. A samurai's life purpose is to serve his master. During his
life, he gains courage, wisdom, and a unimaginable sense of loyalty.
To truly be a successful samurai, one must have no fear of death.
Although it is true that no one is eager to die, a samurai will
sacrifice his life for his master. A samurai is hale in body and
mind, and focuses on nothing other than maintaining his order. Life
as a samurai was challenging, but granted honor and freedom in the
afterlife. Unlike Western societies, samurais fight for the benefit
of their master. Western soldiers fight to maintain their countries'
freedom, and to protect the citizens of their nation. Samurais have
strict beliefs of how they are to live, where Western society is
mainly optional.
jackie damato
Oct 27, 2009, 9:00:45 PM10/27/09
to WMHS World History
A samurai defines his priorities in life by death. They had to choose
between life and death. Everyone wants to live, but they have to
choose between it. Choosing life shows that you might be scared to
die. It tells you that the samurai have different beliefs. The samurai
knew death was coming but had to choose between life and death. They
had different belief systems from Western societies because many
societies didn’t believe in the samurai life. The samurai are more
self sacrificing than other societies.
between life and death. Everyone wants to live, but they have to
choose between it. Choosing life shows that you might be scared to
die. It tells you that the samurai have different beliefs. The samurai
knew death was coming but had to choose between life and death. They
had different belief systems from Western societies because many
societies didn’t believe in the samurai life. The samurai are more
self sacrificing than other societies.
Conor Doherty
Oct 27, 2009, 9:34:05 PM10/27/09
to WMHS World History
A samurai defines his priorities by how his life would positively
affect his surroundings, and what he needs to sacrifice to accomplish
this goal. Samurais accept the reality of death everyday because they
know if they die, they will have died for a valued cause. They
dedicate their lives to bettering all of the Earth and if they die,
they know in their eyes their life was valuable. The life of a samurai
is a life of extremely high morals and strict ethical codes. They feel
you must throw away self-interest and care about others. Only then can
you truly live a valued life in the eyes of a samurai. In Western
military, death is not such an accepted inevitability. Our military
(not saying we are cowards) hides and uses tactical thinking to stay
alive and rid the enemy. Samurai, on the other hand, take death into
account and charge the front lines. Also, even if someone did not lead
a, per se, honorable life, they are still honored if they die in
combat rather than the samurai, who are honored only if their life was
valuable to others.
affect his surroundings, and what he needs to sacrifice to accomplish
this goal. Samurais accept the reality of death everyday because they
know if they die, they will have died for a valued cause. They
dedicate their lives to bettering all of the Earth and if they die,
they know in their eyes their life was valuable. The life of a samurai
is a life of extremely high morals and strict ethical codes. They feel
you must throw away self-interest and care about others. Only then can
you truly live a valued life in the eyes of a samurai. In Western
military, death is not such an accepted inevitability. Our military
(not saying we are cowards) hides and uses tactical thinking to stay
alive and rid the enemy. Samurai, on the other hand, take death into
account and charge the front lines. Also, even if someone did not lead
a, per se, honorable life, they are still honored if they die in
combat rather than the samurai, who are honored only if their life was
valuable to others.
Kristen Abreu
Oct 27, 2009, 10:41:08 PM10/27/09
to WMHS World History
A sumari defines his priorities through life and death and how he is
going to live his life. He accepts that everyone has there time and
place to die. His priority was to be loyal and to think of others
before he thought about himself, and to be a good Sumari you had to do
exactlly this. You had to be able to accept death the way that they
did. They may have not of valued their life that much but because they
knew death was coming and they accepted it is what makes them a good
Sumari. The Western Societies tries to avoid death in a battle but on
the other hand, the Sumaris took in the fact that this may be their
time to go. The Western Societies did not accept death like the
Sumaris did.
going to live his life. He accepts that everyone has there time and
place to die. His priority was to be loyal and to think of others
before he thought about himself, and to be a good Sumari you had to do
exactlly this. You had to be able to accept death the way that they
did. They may have not of valued their life that much but because they
knew death was coming and they accepted it is what makes them a good
Sumari. The Western Societies tries to avoid death in a battle but on
the other hand, the Sumaris took in the fact that this may be their
time to go. The Western Societies did not accept death like the
Sumaris did.
meaghan moore
Oct 27, 2009, 10:59:15 PM10/27/09
to WMHS World History
Intelligence, humanity, and courage defines a samurai's priorities in
life. Intelligence is gained when you interact with the people around
you. Humanity is when the wellbeing and needs of others is put infront
of your own. A samurai learned to be unselfish and consider others in
every action they made. Courage was when a samurai does not fear what
lies ahead no matter what the circumstances are. It is also necessary
for a samurai to completely devote his body and soul to their master.
Prioities of others and their master were the most important to a
samurai. They also were taught to embrace death as an everyday
occurance. The life of a samurai seems to be a dangerous one. They are
taught to be fearless and trust that what happens was meant to happen.
They are dedicated to their master. Death is to not be feared but
accepted and you are to have no regrets. To live the life of a
samurai, you must be daring and never look back. In Western society,
death is feared rather than accepted. Samurai's trust that death will
happen when it is suppose to happen so they do not waste a minute
fearing it. They consider fighting a way of life and never let down
because they trust in their God. Soldiers in the western society often
fear death while in battle. This causes them to become more selfish
inorder to protect their own lives instead of focusing on the task at
hand. The military dogma is to protect the nation, when soldiers start
to put the needs of themselves infront of the needs of others is when
problems start to occur. Samurais limit these problems by devoting
themselves primarily to fighting and to their master. Death is not to
be worried about.
life. Intelligence is gained when you interact with the people around
you. Humanity is when the wellbeing and needs of others is put infront
of your own. A samurai learned to be unselfish and consider others in
every action they made. Courage was when a samurai does not fear what
lies ahead no matter what the circumstances are. It is also necessary
for a samurai to completely devote his body and soul to their master.
Prioities of others and their master were the most important to a
samurai. They also were taught to embrace death as an everyday
occurance. The life of a samurai seems to be a dangerous one. They are
taught to be fearless and trust that what happens was meant to happen.
They are dedicated to their master. Death is to not be feared but
accepted and you are to have no regrets. To live the life of a
samurai, you must be daring and never look back. In Western society,
death is feared rather than accepted. Samurai's trust that death will
happen when it is suppose to happen so they do not waste a minute
fearing it. They consider fighting a way of life and never let down
because they trust in their God. Soldiers in the western society often
fear death while in battle. This causes them to become more selfish
inorder to protect their own lives instead of focusing on the task at
hand. The military dogma is to protect the nation, when soldiers start
to put the needs of themselves infront of the needs of others is when
problems start to occur. Samurais limit these problems by devoting
themselves primarily to fighting and to their master. Death is not to
be worried about.
Tyler Brady
Oct 27, 2009, 11:22:08 PM10/27/09
to WMHS World History
as stated in the very first sentence "A Samurai is found in death."
You must be willing to accept the fact that sooner or later you are
eventually going to face death. You then have to realize how important
loyalty is and fight for others before yourself, which is where the
courage part comes in. Along with courage, you must be able to
accomplish intelligence and humanity. Another quote from the reading
says " One should perceive their nature to be one of quite strength."
The significance of this quote is that you must follow the ways of the
samurai in order to be strong.
You must be willing to accept the fact that sooner or later you are
eventually going to face death. You then have to realize how important
loyalty is and fight for others before yourself, which is where the
courage part comes in. Along with courage, you must be able to
accomplish intelligence and humanity. Another quote from the reading
says " One should perceive their nature to be one of quite strength."
The significance of this quote is that you must follow the ways of the
samurai in order to be strong.
Chelcie Claude
Oct 28, 2009, 11:32:16 PM10/28/09
to WMHS World History
The samurai has many priorities. He lives everyday as if he were
dead. He feels that he will be respeced and it gives him freedom. If
the samurai follows the samurai way then they will not die in a bad
form. He is faithful to his lord without questioning and willing to
face death. A samurai's loyalty is an important pledge between the
lord and retainer. Other priorities the samurai finds important are
intelligence and humanity. A samurai is a devoted, discipline, and
hard working. The samurai is courageous willing to give up his life
for his samurai duties. It is different the military are not willing
to take their own life if they had to. Wars are declared because of
this.
dead. He feels that he will be respeced and it gives him freedom. If
the samurai follows the samurai way then they will not die in a bad
form. He is faithful to his lord without questioning and willing to
face death. A samurai's loyalty is an important pledge between the
lord and retainer. Other priorities the samurai finds important are
intelligence and humanity. A samurai is a devoted, discipline, and
hard working. The samurai is courageous willing to give up his life
for his samurai duties. It is different the military are not willing
to take their own life if they had to. Wars are declared because of
this.
Reply all
Reply to author
Forward
0 new messages