[SWJ] Review received, #3686-4900

[www.semantic-web-journal.net]

A review has been provided for a paper which was assigned to you.

Authors: Alessio Di Pasquale, Valentina Pasqual, Francesca Tomasi, Fabio
Vitali
Title: On assessing weaker logical status claims in Wikidata Cultural
Heritage records
Submission Type: 'Full Paper'
URL:
https://www.semantic-web-journal.net/content/assessing-weaker-logical-status-claims-wikidata-cultural-heritage-records-1
Tracking number: 3686-4900
Assigned editor: Guest Editors Wikidata 2022 (wikida...@googlegroups.com)
Review submitted by: Maximilian Marx
Suggested decision: Accept

Review Comments:
I thank the authors for addressing my comments on earlier versions of
this paper. Indeed, I have only found a handful of minor comments (see
below), so I am now happy to recommend this paper for acceptance.

Minor comments:
- p1, l18: replace “using” by “the usage of”
- p3, l11: “as only 0.4% We”: the end of the sentence is missing
- p4, l51: footnote 4 is broken, the link should go to
https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Wikidata:GLAM [1] instead
- p5, l47: “and is not” ~> “and it is not”
- p6, l5: “in Listing 4” ~> “In Listing 4”
- p7, l19: “the claims is” ~> “the claim is”
- p8, l47: the link in footnote 18 is missing a link target (the URI is
correct, though)
- p16, l21: “it has not been correct anymore” ~> “is not correct
anymore”
- p17, l7: “0,2” ~> “0.2”
- p18, l46: the link in footnote 58 is missing a link target (the URI is
correct, though)
- p19, l51: “cf. point 7”: this is actually point 5, isn't it?

Comments for editor:

You can access the paper by logging in as editorial board member on
http://www.semantic-web-journal.net/

# SWJ in a Nutshell #

The Semantic Web journal is an open and transparent journal. The full
manuscripts, metadata, names of the reviewers (if they do not op-out), their
reviews, names of the assigned editors, and manuscript decisions are public
and will be made accessible within a Linked Data-based knowledge graph as
well as secondary data products such as document embeddings via machine
learning techniques. Rejected manuscripts can be depublished on request from
the journal's webpage. Nonetheless, they may have already been indexed and
copied by third parties such as search engines outside of our control.
Volunteered community reviews are welcome. Different paper categories have
explicitly stated review criteria that have to be addressed by authors and
reviewers. According to our 2-strike rule, a paper has to receive at least a
minor revision decision after the second round of reviews, otherwise it will
be rejected.

Author information: http://www.semantic-web-journal.net/authors
Reviewer information: http://www.semantic-web-journal.net/reviewers

[1] https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Wikidata:GLAM

[www.semantic-web-journal.net]

A review has been provided for a paper which was assigned to you.

Authors: Alessio Di Pasquale, Valentina Pasqual, Francesca Tomasi, Fabio
Vitali
Title: On assessing weaker logical status claims in Wikidata Cultural
Heritage records
Submission Type: 'Full Paper'
URL:
https://www.semantic-web-journal.net/content/assessing-weaker-logical-status-claims-wikidata-cultural-heritage-records-1
Tracking number: 3686-4900
Assigned editor: Guest Editors Wikidata 2022 (wikida...@googlegroups.com)

Review submitted by: Michael Piotrowski

Suggested decision: Accept

Review Comments:

The authors have addressed all issues I mentioned in my last review. In my
opinion, the article is now ready for publication.