[DIY CNC Router Uses Chains The Right Way
Sharif Garmon
Information on antenna chains has been difficult to find, (google seems to think I want to search for antenna gain). I found this IEEE article which defines what they are, but it doesn't explain how I'd use that information when configuring a device.
I installed DD-WRT on my TP-Link WDR3600 and it says I have two physical radio interfaces. Based on the options in the network mode dropdown menu, I assume that one is the 2.4Ghz radio and the other is the 5.0Ghz radio. However, both have the option to select the TX and RX antenna chains (either 1 or 1+2). What is an antenna chain, what does 1 / 1+2 mean, and how would I be able to figure out the correct setting for my device?
Short version: Using both radio chains is potentially twice as fast as just using one. You only want to limit yourself to a single radio chain if you're doing a long-distance outdoor link and trying to save money on antennas, or perhaps for certain troubleshooting situations.
Long version:
802.11n introduced the concept of MIMO (Multiple Ins, Multiple Outs) to Wi-Fi networking. MIMO radios use multiple radio chains working in parallel to transmit twice as much data at a time as a single radio could do.
You always want both chains in operation for the fastest rates. With just one chain, you're not doing MIMO, you just doing traditional SISO (Single In, Single Out), so you're not much better off than 802.11a or 802.11g. A and G used 20MHz wide channels and got a maximum PHY rate of 54Mbps. If you use those same 20MHz-wide channels with 802.11n and limit yourself to SISO (a single radio chain), your maximum PHY rate only goes up to 72.2Mbps. This increase is only because 802.11n added a couple new higher-rate modulation schemes than A/G had.
And it's not just the max PHY rate that doubles. The second radio chain doubles your set available rates. For each of the eight 1-spatial-stream rates, there is a 2-spatial-stream rate that doubles it.
Of course, 802.11n also allows you to double your channel width to 40MHz. Doubling your channel width has the bonus of increased efficiency, so it actually slightly more than doubles your max PHY rate. So SISO 802.11n with 40MHz channels can do 150Mbps, and 2x2:2 MIMO 802.11n with 40MHz channels can do 300Mbps.
The only time you'd want to disable a radio chain is if you were trying to do a long-distance outdoor link, and didn't have an antenna rig that could provide enough separation between your two radio/antenna chains. If you didn't want to have to mount twice as many antennas on your antenna masts at each end of the link, and have them spaced far enough apart that they don't interfere with each other, then you might opt for a SISO link for cost/simplicity sake, even though it means only half the throughput (150 Mbps max PHY rate instead of 300).
I suppose one other reason to limit to a single radio chain would be temporary, for debugging things like interoperability problems. If you have a 1x1 802.11n device that isn't working well with your 2x2 AP, you might want to limit your AP to 1x1 temporarily to see if the 1x1 device works better. Maybe the 2x2 AP is buggy and sometimes tries to use 2x2 rates that the 1x1 device doesn't support, and ends up having to do increased retransmits or has increased packet loss.
Yes, "radio chain" is just a fancy way of referring to a transceiver. I don't know where they get the word "chain", but according to Motorola white paper: 802.11n Demystified (which was also referred by Steve (who asked the question) in a comment below Spiff's answer):
MIMO* introduces a new paradigm in RF systems design. MIMO-capable radios actually perform better within a multipath-rich environment. A MIMO system has multiple radio chains each of which is a transceiver with its own antenna. A radio chain refers to the hardware necessary for transmit/ receive signal processing. A MIMO radio can then apply several techniques to enhance signal quality and deliver more throughput. It is this ability to add signal components from multiple antennas that differentiates MIMO access points from traditional access points that use antennas in a diversity configuration. An access point with antenna diversity selects signal components from the antenna that provides the best signal performance and ignores the other antenna.
If you're lucky, you might be able to figure out which configuration is optimal, but you'll probably have to just try each one and test performance. If you're using a recent version of ddwrt, the defaults were probably determined to be the best configuration.
This should really be called "RF chain" ("antenna chain" seems to be more colloquial). In the world of RF, it's often possible to think of a radio (abstractly) as a series of transformations that are applied to a signal. If a signal takes a linear path and never splits / merges, these transformations can be thought of as a chain. It just so happens that the bits near the antenna often form a functional chain (in simple radios).
An antenna receives a lot more than just the information we're trying to receive (noise) and this signal is very weak. This means we need to filter the signal and amplify it before we can do anything useful. If you were to connect an antenna directly to a circuit without doing these things, you'd get either nothing useful or nothing at all.
Since these basic transformations need to happen to any signal any antenna receives, I guess people started referring to this part as the RF chain, although this term is used very loosely. It's important to note that parts not connected to an antenna might also be called a "chain".
For beam-forming (directing a transmission without moving the antenna), signals from multiple antennas are actually mixed in a special way to adjust for the angle the signal was received from. Since the antennas are at a known position, the antenna RF chains can be configured to mix the signals constructively or destructively depending on where the signal is expected to arrive from. In this case, the "chain" analogy kind of breaks down, because really it's an array of components connected both in series and in parallel.
If the antenna's at one end of a chain, what's at the other end? Well, once the signal is conditioned, there's often a second set of transformations to handle something called demodulation, and a third set of digital components for decoding - possibly (many) others. Often times the components for these things are sort of shared by other parts of the radio, so "chains" of signal sort of converge on them and merge / split. Note that some radios include analog-to-digital conversion in the antenna RF chain, but this was historically done after things like up/down converting, demodulation, and additional amplification/filtering.
Now that you (hopefully) understand what an RF chain is, you might soon be confused by the term "radio" (transceiver). A device like a wireless access point is part radio transceiver part router (among other things) - the parts attached to the antenna are the radio, and the farther you get from the antenna, the less likely it is to be part of the radio. Also, there are sometimes multiple radio transceivers (e.g. for 802.11a), and sometimes one transceiver does double-duty (e.g. 802.11n + 802.11ac).
I have a newer model xcarve and have been running the DWP611 quite nicely. I wanted to try a different power option and did not want to go to a spindle, so I chose the Maktia router and an adapter for my current spindle mount from inventables.
I wanted to know how everyone else powers their routers? I have my dwp ran through the drag chains and plugged right into the outlet. So I physically turn the router on each time and click spindle on in xcarve.
Basically yes. In Easel you would need to go to Machine>General Settings and change the spindle from Manual to Automatic, then those pins on the back of the X-Carve receive power which switches the outputs ON on the IOT and it allows power through to turn on the Router /Dust Collector
\**This post is focused on the X-Carve however it is often applicable to other CNC's running a standard handheld router as well. You would just need to identify the Spindle Output for other CNC's How many times have you wanted your CNC's...
I personally have the IOT Relay, it worked great on my XC, and I was able to use it on my XCP through the mist port. I got mine originally in 2018, and the first one died in 2020. Digital Loggers, however, replaced it even though the warranty was expired.
As a newbie to the CNC router community , I soon learned what happens when the router power cable gets caught on a high profile item. I decided to implement an extra drag chain assembley on the right Y axis, like the Shapeoko Pro.
And of course, drag chain which I got off of Amazon. I chose a larger size than is installed by Carbide3D as I wanted room for a router power cable and maybe other cables such as a long length shielded USB or USB-C cable to deliver signals to accessories via the Z axis.
Remove the existing two outer x axis metal chain support brackets and replace with the printed parts. The hole spacing is the same and the provided bolts are long enough.This will support your new chain.
Ensure to move the carriage to the left hand side when setting the chain to be curled appropriately for that limits. Cut a couple of lengths of the strong double sided tape and place them on the top of your new brackets to stick the new drag chain to it.
On the outer side of the right Y axis, place the larger chain support bracket in place and mark with a pen, two bold holes through the bracket slots. You can either drill 4mm holes in the aluminium frame and tap, or use more double sided tape to hold the larger bracket in place.
795a8134c1