Hi Eric, I share your frustration that some people seem to get the outer tub sent to them if the bearings fail, or inner tub if the spider fails, but its luck of the draw and to go strictly by-the-book means about $600 of labor. When my bearings went, I faced the decision of trying to get them to send parts under warranty ...or just fix it myself. In the end, I decided not to even try to get the parts sent. Those type of phone calls, and the ensuing aggravation take so much out of me, especially since I need to squeeze them into business hours when finding a moment for a personal call is difficult...much less a call where I'm arguing heatedly with customer support about why they should do something extraordinary to make up for their design flaw.
Sears is in a world of pain as a company these days, and they've been cutting costs in the parts and repair business, so I don't expect things to get much better with them.
Luckily for me, my issue was bearings and not the spider. When I got my machine apart, the bearing job went beautifully. I began the job with the idea that I'd be restoring the machine back to 'like-new', and it would be good for another 10 years with any luck. Once I got a good look at my spider, I became resigned to the fact that I'd be lucky if I got another 2-4 years out of it. It wasn't cracked, but the deep pits and corrosion were evident.
It seems that washing manufacturers might do something for individual cases if you're really really persistent, make a lot of noise to the right people, point out that its a design flaw, and get them to realize that its going to cost them less as a company to send you the part, because you're not going to drop the issue. It's a huge uphill struggle that can really take a lot of time and energy. And while you're doing this, the laundry is piling up.