I managed to fix this on my own. For anyone who may have been experiencing the same problem here is what worked for me:
1. Follow the steps for using VPython with conda, at
vpython.org, I will list them here as well
2. Install classic vpython via "conda install -c vpython vpython"
3. Create an environment to run vpython in via, "conda create -c vpython -n vpython_jup_env vpython python" (This creates an environment with name "vpython_jup_env")
4. Activate this environment via "source activate vpython_jup_env" (or simply activate vpython_jup_env on Windows)
5. Open a jupyter notebook via "jupyter notebook" in terminal
6. Create a new notebook and choose "Python [conda env:vpython_jup_env]"
7. From here you should be able to use vpython via "from vpython import *"
Hopefully this helps anyone else who may have had a similar problem.
*As a side note, I realize it may seem as if I was hasty to post to this group without first trying on my own, but I in fact was working to fix this for more than a week and coincidentally happened to fix it right after.