Carl Robinson <robinso...@gmail.com>: May 27 03:48PM +1000
Folks,
A few notes on the AP obit for Dang Van Phuoc. Vietnam War photographer
Dang Van Phuoc dies at 91 in Southern California | AP News
<https://apnews.com/article/dang-van-phuoc-vietnam-war-photographer-death-a0437a3e4e09b32c482ae24ee3bdf2b8?fbclid=IwY2xjawSDXdhleHRuA2FlbQIxMQBicmlkETFJdWp1SFN1dUZYa0hybVVrc3J0YwZhcHBfaWQQMjIyMDM5MTc4ODIwMDg5MgABHiP1jxoRnTGf6yK4o0uQsUn_saK2egmTSMokith4xZeuYzXy2Mv8eWxFBLju_aem_rBAOVK5VTrbrLBJeDVAYcA>
I knew DVP well — in Saigon, and later in the U.S. — and some of the
published details don’t match the man or the history.
*First, the injury.* Phuoc didn’t lose his eye in a grenade blast. He took
an AK‑47 round point‑blank from a VC in a foxhole. That ended his action
photography. He never went back to frontline work after that.
*Second, 1975.* The Vietnamese staff who reached Guam weren’t the “clothes
on their backs” refugees described in the obit. The real issue was AP’s
handling of them. All local staff were given $3,000 and dismissed. Only two
were kept on — Phuoc, because he’d lost an eye working for AP, and Nick Ut
because of the Pulitzer.
AP then sent Phuoc and his family to Hong Kong and Ut to Tokyo, both on
local salaries. I was in New York at the time. Phuoc was miserable in Hong
Kong. I took him to see AP President Keith Fuller to ask for a transfer to
the U.S. Fuller turned him down. Phuoc resigned soon after and moved his
family to Southern California.
*A personal note.* After he lost his eye and married Hoa, my wife Kim-Dung
and I became close to them. The one useful thing about that Hong Kong
posting was that Phuoc and Hoa could act as a conduit for letters to and
from my wife Kim‑Dung’s family in Vietnam. Her father was in a re‑education
camp, and with the U.S. embargo even letters were blocked. They kept that
line open for us.
*Finally, the man.* Phuoc was quiet, tough, and allergic to the mythology
that grew up around the bureau. He had no time for the post‑war narratives.
He also had strong views about who actually took the “Napalm Girl” photo,
and he shared those with me years ago, including the stringer's name. When
I spoke to him in March, he was pleased the truth had finally surfaced,
though he never wanted his name attached to it.
Just adding this for the record, for those who knew him — or thought they
did.
Carl
|