THE TRIBUNE CHANDIGARH
Armed forces to get pay parity with civil services
Vijay Mohan
Tribune News Service
Chandigarh, December 23
The Principal Bench of the Armed Forces Tribunal (AFT) today allowed a
bunch of petitions seeking grant of non-functional upgradation (NFU) to all
armed forces officers on similar lines as it was implemented for civil services
in connection with the Sixth Pay Commission.
(Follow The Tribune on Facebook; and Twitter @thetribunechd)
The AFT’s order marks a turning point in a long battle for parity that saw
a lot of legal and bureaucratic wrangling. The NFU was among several issues
involving benefits and status that the armed forces wanted to be addressed.
Several issues are still to be resolved. Justice BP Katakey and Lt Gen Sanjiv
Langer said the NFU for all officers of the three services would be applicable
with effect from January 1, 2006, although the arrears would be restricted to
three years from the date of the petition.
Disposing of the petitions filed by Col Mukul Dev from the Judge Advocate
General’s Department and about 160 other officers, the Bench also directed that
in case the government decided to include NFU for civilians under the Seventh
Pay Commission, the same would also be extended to armed forces officers. The
Bench also rejected the Union of India’s prayer for leave to appeal to challenge
the order in the Supreme Court.
The NFU scheme, implemented by the UPA government in 2008, entitled IAS
officers and other Group-A officers to get pay scale of the highest promoted
officer of their batch even if they were not promoted. The affected non-promoted
officers are given the higher grade two years after their batchmates are
elevated.
Unlike civil services that have a cylindrical hierarchy, the armed forces
have a pyramid structure and many officers do not make it to the next
selection-based rank, making the issue of stagnation much more severe in the
forces.
On implementation, the NFU was not extended to the armed forces and a few
other organisations. The central armed police forces also got NFU after
intervention by the Delhi High Court.
“The judgment implies that officers of the armed forces, whose status had
been downgraded as their civilian counterpart started drawing higher salary and
grade pay, will now be restored,” Col Rajiv Manglik, the petitioner’s counsel
said. “Besides averring that the denial of NFU was unconstitutional and a
violation of the principle of equality, we had contended that the armed forces
fulfilled all six parameters laid out by the government to categorise Group-A
services.” There are several civilian cadres that do not meet all parameters but
have still been classified as Group-A services.