Feds Kill Funds for Most Successful Senior Housing Project | Alternet
John Gear
Feds Kill Funds for Most Successful Senior Housing Project
Photo Credit: Retirement Housing Foundation
When construction started in mid-October on Heritage Park Senior Village in Taylor, Michigan, it marked the end of 55 years of effort by the federal government to make sure low-income elders can live out their years in decent housing.
The development getting underway 18 miles southwest of downtown Detroit is one of the very last to be constructed under a federal housing program that dates back to 1959.
The Section 202 Supportive Housing for the Elderly Program produced 20,000 housing units per year at its peak in the 1970s. It provided public housing agencies and nonprofit groups with grants that covered the cost to build decent rental housing, as well as subsidies for people who were too poor to pay market-rate rents for comparable housing.
Obama’s Rush to Cut Funds
But three years ago, at the height of the new congressional obsession with budget cutting, the Obama Administration stopped requesting money for new construction under the program. Funding continues at a reduced level to renew existing rental subsidies on existing properties, as well as for repairs and improvements to those properties.
But federal support for new Sec. 202 construction has ended, with little prospect it will ever be revived.
It was not for lack of need, which is very great and growing substantially. It was not because there was something wrong with the program. There was not. In fact, federal officials and many of the nonprofits that sponsored Sec. 202 projects have said it was the most successful federal housing production program in history.
"There were no issues with the program," said Alayna Waldrum, who works on legislation for Leading Age, an association working on housing and other issues affecting the elderly. "The primary reason was the rush to cut as much funding as they possibly could," she added.
If you thought elders were a powerful political force because they vote, think again. Advocates say there was not a single member of Congress prepared to stick his or her neck out to rally support for new construction of Sec. 202 housing.
Like other Sec. 202 projects before it, Heritage Park Senior Village will serve households in which at least one member is age 62 or older. Residents will pay no more than 30 percent of their adjusted income on rent. The 77-unit building is being developed by Volunteers of America, which operates 149 Sec. 202 projects with 7,718 units.
Sec. 202 housing is open to households that earn no more than 50 percent of their area’s median income, and most of the tenants are dependent on Social Security for most or all of their income.
The private market no longer produces any new housing affordable to people at that income level, and much of the older housing stock that was affordable has been demolished and replaced with upscale developments.
Secure Housing Transformed Lives
The buildings the program has produced for over 50 years offer modest apartments with basic architecture. But those properties have transformed the lives of many older Americans.
Tenants of Sec. 202 have a ready community of peers so they’re rarely lonely and disconnected, a common problem for elders living alone. The tenants have well-maintained homes with security and social activities. They receive help connecting with social and health services. Most importantly, they have economic security. They no longer have to worry that their savings will run out and they’ll have nowhere to live.
No one disputes that cutting the program's funding is completely contrary to common sense. In 2002, the congressional Commission on Affordable Housing and Health Facility Needs for Seniors in the 21st Century called the shortfall of such housing a “quiet crisis.” It called for building 40,000 units per year to house the growing numbers of low-income elders. But instead of ramping up, Congress tamped down--all the way to nothing.
“The bottom line is that, with the end of new construction under Sec. 202, we are very close to the point where we will begin losing affordable seniors housing faster than it is being developed,” said Thomas Slemmer, president and CEO of Columbus, Ohio–based National Church Residences, one of the nation’s largest nonprofit providers of affordable seniors housing.
Existing Sec. 202 buildings are getting old, considering that the program began in 1959. So an increasing number of properties will be lost to obsolescence each year.
For every person who gets into a government-subsidized apartment, there are 10 households waiting for one. Demand is highest in urban areas. In places with large proportions of low-income elders, often-ethnic seniors, it’s off the charts.
“It is very hard to tell seniors in desperate need of housing that the wait in most cases is two to three years,” said Steve Protulis, executive director of the nonprofit Elderly Housing Development and Operations Corporation, based in Fort Lauderdale, Fla.
Demand Will Skyrocket
In the coming years, demand for affordable housing among low-income elders will skyrocket, said Robin Keller, vice president of real estate development for Volunteers of America. The number of older Americans is quickly increasing, and their financial resources have declined overall, she said.
The 65-plus population in the United States will leap to 55 million by 2020, up from 40 million in 2010. The number of those 85 and older will increase even more sharply by then, almost tripling from 3 million to 8.75 million.
Households headed by people 65 or more reported a median income in 2010 of $45,763. But older women living alone had a median income of only about $15,000. They are the primary users of Sec. 202 housing, and their numbers are growing.
Among Social Security beneficiaries, the average monthly benefit is $1,269, or about $14,000 per year. In almost any U.S. metropolitan area, those who rely heavily on Social Security cannot afford any housing available on the private market.
"Let's live on the planet as if we intend to stay."