Well, I've found that mormons outside the state of utah are more compassionate
and less self rightous, so even being raised LDS I can see how she would be
different than Utah mormons. It doesn't really matter if you say different,
cuz I've talked to lots of people that think Utah mormons are racist and holier
than thou in their attitudes. If you took offense at that, then that's your
problem.
Hmmm I've done a little thinking and have realized that part of the problem
lies when you let someone get you to lose your temper in some cases. Some
people like to get the person angry so they will make mistakes, cuz if they can
get some mud slinging, then they can prove themselves right. I don't know that
that is what is happening here, but I've seen all kinds of things in Utah.
Most people don't display their best attributes when they are angry. Even if
Jewel had an LDS upbringing (that might explain why in her music she chastizes
unbelievers and tells them not to stand in her way) some of her songs portray
ideals oppossite of LDS teachings. Like saying that in order to be forgiven,
you must first believe in sin... That shows more compassion than I've heard in
the LDS church in utah (in some cases) where they tend to treat people from
states like California as some kind of outsider, and I've had friends who were
made fun of at school because they weren't lds. I know not all lds people are
like that, but even when I attended church here, I knew a good brother who said
that in the church the good and bad made up a 50/50 percentage of the church,
but that god was pleased with the church as a whole. Basically, I see that on
a whole, when it comes to feeding starving people in 3rd world countries they
do pretty well, but when it comes to loving your neighbor in every day life
here where they are prosperous, they tend to slip up sometimes. I've found
that when people find out your from California or Hispanic, they tend to find
ways to drive you into saying bad things about the church as a whole, by
setting a bad example and picking on you. Like it says in the bible, you'll
find wolves in sheep's clothing among religious institutions. Not all may be
that bad, their weakness might lie in an old prejudice brought on by being
offended by someone from California or of Hispanic decent. When people act out
of anger, they sometimes overlook or forget the effect it is going to have...
and the same goes when you act out of pride and prejudice. It's times when I
am writing this stuff that I almost wish I had stayed in church and obtained a
teaching position so I could bring this to attention of members. Now, I know
what some of you reading might think...I am doing this out of spite for the
ones that have offended me. It used to be that and because I was appalled by
their actions, but now I've grown "spiritually" and I want lds people to go
down a different path than what some are being led down... I think as a
religion they are right up their in their ideals. Their idea of the three
afterlifes for people seems pretty compassionate compared to just heaven for
the really really good and hell for everyone else. Being married forever would
be nice too. I just want people to know that rules are made for the good of
man, not man for the rules. Love is the only rule...everything revolves around
that. I don't think people in leadership positions should take advantage of
young people who will react in the way many young people do, rather, they
should take compassion and realize that everyone just wants to be happy. Jesus
dined with harlots, so unless you're better than Jesus, you shouldn't go
judging people by their skin color, their hopes and all their actions. Of
course, there are extreme exceptions like child molestors, but even Jesus said
that for people who hurt little children it is better that they never had been
born. Oh, someone else you should show compassion for are atheists. They just
want to be happy too, they just need a bit more proof of god's existance than
"because I said so and you should have faith."
RISCitUT wrote:
>I found that listening to Jewels new CD was a "perfect solution" to
>racist and hypocritical mormons quite interesting only because she was
>brought up in an LDS home herself (her dad is a BYU grad.). I wonder how
>much of that has influenced her songs and poetry? Just curious.
Well, I've found that mormons outside the state of utah are more compassionate
and less self rightous, so even being raised LDS I can see how she would be
different than Utah mormons. It doesn't really matter if you say different,
cuz I've talked to lots of people that think Utah mormons are racist and holier
than thou in their attitudes. If you took offense at that, then that's your
problem.
Thank god I'm an atheist
 I am rather confused how you can thank God for anything when you don't believe in him.
Ken Laubaugh wrote:
> I found that listening to Jewels new CD was a "perfect solution" to
> racist and hypocritical mormons quite interesting only because she was
> brought up in an LDS home herself (her dad is a BYU grad.). I wonder how
> much of that has influenced her songs and poetry? Just curious.
I am very saddened to see people have so much animosity toward Utah
mormons. As a member of the LDS Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day
Saints, and a resident of the state of Utah it breaks my heart to see that
so many feel that they have been treated so badly by so many. I find myself
wanting to apologize for the behavior of others but know that will not do
anything to change any hurt that has been caused by others.
Even as a member we are all human and all have down falls, yes I do agree
that there seems to be a tendency toward self righteousness in this
community more than others, because I have experienced that myself from
others. I did not grow up in Utah and never heard of mormons until I came
here and since have been a member for 18 years. I have had my own battles
and do not consider myself any better than anyone else on the face of this
earth, but I do consider myself lucky for the opportunity to know of the
gospel and to know that it is true. I am very thankful for the chance that
I have been given to be allowed to raise my children with the knowledge of
Christ and our Father in Heaven and to show them by example that we are all
Gods children and no one man or woman is greater than any other. We all
have things that we could share with one another and teach one another
regardless of ones spiritual beliefs, wouldn't it be like paradise if
everyone felt compassion and love for one another and no one ever got
offended by others attitudes, remarks or behavior? Well Satan couldn't
stand for that so until the day of the coming of our Lord don't ever think
that you will not be offended by ones beliefs regardless of denomination.
I myself would like to apologize if you have suffered from the behavior or
attitude of another member of the Church, and please try to remember that
all people are human and all make mistakes and maybe even forget about the
basics when trying to live their religion.
Ken Laubaugh wrote:
> I found that listening to Jewels new CD was a "perfect solution" to
> racist and hypocritical mormons quite interesting only because she was
> brought up in an LDS home herself (her dad is a BYU grad.). I wonder how
> much of that has influenced her songs and poetry? Just curious.
PS. Just because someone graduated from BYU does not a Member make.
As for mud slinging, that wasn't my intention at all. I was raised in an
"East Coast" LDS home, never visiting Utah until the MTC. After my
mission I returned to Utah to attend school and found that even though I
was in the "majority", there is something different about "Utah
Mormons". Fortunately I didn't encounter the racist and hypocritical
members that others have. One thing that I remind myself is that the
Church is perfect the people aren't. It's not a "hotel for the healthy"
but a "hospital for the sick". Remember the Saviors response to the
Pharisees comment when they asked, "Why do ye eat with the publicans and
sinners?" Jesus answered," They that are whole need not a physician; but
they that are sick."
Just imagine how these people might be without religion.
Ken L wrote:
I myself am a convert, I joined after moving here in 79 from Michigan at the
age of 15. My sister who is a return missionary who served her mission here
was living here but did since move to Texas. This is the only life I know
of being LDS and you are so right about the people not being perfect, I
myself have tried to relay that message to others. We have taken youth into
our home that have been in trouble with the law and we have tried to set an
example for those who have very negative feelings toward the Church due to
the way they have been ostracized (which breaks my heart). We have also had
our share of criticism from others for taking in troubled youth but have
found that every one of the children have been very wonderful kids with no
direction. We tried to provide for them a loving atmosphere and a safe non
judgmental but very structured environment to show them that life can be
full of good choices and rewards.
I only took direction as to what you were saying because I have had several
recent conversations with those who have been turned away from the Church
because of hurt feelings. You and I both know, having our own testimony,
that the Church is perfect and the people are not.
I have found that people in general expect "mormons" to be perfect and when
they can find someone doing something wrong then they can blame the CHurch.
That just makes it easier I guess for them to hide from the truth and take
the easy way out.
I love Utah but I do continue to be saddened by the continuing put down of
Utah mormons for the simple fact that not all are the same in how they treat
others. Again as you stated, not any are perfect members, but I would like
to see more live as if they were trying to be. The stress of being a member
in Utah is greater than it is in other places, it is so taken for granted.
I am still grateful for the opportunity to raise my children here, even
though at times I consider leaving.
Don't take me wrong, there are very many many fine members and other people
as well that are very neat and kind people.
I have friends of all kind that are non-members, other denomination and even
some that have left the Church and joined others. That does not make them
bad people. It does make me so sad once again though to see others hurt so
badly that they would deny the truth, and makes me even more sad for those
who behaved in such a manner.
Where did you serve? What part of the east coast are you on? The only
other members that I have any contact with that are not here in Utah are my
sister and her children in Texas.
 Hmmm I've done a little thinking and have realized that part of the problem
lies when you let someone get you to lose your temper in some cases.
Some
people like to get the person angry so they will make mistakes, cuz if they can
get some mud slinging, then they can prove themselves right.
I don't know that
that is what is happening here, but I've seen all kinds of things in Utah.
Most people don't display their best attributes when they are angry.
Even if
Jewel had an LDS upbringing (that might explain why in her music she chastizes
unbelievers and tells them not to stand in her way) some of her songs portray
ideals oppossite of LDS teachings. Like saying that in order to be forgiven,
you must first believe in sin...
That shows more compassion than I've heard in
the LDS church in utah (in some cases) where they tend to treat people from
states like California as some kind of outsider, and I've had friends who were
made fun of at school because they weren't lds.
 I know not all lds people are
like that, but even when I attended church here, I knew a good brother who said
that in the church the good and bad made up a 50/50 percentage of the church,
but that god was pleased with the church as a whole. Basically, I see that on
a whole, when it comes to feeding starving people in 3rd world countries they
do pretty well, but when it comes to loving your neighbor in every day life
here where they are prosperous, they tend to slip up sometimes.
I've found
that when people find out your from California or Hispanic, they tend to find
ways to drive you into saying bad things about the church as a whole, by
setting a bad example and picking on you.
Like it says in the bible, you'll
find wolves in sheep's clothing among religious institutions.
Not all may be
that bad, their weakness might lie in an old prejudice brought on by being
offended by someone from California or of Hispanic decent.
When people act out
of anger, they sometimes overlook or forget the effect it is going to have...
and the same goes when you act out of pride and prejudice.
It's times when I
am writing this stuff that I almost wish I had stayed in church and obtained a
teaching position so I could bring this to attention of members.
 Now, I know
what some of you reading might think...I am doing this out of spite for the
ones that have offended me. It used to be that and because I was appalled by
their actions, but now I've grown "spiritually" and I want lds people to go
down a different path than what some are being led down... I think as a
religion they are right up their in their ideals. Their idea of the three
afterlifes for people seems pretty compassionate compared to just heaven for
the really really good and hell for everyone else. Being married forever would
be nice too. I just want people to know that rules are made for the good of
man, not man for the rules. Love is the only rule...everything revolves around
that.
 I don't think people in leadership positions should take advantage of
young people who will react in the way many young people do,
rather, they
should take compassion and realize that everyone just wants to be happy. Jesus
dined with harlots, so unless you're better than Jesus, you shouldn't go
judging people by their skin color, their hopes and all their actions.
 Of
course, there are extreme exceptions like child molestors, but even Jesus said
that for people who hurt little children it is better that they never had been
born.
Oh, someone else you should show compassion for are atheists. They just
want to be happy too, they just need a bit more proof of god's existance than
"because I said so and you should have faith."
Thank god I'm an atheist
Just imagine how these people might be without religion.
================================================
I don't know if religion helps these people sometimes. It seems that they
think religion is their "get out of jail free card" which they can use over and
over so they "sin" away and don't give it much thought, since they'll be
forgiven cuz they're going to church next sunday. I don't care if they
fornicate or drink beer, just don't be a redneck. It's a regional thing, I
understand that the lds church doesn't teach it's members to hate minorities.
It's just something you're gonna find where there are lots of ignorant hicks
and the regions of Utah and Idaho are like that. Not only do they do it out of
ignorance, but they think it's cool to put down or pick on minorities. It's a
sharp contrast when you compare them with, say, California mormons who seem to
majorly get along with everyone unless they're froma podunk little town like
Gridley. It wouldn't matter so much to me, but I came here expecting
exceptional treatment from lds members and all I got was mistreatment and it
disillusioned me greatly. I know there are members that are not like this, but
it seems that the bad ones like to make themselves more noticed and then beat
on their chest and proclaim their mormonism. I feel for the good mormons, and
I've even had a large crush on a good mormon girl but never pursued it cuz I
know she would want someone who is active, but she was always kind to me and
even gave me a ride home when she saw me at the mall one time. all I have to
say is that I feel sorry for the mormons that have to go to church with people
like that. I've found that I've had more peace by not going to church and just
enjoying friends and family. It's a shame cuz I'd like to see the cowboy types
feel proud in just liking themselves without hating other people. I guess it
would just mean a lot to me if people thought things out better and treated
each other nicer. It's just a vicious cycle...kids will learn this from their
parents or friends, and when they have kids it happens all over again. I guess
I care cuz I somehow would like to be friends with most people in utah, if only
they'd change. I've just had to many experiences where I've given people a
chance and they just stabbed me in the back. They take pride in being that
way, and if your book of mormon is right, pride is what takes a person down. I
could go on and on but I'll stop here for the time being.
Joe
RISCitUT wrote:
> You're confused at how I can thank god if I don't believe in him? Sounds like
> you're always serious. It's a joke.
> Thank god I'm an atheist
I am not always sereious about all things but about God I am very serious because
I know that he is, and maybe you should take him a lot more seroius.
Yeah.. I can see how church can be a good starting point, but I was told the
book of mormon is written at something like an 8th grade level so that everyone
can understand it. I'm a bit past that now, and I bet that sounds like pride
but I know in my heart what is right and I would like to learn other things
other than just the book of mormon. If you become spiritual, it's not good to
limit yourself to just one book, or even one faith. Life is just too
interesting to be wasted "dreaming of your mansions above." People, and that
includes me, should put their shoulder to the wheel and make something of life
here. I sometimes think about how things would be different but I plan on
doing some volunteer work or something in order to make a difference. Plans
drawn out but never read aren't going to do me any good either. Yeah, I've got
school and friends and family to worry about, but there's plenty of time in the
day to do all these things with room to spare. Anyway, I plan on teaching my
kids the same concepts as the ten commandments, just most likely not in church
cuz I don't want them to pick up any bad habits there, and the same goes for
school. I'm hoping a private school will be better than public, cuz I know how
bad a public school can get. I wish my parents had sent me to a private
school. Anyway, that's enough gabbing. Happy New Year.
It's hard to take god serious when he hasn't told me he exists. All I see are
human beings trying to run people's lives. I opt not to take it seriously, but
thanks anyway.
RISCitUT wrote:
> It's hard to take god serious when he hasn't told me he exists. All I see are
> human beings trying to run people's lives. I opt not to take it seriously, but
> thanks anyway.
> Thank god I'm an atheist
What would be the point? Why if there is a God, would he tell you that he exists,
that sure makes things hard. What I understand and believe this life to be, is a
test, not story time. If God just walked around earth and just told us what to do
all the time, that would be a marxism. Everyone loves that.
Exactly. What use would an omnipotent being have for a big ball swarming with
blindly obediant sheep?
What is the truer test of man? Being told in no uncertain terms EXACTLY what is
what, who is who, and what to do?
Or to be told nothing. Left in the dark... yet provided with colorful examples
of what is good and bad.
Sorry, folks, but I don't think the vagueness of the Holy Book is an accident,
NOR a design flaw. I believe God wants to see what each of us will do with what
little information He's provided.
Life is a test. Use the Bible as a guide, but don't read into it more than
what's there.
Mormonism's odd doctrine of having a living Prophet readily available takes
FREE CHOICE totally out of the hands of the flock.
The obediant Mormon doesn't ask questions, and doesn't need to. What's expected
of him is written in detail on the wall, and spoken by the Prophet of the day.
-Tam- (Gee it's great to be GREEN!)
You've got to be a baptist. In my long experience with religions, only
baptists treat other Christians in the manner you have. I follow the
living prophet, but not blindly. I pray and talk with God myself about
what he says and then make up my own mind. The trouble is that I have
never yet had God tell me not to do as the Prophet directs. So far so
good. Why should I re-invent the wheel when Mormon doctrine has brought
me so much peace and joy. More than I ever got from the screaming
baptists.
Take a breath, don't go green on me. Reed
"Sorry, folks, but I don't think the vagueness of the Holy Book is an
accident,
NOR a design flaw. I believe God wants to see what each of us will do
with what
little information He's provided."
That is a rather petty god you worship then. Think about it, would you
send your son or daughter away to school with only half a book and a
broken pencil? No of course not. God is willing and waiting to send you
everything you want to have and know. After all he sent his most
priceless pocession in the world, his only begotton Son to earth to die
for you. After all that, would he leave you with just "a little
information?" I don't think so.
I have spoken with God. He does live and love us and has taught me many
many things.
Reed
"Mormonism's odd doctrine of having a living Prophet readily available
takes FREE CHOICE totally out of the hands of the flock."
Of course it doesn't. God has sent Prophets since the dawn of time. If
he believed Prophets were necessary in Moses's day, David's day so on
and forever. Why would he refuse to send you a prophet for counsel and
comfort today. And don't say he's given you all you need with the few
scriptures you have. Did God say that to the early Christians in Jesus's
time. The Old Testament teaches of Christ, the Jews just didn't know it.
Had God said to the early Christians all you get is the Old Testament we
would have a dicken's of a time today understanding the New gospel
taught by our Lord. No a Prophet is a guide when you don't know which
way to turn. He is a gift of love to remember the world that God lives
and is speaking today as he always has. You just have to learn which
voice to listen to.
Tam, from your most recent responses to others, I suspect that your less
green now and more beet red. Take a breath and let's talk on.
Reed
[Some quotes from Tamzyn]:
> Exactly. What use would an omnipotent being have for a big ball
swarming with
> blindly obediant sheep?
I agree with this implied answer. Maybe it's just my ego, but I think
God has more in mind for us than to be puppets. I believe (but can't
pull up the biblical reference) that he desires us to have free will.
I'll put it this way - all over the bible, God states that mankind was
created to glorify Him (meaning God). It's pretty hollow when someone
pats you on the back because you've asked them to...it means a lot
more when someone praises you (me) because I've earned it.
> What is the truer test of man? Being told in no uncertain terms
EXACTLY what is
> what, who is who, and what to do?
Actually, I believe this isn't a test at all. Man _can't_ do right,
see the first four books of the Old Testament - somewhere in there it
states that man can't help _but_ sin, and Christ backs that up when he
says (somewhere in Matthew, I think) that nobody has _ever_ been
sinless. And that's for the things that *were* written in stone! :)
just my $.02
Earl
The crazy thing about this thread is. You are all right.
With the exception of our our aethiest friend, that is. However, if he doesn't
mess with me or my world, he too deserves my respect.
Bob
"My country is the world and my religion is to do good."
Tamzyn wrote:
Reed writes: <<You've got to be a baptist.>>Yeah Reed, there's lots of other religions out there that like attacking the Mormons....the Church of Christ, the Methodists, the Catholics, the Jehova's Witnesses, they all rip on us (cause they feel so threatened and have nothing better to do - oops thats me)Sorry, guess again.
<<In my long experience with religions, only
baptists treat other Christians in the manner you have.>>
Once again Reed, noth true. =) Let's not generalize about Baptists. Most of my buddies growin up were Baptists and they treated me with a lot of respect.
What manner is that, Reed? Which one accused the other of ignorance? Which of
us accused the other of not being able to take the heat? Look to yourself,
Reed, before you accuse me of throwing stones.You're so defensive Tamzyn! Reed, he ain't ignerant, he's jsut convinced another way and hear too many Mormons have Horns stories.
Admittedly, I often toss out for discussion what I perceive to be the mostNothin. But Tamzyn....respond to my Baptist irony a little further down the thread....don't you agree with those guys? Inform me if I'm wrong.
blatant of Mormonism's ironies. What's so awful about that?
You go on to write: <<I pray and talk with God myself about what he says and
then make up my own mind. The trouble is that I have never yet had God tell me
not to do as the Prophet directs.>>
I've never had God tell ME not to do what I believe in either... so tacking
your tack, I guess I'm headed down the right path, eh?
C'mon Tamzyn....you just spent forever tellin' us that you don't believe that God will speak to us after the Bible times. Of course he gonna open to you if you don't knock! Get my meaning?
Tamzyn wrote:
Backtracking, I wrote: <<"Sorry, folks, but I don't think the vagueness of the
Holy Book is an accident, NOR a design flaw. I believe God wants to see what
each of us will do with what little information He's provided.">>
Tamzyn, you really believe that man has free will? That surprises me. I thought you were traditionalist Christian. Don't you guys believe in predestination? But I agree with your statement that man can "develop"...heh. You got the makings of a good Mormon and you don't even know it!To which Reed commented: <<That is a rather petty god you worship then.>>
Petty? How so? The God I worship has given mankind the tools necessary to
develop (individually) into an honest, decent, caring human being, yet has
also, in the spirit of every individual's impression of what the Bible means,
offered mankind free will.
What better way to judge humanity's TRUE essence?How true! what is our true essence by the way?
Reed writes: <<Think about it, would you
send your son or daughter away to school with only half a book and a broken
pencil?>>
Your analogy is flawed, Reed. The Bible (to Traditional Christianity, that is)
is all we need, education wise. The entire material needed to produce the
humans that God wants us to evolve into is in there, and then some.
Did you say evolve? ; )Just kiddin...I'm gonna throw the traditional Mormon response at'cha, it is sufficient for me:
Read the whole chapter until your ears start to smoke....
Â
Maybe not for you Mo's... but certainly for the rest of Christianity.
Sticks and Stones...... =)
Tamzyn wrote:
Reed writes: <<Tam, from your most recent responses to others, I suspect that
your less
green now and more beet red. Take a breath and let's talk on.>>
Yeah Reed what in the world are you talkin about?What? Where is this coming from? ROTF! I'm a far cry from red, Reed. In fact,
I'm not NEAR as tan as I'd like to be...
Sorry Reed if you're under the mistaken impression that this "conversation"MO's? Now, now......keep the facts straight.
here has my knickers in a twist. Remember, I'm not the one who's been upset
enough to resort to namecalling and making fun of people's signatures. Ahem...
I think that was you.
Tamzyn wrote:
Eric writes: <<Yeah Reed, there's lots of other religions out there that like
attacking the
Mormons....the Church of Christ, the Methodists, the Catholics, the Jehova's
Witnesses, they all rip on us (cause they feel so threatened and have nothing
better to do - oops thats me)>>
ROFL! You've been spouting off "traditionalist christian" teachings since I've first seen your posts and now youre not representing religion?? (on the floor, again....)Sorry to disappoint you fella's, but there's no conspiracy here. I don't
represent religion in particular.
Furthermore, never have I read any Catholic or Baptist or Methodist materialWell then read some, its out all over the place...just cause you haven't read it (I doubt you though) doesn't mean it doesn't exist. And yep you're right....lotsa other religions get persecuted, I never said they dont.
that rips on the Mormons. Witnesses rip on all non-Witness religions, so don't
flatter yourself into thinking Mo's are alone in persecution there.
The LDS "religion" is being questioned here, by me, one itty bitty person.Ok then lets talk about the theologia, RESPOND TO MY PREVIOUS STATEMENTS! : ) Quit stallin... =) Sorry by the way......I thought you were a guy before...
That's all. I have questions and observations about what I perceive to be a
whopper of a big business, wrapped in the cloak of theologia.
Â
You can play along, or you can use your kill file. It's that simple.
Tamzyn wrote:
Eric writes: <<Tamzyn, you really believe that man has free will? That
surprises me. I thought
you were traditionalist Christian. Don't you guys believe in predestination?>>
I don't know about the "guys," Eric, but I don't. However, it might be a good
idea if you were to delve a tad more into Christianity's basic principles,
kiddo.
Ok kidette, enlighten me... =)
<< But I agree with your statement that man can "develop"...heh. You got the
makings of a
good Mormon and you don't even know it!>>Eric
ROTF! You know, Eric you're right. The way your "Prophets" have a knack for
waffling on Doctrine, who knows? Perhaps one of these days, one of them will
decree God really IS a woman, only WOMEN are allowed in the priesthood, and
reverse Polygamy is the WAY TO GO (I myself could use at least 2 more hubbies).
 Then I just might CONVERT!!!!By golly, Eric... I think you're ON to something!
Want some syrup with those waffles?? Postulation is a boooooring argument =)
Tamzyn wrote:
Eric asks me: <<How true! what is our true essence by the way?>>"Our?"
In the context of my post, "true essence" is an individual thing, Eric. You
know, sort of the meaty part of your soul, that God takes a look at, and
decides whether you were what he was looking for when he created the
brotherhood of mankind...He could say, perhaps:
"Wow, you took that little info I gave you and made me proud. You loved your
fellow man, you helped those in need, you taught your kids honesty, and to love
humanity and to never make fun of others. You worked hard, were honest in
thought and deed. You told it like you saw it, and held your ground. You, dear
Tam, were a FINE specimen."or he could say
"You. You went to church every Sunday. You didn't give much time or money to
charity, but you did serve that mission to Bolivia, and you did pay your
tithing regularly, and you DID get your temple recommend. You've always done
your church assignments with aplomb, so here you go, bud. Here's your stairway
to heaven."Food for thought.
Sorry, guess again.
<<In my long experience with religions, only
baptists treat other Christians in the manner you have.>>
What manner is that, Reed? Which one accused the other of ignorance? Which of
us accused the other of not being able to take the heat? Look to yourself,
Reed, before you accuse me of throwing stones.
Admittedly, I often toss out for discussion what I perceive to be the most
blatant of Mormonism's ironies. What's so awful about that?
You go on to write: <<I pray and talk with God myself about what he says and
then make up my own mind. The trouble is that I have never yet had God tell me
not to do as the Prophet directs.>>
I've never had God tell ME not to do what I believe in either... so tacking
your tack, I guess I'm headed down the right path, eh?
To which Reed commented: <<That is a rather petty god you worship then.>>
Petty? How so? The God I worship has given mankind the tools necessary to
develop (individually) into an honest, decent, caring human being, yet has
also, in the spirit of every individual's impression of what the Bible means,
offered mankind free will.
What better way to judge humanity's TRUE essence?
Reed writes: <<Think about it, would you
send your son or daughter away to school with only half a book and a broken
pencil?>>
Your analogy is flawed, Reed. The Bible (to Traditional Christianity, that is)
is all we need, education wise. The entire material needed to produce the
humans that God wants us to evolve into is in there, and then some.
Maybe not for you Mo's... but certainly for the rest of Christianity.
-Tam- (Gee it's great to be GREEN!)
What? Where is this coming from? ROTF! I'm a far cry from red, Reed. In fact,
I'm not NEAR as tan as I'd like to be...
Sorry Reed if you're under the mistaken impression that this "conversation"
here has my knickers in a twist. Remember, I'm not the one who's been upset
enough to resort to namecalling and making fun of people's signatures. Ahem...
I think that was you.
-Tam- (Gee it's great to be GREEN!)
Sorry to disappoint you fella's, but there's no conspiracy here. I don't
represent religion in particular.
Furthermore, never have I read any Catholic or Baptist or Methodist material
that rips on the Mormons. Witnesses rip on all non-Witness religions, so don't
flatter yourself into thinking Mo's are alone in persecution there.
The LDS "religion" is being questioned here, by me, one itty bitty person.
That's all. I have questions and observations about what I perceive to be a
whopper of a big business, wrapped in the cloak of theologia.
You can play along, or you can use your kill file. It's that simple.
I don't know about the "guys," Eric, but I don't. However, it might be a good
idea if you were to delve a tad more into Christianity's basic principles,
kiddo.
<< But I agree with your statement that man can "develop"...heh. You got the
makings of a
good Mormon and you don't even know it!>>Eric
ROTF! You know, Eric you're right. The way your "Prophets" have a knack for
waffling on Doctrine, who knows? Perhaps one of these days, one of them will
decree God really IS a woman, only WOMEN are allowed in the priesthood, and
reverse Polygamy is the WAY TO GO (I myself could use at least 2 more hubbies).
Then I just might CONVERT!!!!
By golly, Eric... I think you're ON to something!
-Tam- (Gee it's great to be GREEN!)
"Our?"
In the context of my post, "true essence" is an individual thing, Eric. You
know, sort of the meaty part of your soul, that God takes a look at, and
decides whether you were what he was looking for when he created the
brotherhood of mankind...
He could say, perhaps:
"Wow, you took that little info I gave you and made me proud. You loved your
fellow man, you helped those in need, you taught your kids honesty, and to love
humanity and to never make fun of others. You worked hard, were honest in
thought and deed. You told it like you saw it, and held your ground. You, dear
Tam, were a FINE specimen."
or he could say
"You. You went to church every Sunday. You didn't give much time or money to
charity, but you did serve that mission to Bolivia, and you did pay your
tithing regularly, and you DID get your temple recommend. You've always done
your church assignments with aplomb, so here you go, bud. Here's your stairway
to heaven."
Food for thought.
-Tam- (Gee it's great to be GREEN!)
Eric, you think I'm slamming Mormons by using the abbreviation "Mo's?" I'd say
that's GRASPING, wouldn't you?
"Find God?" Is He hiding in the pantry? Was He lost?
Â
Tamzyn wrote:
>What is the truer test of man? Being told in no uncertain terms EXACTLY what is
>what, who is who, and what to do?
>Or to be told nothing. Left in the dark... yet provided with colorful examples
>of what is good and bad.
>Sorry, folks, but I don't think the vagueness of the Holy Book is an accident,
>NOR a design flaw. I believe God wants to see what each of us will do with what
>little information He's provided.
>Life is a test. Use the Bible as a guide, but don't read into it more than
>what's there.
>Mormonism's odd doctrine of having a living Prophet readily available takes
>FREE CHOICE totally out of the hands of the flock.
Â>The obediant Mormon doesn't ask questions, and doesn't need to. What's expected
>of him is written in detail on the wall, and spoken by the Prophet of the day.
Ok I can't argu with that dumb statement because it is a generalization. Its like me saying, the newsgroup writing Tamzyn doesn know how to logically put together feasible arguments. Thats bullcrap. I'm an obediant Mormon (sometimes- hehe) and so are my parents. Growing up I went to other churches all the time and my father encouraged it because he knew the truth would stand up on its own. I was taught to think on my own and came to my own conclusions. Of course I was influenced and gently guided by my parents, but my parents are some of the most objective, non-biased people I have ever met. As a result I have made lots of mistakes in my life without them judging me for them, but always stating what they thought was right. To say that good mormons dont ask question and are just sticks in the mud is like saying all black people are prone to steal your wallet. RACIST! okokok I was just kidding but I think you get my point.
Tamzyn wrote:
Eric answered: << Ok kidette, enlighten me... =)>>
Well, I've started already, but I suppose you missed it. I'll reiterate:
1. There is no such thing as "Catholic law."
2. Traditional Christians believe in one (1) God, whose creational talents
extend far beyond the planet Earth.
3. Traditional Christians believe the ONE God can (and has been known to)
manifest itself as a human (Jesus) and as a spirit (the Holy Ghost, or Holy
Spirit). This manifestation can occur simultaneously in two or three forms.
Cool, huh!
4. Jesus died on the cross for all of mankind.
5. We do NOT believe that Adam had to fail, so that man might live. In fact, we
believe that God had every hope that the poor sop would pass the test.
6. No Traditional Christian religious organizations keep track of tithes. You
pay what you feel you can. Period. No gentle nudges from the ward clerk (well,
T.C.R.'s don't have ward clerks, but you know what I mean.), no denial of
admittance to Holy Rites on the basis of how much you've coughed up this year.
7. More than a few Traditional Christians (no religion in particular, mind you)
have been known to consider the LDS Church to be the Antichrist. (The
Antichrist will come in the name of Christ. As Mormons have been known harp,
"Christ IS in the name of our church!)
'Nuff said.
Eric, althought I'd LOVE to be able to stay up all night and day posting here,
I do have a life, and I have kids to raise. So if I'm not as quick to rebutt
your arguments, hang in there, bub. I'll get to it.. eventually.
I can't respond to them until I read them. BTW... I'm NOT a guy.
So what are you saying, Eric? I must proclaim my creed before I can discuss a
topic? I have news for ya, Eric. One doesn't have to be ANY religion to be able
to discuss it. Honest. It's a generic enough subject, EVERYBODY has an opinion
on it. Even the non-believers.
Suffice it to say I represent the multitudes of non-Mormons living in Utah.
We're all denominations, and NO denomination. We're devout Catholics, Jews, and
Protestants. Some of us are agnostics, and a few of us are Athiests. I speak
for any... for all who want me to. Heck, I'll even speak for those that
don't. <weg>
To which Eric replied: <<Well then read some, its out all over the place...just
cause you haven't read it (I doubt you though) doesn't mean it doesn't exist.>>
I disagree. Catholic literature slamming Mormons is NOT all over the place.
Baptist & Methodist literature slamming Mormons is NOT all over the place. It's
possible, if one were to go to the church, and ASK for information regarding
Mormons, those churches might have a pamphlet or something, but one would have
to go OUT OF THEIR WAY in order to find it.
On the other hand... How far out of my way to I have to go to hear (from the
Mormons) how EVIL Traditional Christianity is? I don't have to leave my house.
All's I gotta do is BE here when the missionaries & the home teachers drop by.
What? Who? Prophets and messengers? WHO? There were no messengers! There were
no prophets. There were only what few Apostles that managed to stay alive.
>How far out of my way to I have to go to hear (from the
>Mormons) how EVIL Traditional Christianity is? I don't have to leave my house.
>All's I gotta do is BE here when the missionaries & the home teachers drop by.
Yeah, of course you're right...the LDS missionaries are taught that the best way to
1st approach people when they come to their door is to tell them how evil their
church is. Its the proven way to get people to warmly invite you into their homes,
and the MTC endorses this way fully. As a matter of fact, thats always how I did my
door approach when I was a missionary. My bad...............Like ANYONE believes
that statement Tamzyn. LOL.
> Tamzyn wrote:
> >I disagree. Catholic literature slamming Mormons is NOT all over the place.
> >Baptist & Methodist literature slamming Mormons is NOT all over the place. It's
> >possible, if one were to go to the church, and ASK for information regarding
> >Mormons, those churches might have a pamphlet or something, but one would have
> >to go OUT OF THEIR WAY in order to find it.
>
> Those churches do have lots of information slamming the LDS church. Including
> full length Videos, and Books. If you go into an LDS church and ask for
> information about the Baptists they wont have anything for you. The LDS church
> spends its time in a more Christian manner because they focus on preaching and
> living their own doctrine. Whereas my Baptist and Methodist buddies attended 5
> days every summer at youth conference in a class that specifically preached
> AGAINST the mormons. There have never been any classes in an LDS church whose
> sole purpose was to tear another church down. At least I've never heard the
> sunday school president say "and for the 'How to Witness to Baptists class' it
> will be in room 15E"
Now for what I said:
....at......many.....points......BEFORE......the.....century.....right......after......Christs......death...............
Points (of time....I didnt think I'd have to spell it out for you) of time before
the century after Christs death encompasses the time from Adam the year 100 AD.
There were MANY Prophets and Messengers from God during that timespan...you can
read about them in the Bible. Now if you wanna split hairs about this crap, then go
ahead, but I'm not going to indulge such ignorance by any more explanations about
what I meant. I know what YOU mean when I read it, and I get what you are trying to
say even though you may not spell it out - because I am a sentient rational human
being. Please dont show off your ignorance by making dumb statements like the one
you made below. I want a good discussion....so lets talk about modern day
revelation....you think its possible?
Tamzyn wrote:
> Eric writes: <<at many points before the century right after Christs' death did
> God have prophets and messengers receiving revelation here on earth. >>
>
> What? Who? Prophets and messengers? WHO? There were no messengers! There were
> no prophets. There were only what few Apostles that managed to stay alive.
>
Tamzyn wrote:
> >1. There is no such thing as "Catholic law."
What an astute observation. I think you know what Reed meant. He wasnt talking
about Catholic Priests giving out Parking Tickets!! However the law is defined as a
set of rules. And Catholics have all of theirs written down in something called a
Catechism. I think you know what Reed meant to say. You do this stuff over and over
and over...you just pick a word that has 2 or more definitions and pick the
definiton that makes the speaker sound like he/she was wrong in saying the
statement. You and Bill Clinton should talk about the word "is", you guys would
have quite a bit to talk about....
>
>
> >2. Traditional Christians believe in one (1) God, whose creational talents
> >extend far beyond the planet Earth.
Ok so you're wrong about one God....I believe that there are many Gods....whats
your point? (yes I'm leaving that one open to your inevitable twisting...even
though you know exactly how I mean what I'm saying now...maybe not...surprise me.)
> >3. Traditional Christians believe the ONE God can (and has been known to)
> >manifest itself as a human (Jesus) and as a spirit (the Holy Ghost, or Holy
> >Spirit). This manifestation can occur simultaneously in two or three forms.
> >Cool, huh!
Ya thats pretty cool. YOUR God sounds like a schizo when he prays to himself, and
asks himself to deliever himself, and descends upon himself. You know when Jesus is
praying to imself in the Garden, he asks himself to make all the apostles one
person just like he is. Hmmmm.........I'm trying to imagine that conglomeration of
bodies and personalities all in one place. Its a good thing he didn't answer
himself right then because things could have gotten messy.
> >4. Jesus died on the cross for all of mankind.
No you don't. You ain't foolin noone here.
> >5. We do NOT believe that Adam had to fail, so that man might live. In fact, we
> >believe that God had every hope that the poor sop would pass the test.
Really? Ok I have some questions about that one so that we can continue this
thread: Why did God hope that Adam would succeed? What was he hoping to accomplish?
AND...why did God create Adam in the 1st place?
> >6. No Traditional Christian religious organizations keep track of tithes. You
> >pay what you feel you can. Period. No gentle nudges from the ward clerk (well,
> >T.C.R.'s don't have ward clerks, but you know what I mean.), no denial of
> >admittance to Holy Rites on the basis of how much you've coughed up this year.
True....traditional christian organizations make ministries that get on the tube
and try every psychological trick know to man to get you to send some money to
them. Thats alot better.
And yes you're right...traditional christian churches don't have any holy
rites....wait...that makes your point moot! If Christian churches dont have holy
rites then they CANT deny their people admittance! You might wanna talk apples to
apples here. hehe ok I'm just givin you some of your word games back. In any case,
there's plenty of scriptures that indicate that
1. God in the past set up a religious organization, and
2. That tithes and offering were expected of God's church. There was no paid
clergy, or people that used the money for their own gain (many of your T.C.
preachers out there make a living out of praching to us) Mormons have a word for
that : Priestcraft = preaching to make money for personal gain.
> >7. More than a few Traditional Christians (no religion in particular, mind you)
> >have been known to consider the LDS Church to be the Antichrist. (The
> >Antichrist will come in the name of Christ. As Mormons have been known harp,
> >"Christ IS in the name of our church!)
>
OOOOOOOHHH! And because they are T.C.'s, what they say goes right? If you are a
"traditional Christian" then of course God endows you with the ability to spot
Anti-Christs from miles away!! And the BIG qualifier is that they have to come in
the name of Christ! That clears it all up for me!
And now she comes up with the E=MC2 whopper of 'em all! Mormons represent
Christ...AND they have Christ in the name of their church....ERGO....they are the
ANTICHRIST!!!! That's brilliant!!! I bow to your superior logic and cower in the
corner. ROFL! Please stop I can't take it anymore! I was just about to give up my
faith for that one. Mercy!
Lets talk some more about points 3, 5, and 6. I think those might be better.
> >'Nuff said.
Futuresboy wrote:
> Oh Eric M of the big planet,
>
> You would do yourself well to feel fuzzy once in a while.
> Me being on my lazy butt has got nothing to do with finding God. It does
> however, explain why I am 20 lbs overweight.
> I happen to believe we will all see God when we are dead. So I hope you are
> right, and that for me, it isn't anytime soon. Thanks for the kind words and
> the vote of confidence.
Tamzyn wrote:
I don't try to lay any guilt trips on anybody. I'm as human and imperfect as
the next guy.
With no more or no less leverage of attaining euphoric eternity than yourself.
We are equal and we are brothers.
Mine is not to convince you to live my way. Mine is simply to rejoice for my
opportunity at living, and to make the most of it in my own way.
Mormonism, in my opinion is a fine religion. Taken on it's merits, it's as
good and moral a way of life as I could lead, or even as good as our green
friend could lead. Just remember,
knowing what's right doesn't mean much unless you do what's right.
You guys keep up the healthy exchanges, it's good for us all, and If you don't
mind, I think I will "moderate" from my easy chair. You two be nice now. And
don't forget, the best way to knock a chip off someone's shoulder is to
pat the person on the back.
Eric wrote back: <<Ok so you're wrong about one God....I believe that there are
many Gods...>>
Oh I see, Eric. Because you disagree with Traditional Christianity's beliefs
in the sole deity, that makes YOU right, and ME wrong.
<<.whats your point?>> Eric
My point? You asked me to enlighten you about Traditional Christian beliefs. So
when I did, you blasted me for not talking about what YOU wanted me to talk
about. I thought I was.
To which Eric commented:<<No you don't. You ain't foolin noone here.>>
Eric, Traditional Christian religions do NOT believe Jesus died only for
Christians. If that's what you've been taught by your Mormon teachers, they
either lied, or did NOT know what they were talking about. Christians
(traditional variety) are taught that Jesus died for all mankind. Period.
Eric replied: <<Really? Ok I have some questions about that one so that we can
continue this thread: Why did God hope that Adam would succeed? What was he
hoping to accomplish? AND...why did God create Adam in the 1st place?>>
God hoped Adam would succeed (meaning, refrain from eating the forbidden fruit)
for the same reason I hope my 13 year old will not watch TV after school until
her homework is done. It won't kill her if she watches it, but I'm trusting
and counting on her not to.
What did he want to accomplish? Who knows for sure, but from a parent's point
of view, simply telling his "child" not to do it, in hopes that he won't, is
quite common. Perhaps it's a measure of trust, or of growth. Who knows for
sure?
Why did God create Adam? Something to do, perhaps? Lab experiment? He needed to
start somewhere, in order to reach perfection (woman) he started with
imperfection (man). Ha ha! You DID ask!
Amazing, Eric. Now who's twisting words? Never did I say that LDS missionaries
blast religions the minute they answer the door. I simply said I don't have to
go anywhere to hear traditional religions slammed...
I HAVE been told by missionaries in my own home that Catholicism is evil, that
the Bible is flawed, that wearing a cross is despicable. YOU may have never
told a prospective convert such, but trust me, it's done. All in the comfort of
one's own home. No need to go find a handbill.
Hmmm, and you're so well versed on Anno Domini proselytizing, eh?
Perhaps you Mormons call the Apostles messengers (Hey... why not? You call your
church presidents "Prophets."). As far as I know, T.C.'s don't.
They were instructed (by Christ) to go forth and baptize, but once Christ's 40
day's of post ressurection fun was up, they no longer had their direct "line"
to God.
Gee Eric I'm so glad I have you to draw pictures for me. Now, lemme see if I
can do the same for you.
As far as I'm concerned, ALL of the Biblical Prophets were confined to the O.T.
Some might argue that Jesus should be included amongst them, but I, feeling
that Jesus was a manifestation of God, don't actually consider Jesus to be a
Prophet. My old Sunday School teacher, however, would probably WHOP me for
that.
Oh, by the way, Eric... I want to commend you for your typical Mormonish
handling of the discussion. You're doing an exemplary job, reacting in
predictable, mean, snide, Holier-Than-Thou fashion. You'd make ol' Brigham
proud, I'm sure.
There were MANY Prophets and Messengers from God during that timespan...you can
read about them in the Bible. Now if you wanna split hairs about this crap,
then go
ahead, but I'm not going to indulge such ignorance by any more explanations
about
what I meant. I know what YOU mean when I read it, and I get what you are
trying to
say even though you may not spell it out - because I am a sentient rational
human
being. Please dont show off your ignorance by making dumb statements like the
one
you made below. I want a good discussion....so lets talk about modern day
revelation....you think its possible?
-Tam- (Gee it's great to be GREEN!)
Tamzyn wrote:
Futuresboy wrote:
Yes only Mormons in their ignorance would refer to an Apostle as a"messenger".
Just admit that all you do to win an argument is twist people's words instead of
actually responding to their point.
> >They were instructed (by Christ) to go forth and baptize, but once Christ's 40
> >day's of post ressurection fun was up, they no longer had their direct "line"
> >to God.
Is this supposed to prove that they were not messengers????
> About 70% of your arguments end up with some emotional response. If you spend all
> your life not liking something....based on your emotional response to it, you are
> going to have problems.
I'm beginning to think that you are one of those people that agree or disagree with
an idea based upon whether or not you like the messenger. If he/she rubs you the
right way then is it ok to disregard reason and accept what they have to say based
on a gut feeling? Is it ok to say something is wrong if the situation is switched?
Excepting, revelation from God, I think that logic should triumph over emotional
judgements. Jesus wasn't a good looking or charismatic guy, and he didn't
sugar-coat his words to the pharisees and sadducees.
I think that the ability to step out of one's emotional state, predjudices, and
environmental factors and examine an idea on a logical basis is a rare trait that
will serve a person greatly if fostered.
There is no such thing as a typical Mormon Tamzyn. If you generalize on our
beliefs, that is a genralization I can accept, but the crap you're spouting off up
there just doesn't fly. I'm not going to argue with you if all I'm going to get
from you is attempts to emotionally dominate me. =) So, ONCE again, gimme some
scriptural....logical...argument about why you believe that modern revelation is
not possible, feasible, etc...
Tamzyn wrote:
Tamzyn wrote:
Tamzyn wrote:
This looks to be yet another vain attempt of yours to put words in my mouth.
Never have I said or implied that "Mormons" are ignorant, Eric. I think the
premise of the Church is faulty, and the Doctrine is well... questionable. But
I'm entitled.
The majority of the Mormon people I know, however, are good, clean, intelligent
people, whom I'm happy to call friends.
So what if I don't like their choice of religion? So what if they don't like
MINE?
No, it wasn't. And I don't believe that I indicated it was.
I think if God had known FOR SURE that Adam would eat the fruit, he wouldn't
have been so hard on him. For in my opinion, it would have been a "set up,"
and God would have been sadistic to punish the two the way he did, had he KNOWN
all along they would not choose to eat it.
In other words, I believe Adam had "free will" from the moment he was created.
Your version would have denied that to him, for if God never intended Adam to
be able to resist, then that shoots free will totally out of the equation.
Look again, Eric. That's not what I said. I said (and I quote) "I want to
commend you (Eric) for your typical Mormonish handling of the discussion."
Which, by the way, is right on the money. I've been in many, many heated
discussions on this topic, Eric, (in many net forums) and the opposition
(Mormons who believe that ALL other religions are the spawn of a flawed gospel)
does, when backed into a corner, get MEAN, SNIDE, and Holier than thou in their
attitude.
Looks like once y'all realize that you haven't got a leg to stand on
argumentatively, you turn on your pompous, snide button, and let 'er rip.
Thank the Lord you're in the minority.
A joke? Aren't jokes supposed to be funny?
Well now whe know what Reed's been busy doing.... !
Your blanket statement has a ring of truth, Reed, but that's all... just a
ring. True, SOME "Christians" believed God was God, Jesus was a man, and the
Holy Spirit was a separate spirit. (Note: they did NOT believe they were 3
GODS. They believed Jesus was HUMAN).
True, Constantine was responsible for the pow-wow that delivered to
Christianity the Nicene Creed. But again, I believe at the time a decision HAD
to be made. They wondered... were they 3 in one, or not? We'd best make a
decision PRONTO!
Unlike Mormons, Christianity at the time had no direct "line" to God... so the
Catholic Cardinals & all the other fat cats got together to set some semblance
of rules.
Apparently, at the time, they thought there was far more evidence that
God/Jesus/H.G. were three in one. And... since they all were alive much much
closer to Jesus's days here on earth than the Mormon Church's past leaders, I'm
inclined to put my money on THEM, and NOT brother Brigham's perception.
Pardon my sarcasm, but.... Reed... What planet are you from????
I made a boo boo. I meant to write "God would have been sadistic to punish the
two the way he did, had he KNOWN all along that they would choose TO eat it."
Ummmm.....if anyone here honestly reviews the arguments before they will note, I
have at many times tried to call you back to a logical discussion. I have tried to
suggest various doctrinal topics. All I ever heard from you is "some mormons were
mean to me" and most mormons this and typical mormons that.
With which doctrinal point you made did you rip my legs out from under me Tamzyn?
=)
Eric
>
>
> Thank the Lord you're in the minority.
> >Your blanket statement has a ring of truth, Reed, but that's all... just a
> >ring. True, SOME "Christians" believed God was God, Jesus was a man, and the
> >Holy Spirit was a separate spirit. (Note: they did NOT believe they were 3
> >GODS. They believed Jesus was HUMAN).
I think you need to qualify that statement. From what I read in the Bible it seems
that the Apostles thought that Jesus was the Messiah. The Messiah was the Son of
God. This is what they preached. The old testament identifies the promised savior
as Jevovah in many instances. If Christ is the Messiah then he is Jehova which then
makes him the God of the Old Testament.
> >True, Constantine was responsible for the pow-wow that delivered to
> >Christianity the Nicene Creed. But again, I believe at the time a decision HAD
> >to be made. They wondered... were they 3 in one, or not? We'd best make a
> >decision PRONTO!
> Ok, but they did this without the consent from God as you yourself say. Churches
> commissioned of men abound today. Churches commissioned of men are prone to the
> errors are interpretations of men. Eternal truths come from God. We assume that
> Paul received revelation from the Lord. And from his epistles we see that he had
> to go back many times to his various flocks to correct them after he had left. To
> keep the doctrine being taught true, Paul had to make corrections several times.
> Now those guys were even closer to Christs time. Additionally a time of apostasy
> was prophecied by Paul. Now the question is when this apostasy happened. With the
> creation of the Catholic church? Or with the creation of the Lutheran church? Is
> it still coming? In the light that incorrect doctrine was already creeping into
> the congregations of the church during Paul's lifetime.....I find it reasonable
> that after the last apostles were killed could be the time that the apostasy
> started. Catholics would probably say that it was at the time of Luther. Since
> you think that the Catholic church was made of men not in touch with God
> ("Christianity at the time had no direct "line" to God") then I think that you
> should give this line of reasoning some credence.....What do you think?
> >Unlike Mormons, Christianity at the time had no direct "line" to God... so the
> >Catholic Cardinals & all the other fat cats got together to set some semblance
> >of rules.
> >Apparently, at the time, they thought there was far more evidence that
> >God/Jesus/H.G. were three in one. And... since they all were alive much much
> >closer to Jesus's days here on earth than the Mormon Church's past leaders, I'm
> >inclined to put my money on THEM, and NOT brother Brigham's perception.
So you are betting that the founders of the Catholic church had it right....
The trinity is a vague and mysterious doctrine that was formulated during the
fourth century.
Three Persons in one body? Jesus prays to himself? Talks to himself? Stephen has a
vision of Jesus standing at the right hand of the Father? If that concept, put in
basic terms, sounds confusing, the flowery language in the actual text of the
doctrine lends even more mystery to the matter:
"...we worship one God in Trinity, and Trinity in Unity...for there is one Person
of the Father, another of the Son, another of the Holy Ghost is all one...they are
not
three gods, but one God...the whole three persons are co-eternal and co-equal...he
therefore that will be saved must thus think of the Trinity..." (excerpts from the
Athanasian Creed).
Let's put this together in a different form: one person, God the Father + one
person, God the Son, + one person, God the Holy Ghost = one person, God the What?
Is this English or is this gibberish?
Corinthians 14:33 states that "... God is not the author of confusion ..."
It is said that Athanasius, the bishop who formulated this doctrine, confessed that
the more he wrote on the matter, the less capable he was of clearly expressing his
thoughts regarding it.
The doctrine of the trinity was debated...and thats all it is, a doctrine that is
the result of a debate amongst men. Men you yourself admitted that had no direct
line to God.
I can see no sense I believing a doctrine that CLEARLY is the result of a vote
among imperfect men. The only kind of doctrine that I can even give a second glance
if doctrine from the Lord. And how had God always given us his word? Prophets,
apostles, who are messengers. Since you are so loath to admit them let me list
some....Noah, Abraham, Moses, Isaiah, Christ himself, Peter, Paul....and after the
apostles there was an apostasy. Is it so hard to believe that God, if he had a
message for us today would give it to us through a prophet? Thats the way he's
always done it!
Seems sensible to me. The belief that God said it all in the Bible doesn't make
sense to me because circumstances change. We are Not facing the same problems we
had back in biblical times. Stating that the Bible "has it all" is not only: 1.
Illlogical- We know that there were many other books written, and once again a
"debate of men" decided which books would comprise "the good book". There were tons
of other writings. The bible does not have it all.
2. Unscriptural- The bible does not ever say that any books written after these
books are of the devil or wrong. I'd like you to find some scriptures supporting
this view if you can. There just simply aren't any. There are a couple of
scriptures however that I'm hoping you will throw out at me. ; P
Lets say God wanted to send a flood to wipe us all out today, but lets say he
wanted to warn us....could he? Can God make decisions after the year 100AD? Can he
speak to us? I know I'm postulating so you can ignore this comment if you
want...but I still feel that it is a logical point.
I still think that scriptures, prophets, answers to prayers, miracles, are just too
hard for our faithless generation to accept. The bible makes it nice and easy for
you. you do not have to exercise any faith. I know that living by faith is not an
easy thing to do...but I believe...and I believe God still can speak to us today.
He really has answered my prayers many times...that doesnt prove to me that the LDS
church is true, but it does prove that he can and DOES speak to us...independently
of the bible. We have individual needs and concerns....Ah damn I ramble... =)
While on your voyage of discovery to Orlando, be sure to stop in at Disney
World. But do stay out of the water, there's lots of sharks out there too.
I know you are saving your comments for greener pastures, but I would like to
leave you with my last message to you if I may.
Do not take life too seriously--you will never get out of it alive.
All the best to you too Reed.
My life experiences have taught me, one cannot collect all the beautiful shells
on the beach.
"All you ever heard?" I made reference to the fact that once, missionaries
told me Catholicism was evil, and that all other religions were a fraud. I
never (repeat: NEVER) wrote that "some mormons were mean to me." Once again,
you haven't been paying attention.
<<With which doctrinal point you made did you rip my legs out from under me
Tamzyn?>>Eric
Take your pick:
The non-existance of archaeological evidence of anything MO in the Western
Hemisphere.
The fact that Brigham Young had over 50 wives.
The fact that Orson Pratt's (and other dead leaders) written "stuff" is
considered to be accurate, yet it's not actively "taught" and thus you (the
person taking the LDS's postition) may disregard it if it contradicts whatever
point you're trying to make at the time.
The fact that Mormons aspire to be Gods and Goddesses.
The fact that Mormons believe Adam HAD to fail... that God knew he would, for
He planned on Adams failure to create humankind as we now know it. (When it
would have saved him and Adam alot of heartache if he'd just have created
humankind that way in the FIRST place, since according to you thats where he
was headed anyway). Like I said... YOUR version of God just doesn't think
ahead.
The fact blacks were considered to carry the "mark of Cain" and thus were not
allowed to hold the priesthood. Yet, amazingly enough, 1978 brought with it a
civil rights violation law suit, a temple going up in Brazil (which, by the
way, has a very high BLACK population), and an incredible new revelation that
blacks NOW could enjoy the priesthood! Kewl! What a mighty coincidence!!!!!!
The fact that you inferred that Christians believed Christ died for THEM on the
cross, and not everyone. (Which, when called on it, you later excused by saying
you were only "joking.")
All these, plus some we haven't had a chance to discuss... Like the Word of
Wisdom's use of the phrase "hot drinks," yet modern day Mo's consider hot
chocolate and green tea to be O.K.
Eric informs me: <<I think you need to qualify that statement. From what I read
in the Bible it seems that the Apostles thought that Jesus was the Messiah. The
Messiah was the Son of
God. This is what they preached.>>
Okay, but pay attention, Eric. Reed was talking about the conception (and
implementation) of the Nicene Creed, which was written in the 4th century. This
means all the Disciples had been pushing up daisies for well over 200 years.
Three centuries after Christ's ressurection, people didn't know WHAT to
believe.
The Nicene Creed, among other things, was designed to put a halt to Arianism.
Arianists believed that Jesus had not been generated from the divine substance
of the Father (meaning He was not GOD), and he was created out of nothing like
all other creatures (i.e. human).
Actually, religious people mess with atheists the most. Many religions have
missionaries or preachers and when they encounter an atheist they don't want to
let up sometimes. I know not all of them are like that but there are a large
number that are. Atheists just want one thing, and that is happiness. People
tend to view anyone that isn't part of religion as evil, which is unfair.
Atheists are pretty vulnerable in society, especially in places like prison,
where they are more likely to be gang raped because they don't believe in god.
That's reflective of how religion has been towards non-believers in past and
present. Of course these days, you won't get tortured for speaking your mind
against religion, but you will make enemies sometimes. I think it's ok that
people practice religion as long as they leave me out of it. I find my
thinking stagnates when I go to church. I have friends that are LDS and I get
along with them fine, we don't get in arguments and they don't preach to me.
It's the ones that are rednecks or self-righteous that get my goat sometimes.
They're the ones pompous enough to make comments about how worthy I am being
related to the color of my skin etc. Utah and Idaho has a lot of that going
on, but people are afraid to talk about it, or they simply look the other way.
That's why I am looking forward to leaving. Every time I go out some redneck
has to make a comment. I guess I shouldn't let it bother me, cuz I know I'm
not as ignorant as they are, but when I ignore them they try a little harder.
That's why I'm a firm believer in the FBI and the ATF. When these rednecks
really get out of hand, someone needs to teach them a lesson.
Thank god I'm an atheist
I have to say you have some pretty good arguments. I'm not ready to completely
accept any religion until the afterlife. I judge the validity of a religion by
the way people act. I don't know how perfect that is but from my standpoint,
are you going to believe something a burglar says, even when he says "don't
judge the church by me or others." Not in my eyes. It's not going to do me
any good to be in that environment. I want to be somewhere where me and my
ideas are welcome, or a least respected, and where the color of my skin doesn't
matter. I'd like to point out that people were usually ok with the color of my
skin in California, but things are different in utah and idaho. Of course
there are nice people there but there's plenty more that think brown is bad no
matter what. That really bugs me and if I have kids I don't want them to go
through what my brother went through going to school here. People get more
agitated when it's a smart Hispanic, because they feel threatened by the fact
that a minority can battle with them intellectually and scholastically, and
compete with them on the job market. The best I can do is not let their
behavior change me, because they would get quite a thrill out of that, and it
would do me no good. Anyway, I guess I'm learning to be positive about this
sort of thing. There are still a good number of mormons and utahn's that are
ok to hang out with. Just be careful what you say about racism and don't talk
religion or politics.
I just don't understand.
If it is happiness you strive for and don't already have it, then you are
screwed, cuz what else do you have but this life to look forward to. Get happy
dude!
BTW, which pagan god are you thanking for your convictions? Could it be one
of your prison buddies?
A little soul searching (even though you swear you don't have one) some
Sunday afternoon while you're not stagnating in church, may be just the ticket
for you.
Twenty years from now you will be more disappointed by the things that you
didn't do than by the ones you did do.
I feel for your plight being a minority. It must suck, and I do feel for you.
However, I was raised in LA and I saw as much or more racial bigotry there.
Although I am a white boy, I did have a short bout with being a minority when
I lived in Hawaii. Although it is not near the problems you must encounter
every day of your life.
Anyway, when I got to feeling down about it, I would pray and ask God for
strength. I'm not sure what you can do, except prevail. Good luck to you my
brother.
I think the mormons would be great for you. They have strong beliefs and
respect for their brothers and sisters. And what better place to learn the LDS
way of life than here in the land of Zion. Next time the home teachers come
by, invite em on in. I think you will be glad you did. Though no one can go
back and make a brand new start, anyone can start from now and make a brand new
ending.
ROTFLMAO!
I'll do just that as soon as I see Him.
Thanks. I think so too.
<<I'm not ready to completely accept any religion until the afterlife.>> Riscit
Wise move, and I must say, I pretty much feel the same. In fact, I'll go a tad
further...
I am not religious at ALL, however, I am VERY spiritual. I believe there is ONE
entity that is responsible for the creation of all. Everything everywhere. Not
just planet Earth.
I also believe that this Entity (God) doesn't care WHAT man-made religion (if
any) a person belongs to, as long as that person is a good, decent, loving,
honest, giving member of the human race.
Which means, you can go to church every Sunday, pay every cent of your
prescribed tithing, jump through all the Church given hoops, but if you DON'T
take care of your fellow man when you can, if you DON'T give that extra 20
bucks that the cashier overpaid you back, if you DON'T teach your children to
treat each other with respect, then I believe God is NOT going to be happy with
you.
So there!
Amen to that! Well said, R.
I'm happy with other things... just not really happy with some aspects of utah.
I don't always think about the bad things... I just pointed out that some
religious people can be bad, so religion doesn't make you instantly good. I'm
happy most of the time anyway, although I'll get pissed for a little bit when
someone makes a redneck comment. I'm sure they are trying to derail me off my
happy train.
> BTW, which pagan god are you thanking for your convictions? Could it be
>one
>of your prison buddies?
Prison buddies? Just because there are atheists in prison, doesn't mean they
are my buddies. Your attitude is typical of utah, and the reason why people go
after utahns for things like the olympic scandal, when people have been doing
it all the time. You lable someone, they're going to label you. Do the math.
I don't pray to any gods, but if I did, it wouldn't be christian.
> A little soul searching (even though you swear you don't have one) some
>Sunday afternoon while you're not stagnating in church, may be just the
>ticket
>for you.
That's another typical attitude. Religous people tend to think that they know
what's best for everyone. I don't let people make my decisions for me, so why
don't you sit in church for me?
> Twenty years from now you will be more disappointed by the things that
>you
>didn't do than by the ones you did do.
Only if I start going to church... I'm here to enjoy this life, not give it
away to someone that promises salvation in exchange for my money, as do most
christian religions.
At least someone got the joke... Humor is a sign of intelligence. You have to
have a sense of humor to be happy in this life I think. If there is a god,
I'll gladly listen to what he has to say when I meet him, but seeing as how
it's just people telling me there is one, I'm pretty cautious about giving away
my time and life to organized religion. Besides, religion is what separates
people the most, along with politics. Peope always fight wars over religion
and politics, so I don't want to add to the carnage or arguments. It's hard
enough to keep the peace by not believing in an angry and jealous god. Well,
there I go again, but I'm glad someone thought it was funny.
I can believe that about LA... Whether it stands for Los Angeles or Lousiana...
everyone hates everyone and they show it too.
>
> Although I am a white boy, I did have a short bout with being a minority
>when
>I lived in Hawaii. Although it is not near the problems you must encounter
>every day of your life.
Well, I appreciate your concern. Praying doesn't seem to do much for me, but I
will tell you this, if there is a god I'll hold a prayer in my heart for him.
Sorry if I misjudged your previous message.... I'm just so used to the
preaching that tells me I'm going to hell, or I'm not good enough because I'm
brown, or that if I don't give my money to them I'm lost, etc. Of course,
there are good people in religion, but something that religion needs to teach
more is patience, and they need to learn a bit more about free agency too.
I've heard about what it's like to be a white boy in Hawaii. Some coworkers
told me they call the white peope "howies" and like to fight with them. It's
because we're driving up the property values so they can't even afford their
own land, let alone get anymore...and they kind of like to guard their women.
It's a shame though that someone can't find a solution.
I'd like to go that route myself... I tried being atheist without any
spiritualism, and it worked ok for a while. I learned a lot, but it's
comforting at least to think that there might be a supreme being, and that
there are other worlds. If not, it's an awful waste of space. Personally, I'd
love to be abducted by aliens. In fact, it wouldn't really be an abduction.
They would just be inviting me over for a while... I wouldn't mind forever in
fact. I'm the curious type and I'd love to see other worlds and learn new
things. Well, one can wish. =]
The more I listen to Jewel, the more I think she is leaning towards
anti-religion, and leaning towards individual spirituality. Let's hope we
survive this adoscelence, and don't blow each other up, or go about fighting so
much. We're still the USA and should get along, as well as along with the
world.
Well, even though I like their idea of "rescuing" the people of dark skin, I
have to say I'm not ready for that now. Perhaps another time, or another
lifetime. I still will make LDS friends though. I might even attend an LDS
dance if there's nothing else to do. The LDS girls are still pretty cute
sometimes. It's too bad the ones I live by are all underage. Now I can't
belive in "the girl next door." =]
>Riscit writes: <<I know that even if you don't believe in God, you should
>love
>your fellow human beings. We're all in it together, so we
>might as well learn to live together in peace and progress.>>
>
>Amen to that! Well said, R.
Thanks... For some reason, I feel like giving everyone a pepsi...or is that a
Dr Pepper? I can't remember how the old commercial goes now. =] I sometimes
stay up late at night and wonder if religion was a test given to us by
aliens... they wanted to see if our species was smart enough to still get
along, or if they would destroy each other. Well, it would make a good book
anyway, or an X Files episode.
I couldn't agree more. In fact, I do wonder if this isn't God's one and only
mistake: Letting mankind ponder about His existance. I have to wonder what
would have happened to mankind had God never sent his "word" down to show us
what He expected. Would we still be apes? Probably... but it would be
interesting to know, eh?
<< It's hard enough to keep the peace by not believing in an angry and jealous
god.>>R
True. For what it's worth, I don't think you'll lose any points in Heaven (if
there is one) for being an Atheist, Risc. Just be as good a humanitarian as
you can, for I do believe that's what life's all about.
<<Well, there I go again, but I'm glad someone thought it was funny.>>R
It's very funny. I think you're on the right track!