An Unparalleled Exploration of Yoruba Existence Across Time and Global Space :Toyin Falola's Global Yoruba: Regional and Diasporic Networks, a Work Highlighting the Journey Travelled in Yoruba Historiography and Evoking Future Possibilities in the Field

[Oluwatoyin Adepoju]

                                    

                                                             

                                             An Unparalleled  Exploration of  Yoruba Existence

                                                               Across Time and Global Space

                                                                      Toyin Falola's

                                                Global Yoruba: Regional and Diasporic Networks

                             A Work Highlighting the Journey Travelled in Yoruba Historiography

                                                                                   and

                                                     Evoking Future Possibilities in the Field

 

                

                                             

                       
        

                                                                 Oluwatoyin Vincent Adepoju

                                                                    Compcros

                                               Comparative Cognitive Processes and Systems

                                    "Exploring Every Corner of the Cosmos in Search of Knowledge"

                                                                  Abstract

A review of Toyin Falola's  Global Yoruba: Regional and Diasporic Networks (2024), describing its strengths, its limitations and my understanding of the promise it holds for the further development of Yoruba historiography.

The main text of the essay is punctuated by a collage made by myself from pictures from the Internet and images of some of the art from the book, accompanied by commentary. The art chosen represents those that appeal most to my personal taste, even though I enjoy all the art in the work. I credit the  creators of the art I reference if their names are indicated in the book. 

Contents

A Great Achievement 

Image and Text: Spatio-Temporal Mapping of Emergence and Global Migration of Yoruba Peoples and Cultures 

Structure

Image and Text: Expansion of Consciousness in Yoruba Origin Spirituality

Artistic Power

Image and Text: Aesthetics and Myth of Female Presence

Inclusion, Exclusion and Suggestive Force 

Image and Text: Cultural Personalization

Between Digital and Print Text

Image and Text: Unity of Humanity in the Embrace of Strangers

Totalistic Yoruba History and Historiography Inspired by Yoruba Thought

          Further Developing Yoruba   Hermeneutics 

                     Epistemology of Imaginative Forms in Yoruba Thought     

                               Proverb Epistemology 

Image and Text: Mercantile and Metaphysical Markets

Adapting Yoruba Philosophy and Spirituality and Related Thought on     the Intersection of   Possibilities     

Image and Text: Intertwined Dynamisms of City and University: The City of Ibadan and the University of Ibadan

       Yoruba Sciences

        Yoruba Oral and Written Literatures Within and Beyond  the  Yoruba        

         Language 

Image and Text: Vitalistic Ibadan

          The Scribal Tradition in Yoruba Philosophy

           Continuities Between Oral and Scribal Cultures in Yoruba                

 Philosophy

                            Parallels with Indian Philosophy

                              B.K. Matilal and Jornadon Ganeri

                             Histories of Indian Philosophy         

                          Parallels with Western Philosophy

                 Yoruba Visual and Performative Arts

                            Yoruba Visual Arts

              Image and Text: Prayer Lyricism

              Yoruba Performative Arts

 

Historiographies and Philosophies of History Inspired by Yoruba Thought

Image and Text: Multiple Illuminations

The Publishing Opportunity 

A Great Achievement 

Toyin Falola's book Global Yoruba: Regional and Diasporic Networks, published by Indiana University Press in November 2024,  is a landmark in Yoruba Studies, and almost certainly going to become a permanent point of reference.

It is an epic book, unparalleled, to the best of my knowledge, in its breadth in exploring the natal, larger African and diasporic development of Yoruba history and culture, emphasizing the growth of Yoruba cosmology as a unifying force across both its native, larger African and trans-Atlantic developments.

Falola pours his decades of exploration of Yoruba life into this book and soars even beyond his earlier engagements with the subject. He does this in readily accessible prose, narratively sweet yet bristling with ideas, richly illustrated with images likely unavailable anywhere else, eloquent examples of classical Yoruba art and new art addressing Yoruba realities.

Elaborate but clearly delineated maps depict the spatial configurations created by the demographic reworkings through which Yoruba identities emerged and moved across space within what is now Nigeria, in relation to West African proximities.

Contemporary Yoruba spatial centres in relation to those of others in Nigeria; the spatial relationships between the central locations of the various Yoruba subgroups; the proximities between these subgroups and other Nigerian and West African peoples; the spatial dynamics of the old Oyo empire, an early centre of Yoruba identity formation and diffusion; the locations represented by the intra-Yoruba wars of the 19th century central to shaping what is now known as Yorubaland; the resulting emergence of new Yoruba states in that time; the trade routes from the interior to the coast strategic to economic and cultural transmission and reshapings; the current spatial centralizations of the Yoruba in postcolonial Nigeria in relation to other peoples within the boundaries created by the River Niger, the River Benue and the Atlantic Ocean, all these are thereby visualized in the diagrammatic shorthand compressing space and time in a manner facilitating a bird's eye view of vastly spread situations and events.

A priceless guide emerges to the cultural and political adventure constituting Yoruba history across the world, from its natal origins to its trans-Atlantic incarnation.

Sumptuously produced in elegant coffee table format yet exquisitely scholarly. Profound in analysis and synthesis  yet enjoyably readable, accessible to a broad range of readers, requiring only close attention to grasp its more theoretical passages.

Does any other book operate at this level of almost encyclopedic range on the subject?

Global Yoruba enables access to knowledge one would have to read through the equivalent of a library in order to approach its breadth of knowledge, but even the sheer accumulation of such knowledge is nowhere near the synergistic mastery within narrative flow and reflective power the book demonstrates, a mighty rock in the flowing river of knowledge that is Yoruba Studies, shaped by and possibly shaping the ocean of existence that is Yoruba being and becoming.

The book is jargon free while being grounded in various theoretically sophisticated fields of knowledge, from decolonization theories to philosophies of space and place, exposing readers painlessly and enjoyably to those cognitive networks, as the very latest orientations in global scholarship, from Africa to the West to the Americas, are brought to bear on the subject, distilling decades of Falola's own multidisciplinary research and publications, complemented by new knowledge and new theoretical positionings.

                                                                         

Image and Text : Spatio-Temporal Mapping of Emergence and Global Migration of Yoruba Peoples and Cultures 

                 

A collage by myself, using images from various online sources, in visualizing the theme of Global Yoruba, the diffusion of Yoruba people and culture across the world. The central image is of an Ife head, an exquisitely modeled,  naturalistic bronze depiction of a human face, representing ancient Ife art and civilization. 

Organized in a cycle round the image are inscriptions and arrows depicting the successive stages of this demographic and cultural diffusion. It begins with ''emergence'' at the bottom, indicating the birth of the demographic and cultural cluster that eventually spread beyond its place of origin, as indicated by the next stage ''diffusion''.

 After ''diffusion’’  comes ''consolidation'', the crystallization of demographic and cultural possibilities in terms of various distinct ethnic and cultural formations, represented by  the convergence of what have come to be known as Yoruba ethnic and cultural  structures. This is complemented by other  integrations actualizing other ethnicities and cultures in  what is now known as Southern Nigeria and perhaps also West Africa.

After ''consolidation'' comes ''slavery'', the trade that took captured Africans to the Americas and the UK, where, in the Americas, they eventually became a deeply impactful demographic, with Yoruba spirituality becoming perhaps the most pervasive spiritual influence on these people torn from their geographical and cultural roots, some of whom later returned to Africa, a return that had deep implications for Yoruba identity.

 

''Colonialism'' comes next, creating new nations out of African ethnic groups, as well as new cultural formations in Africa in which the colonial masters’ cultures became a point of ultimate reference, nations the contradictions and inadequacies of which eventually led to large voluntary migrations from Africa to the countries of the former colonial masters, voluntary migrations in which Yorubas have again been  prominent.

The outcomes of these migrations, forced through slavery, and, later, through voluntary emigration, has created the globalization of Yoruba culture that Global Yoruba is centred on.

The collage highlights the fact that migration in relation to Yoruba cultures began well before the slave trade added the dimension of forced migration on the scale it did, taking people across the Atlantic to the UK and the Americas.

The collage also highlights questions about the possibility of migration from a common demographic and cultural cluster suggested by similarities of philosophies and spiritualities between Southern Nigerian peoples, among whom the Yoruba belong, and perhaps between peoples in West Africa.

These similarities are represented by slightly differing cosmologies central to which  are questions of the relationship between fate and free will, at the nexus between the self and the creator of the universe.These  similarities also include conjunctions between divination systems  employed to mediate between fate and free will. 

The maps in the collage visualize the various geographical regions represented by the migrations and cultural confluences in question.

The collage is inspired by the drawing mapping the development of the Yoruba diaspora by Michael Efionayi on page 10 of Global Yoruba, shown below. I adapt Efionayi's version by adding ''emergence'', ''diffusion'' and ''consolidation'' to the sequence in order to create an expanded image of these migrations within and beyond Africa.

                                                                    

                                          

Structure

Global Yoruba is carefully and ingeniously structured, using various organizational strategies in creating fluid order, demonstrating seamless linkages over a vast, many-sided subject, evoking intellectual excitement and stimulating imaginative upliftment from the beginning to the end of the narrative journey.

The rhapsodic and the architectonic, adapting German philosopher Immanuel Kant's terms on the organization of knowledge, controlled passion and architectural order, imaginative radiance and intellectual structuring, combine, creating something strikingly beautiful in its parts and massively glorious in the complexly interlocking whole, realized in terms of an ultimately limpid beauty, clear and transparent.

Division into five, clearly signposted sections gives the work structural clarity, with the introduction of the idea of global Yoruba in the introduction operative across the text, ultimately summed up in its conclusion.

We are introduced to the formation of Yoruba society as a social order defined by correlative value and knowledge systems, eventually conjoined into a political and philosophical synthesis, the trans-Atlantic journey of these segments and their unifications across time and space, even to the Americas, being core to the book.

The beginnings of pan-Yoruba society in the social amalgamations of the Oyo empire, the destruction of this agglomeration by Islamic jihadists, the defeat of the jihadists by Ibadan and the eventual emergence of  Ibadan as the axis of Yoruba cultural ascendancy is powerfully narrated.

The cultivation of egalitarian values in  Ibadan's beginnings as a war camp for refuge from intra-Yoruba wars is discussed. The transposition of those values from  a combination of military culture and an egalitarian governance model,  a transition shaped within the matrix of the colonial encounter and its aftermath, into sterling cultural capital feeding the entire nation Nigeria, created by Britain, an achievement the impact of which resonates to the present and the future, is examined.

The complication of Yoruba ideological space by the emergence and eventual dominance of Islam, Christianity, Western colonialism, Western education and Western forms of government, are discussed, in relation to the strategies of resistance and accommodation evident in Yorubaland to these seismic changes as Yoruba culture travelled to and thrived in the Americas through slavery, and later, voluntary migration.

The nature of modernity in the Yoruba context is examined, at the intersection of Western and traditional cultures as Western influence radically reshapes the polity, even as Yoruba artistic forms undergo mutation in relation to the expanded scope of possibility opened up by the transformative encounter with new ways of living.

Artists and cultural activists, genetically Yoruba and from beyond Yorubaland and even beyond Africa, politicians and political movements, are vividly depicted, individualistic and group demonstrations of struggles for self-actualization and communal projection within and in relation to Yoruba geographical, cultural and ideological space.

Contemporary Yoruba politics in Nigeria, Yoruba film, Yoruba music and Yoruba written literature in Nigeria,  Yoruba cultural politics in the Americas and  Yoruba spirituality across the world, are explored in building a picture of contemporary Yoruba identity within and beyond its homeland in what is now Nigeria, as the book sums up the emergence of Yorubaness as  an ethnic and genetic identity as well as an ideological and cultural matrix, manifest in various ways across the world.

Image and Text: Expansion of Consciousness in Yoruba Origin Spirituality

                                                                                              

                     

This drawing by Kazeem Ekeolu is used in Global Yoruba in evoking the experience of trance undergone by devotees in classical Yoruba spirituality. 

Kazeem's figure is seated in the lotus posture, made famous by the Indian discipline Hatha Yoga, the balance of the upper body on the crossed legs evocative of the lotus flower held aloft by roots sunk in water, an inanimate form suggestive of the blossoming of expanded consciousness from roots in the limitations of matter, the pose being used in cultivating physical and mental poise vital for pursuing such mental expansion.

Seeing a landscape lit by lightning, is how Susanne Wenger describes trance in Orisha spirituality in Ulli Beier's The Return of the Gods: The Sacred Art of Susanne Wenger. ''...the triumph of serene joys and sublimated passions. The young maid of Ela. The transfigured wrinkles of Orisanla. Inertly rendered bodies and unearthly exaltation in the eyes, and on the skin. Deft whispers of the godhead, numinous presences, flooding the mediums sympathy'' is Wole Soyinka's depiction of a particular kind of trance in that spirituality ( The Interpreters, Fontana, 1978, 177), referencing the names of deities understood as shaping human consciousness in those mental states.

The serenities of trance  depicted in that Soyinka quote are akin to the contemplative orientation visualized by Kazeem's drawing, focused in the physical stillness of the figure as his or her mind seems to explode into a  radiance of complex harmonies visualized by the conjunction of circles and triangles seeming to emanate from the figure's form.

Kazeem has ingeniously reshaped archetypal geometric forms in their use across various cultures, employed particularly in Hindu yantra and Buddhist mandala iconography in suggesting cosmic structure and its correlates in human cognition.

He reworks these forms in a manner that powerfully suggests the synergy of cosmology and cognition, the metaphysical structure and dynamism of the cosmos and processes through which understanding of these unities is reached. His image evokes a dialogue between metaphysics and epistemology, between a conception of cosmos as independent of the human being and the human being's understanding of this reality beyond the self. He achieves this oscillation through spatial relationships between  symbolic geometric constructs and the human form.

The concentric circles and intersecting triangles motifs particularly powerfully developed in yantra and mandala symbolism is constructed here in terms of concentric structures of intersecting triangles and circles that seem to bloom outward from the seated figure, suggesting conjunctions of insight in complex combinations, embodied by the seated personage.

What kinds of perceptions of such rich complexity could emerge in the context of Orisha spirituality? The perception of the egg breaking into the multiplicity constituting the cosmos, each orisha or deity being a window into the universe from a particular perspective, with the sum total of all those perspective being Odumare, axiom paradoxon, beginning and consequence, beyond being and becoming, yet enabling the existence and dynamism of cosmos, as may be adapted Ulli Beier's depiction of the Orisha cosmos  in The Return of the Gods and Susanne Wenger on Odumare in her review of Harold Coulander's Yoruba Gods and Heroes? (Research in African Literatures, Vol. 7, No. 1 , 1976, pp. 74-76).

                                                 

Artistic Power

Global Yoruba contributes to enriching Yoruba culture and its study, not only through the book's ideational synergies but also in constellating  works of art never before assembled for this purpose, some of them possibly created for this text.

The artistic dimension of the work is itself a sterling achievement, complementing the near encyclopedic scope of the gripping and ideationally ambitious narrative, scintillatingly crafted in striking prose readily accessible to the general reader yet beautiful in its rhythms.

Visual art strategically shapes the optical power of the text, amplifying its ideational projections and the pleasurable experience of assimilating knowledge within the multi-cognitive space constituted by the book, sensorially uplifting and intellectually stimulating.

The only comparable book known to me in unifying images and text on Yoruba culture and art at this level of volume is Rowland Abiodun,  Henry Drewal and John Pemberton III's Yoruba: Nine Centuries of African Art and Thought, an indispensable work in Yoruba arts and its philosophical contexts, its combination of glorious visuality and powerful text yet unequalled in Yoruba Studies, to the best of my knowledge, even by the very rich complementary book The Yoruba Artist: New Theoretical Perspectives on African Arts , edited by the same team.

Global Yoruba, however, operates in terms of a more modern artistic register than those two other books, which are centred in great examples of classical Yoruba art. Global Yoruba also demonstrates modern adaptations of the classical tradition while introducing new artistic orientations to Yoruba culture, mainly using strikingly original drawings. 

Image and Text: Aesthetics and Myth of  Female Presence

             

                                                

This painting is used in Global Yoruba  in illustrating the rich Yoruba culture of dress. It may also be seen as integrating the sartorial values represented by the woman's elegant clothes and the suggestive force of the female form, the latter a centre of far reaching though contending values in classical Yoruba culture, at the nexus of the tension between veneration and fear in relation to women.

Values ranging from the variegated aesthetics of dress and grooming in Yoruba culture, to the symbolism of clothing, to the combination of the sensual and the maternal actualized by the female form, are evoked by this image.

The beauty of the  lyrically crafted forms represented by the elaborate headwear, the artistically folded and unfurled gele crowning the head, the short piece of cloth hung on the shoulder, giving extra heft to the main top and bottom full length clothing, are actualized in their balance with the structure of the person who fills out the clothes.

Her waist bends slightly in a manner evocative of the Indian aesthetic practice of the three parts break, the Tribhaṅga, in which the symmetry of the human form is highlighted by breaks from the linear flow of the body at three points, bending at the neck, the waist and the knees.

The elegant verticality of her form is accentuated by its resonance with what look like the beams of an overhead tank at the foot of  which she stands, and the sinuous trunk of a tree at her side.

Her face and the clothing at her upper body are shaped by patterns of light and subtle geometric forms that enhance the aesthetic radiation of her body and clothing, light intensified in the brilliant white of the ceremonial fly whisk, a symbol of authority and poise which she holds at her waist, patterns enhanced by the subdued hues of the surrounding space, luminosities amplified by the surrounding darkness. 

Within the network of associations generated by varied figures in Yoruba arts, this quietly elegant, classically beautiful figure is the complementary opposite of another image of female power from Yoruba aesthetics, the imposing, naked woman who exemplifies associations of the feminine with primeval potency, with force that is both monstrous and human, embodying the co-existence of the unhuman potencies of nature and the disciplined contours of human existence, the shadow side of the feminine in classical Yoruba thought, dramatized by the image of the naked woman who walks out of the forest to feast on the sacrifice of uncooked animal entrails offered by Orunmila in his quest to understand the underlying logic driving the paradoxes of life on Earth, in an ese ifa,  the literature of Ifa, the central Yoruba knowledge system, which I engage with in " Orunmila and the Imposing, Naked Woman: Engaging With the Arcane Feminine in the Context of Yoruba Iyami Aje Spirituality" ( Facebook, 2021).

Adapting insights particularly clearly projected in Hindu thought, archetypal patterns expressed in terms of mythic imagery may be understood in terms of the complementarity of opposites in specific mythic systems, as the classically beautiful Goddess Tripurasundari is complementary to the horrifying image of the Goddess Kali, depicting another kind of beauty, both Goddesses understood as members of the ten Mahavidyas, a cycle of complementary female divine figures, themselves aspects of Shakti, the feminine principle enabling the dynamism of the universe in the Tantric orientation of Hinduism, as described, among other texts, in David Kinsley's Tantric Visions of the Divine Feminine:The Ten Mahavidyas.

Along similar lines, even though not as theoretically explicit and systematized as in Hinduism,  in Yoruba thought, images of classical, carefully ordered feminine beauty and power cohere with depictions of wild, feminine force, projecting their own kind of beauty.

These complementary contrasts resonate across figures represented by the goddess Oshun, who is both voluptuously beautiful and a mistress of magic and divinatory insight, who, as stated in an ese ifa,  "is aje, as all women are aje", a controversial and fearsome category of being, both destructive and creative, maternal and bloodthirsty, as the spectrum of characterizations of this particular image of the feminine recur in the mirrors of the development of  diverse  bodies of thought in Yoruba discourse represented by ese ifa.

Ese ifa's  varied images of the feminine in turn resonate with the arcane feminine personages of edan ogboni sculpture, the central artistic form of the Yoruba origin esoteric order, the Ogboni. Edan ogboni depictions of the feminine are themselves  conjunctive with the fearsome forms referenced in Gelede poetry, honoring the creative and destructive  force of feminine spiritual powers.

These feminine potencies include  Iyan Nla, the Great Mother, a characterization perhaps of Ile, Earth, ''combining in her nature the attributes of all the principal female deities'', invoked in terms of mystery and crushing force alongside illuminating embrace of the great mother, "the pot breasted mother/ inexhaustible sea/ immense water/ roaring eddy of seashells/ vibrations from the deep/ the one that rolls on and on without breaking/ owner of the vagina that suffocates like dry yam in the throat", as described by Babatunde Lawal in The Gelede Spectacle.

         

 Inclusion, Exclusion and Suggestive Force 

Global Yoruba is foundational for Yoruba Studies, exemplificatory in terms of what it discusses and how it engages them as well as suggestive of how to approach what it does not discuss.

Though the text richly explores Yoruba film and modern Yoruba music,  it does not examine such strategic Yoruba cultural forms as the history of Yoruba oral literature and Yoruba visual and performative arts outside film and modern Yoruba music, and Yoruba sciences, such as mathematics, significantly studied by such figures as Olu Longe and Aimee Dafon Segla.

Even though it does not discuss those subjects the book's interpretive model can be fruitfully applied to the exploration of those fields.

Image and Text: Cultural Personalization

                                               

                                                                         
                                                               

All the images, photographs of paintings, sculptures and drawings in Global Yoruba are either from Falola's private collection, as they are described in the book, or, as I expect is the case with the drawings, specially commissioned for the book, thereby also belonging to Falola.

Why would an author choose to populate such a large text on an ethnic group, a book centred on its global demographic and cultural spread,  with only artistic works belonging to him or freshly commissioned by himself, thereby uniquely stamping his own aesthetic sensitivities on the book?

This  orientation is amplified by the cover image which centres a painting of Falola in an iconic pose from the repertoire of classical Yoruba sculpture. He is flanked on one side by the Statue of Liberty, the famous sculpture symbolizing entry into the United States of America on account of its prominence on Ellis Island, New York, once the primary entry point for immigrants into the US, and therefore evoking the trans-Atlantic migrations of the Yoruba to the Americas strategic to the book's exploration of Yoruba globalization.

On the other side, Falola is flanked by an image of Orunmila, the Yoruba Orisha tradition deity embodying divine wisdom, suggesting the spiritual and philosophical culture distilled from Yoruba civilization in its journey within the Yorubas and cognate peoples  and across the seas to new lands, an aspirational essence demonstrating reworking in new ways in varied circumstances. 

At Falola's feet is an image of a woman with the body of a fish as her lower half, and that of a human woman as her upper body, a mermaid, as understood in other cultures, and a mami-wata, as this figure is named in African pidgin English, holding a covered bowl in her hands. A covered bowl in Yoruba aesthetics may suggest something precious, protected by being thus covered. It may be a spiritual potency latent within the ritual preparation inside the bowl, making the bowl a kind of shrine. In association with mami-wata, it could suggest wealth, since  mami-wata  is associated with wealth, an idea further evoked by the cowries strewn around her figure and at Falola's feet. Cowries passed from being used as currency in Africa to being employed as ritual objects.

As an entity believed to live in seas and rivers, the mami-wata represents the motif of intelligent life as transcending conventionally visible forms of existence exemplified by humans and other animals, extending to entities who are not normally visible but may be encountered in special situations, a globally emergent belief, particularly in terms of the mermaid motif depicted here, but which has sunk into folklore and fantasy in many cultures while it remains live in the animistic cultures of the kind represented by classical Yoruba thought.

The mami-wata not only evokes the multiplicity of obviously conscious species perceived to exist in an animistic cosmos, but also the aquatic element through which Yoruba migrants passed to the Americas as they were ferried in slave ships, holding their culture within them even within the dehumanizing economic and political system of slavery in which the fire of that culture sustained them in preserving and even reshaping their humanity.

At Falola's bottom left is an oshe Shango, a statuette of the deity Shango, topped by a double headed axe, suggesting power evoked by the thunder and lightning to which Shango is related. ''...the twinned celts [ the double headed axe, suggest ]  power plus power … Shango squared [ representing ]  the inner spiritual reality of the priest with the power of Shango imbedded in the head and emanating from the top'' observes Margaret Thompson Drewal.

''The entire surface of the oshe'', she continues,  ''becomes [ in the ritual context, akin to]  a vast force field of lightning, energized with ...patterns that radiate outward from the central shaft [ suggesting]  power serving protective as well as decorative functions'' (  ‘’Art and Trance among Yoruba Shango Devotees’’, African Arts, Vol. 20, No. 1, 1986,  60-67+98-99; 60, 62, 66).

Falola is depicted as holding in his hands objects emblematizing royal power, in the archetypal style evident in classical Yoruba art, ancient Egyptian and classical Tibetan art.

In one hand he grasps what looks like an o̩fò̩ horn, an instrument believed in Yoruba spirituality to enhance the spiritual power of speech, enabling the speaker's commands to magically come true. In the other hand, he holds what looks like a bag of  oògùn, as named in Yoruba, magical concoctions meant to restructure reality through the overriding power of spiritual  force.

Why would a scholar in the Western tradition in which Falola has been primarily educated, having achieved the acme of Western academic training, a PhD, as well as the height of professional academic advancement in that tradition, a professorship, and one employed in a 21st century Western university, in the United States, the University of Texas, representing a culture far removed from that of Yoruba spiritual culture, depict himself in terms more befitting for a Yoruba spiritual adept, complexifying the image through the evocation of the Statue of Liberty representing a world far from the Yoruba universe embodied by those icons? 

The image collage evokes the transport to the US of the Yoruba spiritual universe depicted by its symbols in the visual tableau. Falola's image at the centre of the visual composition suggests him as embodying those spiritual values in their transport to the New World. 

To what degree does he actually embody those values and to what degree is his image simply representative of a reality he studies but which does not define him? Does his powerful meditation on the orisha Eshu in his essay " Ritual Archives" suggest an actual contemplative practice in relation to the deity, complementing the more intellectual summation of his introduction to his edited book  Èsù : Yoruba God, Power, and the Imaginative Frontiers?

What is the implication, for these questions, of his deep exposure to the practice of Yoruba spirituality, as evidenced by his autobiographical account in A Mouth Sweeter than Salt and Counting the Tiger's Teeth, of his childhood relationship with Iya Lekuleja, an elderly female seller of assorted items for spiritual work, as well as being regarded as a preeminent spiritual figure herself?

As one of the most significant writers on Yoruba spirituality and philosophy, evidenced by the largely scholarly character of his writings, depicting Yoruba spirituality more in terms of analysis from an external standpoint rather than from within an internal, practitioner's vantage, may the  Falola image  be seen as evocative of the transmutation of the traditional symbolism in terms of his own practice as a writer, scholar, public speaker and institutional organizer?

May the ọfọ horn be understood as evoking Falola's mastery of the power of language in Yoruba and English, projecting expressions strategic to reworking thought worlds across the globe wherever Africa is studied?

May the oògùn bag suggest Falola's creation and maintenance of systems of knowledge creation, integrating people and industrial processes, research networks and publishing systems, creating landscapes of knowledge about Africa, monuments of understanding contributing to illuminating the continent?

Dominating the visual tableau defining the cover of Global Yoruba are the light held up by the Statue of Liberty and the radiant white of Orunmila's staff and form, the sense of illumination projected by both figures amplified by their towering height. Ideas of illumination, in terms of knowledge and freedom, are evoked by the synergy of these iconic forms, from the United States and Nigeria's Yorubaland.

May Falola's iconicized image at the centre of the visual framework  suggests the book on the cover of which the artistic configuration appears as his own dramatization of the intellectual possibilities of  Yoruba culture, his own textual actualization of a universe of values intimately related to him and which he identifies with in terms of a balance between identification and critical examination, an orientation developed at length in his Decolonizing African Knowledge: Autoethnography and African Epistemology?

The collage, however, goes beyond those purely rationalistic orientations, framing the central figure in mythic terms, as associated with the overwhelming force of Shango, radiant with the wisdom and power of Orunmila, the deity holding an  o̩fò̩ horn similar to that held by Falola, thereby suggesting a parallel of power between human and deity, a human figure identified with the aquatic mobility of mami-wata and her cabalash of mysterious endowments, in a scene awash with the wealth symbolized by cowries, and correlative with the torch of illumination projected by the symbol of liberty, all these fused in the slightly bearded figure with the short Yoruba style trousers, part of the cycle of Falola's self iconicisation ongoing in the illustrations to various books of his.

Between Digital and Print Text

The publisher, IUP,  has made Global Yoruba available as an open access text which one may read on the Press' website.The digital version thus graciously provided  is very impressive in projecting the ideational, structural and visual power of the work.

I have to mention, however, that the sumptuous production of the print version demonstrates why print publication can never be superseded by digital publishing, indispensable as digital publishing is.

Holding the print version, leafing through the splendidly crafted pages through paper luminescent in peerless white, as creatively provocative illustrations- largely rich drawings but also pictures- punctuate one's motion through the bibliophilic feast, is like a leisurely journey through the physical landscape of an enchanted loved one, a robustly built woman possibly, alluringly irresistible.

Image and Text: Unity of Humanity in the Embrace of Strangers

                                                                                                                                                                                                                         

                                                                                                                                                                

Another drawing by Kazeem Ekeolu in Global Yoruba, titled Strangers in Bed, showing figures lying down in the same space, their bodies intertwined in intimacy. The image is described as depicting ''two people, unknown to each other, who could sleep together, as in coexistence and peaceful relationships. The Yoruba value system emphasizes hospitality, even to strangers.''

The intimacy evoked by the intertwined figures is therefore neither erotic nor amorous but represents the recognition of the unity of human beings,  the intimacy of good neighborliness, the sharing of the creative bonds that unite humanity.

This depiction is particularly poignant for me since it reflects my experience in the Yoruba city of Lagos when a female friend and I, a man, stayed out too late to return home since there were no more commercial vehicles plying the roads at that time of night.

We were taken in by an OPC man, an operative of the Oodua Peoples Congress, a Yoruba paramilitary group, who asked us to share his sleeping space with his wife and himself. My mind will never let go of the image of four of us on that cloth or mat spread on the ground, since that was all he had, no bed, a wealth of hospitality given in the midst of the little he possessed. 

                   

Totalistic Yoruba History and Historiography Inspired by Yoruba Thought

The artistic dimension of Global Yoruba, taking further Falola's pattern of using visual art, either drawings, paintings or photographs, at times uniquely created for particular texts, visualities particularly evident, among other texts,  in his The Toyin Falola Reader, in his In Praise of Greatness: The Poetics of African Adulation and his Milestones in African Literature, suggests, not only the distance travelled in demonstrating the multi-dimensionality of Yoruba discourse, the degree to which this has been interactively engaged with in scholarship, but also the ground remaining to be traversed in creating a totalistic Yoruba history, something the scope of this ambitious work beckons towards.

Akinwumi Ogundiran's The Yoruba: A New History uniquely broke ground by historicizing Yoruba philosophy and spirituality on a large scale, exploring the situational logics across diverse times and places through which these cognitive orientations were developed, in relation to the breadth of the social contexts of the growth of Yoruba civilization from pre-history to the 19th century, if I recall his cut off time correctly.

Falola has taken up the historicising challenge initiated by Ogundiran, developing another conception of the development of the matrix of thought, action and creative forms constituting Yoruba civilization as both an ethnic identity and an ideological or even spiritual and philosophical configuration, demonstrating how "the arts of being Yoruba" to borrow the title of Adeleke Adeeko's book, have become a near global phenomenon through physical and cultural migrations of Yoruba civilization across the world.

Falola and Ogundiran powerfully dramatize the significance of the development of philosophical and spiritual thought worlds in this process, with Ogundiran demonstrating how some examples of Yoruba visual art, such as Yoruba bead work and ile iri, the house of ori, focus these ideational developments, an achievement which, however, could be taken even further than Ogundiran has done, building on his inspiration.

Falola focuses on illustrating the expressions of ideas in terms of art, and discusses Nollywood, the Nigerian film industry, in relation to Yoruba film, from the earlier periods represented by Hubert Ogunde to the contemporary work of Kunle Afolayan.

Film, Yoruba written literature and modern Yoruba music are, however,  the only art forms discussed in depth in the book, although visual art strategically shapes the visual power of the text.

In unifying philosophy, spirituality, art, economics and politics to the degree  they have done, Ogundiran and Falola suggest the possibility of totalistic Yoruba history, an achievement which, if my knowledge of the state of the field is adequate, still lies in the future.

What do I mean?

          Further Developing Yoruba   Hermeneutics 

                     Epistemology of Imaginative  Forms in  Yoruba  Thought     

                               Proverb Epistemology 

Ogundiran splendidly marshals an interpretation of the cognitive orientations of Yoruba thought as emerging from and shaping the scope of Yoruba social experience.

His project could be further taken forward, through a use of Yoruba hermeneutic strategies beyond his employment of proverbs which strikingly enliven his text.

His foregrounding of Yoruba history as an adventure in the intertwining of thought and action could be further advanced through, not only using Yoruba proverbs in vitalizing his narrative and exploring the significance of the events  he discusses, but through a discussion of the logic of the use of proverbs in Yoruba discourse, establishing the conventional understanding of proverbs as steeds of discourse, forms of discovery, excavation, recreation and transformation of thought  and expression, as described by the Yoruba expression " owe lesin oro, toro ba sonu, owe la fin wa", " proverbs [condensed verbal imaginative forms requiring sensitive unravelling] are the steeds of discourse, when discourse is lost, when it goes astray, we use metaphorical expressions,  proverbs, in seeking it out", but also in terms of metaphorical expressions as dramatizing the ontological unity of imaginative expression in Yoruba thought, ultimately projected through the mapping of the unfolding of being in space and time represented by the Yoruba literary genre, oriki, as discussed in Rowland Abiodun's Yoruba Art and Language.        

Image and Text: Mercantile and Metaphysical Markets

                                                                             

                   

A market in Yorubaland, as depicted in a painting in Global Yoruba. Markets in the traditional sense in what is now Nigeria, and perhaps in West Africa and Africa, generally, are air open air structures.  In the Yoruba context, markets signify more than the activity of buying and selling and its social implications. Like in Igboland, and some other African contexts, a market is a philosophical metaphor and a spiritual nexus, a philosophical value discussed by Nkeonye Otakpor of the Igbo context in ''The World is a Marketplace'' ( Value Inquiry 30, 521–530, 1996).

 As a philosophical metaphor, the gathering of people engaged in buying and selling within the limited time in which the market holds each day is akin to the constellating of humans on Earth within a limited time frame, arriving on Earth from a permanent abode, transacting with other humans for a fixed time  of activity on Earth and returning home on completion of that activity, hence the Yoruba expression ''aye loja, orun nile", ''  (Aye ) The world [ aye] is a market place, orun [the zone of ultimate origins where the ultimate creator may be encountered] is home''. The world is the market where the fortunes agreed upon with the ultimate creator in orun are worked out or negotiated.

The market, along with being a metaphorical space, is also understood in Yoruba, Igbo and some other African cultures, as a spiritual nexus, a meeting point of humans and spirits, who also come to the market to buy and sell, making the market metonymic for the world in general as a confluence of spirit and matter, physical and non-physical, invisible spiritual entities.

These values associated with the market mobilize huge potential in African thought, leading to their becoming the staging place of such epic events as the voluntary transition to the world beyond death through a ritual dance by the Elesin Oba, the Horseman of the King in Wole Soyinka's play Death and the King's Horseman, a play based on a discontinued  tradition in the Yoruba kingdom of Oyo where the Elesin would so accompany the Alaafin, the king,  in death, after the Alaafin had passed away, a dramatic staging in which the world beyond death resonates with the activity in the market, ''do the rhythms of gbedu [ a majestic drum] cover you then, like the sounds of royal elephants?'' declares the praise singer meant to inspire the Elesin Oba on his voluntary journey into the world beyond death. 

''Is there a light at the end of the tunnel, a light I dare not look upon? Does it show those [the ancestors] whose touches are often felt, whose wisdoms come suddenly to the mind when the wisest have shaken  their heads and murmured 'ít cannot be done?' '' 

A particularly poignant use of the market motif in African writing occurs in  Chinua Achebes ''The Madman'' ( Girls at War and Other Stories), in which Nwibe, surprised while bathing in a river by a naked man who wraps his cloth around himself and runs away, races naked after the intruder who stole his cloth, towards the market  the thief is running into.

One of his relatives drops his collection of yams meant for the market and another his farm produce so they can catch Nwibe before he sets foot in  ''the enchanted square'' that is the market, as Achebe puts it,  but they were too late. 

The first dibia [ spiritual specialist in Igbo religion] they take him to, declares ''there is nothing I can do. They [the spirits of the market]  have already embraced him. Nothing can save a madman who runs naked into the marketplace [ in running naked into the market Nwibe certainly  demonstrated a newly emergent madness, everyone believes, his story of someone stealing his cloth, leading to his loss of self control in pursuing the person while he was naked seen as another evidence of the delusionary universe he now inhabits].  He has already drunk of the spirit waters of ani mmo [the land of spirits]. 

He is like a man who runs from the persecution  of his fellows to the grove of an alusi, [ a spirit] and declares  'save me O spirit, I will be your osu'. Henceforth he is free of men but bonded to a god''.

The motif of the market thus becomes a matrix for cosmological beliefs and social customs, here evoked by the osu tradition of outcasts or of people discriminated against , as one view understands it, these beliefs becoming an axis for the writer's ironic treatment of his material, provoking the questions ''was Nwibe really mad? Are there really spirits in the marketplace? What validity do spiritual beliefs and socially sanctioned views on reality actually have?''

 

                          

         Adapting Yoruba Philosophy and Spirituality and Related Thought on the Intersection of  

         Possibilities     

Yoruba hermeneutics may be further developed through adaptations of ideas of relationships between fate and free will, between individual creativity and circumstance in the construction of history represented by conceptions of "ori", the self, represented by the head, and "ase", pervasive and individualized creative power,  in Yoruba thought, as these juxtapositions are particularly fruitfully explored by such works as Abiodun, Drewal and Pemberton's Yoruba:Nine Centuries  and Adegboyega Oragun's Destiny: The Unmanifested Being (1998), grounded in interviews with Yoruba babalawo, adepts in the esoteric knowledge of Ifa and the writings of Segun Gbadegesin, references exemplifying texts I know that examine the relationships between fate and free will in Yoruba thought.

Such examinations of relationships between context and outcome, environment and history are vital for historiography.

They are more fruitfully engaged, though,  through dialogue with varied responses to these subjects in geographically cognate thought to that of Yorubaland,  such as Igbo philosophy, which develops its own orientations to the same questions.

These investigations  may be further enriched through comparisons with a global choice of ideas on relationships between self and possibility, environment and outcomes, juxtapositions foundational to Yoruba thought on development in time and space, the subject of history.

Image and Text: Intertwined Dynamisms of City and University: The City of Ibadan and the University of Ibadan

                                                                        

                 

         A striking impressionistic drawing, by Kazeem Ekeolu, of the front of the University of Ibadan, suggesting

 the dynamism of school and city, of the university and Ibadan, where the institution is located.

The iconic central tower at the institution’s entrance, emblazoned with the logo and motto  of the university, is visible, while the skyscraper from the city, possibly the storied Cocoa House, the first skyscraper in West Africa, around which cluster smaller buildings, crowd into the image space on the bottom right, as what looks like a commercial vehicle possibly linking city and university, seems to takes off from the campus.

A figure who seems to wear a backpack, perhaps a student or a researcher in transit between research locations, looks on.

The entire scene is rendered in rough, broad strokes, suggesting dynamism in relation to the fixity of architectural structures, dynamism evocative of the strategic role of the University of Ibadan in the decentring of Western centred cognitive systems in creating a great African based intellectual culture resonating across the globe.

The traffic between possibilities, the synergy between cosmopolis and centre of learning suggested by the spatial merging of city and university as well as the commercial vehicle which may ply both locations, all come alive for me in this memorable impressionistic portrait, a splendid reworking of immediate visual reality in terms of the dynamism of history as it continues to resonate in the present.

 

       Yoruba Sciences

A discussion of science in Yoruba discourse from the past to the present is strategic for a totalistic history of the Yoruba, demonstrating how Yoruba people have related to the understanding and shaping of the universe in ways that can be empirically verified by people using the same tools, from mathematics to medicine, even though in those contexts,  scientific techniques, such as mathematics and the use of medicinal leaves, are likely to co exist with spirituality.

Falola's books, however, collectively engage the entire range of Yoruba discourse, but like Global Yoruba, often do not address  science, to the best of my knowledge, except such an example as the discussion of Ifa mathematics in ''Ritual Archives''.

Science in Yoruba culture, however, is further represented by such texts as  Aimee Dafon Segla's Yoruba Mathematics and his work on relationships between mathematics and cosmology in Yoruba thought, by Olu Longe's  and others' work on relationships between Ifa mathematics, as an information management system, and computer science, and by Yoruba psychiatric medicine, which pioneering psychiatric doctor Adeoye Lambo describes as influencing his innovations ( Towards a Culturally Sensitive Psychiatry: Lessons from Adeoye Lambo, Alapa Odugbo, 2024), and Yoruba herbalogy, evident in terms of its relationship with spirituality in Pierre Verger's monumental Ewe: The Uses of Plants in Yoruba Society. 

            Yoruba Oral and Written Literatures Within and Beyond  the  Yoruba Language 

           

Global Yoruba also does not discuss Yoruba oral literature, a field in which a good body of scholarly publications exists. Yet, Falola's range of publications demonstrate his accomplishments in discussing Yoruba literature and his ability to engage it beyond his efforts so far, given his fluency in Yoruba and his publications on Nigerian literature, in particular, and African literature, in general.

Yoruba oral literature is foundational for the imaginative and expressive universe of Yoruba thought and arts. The identity imaging and historicising character of oriki, the philosophical, spiritual, and comedic thrusts of ese ifa, the naturistic celebrations of ijala, the musical pathos of ewi, the incantatory power of ofo, and more, are among demonstrations of the creative power of Yoruba arts at its best.

How did these genres emerge, develop and contribute to the development of Yoruba thought, influence other arts, such as the visual and the performative, and contribute to written literature within and beyond Yoruba culture?

 I expect the scholarship exists to construct a relatively complete history of Yoruba literature, if one has not been done,  from the more speculative efforts necessary to historicizing the oral tradition to the evident history of the written tradition.

My very limited exposure to efforts to historicise the oral tradition, though without dating but focusing on processes of change in how ideas are constructed in the tradition is Karin Barber's ''How Man Makes God in West Africa: Yoruba Attitudes Towards the "Orisa" (Africa: Journal of the International African Institute, Vol. 51, No. 3, 1981, 724-745). 

Scholarship on the continuity between the oral and the written traditions is exemplified by Abiola Irele's particularly rich essay  "Tradition and the Yoruba Writer: Fagunwa, Tutuola and Soyinka" (The African Experience in Literature and Ideology (1981/1990), indicating a perception of Yoruba literature as extending beyond those writing in Yoruba, such as Daniel Fagunwa, but also to authors deeply inspired by Yoruba thought but writing in other languages, such as Amos Tutuola and Wole Soyinka’s works in various kinds of English. Fagunwa, Tutuola and Soyinka are discussed in Global Yoruba but outside the framework of their relationship to the oral tradition. 

Image and Text: Vitalistic Ibadan

                                                 

                         

A painting of Ibadan by Michael Efionayi in Global Yoruba, based on a Wikipedia picture of Ibadan by Ayokanmi Oyeyemi, foregrounding the statue of Ibadan general and statesman, Bashorun Oluyole, overlooking the busy city, a picture emphasizing the city’s  human density as suggested by the river of roofs which seem to flow into the distance, in tandem with the road running through the centre of the city, alive with cars and people in motion, the entire scene seeming to palpitate with life as the towering statue looks on.

Will Rea evokes the aesthetic power of Ibadan:

Running splash of rust 

and gold – flung and scattered

among several hills like broken

china in the sun.

[ J. P. Clark, ''Ibadan'']

The poet’s image is of Ibadan, the rust and gold splashed, as Rome was, against seven hills. These hills within which the city of Ibadan is set are, however, the rolling deep green hills of still remaining tropical rainforest which, fading to a gunmetal, smoky blue surround the city.

The city of Ibadan, located 78 miles inland from Lagos in Yoruba-speaking southern Nigeria, is a city of hills; it has multiple highpoints, each of which forms a centre around which different districts form their distinct characters, but the centre of the city falls from the tallest of the hills, tumbling down the hillside in a seemingly chaotic jumble of rusting corrugated iron roofs and crumbling mud buildings, tumbling from the [highest point] overlooking Ojoba market as it cascades downhill, market wares seemingly sprawling out in all directions, [at which point is] a statue of Shango, Yoruba deity of thunder and tutelary deity of the Oyo, the founding genitors of the city.

("Ibadan 1960'', British Academy Review 10)

              The Scribal Tradition in Yoruba Philosophy

I also don't recall encountering in Global Yoruba a discussion of the scribal tradition in Yoruba philosophy. The scribal tradition in Yoruba philosophy is represented by texts that came into public visibility through writing, rather than the oral formulations represented by what I describe as the classical period.

Such scribal texts represent efforts to engage creatively with the oral tradition, rather than describing it, powerful and indispensable as that is, or strike out in new directions, while demonstrating significant affiliations with other thinkers in the tradition.

Examples of such creative reworkings include Segun Gbadegesin's explorations of the logic of the concept of ''ori'', the self  ( in African Philosophy: New and Traditional Perspectives, ed. Lee Brown, 2004);  my own study of the interpretive possibilities of Ifa divinatory hermeneutics beyond Africana contexts, engaging Western autobiographical theory in relation to the letters and paintings of the Dutch artist Vincent van Gogh ( Reconfigurations, Vol.6,  2020),  and in relation to the philosophy of space, integrating the London Underground, Italian writer Italo Calvino's Invisible Cities and German philosopher Martin Heideggger (The Palgrave Handbook of Africa and the Changing Global Order, ed. Samuel Ojo Oloruntoba and Toyin Falola, 2022) and on the value of Yoruba philosophy for educational theory and practice ( Yoruba Studies Review, Fall 2018); Wole Soyinka's discussion of drama in relation to cosmology through the lens of African and particularly Yoruba discourse ( Myth, Literature and the African World, 1976) ; Richard Olusegun Babalola's discussion of his vision and challenges with adapting classical Yoruba architectural thought and practice in a contemporary context (INTBAU, 2013) ; Toyin Falola's individualistic adaptation of Eshu hermeneutics ( in ''Ritual Archives'', in The Toyin Falola Reader, ) Malcolm Allen's description of the challenges of the British Psychoanalytic Society in terms of Eshu hermeneutics ( ''Renewal or Retreat? Psychoanalytic Psychotherapy at the Crossroads'', Psychoanalytic Psychotherapy, Vol. 24, No. 1,  2010, 44–50; and Moyo Okediji's efforts at expanding the mathematical scope of Ifa in relation to ideas of infinity, if I have understood him correctly, Rowland Abiodun's creation of new concepts in Yoruba aesthetics ( Yoruba Art and Language, 2014); Susanne Wenger's exposition and rethinking of Yoruba Orisha cosmology, represented most forcefully by her A Life with the Gods in their Yoruba Homeland ( 1983); ( Akinsola Akiwowo's work in developing sociological models from Yoruba oral literature and thought ( "Contributions to the Sociology of Knowledge from an African Oral Poetry'', International Sociology, Volume 1, Issue 4, 1986), among the few works I am aware of. Akiwowo is one of the most important figures in the globalization of Yoruba thought on account of the international impact of his efforts, as demonstrated by the debates it inspired in sociology about developing sociological paradigms beyond Western thought.

      Continuities Between Oral and Scribal Cultures in Yoruba Philosophy

But then, to what degree can Babatunde Lawal's account of Yoruba aesthetics in ''Àwòrán: Representing the Self and its Metaphysical Other in Yoruba Art'' (The Art Bulletin, Vol. 83, No. 3, 2001, 498-526) , be described as a description of or a report on Yoruba aesthetics, rather than a reconstruction of that aesthetics shaped by his own creative selectivity in making sense of a broad range of material gathered from broad ranging field work?

Are his efforts at interpreting Ogboni symbolism of the number three and other Ogboni forms is not enriched by his combination of speculative creativity and concrete information? (  ''À Yà Gbó, À Yà Tó: New Perspectives on Edan Ògbóni'', African Arts, Vol. 28, No. 1, 1995, 36-49+98-100).

To what degree is Akinwunmi Ogundiran's recreation of the ideational matrices of Yoruba society a product of that society or an outcome of his own convergence of intellectual observation and imaginative creativity? ( The Yoruba: A New History)?

Rowland Abiodun's integration of various ese ifa in constructing an expanded conception of ''oro'', discourse, is magnificent in its skillful use of oral sources, but is he not better understood as a creative thinker continuing the reworking of the oral tradition represented by the oral artists whose works he draws upon? ( Yoruba Art and Language).

      Parallels with Indian Philosophy

            B.K. Matilal and Jornadon Ganeri

A helpful example in appreciating the historical and ideational continuity of what I describe as classical and post-classical Yoruba philosophies is the Indian tradition, in which contemporary thinkers may both describe and rethink the classical culture as well as develop new orientations, in dialogue with other traditions, at various degrees of relationship with the classical tradition.

This is exemplified by such figures as Bimal Krishna Matital, whose works range from exploring the ethical implications of ancient Indian religious classics ( Ethics and Epics, 2015), to a broad range of philosophical questions ( Mind, Language and World, 2015) and  Jornadon Ganeri, who has studied the epistemic implications of classical Indian texts ( The Concealed Art of the Soul: Theories of the Self and Practices of Truth in Indian Ethics and Epistemology, 2013) while ranging widely over other aspects of philosophy ( such as  The Self: Naturalism, Consciousness, and the First-Person Stance, 2012, ''The first book to draw together the Indian philosophical tradition with current philosophical work on the self''). 

          Histories of Indian Philosophy         

This sensitivity to continuity in Indian philosophy is represented for the classical tradition by such works as  Surendranath Dasgupta's A History of Indian Philosophy ( 1922-1955) which traces intertextual developments from the most ancient texts across centuries of development in classical Indian thought.

Purushottama Bilimoria's edited  History of Indian Philosophy (2017)  takes the story up to the present, in terms of the continuity between the classical and the post-classical traditions, showing how the tradition  is rooted in the most ancient texts and practices, presenting ''the various streams of Indian philosophy in constant contact, as flowing in and out of each other as it were, for this truly reflects an aspect of Indian philosophy itself, which, to a certain extent, sets it apart from western philosophy. "-Arvind Sharma, Journal of Dharma Studies ( Quoted on Amazon). 

         Parallels with Western Philosophy

Histories of Western philosophy do not include such foundational religious texts as the Bible while those of India necessarily engage with such equivalents in Indian thought as the Upanishads, the Bhagavad Gita and the Mahabharata, but an adequate grasp of the history of Western philosophy is impossible without an understanding of the influence of Christianity on that tradition, even amongst supposedly secular thinkers. 

Martin Heidegger's exploration of the nature of being may be better appreciated in relation to Christian theologian and philosopher Thomas Aquinas' exploration of the same subject while Aquinas and Heidegger are both indebted to the ancient Greek thinkers,  Aquinas needing to be understood at the intersection of Christian theology and its Biblical roots and ancient Greek thought.

Immanuel Kant's deeply impactful Critique of Pure Reason can only be adequately appreciated against the context of Christian theology, its Biblical roots  and the influence of these religious strands on philosophy, influences to which he responds as he develops his own approach to the tension between faith and intellect, between spirituality, intellect and imagination that shapes his work. 

G. W. F. Hegel's philosophical project may be understood as an effort to intellectualize a central point of Christian faith, the belief in the spirit of God as shaping history, an idea Hegel adapted to a study of the relationship between the human mind and that spirit interpreted in relation to consciousness as underlying  the universe.

Ancient Greek thought, which, with the Judaic tradition, constitutes the other matrix for Western philosophy, is itself represented by the dialogue between intellect and faith, myth and logic, a dialogue from which ancient Greek philosophy emerged, as represented by Parmenides, particularly by the mythic framework of presentation of logical thinking as the quality humans share with gods (   To Think Like God: Pythagoras and Parmenides:The Origins of Philosophy, Arnold Herman, 2004)   and Plato's use of the dialogue between intellect and imagination.

Yoruba philosophy may also be understood in terms of a dialogue from ancient times to the present, in which old and new themes and forms of thought are continually engaged through rethinking, creating, consolidating, reworking and breaking new grounds.

Emphasizing such  a history, as it emerges in Yoruba thought within and beyond Yorubaland,  would advance the complementary theme of Global Yoruba, Yoruba being and becoming, existence and change across the world, as a process reflected in various cognitive forms, representing people trying to make meaning of existence at different points in space and time. What better way to demonstrate this than through the permutations of Yoruba thought as taken forward by various thinkers from the past to the present?

       Yoruba Visual and Performative Arts

Global Yoruba also does not discuss Yoruba visual and performative arts apart from Yoruba music and Yoruba film, even though the history of those genres is richly represented by various texts, making them strategic to the study of African arts.

                     Yoruba Visual Arts

Explorations of the history of Yoruba visual arts have become paradigmatic for the study of African arts from ancient times to the present, with particular names becoming prominent in the classical context, such as Olowe of Ise and Lagbayi ( The Yoruba Artist: New Theoretical Perspectives in African Arts, 1994, ed. Rowland Abiodun, Henry John Drewal and John Pemberton III; Yoruba: Nine Centuries of African Art and Thought, 1989, ed. Henry John Drewal, John Pemberton II and Rowland Abiodun).

Other masters are recognizable by their styles and schools of expression, such as that of edan ogboni sculpture,  even when the creators may or may not be known, as evident with Babatunde Lawal's study of edan ogboni style and picturing of two artists in that tradition (  ''À Yà Gbó, À Yà Tó: New Perspectives on Edan Ògbóni'').

Artists such as Lamidi Fakeye and his children bridge the classical and post-classical periods in Yoruba sculpture and figures such as Moyo Okediji, Osi Audu and Susanne Wenger and her school project traditional conceptions in new terms.

 Okediji depicts the odu ifa, the organizational categories of ifa, in terms of organic assemblages  (''Revisioning Odu Ifa:Abstraction to Concreteness: Earth to Earth: Moyo Okediji's Odu Ifa Earth Series Installations'', 2013, Oluwatoyin Vincent Adepoju, Facebook) and in painting   and thread weaving, as well as visually exploring the geometric inscriptional possibilities of opon ifa, the divination platform and cosmological symbol of Ifa ( "Rethinking Ifa : From Classical to Post-Classical Geometries 1 : The Ifa Vectors of Moyo Okediji, 2021, Oluwatoyin Vincent Adepoju, Facebook).

Audu explores  conception of the self through geometric and other images,  moving from his grounding  in Yoruba philosophy, on which he has published an article on the Yoruba philosophy of the self (  Oxford Companion to the Mind, 2004) to more general considerations. 

Wenger and her school have visualized Orisha cosmology in terms of sculptural  and architectural forms in unique styles reshaping the Oshun forest in Oshogbo ( the best introduction to their work known to me being  Ulli Beir's The Return of the Gods: The Sacred Art of Susanne Wenger, 1975 complemented by the magnificent presentation at the site of the Adunni Olorisa Trust Adunni Foundation ).

Demonstrating the various forms of globalization evidenced by Yoruba culture, Okediji and Audu were born in Nigeria, schooled there, and, with Okediji, already had a thriving art practice there,  and subsequently emigrated to the US, while Wenger was an Austrian, already established as an artist in Austria before visiting Nigeria with her German husband, Ulli Beier, the great cultural catalyst, and remained in Nigeria, working with culture bearers and artists in Yorubaland.

Image and Text: Prayer Lyricism

                                                                                                                                                            

                                             

The lyricism of worship is depicted of Christian prayer by this painting in Global Yoruba, evoking the highly emotive and physically dynamic worship of Pentecostal Christianity, its African variant described by one view as adapting prayer styles from classical African religions.

Pentecostalism is represented in Nigeria by, among others,  Yoruba pastors such as David Oyedepo of the Living Faith Church, Enoch Adeboye of the Redeemed Christian Church of God and Daniel Olukoya of Mountains of Fire and Miracles Ministry, who have created global brands from their bases in Nigeria.

The figure in the painting is ecstatic and yet serene, basking in sensitivity to a powerful force beyond the currents of the everyday, transported from time into the timeless, the slightly open lips and closed eyes testifying to rapture, as flowing lines seem to merge the praying person with an enveloping space in which worshipper, worship and the worshipped fuse as one.    

                   

     Yoruba Performative Arts

Yoruba performative arts beyond modern music and film  are also not discussed in Global Yoruba. These arts include theatrical forms which emerged from ritual, such as as the Alarinjo travelling theatre which evolved from the Egungun ancestral masquerade in the 16th century within the politics of the Oyo empire, undergoing creative transformation and diffusion into other Yoruba regions after the fall of the empire, thereafter becoming the inspiration or progenitor of Yoruba theatre and its influence on written drama and film making, with prominent figures in Yoruba theatre having been, among others,  Hubert Ogunde, Duro Ladipo and Kola Ogunmola, developing their own innovations within the tradition ( “Aláàrìnjó” ( Wikipedia), Omotayo Oloruntoba-Oju, ''From Alarinjo to Arugba : Continuities in Indigenous Nigerian Drama'', African Identities, 2013, Vol. 11, No.4, 395-406; ''Yoruba Theatre, Nigeria – A Study'', Classical Arts Universe; Biodun Jeyifo, The  Yoruba Popular Theatre of Nigeria, 1984).

Historical explorations of the development of ritual into theatre and the influence of these forms in other performative genres in the Yoruba diaspora may also be traced, as Robert Lima does for Cuba (“The Orisha Chango and Other African Deities in Cuba Drama, ” Latin American Theatre Review, 1990, 33-42).

A totalistic history of Yoruba civilization would therefore involve the exploration of the growth of philosophy, spirituality,   the visual, verbal and performative arts and the sciences in relation to the full range of social developments as they have unfolded in constituting that civilization across time and space.

Historiographies and Philosophies of History Inspired by Yoruba Thought

Such a history could also develop a philosophy of history or a historiographic methodology correlative with Yoruba thought, demonstrating the potential of Yoruba philosophy as a guide to exploring and influencing the complex of factors shaping experience across space and time.

Is that not one way of describing Ifa divination, the premier Yoruba knowledge system?

May what can be described as Falola's illumination of temporal, spatial and ideological networks in exploring Yoruba history in Global Yoruba not be productively visualized through the symbols of Ifa hermeneutics?

Falola's book narrates the vertical, temporal progression of Yoruba history, from the remote past to the present, within and beyond Yorubaland, across Africa and into the Americas.

Ifa divination symbolism is represented by the drawing of a vertical line on the opon ifa, the divination platform and cosmological symbol of Ifa.

Falola also explores what may be described as the horizontal dimension of time in Yoruba experience, specifically in its spirituality and philosophy, a horizontality cutting across the vertical, and representing the aspiration to both immerse oneself in the depths  of the immediacy of experience and transcend that immediacy through  entry into the trans-temporal or timeless, aspirations pursued through ritual, through music, through textual engagement, efforts both discussed by Falola and potently visualized through art of spiritual activity in Global Yoruba.

Ifa divination symbolism also involves the drawing of a horizontal line to intersect the vertical line on the opon ifa, preparatory to a divination session, as described in Abiodun, Pemberton and Drewal's Yoruba: Nine Centuries.

Falola's interpretive model is centred in the spatial diffusion of Yoruba culture from its natal origins to different parts of the world, possibilities developing varied ways of engaging relationships between being and becoming, time and eternity constituted by philosophy and spirituality.

The opon ifa operates in terms of the visual equivalent of such a principle of centrifugal motion, motion from a centre to a circumference, represented by the empty centre of the opon ifa surrounded by its circumference populated by diverse carved forms, that centre being the space where the divinatory symbols are configured when cast in divination, configurations generating responses to queries brought to the oracle.

The ultimate possibilities of Yoruba culture are discussed by Falola as embryonic within its original formulation, breaking open afresh in new constellations under the impulse of diverse circumstances, multifarious creativities orbiting the inspirational centre as radiations from an originating nexus.

What is the significance of such interpretive models, using visual symbolism in generating a breadth of ideas?

They help stimulate thought through the evocative power of images and concentrate and consolidate understanding through the integrative power of visual symbols, evoking a field of ideations through a single image.

In achieving these goals, they demonstrate the cognitive force of Yoruba thought, the achievements of past centuries resonating in the present and future in new formations, the central thesis of Falola's book on the globalization of Yoruba existence, moving from geography and biology to ideology, travelling across space and time.

Image and Text: Multiple Illuminations

                                                                                       

                                                 

               

 A whimsical, almost comedic depiction of what may be an urgent need for a person experiencing it, " Searching for the True God" by Kazeem Ekeolu, as pictured in Global Yoruba, evoking the variety of faiths-Christianity, Islam, Judaism and traditional African religions, populating the geographical and mental space of Yoruba people, provoking questions about the authenticity of each one, in the light of the exclusivist vision of spirituality championed by the faiths ultimately inspired by Abraham, who is described as seeing his God as either the only true God or as supreme over all others, an orientation taken forward in Judaism, Christianity and Islam but alien to classical African spiritualities, and to Hinduism and Western esotericism, which can also be found in Southern Nigeria, where the Yoruba are concentrated.

The playfully visualized figure peers in wonder, awe or consternation or all these emotions, at the kaleidoscope of faiths populating the globe, his position outside the terrestrial sphere where the symbols of these belief systems are placed suggesting psychological distance between those faiths and their call to the human person, the human being as the agent appealed to by these belief systems and the possibile battleground for their contending claims.

Will the enquiring figure discover the one true God as propagated by these faiths or will he see that God as inaccessible through any of them or will he testify to the relative value of each as a means of reaching this God or will he cease to identify with the idea of God?

The Andalusian Muslim thinker Ibn Arabi declares in The Tarjuman al-Ashwaq, The Interpreter of Desires:

        " Wonder,

A garden among the flames!

My heart can take on any form:
A meadow for gazelles,
A cloister for monks,
For the idols, sacred ground,
Ka'ba for the circling pilgrim,
The tables of the Torah,
The scrolls of the Quran.

My creed is Love;
Wherever its caravan turns along the way,
That is my belief,
My faith"

 

As translated at AllPoetry.

The Publishing Opportunity 

Falola has done his own work in writing  Global Yoruba   and having it published by one of the best academic presses in the world.

 Others need to do their best to have this book published in the natal home of the Yoruba people. The book needs to be published in Nigeria for Nigerian and Africa wide consumption at prices readily accessible in those locations. The digital open access availability provided by the publisher is great but is not enough.

What do we need to do to make books like this readily accessible to the people it is about in their native countries? Awesome books in Yoruba Studies are steadily emerging from Western publishers and priced for the Western market. This book is $55 in paperback for example, almost a 100,000 naira in Nigerian currency, a significant amount for many Nigerians.

Happily, Indiana UP, the publishers, have also made it available as an open access e-book. I think, though, that the presence of physical books cannot be eclipsed by digital texts which at best complement the physical texts.

The same publisher brought out  Akinwumi Ogundiran's fantastic The Yoruba: A New History, an indispensable text in the effort to historicize Yoruba thought in the context of bringing Yoruba political, military, economic, philosophical and spiritual history alive in a manner imprinting vivid narratives of epic scope and individual identity and travail on the mind of the reader, a work shaped by a harmony of novelistic narrative force and scholarly ideational configurations.

Recent works also include Falola's Decolonizing African Knowledge: Auto-Ethnography and African Epistemologies, exploring Yoruba culture in terms of the author's engagement with a spectrum of Yoruba cultural forms, including a spell binding chapter on Yoruba philosophy of female hair styling.

Earlier works include Rowland Abiodun's Yoruba Art and Language:Seeking the African in African Art, a trenchant examination of Yoruba aesthetics, extending the flexibility of the Yoruba language in creating new aesthetic terms.

Works by Jacob Olupona, Adeleke Adeeko, Susanne Preston Blier,  Aimee Dafon Segla's book on Yoruba mathematics, among other majestic books, demonstrate the vibrance of Yoruba Studies outside Africa, excluding that of Segla, who is in Africa,  though I include him here on account of the lesser visibility of work on science in Yoruba culture, while his book was published in the West, implying the same pricing regimen of Western published academic books that make access to them prohibitive for regions with weaker currencies, as in Africa.

How can these works be reprinted in Nigeria, the primary home of the Yoruba, used in educational curricula, made readily accessible to academic readers and the general public, inspiring people to engage this feast of knowledge?

Pan-African University Press, an initiative in which Toyin Falola has played a central role in its creation, is already working in that direction, by publishing scholarly books, high in content quality and physical production, and making them readily affordable for the Nigerian market. Perhaps the Press and other publishers could buy the rights to African cented scholarly works from Western publishers and republish them in Africa, pricing them for the African market.

Nigerian bookshops, such as Sunshine Booksellers and Moruso the Booksellers, in Ibadan, and Roving Heights bookshop in Lagos, stock Falola books, in their high quality physical production, at cheap prices.

  

 

 

[Michael Afolayan]

Oluwatoyin Adepoju's review of Falola's Global Yoruba: Regional and Diasporic Networks is monumental and laudable. The intentionality and depth of analysis make Adepoju's review something worth serious consideration. The cerebral mentation entailed in the review, in addition to the logical arrangement of facts on the context and contents of the work arrest the reader, constructing an intellection that tantalizes the inquisitive interest of a Falola reader. Without a doubt, Adepoju's review is truly a positive endorsement of this monumental work. It truly gives a bird's eye view of the entire volume. Kudos to this reviewer for the quality (and quantity, I must add) of the production. To painstakingly review the words, the world, and the images that saturate pages of this huge contribution to Yoruba (and African) studies is a daunting task that must be noted. Yes, indeed, Indiana University Press is no stranger to publishing notable works of sound African intellectuals, and has done well with this one as well. 

In quoting John Pepper Clark's famous "Ibadan" poem, however, Adepoju needs to change the word "several" to "seven" except, perhaps, he intends to deliberately reconstruct the poem to achieve an intended effect; after all, the hills that surround Ibadan, plus those on which the city is built are myriads in number. 

Adepoju did Indiana University a great favor in this review and I hope the Press would take note of the effort because his is a commentary that forcefully trumpets Falola's work, in his own words, as "an exploration of Yoruba existence across time and global space."  

High fives, Adepoju!

More grace, Falola!

Michael O. Afoláyan

(From the State of the Living Spring)

--
Listserv moderated by Toyin Falola, University of Texas at Austin
To post to this group, send an email to USAAfric...@googlegroups.com
To subscribe to this group, send an email to USAAfricaDial...@googlegroups.com
Current archives at http://groups.google.com/group/USAAfricaDialogue
Early archives at http://www.utexas.edu/conferences/africa/ads/index.html
---
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "USA Africa Dialogue Series" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to usaafricadialo...@googlegroups.com.
To view this discussion visit https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/usaafricadialogue/CAGBtzfMDm7%3DfQy3XZk-ZEYqGjD4L6gPNByd4nL4BLxWuS%2BTFPw%40mail.gmail.com.

[Oluwatoyin Adepoju]

Dear Prof Afolayan,

Please allow me to dobale in appreciation.

Thanks for the correction on the J.P. Clark line. I'll effect it.

The article was written in Gmail, with saving in Word as backup, an approach with a lot of pluses but very risky for losing accidentally deleted text since Gmail saves all changes automatically.

One calls oneself an Independent Scholar running purely on his own steam, but that is not fully true.

Appreciation is a critical engine even for someone "wandering on social media or cyberspace" as you ruefully put it once.

Yes, your own grounding in the field, along with your general cognitive culture, facilitates your engagement with the issues.

I thank Falola for giving me the book. If I had to rely only on the free digital version I wonder when I would have done the review, since the sumptuously inviting print text projected a sense of urgency.

Anyway, hopefully I'm just getting started with that book.

With books like this one and Ogundiran's The Yoruba:A New History, one arrives at the latest stage in the long journey of Yoruba historiography and can better track the journey travelled, orienting oneself accordingly, even in African and world history, possibly using the Yoruba matrix as an inspirational starting point.

With the exposure and incentive provided by books like these, I can start to more systematically educate myself in Yoruba Studies, complementing  the approach I've employed before now.

Ironically, my journey in Yoruba Studies, in general, and Yoruba spirituality, in particular, began in Benin-City, where, hungry for literature not available on Africa in my family's relatively rich library, I discovered Soyinka's Myth, Literature and the African World, Bolaji Idowu's Olodumare: God in Yoruba Belief and Wande Abinmbola's books on Ifa. 

I doubt if even Benin culture has such a staple of masterwriters, initiating one into their philosophies and spiritualities with such a combination of intellectual force and spiritual sensitivity.

The presence of a Soyinka, for example,  in the Yoruba cultural space represents an awesome advantage which I wonder if any other African culture possesses. By the time one adds the Susanne Wengers, the Ulli Beiers, the Pierre Vergers, the Falolas, Ogundirans, Afolayans, Yoruba and non-Yoruba people addressing Yoruba culture, the harvest is momentous.

Yoruba philosophy, spirituality and arts have been so thoroughly intellectualized, enabling easy lifting from their geographical contexts and application elsewhere, they have proven invaluable in understanding my journey in Benin spirituality at intersections with Igbo thought and other Southern Nigerian and Akan thought.

Mazisi Kunene on Zulu philosophy, Ayi Kwei Armah on Akan thought, Ahmadou Hampate Ba on Fulani thought, are among my encounters with the heights of human thought. I need to read more of such masters on other African thought.

Reading such books as Global Yoruba and The Yoruba:A New History and responding to them helps one organize one's knowledge, as one wonders how such books are written, so powerful they are.

Falola's trajectory towards  Global Yoruba , however, may be understood as relatively clear since his post-PhD publications, as he assimilated what was known, and  reflected upon various levels of knowledge as they became available in succeeding decades.

I get the impression that his treatment of Yoruba cosmology in The Yoruba: From Prehistory to the Present, with Aribidesi Usman, is different from that of Global Yoruba .

In the previous book,  devoting just one chapter to the subject, Yoruba cosmology seems to have been presented in the conventional static manner,  a frozen approach that Ogundiran critiqued,   in favour of the need to historicize the development of ideas and practices represented by the tradition, even though I'm still trying to adequately understand Ogundiran's rationale, in terms of temporal identification  and motivation for innovations in the tradition, for his various historicizations, and I wish he gave more room for the speculative and genuinely spiritual element in classical Yoruba philosophy and spirituality, although his characterization of the Orisha, the deities of the classical cosmology, is sublime, comparable in  imaginative force with a correlative image of infinity from Buddhism, the famous Net of Indra, though Ogundiran draws on an idea from physics of a kind likely unknown when the Buddhist text was composed.

Falola strives, in Global Yoruba, to engage the philosophical and spiritual tradition as an evolving entity, as it were, metamorphosing across Yorubaland, and beyond, into the Americas, where it has taken on an amazing life.

Falola's book on Yoruba metaphysics is coming out this year.

Will it include his personal relationship with this metaphysics, in dialogue, perhaps with other systems he has explored, such as the meditation Vik Bahl, perhaps, recommended he use in order to recover from the trauma of losing his manuscripts in transit before he began to store them in the digital cloud, as he states in an interview?

Falola also presents a rich and unconventional meditation on the Yoruba origin Orisha tradition deity Eshu in ''Ritual Archives'',  a version of what is known in Western magic as the Assumption of God Form, the contemplative assumption of the identity of a deity, also well developed in Hinduism and Buddhism, and correlative with deity identifications in classical African spiritualities, although the little I have read so far about the latter emphasizes possession of devotee by deity, suspending the devotee's consciousness in the process while the possession proceeds, while the Western, Hindu and Buddhist approaches I am referencing emphasize the expansion of the consciousness of the devotee through contact with the being of the deity, an approach the Falola Eshu meditation seems to suggest.

Is more to be expected on his relationship with his childhood mentor Iya Lekuleja, his accounts of her in his autobiographies being classics of description of a spiritual master, although he states in Counting the Tiger's Teeth that his efforts to reveal her mystery have led to dreams of being chased by a fierce and powerful animal?

He claims, in the first chapter, I think, of Decolonizing African Knowledge: Auto-Ethnography and African Epistemologies, that his memory is aided by magic, if I recall correctly, performed by Leku, but what Leku is described as doing seems to be giving him a herbal concoction to drink, the use of such ingested material enablements also known as employed in the training of Ifa priests to aid memory.

So, is the active ingredient therefore a material, herbal preparation, even though with Leku and some instances of Yoruba herbalogy, spirituality and herbs go together, at times through ofo, incantatory language meant to empower oogun, the material preparation which may be medicinal or spiritual or both?

It would be great if African scholars were to open up more on the intersection of their spirituality and their scholarship, as some Western scholars are doing. 

As magnificent as the Ogundiran and Falola books are, they leave me yearning for more, having taken one to a mountaintop where new vistas become visible in the unfolding landscape.

In terms of communicative technique, one of the wisest things Falola has done of recent is to use rich, original illustrations for his book covers and in the interiors, thereby creating synergy between the aesthetic stimulation of art, its ideational projection and the intellectual power of written text.

If I had the opportunity, I would not only republish Global Yoruba for the African market but commission the artists to reproduce those works in colour, as much as possible, further  actualizing the character of the book as a means of both pleasure and learning.

I continue to marvel at what Yoruba scholars are doing with Yoruba civilization in their scholarship. It might not be a popular observation, but has it been up to 200 years since the widespread art of writing emerged in Yorubaland through the colonial encounter?

Islam in Yorubaland, before Western colonization, would have come with the art of writing but that scribal culture  does not seem to have impacted what we now know as Yorubaland in a deep manner. I wonder why.

One commentator on the contemporary escalation of the struggle for cultural dominance in Ilorin by Fulani jihad inspired Islam which conquered Ilorin after the dramatic story of Afonja and Alimi holds that the strain of Islam dominant there understands itself in terms of cultural superiority to classical Yoruba civilization represented by Yoruba origin Orisha cosmology, a situation partly represented by the fact that they, the Muslims, were literate while their Isese, Yoruba tradition practising neighbors were not. 

Books like Global Yoruba might not often be invoked when discussing contemporary cultural politics, but the incidental intersections between the Ilorin struggle of last year, if I recall properly, and such an ecumenical text as Global Yoruba and Falola's Sacred Words and Holy Realms, the latter being both particularly rich on Islam and Ifa, in relation to Falola's projected third part of his autobiography which  he says will deal with his time in an Islamic school, may provoke questions on what Falola's teacher J. D. Y. Peel describes in his book of that title as further developments in religious encounter in the making of the Yoruba.

Books like Global Yoruba, Ogundiran's The Yoruba:A New History and Soyinka's awesome Myth, Literature and the African World, valorize classical Yoruba cosmology but what is the fate of that cosmology and its arts, among the greatest contributions of Yorubaland to civilization, in the land of origin of that cultural system?

How live is it beyond Nollywood?

As a person put it to Isese partitioners during the Ilorin debacle, ''how many members of government or other prominent people in Nigeria publicly subscribe to your religion?''

We have all become Christians and Muslims.

Happily the growing literature will help distill the inspirational core of this classical spirituality and philosophy, taking it beyond its accustomed ritual contexts, making it more accessible, more mobile, more portable, so that its efflorescence will not be limited to the diaspora.

The future for classical Yoruba spirituality and philosophy in Yorubaland might lie in syncretism with Christianity and Islam. 

My almost heartbreaking experience in Ijebu-Ode this year convinced me that the battle for the centralization in Yorubaland of classical Yoruba philosophy and spirituality and its awesome arts  is irrevocably  lost, as I observed the total dominance of that capital city by mosques and churches at various levels of grandeur, with traditional spirituality locations not readily found and commanding nothing like the visual vigour and care of the Abrahamic sites, while in the centre of the city, the memorial to the story of a legendary magical exploit by an Ifa diviner  at the founding of Ijebu Ode was not in impressive condition though the story is still gloriously told.

At the former University of Ife,  the city that is the heartland of Yoruba spirituality as perhaps Mecca is to Islam, I saw in 2022 a superb church and mosque, with superb art in the church but I saw nothing for the worship of classical African spiritualities, decades after Soyinka took up that struggle, as he recounts in A Credo of Being and Nothingness.

So, a Yoruba philosophy and spirituality practitioner  such as myself and scholars who appreciate the significance of that cosmology as centrally demonstrating a culture's creativity would be excited by the wonderful work of Global Yoruba and Ogundiran's The Yoruba in highlighting these systems, African Americans and other orisha devotees in the Americas will see such books as a form of Christmas,  a wondrous gift, but, for the philosophical and spirituality sections of those books dealing with classical Yruba thought, what is likely to be the story in Nigeria, where I understood some Yoruba parents don’t want their children to study Ifa literature because it is seen as fetishistic?

What could be the future for Yoruba scribal philosophy in Yorubaland, philosophy that is primarily written rather than oral?

For how long will such philosophy foreground a marginalized school of thought represented by classical Yoruba thought, rich as that is?

Will the way forward be akin to that taken by ancient Greek religion, in its assimilation into and transcendence by philosophy, as different from India in which direct continuity between the classical and contemporary traditions is ensured through allegiances of faith and the existence of ancient texts to draw on?

Will classical Yoruba cosmology survive largely as a form of myth, as ancient Greek myth has?

Or will the picture in the next one hundred years be closer to that of the Yoruba community at Ikpodo, near Ikeja-Under-Bridge in Lagos, where Muslims and practitioners of traditional Yoruba spirituality collectively manage the Eshu, Aje and Egungun shrines, as I observed some years ago?

Falola discusess examples of such integrations in how Yorubas in Nigeria and the Diaspora practice Islam. He also examines the Yorubanization of Christianity.

A correlative example is the philosophy of Nimi Wariboko, fed by traditional Kalabari, Pentecostal and Christian thought. Such syncretisms might be more visible in the future.

 Great thanks

toyin

 

 

 

 

  

 

thanks

 

toyin

 

 

 

[Cornelius Hamelberg]

Oluwatoyin Vincent Adepoju,

Ojogbon is always busy and you too have been a little busy, Ojogbon has caused you to be busy and has kept you busy. Great Congratulations ! Busyness helps diminish personal/ individual ignorance, and helps to expand our horizons. 

The book is obviously for specialists and not for beginners such as yours truly.

Hopefully, your much lauded review of Ojogbon Toyin Falola's Global Yorùbá: Regional and Diasporic Networks would be even more useful if it were to be published at e.g 

https://republic.com.ng/ - and at other scholarly oriented sites  

My initial reaction  - a few moments ago was : by all means spread the good light , but minus your explanatory, rather overarching subtitle, “Yoruba Existence Across Time and Global Space” -  time & space (over the down-ro-earth concreteness of the chronological and the geographic spread , the  regional / mother heartlands and the diaspora) to my uninitiated mind is strongly suggestive of your predilection for the cosmic & the cosmological & possibly some quantum leaps into the special mystical gobbledegook vocabularies ( although not having read the book that you have reviewed, I cannot and do not know whether or not it is / was Ojogbon’s intention to cover that kind of territory , or if he indeed does so.

But then again I have been thrilled to meet diaspora Cuban exponents of Santeria over here in Stockholm  40 years ago -- and just isolating religion alone, how can we talk about how Yoruba religion got to Cuba - and to Sweden without subsuming the discussion under the general / specific title “Yoruba Existence Across Time and Global Space”?

So you’re on the ball, after all, Sir…

[Oluwatoyin Adepoju]

Thanks Cornelius.

The book is deeply informed by specialised knowledge but is not a book for specialists.

Its style and rich illustrations- drawings, paintings and photography make it both entertaining, fun and informative, while the robustness of the paperback provides a lush comfort to the hand as one holds it, an experience I expect is delivered in different terms with the hardback, if there is such a version.

Yes, the title of the review reflects my philosophical orientations and even suggests a hint of the mystical, my ultimate inspirational ground, but I was not able to carry the review in that direction, although a part of me wanted to, a pull I had to resist in the name of the integrity of the essay, mysticism meaning, in this context, the subsummation of reality in terms of an ultimate synthesis.

The book is deeply grounded in a philosophical exploration of Yoruba existence and so justifies the aerodynamic orientations of that title, although Falola's kind of philosophy is reflected in clarity of expression and thought, free of jargon.

You can look through the book for fun, simply enjoying the pictures and dipping in now and again or reading at any pace one wants.

Its organized in terms of subsections within subsections, fractal continuities, as it were, of parts within wholes, which one can enjoy independently of the surrounding text, yet the whole thing flows seamlessly.

The writer clearly spent a lot of time in pursuing clarity along with compression.

True, studying Falola's work is a lifetime's pursuit and can expand one's knowledge considerably, as well as facilitate integration of what one knows, even taking beyond Falola's own range of reference as one considers the implications of his ideas.

Thanks for suggesting a more scholarly publication option. Ive been to that site and find it attractive. Its possible, though, that the essay will be published in the Yoruba Studies Review.

As it is, though, I'm considering expanding the essay.

I forgot to engage Olabiyi Yai's superb interpretation of the relationship between classical Yoruba theory of the self in terms of a concept of motion in time and space as the essential human condition, motion expressed in terms both metaphysical and material, embodied, one could say, in the African motif of the market as metonymic for the comings and goings of humans from the market that is Earth, an approach privileging departure from the familiar into the unfamiliar in terms of life in general and art in particular and dramatized in the privileging of diaspora as the human person explores new territories.

How may one relate these reflections of a post-classical ( my own term in this context) thinker to the painful diaspora of slavery that laid the foundations of the Yoruba and African diaspora in the Americas?

Could it be a style of explaining the survival of classical African and particularly Yoruba cultures in the Americas?

In terms of correlating diaspora and trauma, diaspora in relation to metaphysical contexts and diaspora in physical terms, how could one relate Yai's ideas to what is described as Gershom Scholem's interpretation of the mythic metaphysics of Isaac Luria in terms of the trauma of the expulsion of the Jews from Spain after the defeat of the Moorish conquerors whom they were described as collaborating with, a terrible event he is is stated as describing  as influencing Luria's description of the cosmos as coming into being through the rupture of the vessels into which the creator of the universe poured his divine power, the vessels constituting the manifest universe shattering under the impact, generating the moral challenges constituting human life, as the devoted seeker seeks to find the shattered divine sparks and reunite them with their origins?

How may this correlation of earthly trauma and metaphysics relate to the horror unfolding in Gaza at the hands of Luria's descendants in response to the cycle of savagery represented by the Hamas attack in response to the Israeli occupation, leading to the genocidal Israeli reaction?

Im writing this at about 3 am, having woken from sleep not long ago, and in my shrine, a spatio-temporal context highly conducive to inspiration for me.

Thanks for prompting my reflections, which might make you think one is being arcane in one's thinking but I know Luria's Kaballah and the Gaza struggle certainly speak to your sensitivities.

Great thanks 

Toyin

[Cornelius Hamelberg]

Oluwatoyin Vincent Adepoju,

Great Congratulations for this output, once again a result of the great mental powers, the cerebral & emotional energies that are constantly at the service of your elucidatory proclivities which are said to be at their inspirational heights at circa 3am with or without the additional assistance of Benjamin Franklin’s electrical power in you Lagos hideout, your shrine.

And what does electricity

or the lack of electricity

matter when you yourself 

are the tyger  - when you yourself

are the tigritude tiger and the light 

burning bright, In the forests of the night ?

I suppose that Yoruba Studies Review is the best ultimate destination of your review of 

Global Yorùbá. Regional and Diasporic Networks. by Toyin Falola.

You say that “The book is deeply informed by specialised knowledge but is not a book for specialists.” Thanks for making that clear, because some book reviews can be quite intimidating  and off-putting you know, for even the most willing and well-intentioned layman; for me, for instance, time being of the essence, I was already feeling slightly intimidated by the size of Ojogbon’s latest, a whopping 519 pages, even bigger than the King James Version of the Bible which I’m sure that the average motor park poet has not read, speak less of “digested.” 

As for me, I’m still more than content with the poetic and marvellously illustrated encyclopaedic literary reservoir  ETCHES On Fresh Waters , a deep and unending oasis for Cornelius the thirsty. 

It's said  - an overgeneralization of course, that as early victims of missionary zeal, one of the problems of the African Petty-bourgeoisie is that in their search for relevant truths, religious orientation, lifestyle, directions as to how to live their lives, they may roam far and wide, but the very last place that their quest takes them to, is HOME. By age eleven, they are more acquainted with the Sunday School Geography and topography of The Holy Land - with the Biblical place names such as Judea, Galilee, Bethlehem Jerusalem on their lips and at their fingertips, as if they were there, familiar  with Abraham, Isaac, Moses, David, Solomon, Jesus , Saul on the Road to Damascus, etc and infinitely less acquainted with Sundiata Keita and Mansa Musa.

In the last century the publication and other media disseminations of Alex Haley’s Roots, fired the imagination, curiosity, consciousness of the Black Diaspora in North America especially, and set many blazing on a quest to find their roots. Spielberg’s Amistad  also achieved some of that magical effect as did Pharaoh Sanders : Our Roots Began in Africa , and , of course, Hip Hop and RAP overwhelmingly contributed to that purpose.  

In the last century the curiosity and the appetite was there alright but what was missing was the funding of reliable knowledge bases, libraries , schools and  the necessary outreach, to satisfy the curiosity of the dictum

“Know then thyself, presume not God to scan, 

The proper study of mankind is Man.”

But all that is rapidly changing, among other causes, for those who have such specific interests, thanks to the prodigious output by Ojogbon Falola and others such as Akinwumi Ogundiran about The Yoruba and in no small measure thanks to explicators and interpreters such as the venerable Oluwatoyin Vincent Adepoju, masses of Diaspora Africans are moving away from what you so aptly describe as “the cycle of savagery represented by the Hamas attack in response to the Israeli occupation, leading to the genocidal Israeli reaction” - are moving away from what they refer to as “judgmental religions” that they say preach the so called “poetic justice” of the hell fire waiting to consume the miscreants and actively searching for the holy grail to be found among other places, in Yoruba religion and way of life. Hopefully Nollywood will also contribute their share to such a serious purpose. 

BTW, I’m taking a good look at this series  Casting pearls before swine 

[Michael Afolayan]

Oluwatoyin Adepoju:

Permit me to digress a little, would you?

Three things:

One: I spent all day yesterday in the historical town of Oyo, under the roof of Baba Awise Awo Agbaye, Professor Wande Abimbola, just listening to the sage. His perspectives on the global Yoruba is no joke. We talked at length on a variety of subjects, Toyin Falola's latest work being one of them. Baba is familiar with the bounteous works of TF. It's no coincident that the two men are of the Ifa extraction. The cover image is certainly not a mere coincidence. Believe me, your subtitle of “Yoruba Existence Across Time and Global Space,” which my good friend, Cornelius, finds to be too stretchy, would fit perfectly into the paradigm in which Baba Awise perceives the Yoruba world to be. It's a world larger than many of us know - it is far larger than those of many of its counterparts. But let's set that aside today. 

Two: To complement this work of TF, there are many more to build around it. You are a voracious reader. From briefly hanging out with you in Lagos last week, reading and writing are your second nature. Works of giants of Yoruba/African Studies like Rowland Abiodun, Akin Ogundiran, Olufemi Vaughan, Wale Adebanwi, Adeleke Adeeko, Babatunde Lawal, Andrew Apter, Jacob Kehinde Olupona, and more, are also worth reviews. I know you've worked on Abiodun and Ogundiran in the past. 

Three: Please re-read Cornelius' admonishment, when he said, among other things: "Hopefully, your much lauded review of Ojogbon Toyin Falola's Global Yorùbá: Regional and Diasporic Networks would be even more useful if it were to be published at e.g The Republic: Serious Journalism from an African Worldview- and at other scholarly oriented sites..." I cannot agree more. That was exactly how I felt reading the excellent work you did in your review. I'm glad someone else felt the same way. Even if you choose to publish this review (and many of your other write-ups in Yoruba Studies Review, your style would fit more snugly in that kind of online scholarly outlet Cornelius is recommending. I don't think there is any legal restriction if you choose to use both.

 

Good luck, my friend!

 

MOA

--
Listserv moderated by Toyin Falola, University of Texas at Austin
To post to this group, send an email to USAAfric...@googlegroups.com
To subscribe to this group, send an email to USAAfricaDial...@googlegroups.com
Current archives at http://groups.google.com/group/USAAfricaDialogue
Early archives at http://www.utexas.edu/conferences/africa/ads/index.html
---
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "USA Africa Dialogue Series" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to usaafricadialo...@googlegroups.com.

To view this discussion visit https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/usaafricadialogue/CAGBtzfNrSzuEoVxYuL9vPfNvqs9SyiyVb_ZLEzZ%2BEDbyzxYyCA%40mail.gmail.com.

[Dr. Oohay]

Breaking News: PM (Trudeau) of our northern neighbor (Canada) to resign….(Quasi “Domino”effect begins?

--

Listserv moderated by Toyin Falola, University of Texas at Austin
To post to this group, send an email to USAAfric...@googlegroups.com
To subscribe to this group, send an email to USAAfricaDial...@googlegroups.com
Current archives at http://groups.google.com/group/USAAfricaDialogue
Early archives at http://www.utexas.edu/conferences/africa/ads/index.html
---
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "USA Africa Dialogue Series" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to usaafricadialo...@googlegroups.com.

To view this discussion visit https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/usaafricadialogue/d9e319b1-d560-41f8-94b2-5bbc33fab2b0n%40googlegroups.com.

[Cornelius Hamelberg]

I was already feeling slightly intimidated by the size of Ojogbon’s latest, a whopping 519 pages?
Correction : It’s actually a whopping 670 pages !

__________________________________________________________________________

Gaza 

https://www.google.de/search?q=Gaza

https://www.bing.com/search?pglt=43&q=Gaza&

More of the genocidal Israeli barbarism :

Israeli lawmakers demand military destroy all food and energy resources in Gaza

[Oluwatoyin Adepoju]

Great thanks Prof Afolayan.

Yoruba Studies, African Studies, Religious Studies and Literary Studies are forever indebted to Wande Abimbola for his clear and  luminous expositions of a body of knowledge constituting one of humanity's great achievements, ese ifa, the literature of the Yoruba origin Ifa system of knowledge. I hope to meet him one day.

Thanks for suggesting reviews of the works of those other masters in Yoruba Studies. I hope to study and possibly review them too.

My review of Global Yoruba had as a subconscious  undercurrent Olabiyi Yai's short,  magnificent review of Drewal, Abiodun and Pemberton's Yoruba:Nine Centuries. About one to two pages long, its an original contribution to the field and one of the best things I have read in Yoruba thought and arts.

Another such subcurrent for me is Nkiru Nzeogwu's review of Abiodu's Yoruba Art and Language. Its ideational range and structural power, its architectonic genius, make it equivalent to a book of its own. Abiodun is reproducing that and other reviews of the first edition in his second edition of the book due out this year.

Referencing critiques of books, Yai has a wonderful engagement with Meville and Frances Herskovits' anthropological classic,  Dahomean Narratives, ''The Path Is Open: The Legacy of Melville and Frances Herskovits in African Oral Narrative Analysis''.

In those book critiques like those of Yai and Nzegwu, the writer is engaging the work in such a way as to constitute a contribution to the field the book belongs to, engaging the work in terms of a breadth of knowledge of the field in question.

I wonder what the world has gained from Yai going into UNESCO rather than remaining in academia.

If he had remained, he would at least have rivalled Abiola Irele in the quality and scope of his thought, its cumulative force and   its accessibility. As it is, his former graduate student Adeeke Adeeko states his best work is unpublished.

In Global Yoruba, I wonder why Falola did not discuss Yoruba oral literature and visual arts,  perhaps bcs he does not understand them as demonstrating a pan-Yoruba scope? Or did I miss the discussions in the book? 

But perhaps globalization is also represented by the breadth of distribution of scholarly study of a field. In the study if classical African arts, I am not aware of studies of classical African aesthetics that are equal to the clarity and scope of studies in the endogenous aesthetics of Yoruba arts, pioneered by people like Rowland Abiodun in his wonderful 1990 paper ''The Future of African Arts Studies: An African Perspective''. I read that paper with repeated devotion, like scripture. I still treasure my battered 20 year old copy of the paper.

In keeping with the international character of Yoruba civilization, an ideal scholar in Yoruba Studies should be fluent in reading, writing and possibly speaking English, Yoruba, French, Spanish and Portuguese. I am yet to go beyond English fluency, though.

I'll submit the essay to that platform you suggested.

Great thanks

toyin

[Oluwatoyin Adepoju]

Thanks Cornelius.

I actually now have 24hr power, on account of large amounts of money spent on fueling a diesel generator in spite of the huge increase in diesel costs in the present administration.

This enables me to write any time of the day or night since I dont use pen and paper anymore but the price paid is indicated by the blissful silence that has descended with the putting out of the gen at 3.30 am, the kind of silence  that subtly but powerfully speaks that everyday is morning yet on creation day as the darkness envelops one as if one is in the womb of the ultimate beginning.

I intend to move for some time to Agbarha-Otor in the Niger Delta, where sadly, there is no electricity right now and am wondering how to cope.

The place is a researcher's heaven, with an unstudied religious culture- until my recent writings- which I need to share more on this group, but which are accessible at my Facebook page Searching for Bruce Onobrakpeya, the name referencing a man who is perhaps one of the greatest artists ever, who has a gallery in that place, his home community, a gallery housing some of his greatest works.

I salivate at the thought of greeting the rising of the sun by visiting those galleries within the sparse human presence of the area, the contemplative silence, and moving from roaming the galleries and perhaps after being intimate with one or two works of art, ill retire to the magnificent palm tree plantation nearby to enjoy further resounding solitude, powerful silence in nature.

The intimacies with the works of art could even extend to spending the night in the gallery, sleeping on a mat/duvet in front of Onobrakpeya's Akporode shrine installation, for example.

Going to bed after meditating on it and waking up to encounter the constructed personage as the first encounter my eyes enter into on waking, would be wonderful, as I study every inch of that installation, painstakingly inscribed with arcane symbols, as the artist creates his own unique language from classical Urhobo sacred arts, in dialogue with Benin, Yoruba, Fulani, Akan, and other African visualities.

 Akporode is itself at the beginning of a sequence of two and three dimensional works culminating in Onobrakpeya's Last Supper, representing his Christian art, in which Black people embody the Christian narrative.

That section of the gallery continues into his collection of uniquely powerful examples of classical African sacred arts, from Yoruba edan ogboni to chi wara of the Bambara, to Yoruba war vests loaded with magical charms and more.

Agbarha-Otor is less than 30 minutes from the Ughelli metropolis, where I have been invited to meet the city elders so they may decide how to grant me access to their shrines and sacred groves.

Ughelli is a short distance from Benin, which I would love to relocate to after Agbarha and where I would spend at least one month in daily visits to David Ebengho 's awesome, multi-deity shrine, an absolute masterpiece of shrine complexes that im the first to study, complemented by learning about the priest and his family.

From Benin, I would like to move to Ife and study the forested landscape of the university, an awesome bounty.

With that cycle of activity completed, 2025 would be utterly fulfilling.

For 2026, I would like to move to Cambridge and use the Betty and Gordon Moore Library, the central science library of Cambridge University where the plausibility of Abiola Irele's vision of the construction of a world view integrating science and an Eshu centred cosmology first hit me on account of the kinds of books I saw, for the first time, in that library.

Great thanks for the inspiration.

Toyin

[Cornelius Hamelberg]

Oluwatoyin V. Adepoju,

As a Nigerian, how lucky you are to be one of the divinely lotted to enjoy uninterrupted electricity always, albeit with “large amounts of money spent on fueling a diesel generator”

Re - countries with the largest electricity generation 

BTW, Peter Obi missed a golden opportunity : He should have promised  and sworn on the Holy Bible and if need be, on the Holy Quran as well, if he was indeed seriously intending to keep such a promise, that he was going to provide 24hrs a day electricity everywhere in Nigeria , for which reason alone I’m sure that you and everybody at the Owerri Motor Park would have voted for him. 

For me the Owerri Motor Park is a symbol of the country's intransigence/ resilience/ Democratic Nigeria’s axis of resistance, all at the same time . For any egomaniac suffering from delusions of grandeur, or any illiterati / illiterate who thinks that according to AI  he /the Owerri Motor Park is the greatest fellow, that everything is about him/ the Owerri Motor Park, and consequently would want to take it personally, let him dig this and take it to heart ;

”Light is and will be. It's not a big deal when the Light is beyond your personal horizon.”

For the less fortunate fellow compatriots who have been inadvertently condemned to live in darkness after the sun sets,  here is some encouraging news , that at least they won’t have to pay through the roof to get their fair share of the electric juice, this twenty-first century:

70+ Ingenious DIY Projects to Survive a World Without Electricity

https://www.google.de/search?q=70%2B+Ingenious+DIY+Projects+to+Survive+a+World+Without+Electricity&trackid=sp-006

And how nice that you are enabled “to write any time of the day or night “.  Congratulations.

Should we not be counting our blessings? 

To be able “to write any time of the day or night”,  is that not also a divine right, even for those who for some reason or other find themselves in prison , from which unfortunate temporary abode has issued quite a few literary masterpieces , some reflections from the inside,  prison diaries etc, a genre known as “ Prison Literature”  - hence we got Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn’s “The Gulag Archipelago, 1918-1956 an experiment in literary investigation” , Wole Soyinka's The Man Died and from over there in the Philippines, Prison diary of Amelita Reysio-Cruz 

What do you mean by “ I don't use pen and paper anymore” ? What do you use? Please explain.

I empathise with and completely understand what you, excited and waxing poetic, mean by “the blissful silence that has descended with the putting out of the gen at 3.30 am, the kind of silence  that subtly but powerfully speaks that everyday is morning yet on creation day as the darkness envelops one as if one is in the womb of the ultimate beginning.”  - mind full, like Brer Achebe and his “Morning Yet on Creation Day”

Verily,  it’s kind of like the peace of God that passeth all understanding, isn’t it ? I used to get that kind of feeling in Ahaoda when we turned off the infernal generator and finally obtained some peace and quiet. But you’ve got to be careful O ! Back in the day the night thieves’ modus operandi was to slip in some chloroform type substance into the external air-conditioning app   which could send you into peaceful slumber whilst they plied their trade, peacefully made off with your most precious belongings which I suppose in your case consists primarily of all the books that make up Ouwatoyin Vincent Adepoju’s beloved library, like Golum’s “My Precious! O my Precious!”

About  forsaking city civilisation and voluntarily moving to “Agbarha-Otor in the Niger Delta, where sadly, there is no electricity”, my Better Half would say that that romantic, pastoral streak is what you and Cornelius Ignoramus and a whole lot of cultural anthropologists  have in common with the Swedish writer Carl Jonas Love Almqvist.You say that right now, you’re wondering how  you’re going to cope? Only God knows, how you’re going to cope or if you are going to hope and cope, but you being you, you’re going to have to be careful because  - and I don’t know if this is so for all Ijaw women , but the Kalabari women  do not practise clitoridectomy which could mean that 

an independent, avantgarde, 

spiritually randy, liberated & horny

libertine scholar

from the big city,

could find himself singing

along with Bobby D,

 “They got some hungry women there, and they'll really make a mess outta you”

You have spoken so superlatively of Bruce Onobrakpeya before, in this our dialogue series and God knows how dearly you would like to live in the sheer heaven of such an artistic environment. I too, share your enthusiasm about the wondrous possibilities waiting for you at Agbarha-Otor and hope that  your anticipations of joy and of heaven will culminate in the success and the satisfaction of fulfilment in achieving the goals that you are setting out to achieve in your project - your journey of discovery, and  that this could also lead to something of a flowering such as Lines Composed a Few Miles above Tintern Abbey 

About Cambridge - the project  which seems to me to be unique, and the facilities that are uniquely available there are, I suppose are more than enough to justify and sustain your motivation and to that end I suppose that you have to work on it and make the necessary contacts and arrangements etc, , well in advance. N.B. Trust in the Almighty and don’t be too shy to ask …

https://www.facebook.com/watch/?v=8685394534842615&rdid=CM36NUr5vLha1yG6

[Oluwatoyin Adepoju]

Very very great thanks Cornelius for that marvellous and most inspiring response.

May you also be greatly inspired in your visions

Toyin