It’s disgusting. Kennedy Emetulu is absolutely guilty of what he accuses others of: recycling lies and hoping that with sufficient repetition the atrocious lies will miraculously transform into some truth, like Jesus turning some water into wine
RE- “As Federal Commissioner for Petroleum in a military government in the late seventies, the records show that he presided over the stealing of $3 billion of Nigeria’s money. After a public demand that the issue be probed, Buhari was indicted by the Senate of the Second Republic, but he then returned at the head of a military coup to sack that government and the first thing he did when he took over as the leader of that military junta was to ransack the Senate and destroy all papers and resolutions relating to the stolen money.” (Kennedy Emetulu – again!)
Salimonu Kadiri has already settled that score here - and yet Emetulu brings it up again. I’m still looking forward to the epistle in which he promised to take up the attempted kidnap and bringing home to Justice of the late Umaru Dikko. Patiently waiting. All he can come up with just now is some cheap shots about Great Britain’s extradition laws being contravened as if he is not aware of what happened with President Noriega – or better still as if he has never heard of Simon Wiesenthal - not that I’m comparing the late Umaru Dikko to the sort of scum that Simon Wiesenthal was hunting, but I was one of the people waiting patiently in Port Harcourt and very disappointed as to how things turned out at the last moment. The crowd was hoping that Mr. Dikko would “vomit the money” – only that the crowd does not know that to have about £5 billion Sterling in the Bank of England is a lot of money. It confers great privileges, can even terminate an extradition order – and there are several looters currently enjoying a life of luxury, mansions, Rolls Royces, country estates, hotels in Spain and California and other pieces of property everywhere…
“Discerning Nigerians know that the change we crave is already here and we are experiencing it for real under President Goodluck Jonathan” (Kennedy Emetulu).
I wonder on which planet he is living.
Does this not bother you: As western oil companies loot some $140 Billion a year of Nigeria’s black gold two thirds of the country’s 100 million people live on less than $2 a day
How is this permitted to happen on such a grand scale and who is it that permits it? The Goodluck Jonathan Government? The Niger Delta Militants who say that all the oil that is located in their backyard rightfully belongs to them – and that they should be given a free hand to do what they like with it?
Governor Rotimi Amaechi explained some of these phenomena on BBC Hardtalk – about Nigeria losing $1 billion a month of oil revenues to oil thieves – and mind you, this is happening during the tenure of the Goodluck Jonathan administration. That’s a lot of money. You must agree that $1 billion dollars a month could overhaul the Nigerian educational system, even create some top notch university students, and produce the first Nigerian automobile, the Nobel Prize in Economics or Medicine...
“...what Jonathan has done is to establish the condition for the growth of a viable opposition in order to strengthen our democracy and give Nigerians real alternatives” (Kennedy Emetulu).
Are we to suppose that accounts for people deserting his PDP party in droves and joining the APC?
And please, which/what “industrial-military complex” is Emetulu talking about?
The elections are now only eleven days away!
Over here the Stockholm temperatures are still below zero
Pray for yourselves, pray for Kennedy Emetulu and pray for us too.
...
"I am not bothered about the personal abuses: I actually expected worse. What name has the government not called President Obasanjo or any person who has dared to disagree with it of late? Anyone who disagrees with the government must either be ‘insane’ or have a ‘character’ deficiency or must be ‘looking for a job’ or ‘without honour’, or a ‘charlatan’. Yesterday, Sanusi alleged that $20 billion was missing and he was accused of gross financial mismanagement, recklessness and poor governance to the point of being the first governor of central bank to be suspended from office. Today, he is the good one; and for daring to award an “F” grade for our economic performance, Soludo has become the ‘worst’ and ‘without character’ or perhaps ‘looking for position’ (Lol!). Some days ago, a former president was called ‘a motor park tout’ and ‘un-statesmanly’ just for disagreeing. This “how dare you criticise us” mind-set of the government is dangerous for our democracy."
--
Listserv moderated by Toyin Falola, University of Texas at Austin
To post to this group, send an email to USAAfric...@googlegroups.com
To subscribe to this group, send an email to USAAfricaDial...@googlegroups.com
Current archives at http://groups.google.com/group/USAAfricaDialogue
Early archives at http://www.utexas.edu/conferences/africa/ads/index.html
---
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "USA Africa Dialogue Series" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to usaafricadialo...@googlegroups.com.
For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/d/optout.
…
Cornelius Hamelberg,
I do not think I have ever engaged you in a discussion on this forum, possibly because apart from posting sparingly, I’m hardly here. In fact, I did not see your response on my incoming email feed. It was IBK that posted it on a Facebook group that both of us belong to and which necessitated that I come to the USAAfricaDialogue listserv to read it for myself and make a response.
First, I thank you for your view. We are in a political season and the beauty of democracy is that everyone has a voice. Those who refuse to exercise theirs are their own worst enemies. We are lucky.
Now, you accuse me of recycling lies and quoted my comment on Buhari and the money stolen under his watch as Federal Commissioner for Petroleum to buttress your point. You then seem to think the comment of someone here had since settled the matter. This fellow you referenced is Salimonu Kadiri, who apparently responded to my article “Buharists and their Stockholm Syndrome”. Here is how Salimonu Kadiri began his response to me (11/6/14):
“Kennedy Emetulu is not a Jonathan-nist but a political mercenary employed by Jonathan's Subsidy Re-investment Empowerment Program (SURE -P). I will come to what that means later. Kennedy Emetulu would have justified his SURE-P employment if he had supported his long epistle with facts instead of innuendos. If I have to respond in full to his lengthy sermon from SURE-P mountain, it would cover several hundred pages. Therefore, I will just remove three blocks on which Emetulu has built the house of lies on Buhari for the house to crumble”.
Now, let’s think of that for a minute. A man I have never met in my life, a man who knows nothing about me comes here in public space and states that my public commentary, which I probably started before he got into diapers is being motivated by a supposed employment with SURE-P or because I’m getting some benefit from them. Then he grants himself the immunity of providing proof for this absurd claim by saying if he had to provide some, “it would cover several hundred pages”. So, who is afraid of hundreds of pages of proof for an allegation you’ve made in public? Shouldn’t that have helped all of us here understand who Kennedy Emetulu is? I mean, I wrote my piece and didn’t mention SURE-P and never revealed upfront for the purposes of full disclosure that I work with them or that I’m a contractor with them or that I benefit from them in any way. So, if someone comes up here and says he knows about my relationship with SURE-P, what prevents the decent people of this listserv from saying: “Hold on a minute, Salimonu, why not provide the proof of the accusation you’ve made against Kennedy Emetulu?” Why did nobody ask him to provide just any form of evidence of his claim?
You see, I read a lot of cranks making all sorts of allegations against me, but I’m never bothered and most times I totally ignore them. I’m not bothered, because people who know me know me and I know myself. I don’t know anybody in SURE-P, I have never applied for anything in SURE-P on behalf of myself or anyone else, I do not have any benefit from them directly or indirectly, I’m not a government contractor and have never been, I don’t get paid by anybody directly or indirectly to say what I say. I speak publicly out of belief and I can walk through the gates of hell defending whatever I present as fact, while I accept that people can have a different opinion, even if I don’t agree with them. You do not expect me to come here and respond to a desperate fool, a vermin who would manufacture a lie as bad as this out of thin air in an attempt discredit someone he cannot challenge with truth. I call out Salimonu Kadiri to come out here and provide evidence of his claim. I call on him in the name of all that he truly believes in to come out here and back up his claim or forever remain a caterwauling creepy-crawly that he is! God will judge him for bearing false witness against me.
Now, with regard to the issue here, below is the portion of Salimonu Kadiri’s piece that you’re saying settles the matter:
“In his mud slinging essay against Buhari, Kennedy Emetulu asked, "Should I start with the scandal of the N2.8 billion NNPC money that got stolen under his watch as Petroleum Minister and head of NNPC in 1978? ... the Shehu Shagari government ...set up a Senate probe which traced the money to a London Midland Bank account belonging to Buhari from where the money again got missing." For the mere fact that Emetulu is telling readers that N2.8 billion NNPC money got stolen under Buhari's watch exempted Buhari from the actual stealing of the said amount of money. Secondly, Shehu Shagari's government could not have set up a Senate probe because, according to the Republican Constitution, there was separation of powers between the Executive and the Legislature. While it was true that the Senate set up a committee headed by Senator Olusola Saraki, the committee completed its investigation in 1981 without any public or official report on their findings. If the N2.8 billion NNPC money was traced to a London Midland Bank account belonging to Buhari, then we need to know the number of the account and for the money to disappear from the said bank, it should either be withdrawn or transferred by someone. We are talking about London, England, and not Nigeria where employed ghosts at all levels of government do normally get promoted, sign and cash salaries in the banks undetected. If we are to believe the tale by the moonlight being touted by Emetulu that the motive behind the military coup of December 1983 was to obstruct or destroy documents pertaining to the N2.8 billion NNPC money, why should they wait until two years after the investigation had been completed? There is no sense in the story”.
Mr Hamelberg, okay, ask yourself, does the above really look like a proper response to my accusation against Buhari? What has Salimonu Kadiri said in the above excerpt to debunk me? How can a man of such extraordinary ignorance convince you that “Shehu Shagari's government could not have set up a Senate probe because, according to the Republican Constitution, there was separation of powers between the Executive and the Legislature”? Is this the type of pedantic argument real adults or reasonably educated people should be having here or elsewhere? Was the Senate of the Second Republic not a part of the Shagari government of the Second Republic? Did I not indicate clearly there the branch of the government that set up the probe? I mean, the funny Mr Kadiri actually admitted that “the Senate set up a committee headed by Senator Olusola Saraki” but that “the committee completed its investigation in 1981 without any public or official report on their findings”. So, where is the argument? Did you yourself read my piece and the things I said? Did Salimonu Kadiri dispute what Dr Saraki told Vera Ifudu? Did he dispute the fact that the NTA under the Buhari regime sacked Vera Ifudu over this affair and that she went to court and got a huge payout just to shut her mouth? Did Buhari not send soldiers on coup day to go ransack the Senate building? Does all that indicate that Buhari is above board in this matter?
Now, let me also bring something to your attention: Sometime ago, my good friend and brother, Professor Moses Ochonu had an exchange with me on Facebook and by way of clarifying this issue, he said the following:
“In 1977, the military head of state, Lt. Gen. Olusegun Obasanjo, set up a crude oil sales tribunal to investigate the operations of the Nigerian National Oil Company (NNOC, which metamorphosed into NNPC same year). The tribunal found out that in three years, NNOC had failed to collect its equity share of oil produced by Shell, Mobil and Gulf. As a joint venture partner, NNOC was entitled to 182.95 million barrels of oil production. But NNOC did not find buyers for its own share, thereby losing a potential income of $2.8 billion. But it was instead reported by the media that $2.8 billion was missing.” – (Quoted from Moses Ochonu’s post in the exchange)
Here was my response:
“Agreed that the Nigerian political space is swarming with historical rumors of all types; but, please, do not declare the N2.8 billion issue a mere rumor and then substitute it with another manufactured rumor without applying due diligence and looking at it logically. I say this, because you are one of the most credible public intellectuals we have from Nigeria and one of the most dependable commentators on national affairs. I say this, because I can bet my bottom dollar that if you had taken the pains to look more closely at the issue, you wouldn’t publicly declare it one of the “enduring rumors and urban legends in Nigerian politics and history…mischievously recycled every now and then to discredit General Buhari, who has been running for president since 2003, because he was the Petroleum minister when the money allegedly went missing”.
“First, the thing you’ve stated here as the truth is not backed up by any contemporaneous report, quite apart from the fact that the claim is totally illogical. I mean, from 1974, which was the height of the oil boom, Nigeria could not sell its share for three years? They could not find buyers at a time Nigeria engaged in some of the most grandiose capital intensive projects of the time, that is at a time Gowon was proclaiming that we have too much money and that our problem was how to spend it? So, what money were we spending all that while? Who were the members of this crude oil sales tribunal? Where is this report? Where did they sit and what at the time linked their report, if any, with the N2.8 billion issue? The honest truth is any person who has a basic idea of how the oil market works will not buy such embarrassingly childish explanation! It is obvious that this is a latter-day manufactured explanation to get Buhari out of the pickle!
“Secondly, the Irikefe report which claimed no money was lost did not produce this explanation neither did the Saraki Senate report. In fact, Obasanjo had to quickly go to court to obtain an order to stop his appearance before the Irikefe Panel. If he or any member of his government, including Buhari had any logical explanation or even the above explanation you are tendering here, why didn’t they go to the Panel to explain this? What you are quoting here as the truth is actually something plucked from thin air by Simon Kolawole of ThisDay in his June 1 2014 column of the paper. Kolawole is someone who is unapologetically a Buhari acolyte. His claim is not backed up anywhere on record or in public space. It is one of those historical rewrites that a lot of them have today invested in on behalf of Buhari in this whole mission of selling him to unsuspecting and uninformed Nigerians as incorruptible. It will not work!
"True, the N2.8 billion issue is enmeshed in mystery, but you would expect such abracadabra in anything to do with public corruption in Nigeria, especially one of this nature and with the personalities mentioned. We do not expect that they would all come out to us and publicly confess that indeed such money was missing. All we can do is reasonably conjecture with publicly available facts. What is fact is that Dr Olusola Saraki, the Second Republic Senate Leader and head of a Senate Committee established to look into the matter did publicly confirm on NTA that indeed the money was missing and that it had been traced to a London account belonging to Buhari. While anyone can pick issues with that, Buhari’s own reaction told us something about the issue as well and where the truth may lie. I mean, why did he upon taking over as head of state pressurize NTA to sack Vera Ifudu, the journalist who interviewed Saraki and who stood by what she was told? Why did the court, upon review of the evidence, grant the prayers of Ifudu over the matter of wrongful dismissal? Why did NTA quickly pay her a huge sum, including making her to sign a confidentiality agreement? Saraki lived until November 2012 and never at any point recanted on his position and Buhari never publicly challenged him while he was alive or even after, even though he jailed the man for more than a year when he took over on no charges at all whatsoever. Whatever anyone says, Buhari has not discharged the responsibility of explaining what happened. Everything he has said and that has been said on his behalf points to guilt strongly.
“My brother, let me say clearly that I get the point you are trying to make about rumors in our public life, but this N2.8 billion affair is not a basis of such a psychological or sociological study of the phenomenon in Nigerian politics to the extent of freeing Buhari. Buhari is part of the corrupt elite and should therefore spare us the hypocrisy of pointing fingers! Yeah, we need change, but not this hollow type preached by him and his fellow travellers! The fact that he has been a beneficiary of Nigeria’s culture of useless probes does not make the N2.8 billion story a mere rumor. There are very good reasons to believe that he himself has always been economical with the truth. For instance, when he was asked about this is an old interview with the Sun Newspapers published on 24 December 2012, all he could offer by way of defence or explanation was that Professor Awojobi, Tai Solarin and Fela went to the Irikefe Panel with newspaper cuttings as proof of the missing money and that Clemet Isong, who was the then Central Bank Governor said such money couldn’t have been missing. Why should we believe Clement Isong who himself was potentially culpable as this happened under his watch and who at the time of the Irikefe Panel was already a career politician as Governor of the old Cross River State? Why did Buhari not make any reference to the Saraki Senate Panel and the claims publicly made by Saraki? Why did he not refer to the Vera Ifudu affair?”
The reason I have taken the pains to also post the above exchange with Professor Ochonu is to let you see that every day, people are manufacturing excuses for Buhari from thin air as a way of airbrushing his reputation. It is also to let you see that though the issue has been mired in controversy, one consistent thing is that the powers that be have one way or the other ensured that whatever probe instituted over this matter never ever gets conclusive or where conclusive never sees the light of day officially. This is the hallmark of a consistent attempt to protect someone or a group of people. I have stated my own view on it by way of assessment of all the facts and making reasonable conjectures from them. You are entitled to your view, but don’t tell me some vermin has settled the matter with his lies and ignorance.
“I’m still looking forward to the epistle in which he promised to take up the attempted kidnap and bringing home to Justice of the late Umaru Dikko. Patiently waiting. All he can come up with just now is some cheap shots about Great Britain’s extradition laws being contravened as if he is not aware of what happened with President Noriega – or better still as if he has never heard of Simon Wiesenthal - not that I’m comparing the late Umaru Dikko to the sort of scum that Simon Wiesenthal was hunting, but I was one of the people waiting patiently in Port Harcourt and very disappointed as to how things turned out at the last moment. The crowd was hoping that Mr. Dikko would “vomit the money” – only that the crowd does not know that to have about £5 billion Sterling in the Bank of England is a lot of money. It confers great privileges, can even terminate an extradition order – and there are several looters currently enjoying a life of luxury, mansions, Rolls Royces, country estates, hotels in Spain and California and other pieces of property everywhere…” – Cornelius Hamelberg
Not sure what you are talking about in that bit about justice for Umaru Dikko and so on. I can’t remember making any such promise to you or anybody. If you insist I did, you might want to tell me where and when. I always keep my promise and if I can’t, I’ll let you know why.
I’m not sure why you think the example of the US kidnap of Noregia justifies whatever Buhari planned over Umaru Dikko. The world was united in pointing out that the US Operation Nifty Package or Operation Just Cause breached Panamanian and international law in kidnapping Noregia; but for the United States, they were technically at war with Panama, so kidnapping the military leader with whom they were at war was par the course. They were further boosted by the Vatican declaration that Noregia who had taken refuge in the Apostolic Nunciature in Panama City had no asylum. Thereafter what the world wanted to see was a fair trial in a US court and Mr Noregia got that. It’s enough for me that you have admitted that you are not comparing Umaru Dikko to the sort of scum Simon Wiesenthal was hunting, which is precisely why the Dikko kidnap was a bad advertisement for a government supposedly fighting for corruption.
I’m not going to join in you to debate Amaechi and his silly claims in that Hardtalk programme you mentioned neither am I going to engage you on the various charges of corruption being bandied about at the moment, because both parties and Nigerians are all guilty of this and until we come together to deal with the matter institutionally, rather than pointing hypocritical fingers, we won’t go anywhere. My hope is that with the implementation of the recommendations of the National Conference and the institution of true federalism (including its fiscal aspects), we will begin to appreciate how we can use institutional measures to cut out corruption in public service through better accountability.
At the moment, we are in a political season and my own support for Jonathan is clear. For several months now I have come out to say I support him against anybody the APC produces. In fact, I can say it’s a decision I’ve taken for more than a year now. But my principle is that being a partisan does not give you the licence to lie in an attempt to sell your candidate. True, Jonathan would ordinarily not be my candidate in a presidential election, because I believe he’s just an average leader and in these times, I expect an above average leader to take Nigeria forward. But the system has conspired to produce for us a Hobson’s choice and in the circumstances, I’m supporting Jonathan by default, not because he’s the best thing since Agege bread. Buhari is a no-no, not only because of his antecedents but also because of where I think he’ll taking the nation. He is returning us to the Dark Ages and nothing anyone says can convince me otherwise, because I have reviewed the evidence thoroughly before reaching this conclusion.
In any case, having adopted Jonathan, I have to sell him in the best possible way without undermining my own credibility. It’s important to let people know you are a partisan who is only expressing your opinion. Anyone can debate your opinion with you, but let the facts remain sacred. As I have implied, the two viable choices in Jonathan and Buhari are not the best, but Jonathan is infinitely better for now and the future of Nigeria than Buhari. Those behind the Buhari hype know this, but as I said, they are using him as a stalking horse to take us back to the hounds. With all due respect to your position, I will do everything legitimately within my power and capacity to stop Buhari from getting to that seat again. So, yeah, pray for me, ‘cause I need the prayers. More importantly, pray that the Good Lord continue to protect our people and our nation from those who want to destroy it.
In conclusion, I think you should be keeping faith with your agreement with Professor Segun Ogungbemi who you quoted as saying “All that has been said negatively against Buhari needs to be investigated.” and that “Secondly, Buhari needs to defend himself at well organized debates.” Buhari has the opportunity to address these issues openly with Nigerians in a presidential debate now, encourage him to take the opportunity, rather than this stonewalling and hiding he’s busy perfecting. The ball is in his court.
CHEERS AND STAY BLESSED!
…
..
Ms Ayo Obe,
I am writing this, not to take you on publicly for your comment here about me, but to explain to you why I wouldn’t do so, even as I vehemently disagree with your assessment of my piece, my conduct and the view I have expressed in response to Lola Shoneyin. I will never publicly take you on, because you are an inspiration to me. You may not know it, but you have been my benefactor and supporter in public affairs at a dark time in our nation. People like you are not many in our nation and no matter what I think of what you say about me or any other person publicly, the best I can do is to privately express myself to you. I will never take you on publicly.
The reason is this: In 1996, after months of a grueling struggle against the Abacha government, I led leaders of 250 families of Harvey/Moore Road Resettlement Quarters to your office in Surelere. At the time, you had just taken over from Mr Olisa Agbakoba at the CLO and I was leading the community elders to your office to say thank you for the support your organization, amongst others had given us.
Let me briefly give a background to this. In early 1996, the Abacha government decided they wanted to take the land housing about 250 families on Harvey/Moore Road Yaba, behind the Atan Cemetery. Abacha’s military boys under the then Minister of Works, Abdulkarim “Bulldozer” Adisa went to work and issued the residents a quit notice to vacate the place in 30 days. I was not a resident there, but I had friends living in the area who were discussing the issue when I paid them a visit.
I became interested and decided to go to the community to ask questions and see things for myself. I got there and the place was in total chaos as old and young where in panic. This was a community set up in 1948 to resettle people who were moved from central Lagos when the colonial government took their homes to develop the place as our federal capital. They were dumped on the Harvey/Moore Road grounds at a time the whole place was just a bush with only the fenceless Atan Cemetery as neighbours. The government promised to build a fitting place for them elsewhere, but never did. These families got on with life and lived in this place as best as they could until 1996 when Abacha decided he was rooting them out. The point was that at this time, the land had become choice land. With water taking over the choice lands of Ikoyi, the military boys were looking for something else and this land appealed to them, because it was in Yaba, which is the only place without a slum in Lagos and it had now become a centre of development with University of Lagos, Yaba College of Technology and the Herbert Macaulay Road and so on bordering it. Abacha and Adisa care less about due process and at the time when Adisa was feared all over Nigeria for the destruction he was wrecking on communities through his demolition programme, the Harvey/Moore Road people thought they had no chance. In fact, by the time I got there, many people had fled in fear.
To cut a long story short, I took on the battle on their behalf and I involved your organization, CLO, Shelter Rights Initiative under Eze Onyekwere and the Centre for Housing Rights and Eviction, Switzerland. I organized an underground media campaign that had the world and the Nigerian human rights community giving us support. I recall that people like Anselm Odinkalu, young Chido Onumah, Franco Olize and a host of other people in the human rights, media and international community showed support. But it was the CLO that mostly stood by us as the Abacha terror machine took us on.
As the arrowhead of the people’s fight, I was specially targeted by the Abacha forces with the aim of suborning me or just taking me out. At the time, I was working as a Special Correspondent and Member of the Saturday Editorial at the Guardian, but Abacha’s security forces laid siege there. I was sleeping in the cemetery at night and coming out in the day to lead the campaign. When they began demolition of the houses where the people had barricaded themselves in defiantly, it was Buhari’s PTF bulldozers they were using. When I was eventually arrested, it was a PTF vehicle they used to ferry me, bound up to Alaka Police Station where I was tied to a chair and tortured. When they then attempted to convince me of the futility of fighting Abacha and I kept telling them I was not NADECO, but part of a community only fighting to have roof over our head, they threatened to blow me up and pour acid on my body. Of course, I was part of the pro-democracy movement as the leader of the Public Awareness Network (PAN) and Lagos Mainland Committee for SDP Awareness, two organizations registered with the Beko-led Campaign for Democracy (CD) and I was also a founding member of the Gani-Fawehinmi-led National Conscience Party (NPC). But revealing such information at that point would have been sure death, so I stuck to the story that all we were asking was a roof over our head and that we were not politicians or pro-democracy. Even though the people knew my pro-democracy activities, they protected me from the security forces when they were questioned.
When I did not budge, it gave the community fillip and they stood their ground. Upon my release, I joined them and intensified the campaign. The CLO pursued the case at the Federal High Court on our behalf and it was through their effort we got the first injunction barring the Abacha government from demolishing the homes, which bought us time to intensify the media campaign. By the time they were breaching it and demolishing, we had gained enough public sympathy to ensure they just couldn’t ignore us.
In the end, we won. Shortly before I left for England the following year, they entered into negotiation with us and I led the community to those negotiations at the Federal Ministry of Works, while one Dr Oduma and his team of ministry officials represented the Ministry. In the end, they were forced to rebuild the place for the people who refused all attempts to manipulate them. Even those who had ran away in fear returned and those who didn’t return were paid compensation. Today, if you go to Harvey/Moore Road, you will see the medium-sized high-rises that are monuments to that struggle. The people regained a better home without paying a kobo! I am proud of the role I played there. I was not paid. I was not a rich man, but I put my time and resources to the fight, because I believed in it. I was offered a flat free by the Ministry of Works negotiators in recognition of my effort, but I rejected it. I did not do it, because I wanted to get a house. I did it, because I believed in the justness of the cause. It was a struggle you and your organization supported and to which I am eternally grateful.
So, I cannot come out in public and disagree with you, no matter what you say about me, because people like you, Olisa Agbakoba, Gani Fawehinmi, Fela Anikulapo Kuti, Beko Ransom-Kuti, Alao Aka-Bashorun, Dr Frederick Fasheun, Chima Ubani, Anselm Odinkalu, Eze Onyekwere and a few others like you that stood in the gap for our people during the locust years are my own political gods. If you were the one flying the APC presidential banner today, I would give my life to have you sit in Aso Rock. But a Buhari? Never!
….
...
--
“But, in fact, the total pension package is N2,909,122.75 per quarter — as confirmed to me by a former head of state. The breakdown: pension, N878,676.20; upkeep, N1,050,000; salaries of personal staff, N845,446.50; telephone, N75,000; and postal services, N60,000. Buhari never rejected any part of it. For goodness sake, it is his legal right. Why would he not collect it?”
sk/meo
There is legal right. There is moral right. There is proprietary right. There is right for its own sake. There is right for goodness sake. There is also right for exemplary reasons. Good leaders lead by word but more importantly by example.
Would it be imprudent or out of place to expect or challenge a supposedly not corrupt patriotic leader, reported to claim that money is not a matter of great object to him, to reject remuneration that is unquestionably immoral by objective economic and social standards, in a developing country? Is the politician really who he is asserted to be if he collects immoral remuneration for legal reason only?
oa
oa
As this is a matter of public probity , I can only ask you, do you have the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth? And is that truth in your possession? Do you swear on the Holy Bible when you say this?
Sincerely,
Cornelius
…
Cornelius Hamelberg,
I do not think I have ever engaged you in a discussion on this forum, possibly because apart from posting sparingly, I’m hardly here. In fact, I did not see your response on my incoming email feed. It was IBK that posted it on a Facebook group that both of us belong to and which necessitated that I come to the USAAfricaDialogue listserv to read it for myself and make a response.
First, I thank you for your view. We are in a political season and the beauty of democracy is that everyone has a voice. Those who refuse to exercise theirs are their own worst enemies. We are lucky.
Now, you accuse me of recycling lies and quoted my comment on Buhari and the money stolen under his watch as Federal Commissioner for Petroleum to buttress your point. You then seem to think the comment of someone here had since settled the matter. This fellow you referenced is Salimonu Kadiri, who apparently responded to my article “Buharists and their Stockholm Syndrome”. Here is how Salimonu Kadiri began his response to me (11/6/14):
“Kennedy Emetulu is not a Jonathan-nist but a political mercenary employed by Jonathan's Subsidy Re-investment Empowerment Program (SURE -P). I will come to what that means later. Kennedy Emetulu would have justified his SURE-P employment if he had supported his long epistle with facts instead of innuendos. If I have to respond in full to his lengthy sermon from SURE-P mountain, it would cover several hundred pages. Therefore, I will just remove three blocks on which Emetulu has built the house of lies on Buhari for the house to crumble”.
Now, let’s think of that for a minute. A man I have never met in my life, a man who knows nothing about me comes here in public space and states that my public commentary, which I probably started before he got into diapers is being motivated by a supposed employment with SURE-P or because I’m getting some benefit from them. Then he grants himself the immunity of providing proof for this absurd claim by saying if he had to provide some, “it would cover several hundred pages”. So, who is afraid of hundreds of pages of proof for an allegation you’ve made in public? Shouldn’t that have helped all of us here understand who Kennedy Emetulu is? I mean, I wrote my piece and didn’t mention SURE-P and never revealed upfront for the purposes of full disclosure that I work with them or that I’m a contractor with them or that I benefit from them in any way. So, if someone comes up here and says he knows about my relationship with SURE-P, what prevents the decent people of this listserv from saying: “Hold on a minute, Salimonu, why not provide the proof of the accusation you’ve made against Kennedy Emetulu?” Why did nobody ask him to provide just any form of evidence of his claim?
You see, I read a lot of cranks making all sorts of allegations against me, but I’m never bothered and most times I totally ignore them. I’m not bothered, because people who know me know me and I know myself. I don’t know anybody in SURE-P, I have never applied for anything in SURE-P on behalf of myself or anyone else, I do not have any benefit from them directly or indirectly, I’m not a government contractor and have never been, I don’t get paid by anybody directly or indirectly to say what I say. I speak publicly out of belief and I can walk through the gates of hell defending whatever I present as fact, while I accept that people can have a different opinion, even if I don’t agree with them. You do not expect me to come here and respond to a desperate fool, a vermin who would manufacture a lie as bad as this out of thin air in an attempt discredit someone he cannot challenge with truth. I call out Salimonu Kadiri to come out here and provide evidence of his claim. I call on him in the name of all that he truly believes in to come out here and back up his claim or forever remain a caterwauling creepy-crawly that he is! God will judge him for bearing false witness against me.
Now, with regard to the issue here, below is the portion of Salimonu Kadiri’s piece that you’re saying settles the matter:
“In his mud slinging essay against Buhari, Kennedy Emetulu asked, "Should I start with the scandal of the N2.8 billion NNPC money that got stolen under his watch as Petroleum Minister and head of NNPC in 1978? ... the Shehu Shagari government ...set up a Senate probe which traced the money to a London Midland Bank account belonging to Buhari from where the money again got missing." For the mere fact that Emetulu is telling readers that N2.8 billion NNPC money got stolen under Buhari's watch exempted Buhari from the actual stealing of the said amount of money. Secondly, Shehu Shagari's government could not have set up a Senate probe because, according to the Republican Constitution, there was separation of powers between the Executive and the Legislature. While it was true that the Senate set up a committee headed by Senator Olusola Saraki, the committee completed its investigation in 1981 without any public or official report on their findings. If the N2.8 billion NNPC money was traced to a London Midland Bank account belonging to Buhari, then we need to know the number of the account and for the money to disappear from the said bank, it should either be withdrawn or transferred by someone. We are talking about London, England, and not Nigeria where employed ghosts at all levels of government do normally get promoted, sign and cash salaries in the banks undetected. If we are to believe the tale by the moonlight being touted by Emetulu that the motive behind the military coup of December 1983 was to obstruct or destroy documents pertaining to the N2.8 billion NNPC money, why should they wait until two years after the investigation had been completed? There is no sense in the story”.
Mr Hamelberg, okay, ask yourself, does the above really look like a proper response to my accusation against Buhari? What has Salimonu Kadiri said in the above excerpt to debunk me? How can a man of such extraordinary ignorance convince you that “Shehu Shagari's government could not have set up a Senate probe because, according to the Republican Constitution, there was separation of powers between the Executive and the Legislature”? Is this the type of pedantic argument real adults or reasonably educated people should be having here or elsewhere? Was the Senate of the Second Republic not a part of the Shagari government of the Second Republic? Did I not indicate clearly there the branch of the government that set up the probe? I mean, the funny Mr Kadiri actually admitted that “the Senate set up a committee headed by Senator Olusola Saraki” but that “the committee completed its investigation in 1981 without any public or official report on their findings”. So, where is the argument? Did you yourself read my piece and the things I said? Did Salimonu Kadiri dispute what Dr Saraki told Vera Ifudu? Did he dispute the fact that the NTA under the Buhari regime sacked Vera Ifudu over this affair and that she went to court and got a huge payout just to shut her mouth? Did Buhari not send soldiers on coup day to go ransack the Senate building? Does all that indicate that Buhari is above board in this matter?
Now, let me also bring something to your attention: Sometime ago, my good friend and brother, Professor Moses Ochonu had an exchange with me on Facebook and by way of clarifying this issue, he said the following:
“In 1977, the military head of state, Lt. Gen. Olusegun Obasanjo, set up a crude oil sales tribunal to investigate the operations of the Nigerian National Oil Company (NNOC, which metamorphosed into NNPC same year). The tribunal found out that in three years, NNOC had failed to collect its equity share of oil produced by Shell, Mobil and Gulf. As a joint venture partner, NNOC was entitled to 182.95 million barrels of oil production. But NNOC did not find buyers for its own share, thereby losing a potential income of $2.8 billion. But it was instead reported by the media that $2.8 billion was missing.” – (Quoted from Moses Ochonu’s post in the exchange)
Here was my response:
“Agreed that the Nigerian political space is swarming with historical rumors of all types; but, please, do not declare the N2.8 billion issue a mere rumor and then substitute it with another manufactured rumor without applying due diligence and looking at it logically. I say this, because you are one of the most credible public intellectuals we have from Nigeria and one of the most dependable commentators on national affairs. I say this, because I can bet my bottom dollar that if you had taken the pains to look more closely at the issue, you wouldn’t publicly declare it one of the “enduring rumors and urban legends in Nigerian politics and history…mischievously recycled every now and then to discredit General Buhari, who has been running for president since 2003, because he was the Petroleum minister when the money allegedly went missing”.
“First, the thing you’ve stated here as the truth is not backed up by any contemporaneous report, quite apart from the fact that the claim is totally illogical. I mean, from 1974, which was the height of the oil boom, Nigeria could not sell its share for three years? They could not find buyers at a time Nigeria engaged in some of the most grandiose capital intensive projects of the time, that is at a time Gowon was proclaiming that we have too much money and that our problem was how to spend it? So, what money were we spending all that while? Who were the members of this crude oil sales tribunal? Where is this report? Where did they sit and what at the time linked their report, if any, with the N2.8 billion issue? The honest truth is any person who has a basic idea of how the oil market works will not buy such embarrassingly childish explanation! It is obvious that this is a latter-day manufactured explanation to get Buhari out of the pickle!
“Secondly, the Irikefe report which claimed no money was lost did not produce this explanation neither did the Saraki Senate report. In fact, Obasanjo had to quickly go to court to obtain an order to stop his appearance before the Irikefe Panel. If he or any member of his government, including Buhari had any logical explanation or even the above explanation you are tendering here, why didn’t they go to the Panel to explain this? What you are quoting here as the truth is actually something plucked from thin air by Simon Kolawole of ThisDay in his June 1 2014 column of the paper. Kolawole is someone who is unapologetically a Buhari acolyte. His claim is not backed up anywhere on record or in public space. It is one of those historical rewrites that a lot of them have today invested in on behalf of Buhari in this whole mission of selling him to unsuspecting and uninformed Nigerians as incorruptible. It will not work!
...
PS.
Hon Kennedy Emetulu
You say , ”Not sure what you are talking about in that bit about justice for Umaru Dikko and so on. I can’t remember making any such promise to you or anybody. If you insist I did, you might want to tell me where and when. I always keep my promise and if I can’t, I’ll let you know why”
I was referring to your statement here below:
“Then the regime’s secret attempt to smuggle Umaru Dikko (a former Minister of Transport in the ousted Shagari government) back from London in a crate sealed the regime’s fate internationally and embarrassed Nigeria greatly in the comity of nations. This affair, which I shall discuss in more detail later, further exposed the vacuousness and viciousness of the regime. The leadership was thereafter seen as thuggish and tyrannical and not many people were dealing with them outside Africa.”
…
Cornelius Hamelberg,
Hon.Kennedy Emetulu,
For me, and this is basic philosophy of the logical positive school:to say that you know something, that thing has to be true. This for example is a fact of a slightly different order from what is attributed to Philip Emeagwali in connection with the internet.
The ad hominem is not the way.
Respect will be responded to with respect. In the name of common decency, I kindly request that you to take the advice given by the Almighty's piece of honesty, the sagacious Samuel Szalanga and cease henceforth with your indecencies aimed at my dear friend and mentor Brother Saliman Kadiri. I have known him for decades and never found him wanting in my esteem.
My approach is entirely legalistic: The onus of proof is on you – you are the one who has made certain statements about Brother Muhammadu Buhari – and you are the one who is standing in the dock to give your testimony and you dare to start accusing Ogbeni Kadiri when under cross examination and asked to produce your proof ?
And by the way, an explanation is not a proof. Whether it's an explanation of the Holy Trinity, the Virgin Birth, the Sanctification of Goodluck Jonathan or some of the holy people that are said to surround him.
Like my songster bard I also do not put my faith in anybody, not even a scientist.
Finally, I'm patiently waiting for the details that you promised when you wrote about, “This affair, which I shall discuss in more detail later”. I'm interested the Mossad angle and some other implications thereof such as the flexibility in the Buhari- Mossad co-operation
As you say, stay blessed - have a blessed weekend.
| From: Cornelius Hamelberg Sent: Friday, 6 February 2015 16:46 Reply To: usaafric...@googlegroups.com Subject: Re: USA Africa Dialogue Series - Re: Lola Shoneyin's False Testament |
..
What are you on about, Mr Hamelberg? What nonsense are you spewing here? Are you now going to stand here and support that lying snake, because he’s your friend, mentor and brother? You have no shame? Simply asking your friend, brother and mentor to show evidence of his claim is too much for you, silly fool? I’m not surprised. Show me your friend, brother and mentor and I will tell you who you are! Now, you can take yourself and your stupid liar of a friend, brother and mentor back to whatever cave you crawled out from! Both of you do not deserve to be mixing with decent people! Silly sods!
On Buhari and whatever I’ve said about him, since you are going “entirely legalistic”, why not sue me to court or encourage him to do so, pinhead?
…
..
Salimonu Kadiri,
Shut your trap, you idiot! Just shut up and slink away to a corner and hide your lying face! You think you’re dealing with kindergartens here? What has my brother contesting for the PDP gubernatorial ticket got to do with anything? Why are you talking here as though you’ve made some damaging discovery about me when I was the one that publicized my brother’s campaign on my Facebook wall and elsewhere and used his picture as my profile picture? Even as I write this, his picture is still my Facebook cover picture, so what has that got to do with anything?
Yes, he was Commissioner for Energy in Delta State, chosen by my people to contest for the governorship in the course of which he and other contestants reached an agreement to collapse their structures and present one main candidate from Delta North in order to win the ticket. They did that and succeeded and here you are talking five votes as if it’s an issue? Now, how does that concern me? I never visited his office all the while he was Commissioner neither did I or anyone close to me and my family apply for or got a contract at his office. All I did when he was appointed was pray for him as my junior brother and remind him the son of who he is. I told him to go there and not soil my family name and he went there and did everyone proud as an outstanding public servant. He was the first public official cleared by the security services to contest that election and the only one without a blot in his file. I donated to his campaign and helped him as much as I could, because I believe in him, even though I’m not a member of the PDP. So what has all that got to do with me and SURE-P?
You really are a hydra-headed idiot. You need to make peace with your God, because you are the Son of the Devil! Oh yes, you said I’m a Christian and you are right. I speak boldly, because I’m a Christian; I speak because I fear no man but God! So, if I call on my Father to justify me before men, He will! If I call on my Father to expose a snake who bears false witness against me, He will surely answer. You are this moment you are reading this facing the judgment of God. Be silent. Be silent before God to receive your due. You still have an opportunity to say the truth. But as far as you continue in your lies, you will be brought low before men and God. May your lies bind you and suffocate you till you blurt out the truth in pain in front of the whole world! Surely as I speak here on earth, it’s already decreed in heaven in Jesus’s Name! Amen!
Now, you may return here to dance naked, but this is my last response or communication with you on this issue until you speak the truth that will burn your insides untill you actually speak it publicly.
…
..
Mr Abolaji Adekeye,
Are you listening to yourself? Are you with your senses at all or someone is frying your brain in a microwave somewhere? Don’t you know the road to a law court? Don’t you have access to Buhari and his campaign organization to advise them to sue me for libel or whatever takes their fancy? You guys are pathetic! Get out of here, eranko jati-jati!
…
Looka here emetulu :
I have many friends and mentors !You are not one of them and I'm not about to start rolling in the mud with the likes of you. You are too irrelevant to take to court – nor do I start arguing with all and sundry recently escaped from some mental asylum. The sum total of what you have said so far or will say in the future is of no relevance to me whatsoever - whether it's about Buhari & Mossad to get Umaru Dikko or whoever it is you want to be president of Nigeria is of no importance to me, whatsoever.
Now you can go eat your shit and die for all I care !
And there you have it!
Cornelius