Legislative and judicial branch records should be public records in the United States, not private papers

7 views
Skip to first unread message

Alexander Howard

unread,
Sep 1, 2026, 2:08:47 PMSep 1
to US Open Government

As Jodi Kantor reports, a congressional commission recommended in the late 1970s that all federal records generated across all three branches of the federal government should be regarded as public property: 

“all records and documents accumulated by all Federal officials in the discharge of their official duties should be recognized by Congress to be the property of the United States.*

“The documents of a nation preserve its memory, the record of its errors and triumphs, and offer the citizens of a republic the means to understanding and judgment. While the current laws, customs, and practices have led to the preservation and availability of much significant documentary material, the system has relied too heavily on chance and the historical instincts of elected officials and members of the judiciary.

The Commission has concluded, therefore, that it is time to bring to an end the tradition that papers generated or received in the conduct of public business belong as a species of private property to Presidents and other public officials. We are satisfied that the tradition of private ownership of public papers became established by reason of the failure of the government to provide an alternative. It is time to remedy the situation.”

My view: in any government of the People, the records generated by public business belong to the public, not to presidents, legislators, mayors, judges, & officials entrusted with upholding our laws. 

Presidents and officials in the executive branch generate public records under PRA & FRA reforms enacted after Watergate, not private papers.

To me, it follows that Justices & officials in the judicial branch generate public records, not private papers. 

And that legislators and staffers in the legislative branch generate public records, not private papers.

I think ambitious democracy reform in 2027 or 2029 should include updating and enacting this commission’s prescient recommendations!

My 2 cents, rounded up to a nickel.

-ABH


—
Sent from my pocket supercomputer
410-849-9808 | @digiphile
Reply all
Reply to author
Forward
0 new messages