Hi all,
I'm a MS student interested in using N-mixture modelling to estimate abundance from a count dataset I've collected. I've only just started exploring them and have some beginner conceptual questions.
First, do these models assume that surveyed sites are occupied? My survey methods have a high detection probability as estimated from static occupancy modeling ( ~0.7) but I have several sites with zero detections across all their respective repeated surveys. However, when examining output from N-mixture models I fit using pcount(), I still get low abundance estimates from sites with zero detections. Due to the sites with all zeros, would fitting models using a ZIP mixture be reasonable?
Additionally, the detection probabilities given by N-mixture models are much lower than those given by occupancy models. Do detection probabilities for N-mixture denote detectability of the species, as in occupancy models, or do they describe detection probability of detecting an individual?
Finally, I have ran into what I'm learning is a common issue: the "good fit, bad estimate" problem. NB mixture models I fit have the lowest AICc and have a more reasonable goodness of fit compared to ZIP and P models (c-hat is around 1 for my NB global model but >2 for both ZIP and P). However, all NB estimates are sensitive to K, unlike ZIP and P models. Given this situation, what following steps would be recommended? I have thought of selecting P or ZIP models using QAICc to account for overdispersion these provide, while retaining the finite estimates. Would I be on the right track there?
Thank you for any help or information,
David Rosenbaum