Many Thanks Richard,
I was, in part, following Kéry et al. 2005, who also had transects within quadrants and used route length as an abundance covariate to account for similar variation within effective sampled area. My transects were not fixed width and there is considerable variation in terms of visibility amongst habitats sampled. In actuality snares are so well concealed they are only usually detected on or within a couple meters of a transect irrespective of habitat, so the effective sampled area was just a narrow strip, which I could guestimate, but still I am not sure I could comfortably assume negligible heterogeneity in detection across habitats. Hmmmm.
How about the rest of my equation attempting to replicate manually what Predict does with pcount, does that look correct at least?
HannahYes, you’re right, it was actually the inverse of transect length that Marc and Andy used to deal with the “exposed population” issue, but I didn’t think this was appropriate in my context because we never came anywhere close to saturation in terms of sampling each site. In any case, now I have a quicker plotting method I’ll try a few approaches and see how the maps look; I’m not interested in absolute numbers of snares but more a relative picture with which to compare anti-poaching patrol data.
The paper you refer to could certainly be a very useful sampling framework, and not just for snares (I also use scat dogs which generate exactly this type of data). In fact, snares are uniquely identifiable by gps-marked location, but because different routes were walked there were no “re-captures”, and this is something I will definitely change if we repeat the survey (i.e. observes will follow the same routes). I guess I’ll also have to bite the bullet with WinBUGS....
Thanks again for all your help and for keeping such a close eye on the forum!
Hannah
I'm not sure why simply using log(length) as an offset on abundance should not be sensible ? This should give you an estimate of snare abundance per unit-length transect. But yes, we have used length in a slightly more complicated way as a proxy for the proportion of the nominal sample area covered (in Royle et al, Ecol. Mono., 2007), because our transects sampled a 1km2 quadrat in a highly sinuous way with frequent loops.
Kind regards -- Marc
________________________________________
From: unma...@googlegroups.com [unma...@googlegroups.com] on behalf of Richard Chandler [richard....@gmail.com]
Sent: 10 May 2013 14:25
To: Unmarked package
Subject: Re: [unmarked] mapping spatial predictions using pcount
Hi Marc,
Yes, a measure of abundance per km walked was what I thought I was getting, possibly more appropriate as we just did one pass through each site and so effectively sampled only a minimal proportion of it. My difficulty comes when trying to translate this into a map, because I am not sure how to reconcile the scale of my estimates with that of my covariate data used for prediction.
Hannah
Thanks Richard, I see the distinction you point out here, and it is important, so my approach is not entirely satisfactory, but maybe still useful in relative terms. Especially as I’ll be comparing these results with patrol data consisting of a similar measure – encounters per unit effort. I may also experiment with transect width and translating into density, just to see how it looks.
Thanks again,
Hannah