On each search occasion, an observer searches for snakes for a variable amount of time (dictated by logistical constraints, including weather, NOT by capture rates), with most non-urban habitat searches ( forest & savanna, 15 sites) being 100 to 180 minutes long and most urban searches (3 sites) being 45 to 120 minutes in duration.
What is the proper method for accounting for this variation in observation duration? Some candidates:
minutes <-pcount(~min ~site, data=umf) #Duration as obsCov
intercept<-pcount(~min+h3 ~site, data=umf) #Different intercepts by habitat
interact <-pcount(~min*h3 ~site, data=umf) #Diff. slope/int by habitat
offset <-pcount(~1+offset(min) ~site, data=umf) #Duration as offset
nPars AIC delta AICwt cumltvWt
interact (min*habitat) 24 3831.55 0.00 1.0e+00 1.00
intercept(min+habitat) 22 3854.97 23.42 8.2e-06 1.00
minutes (min) 20 3857.27 25.72 2.6e-06 1.00
offset (offset(min)) 19 4885.42 1053.87 1.4e-229 1.00
Allowing a different slope and intercept for each habitat type “fits” better, by far…but is this appropriate? Does this allow the 1180 observations to explain an inordinate amount of the variation in encounter rates as opposed to abundance covariates at just 18 sites, or are observation and abundance so decoupled that this should not matter?
I’ve seen discussion in previous unmarked posts of including an "offset" term in the GLM formula as a constraint on the relationship (more time = higher counts, e.g. “exposure time”, more area = higher counts), but I’ll confess to not fully understanding how this works, including whether it should be offset(min) or offset(log(min)). Further, including duration as an offset is nowhere in the ballpark with respect to AIC values. Are models with an offset and without comparable in an AIC framework?
Thanks in advance.
--
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "unmarked" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to unmarked+u...@googlegroups.com.
For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/groups/opt_out.