--
Replies are set to default to send to the whole group
---
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "UKCP in Scotland" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to ukcpinscotlan...@googlegroups.com.
To post to this group, send email to ukcpins...@googlegroups.com.
For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/groups/opt_out.
Hi Mary
There were two replies from me. The first was responding to your “provisional proposal” of 26th June when I commented:
“That might work well but I think that it is important to have our own Scottish meeting. If there is “input from the UKCP team” that might become the main focus. It would be a pity if some folk have to leave before we get to decision-making.”
The second was a response to Courtenay Young who suggested a venue in central Edinburgh – to which I replied:
“I think Mary suggested that we meet in Glasgow this time because last year’s meeting was held in Edinburgh.
I can offer a low cost venue in the city centre (Berkeley Street near the Mitchell Library).”
I hope this helps.
Alastair
Hi Mary, Courtney and All
Firstly, I think it is time to change the subject line!
One of the initiatives we can take is to identify psychotherapy research in Scotland or members in Scotland who have research experience.
Mark Widdowson who lives in Glasgow and trains in Edinburgh, Kegworth (near Nottingham) and elsewhere has been conducting the efficacy of TA in the treatment of depression. It uses a case study, qualitative approach. He is doing the research for a Ph.D. and so it is being properly supervised by a university department. I’m sure that Mark would be willing to talk about his research if the date is suitable. Another member of the TA community, Salma Siddique, has an academic research post at Edinburgh Napier University.
I would support an autumn meeting that focused on the Scottish scene and was not distracted by having representatives of UKCP Central.
Regards
Alastair
From: ukcpins...@googlegroups.com [mailto:ukcpins...@googlegroups.com] On Behalf Of Mary MacCallum Sullivan
Sent: 17 July 2013 06:47
To: ukcpins...@googlegroups.com
Subject: Re: [UKCP in Scotland] post from Alastair
Hi Courtenay
This is very useful information indeed, and perhaps we should address this specifically on the agenda for 21st September: that UKCP should propose someone for membership of the relevant SIGN guideline revision group.
Your point is well made about venues; it would be great to hear from group members about suggested venue cities/towns/centres. So where would be good for people who may find it difficult to get to Glasgow or Edinburgh? Perth/Dundee/Inverness/???
Regards
Mary
From: Courtenay Young <cour...@courtenay-young.com>
Reply-To: <ukcpins...@googlegroups.com>
Date: Tuesday, 16 July 2013 22:31
To: <ukcpins...@googlegroups.com>
Subject: Re: [UKCP in Scotland] post from Alastair
Dear All
I am not totally familiar with the Scottish Intercollegiate Guidelines Network or SIGN (Scottish equivalent of NICE) Guidelines for the Non-Pharmaceutical Management of Depression, but they can be accessed here: http://www.sign.ac.uk/guidelines/fulltext/114/.
It seems that Behavioural Activation, Cognitive-Behavioural Therapy and Interpersonal Therapy are "... recommended as a treatment option for patients with depression" and Problem Solving Therapy and Short-term Psychodynamic Psychotherapy "... may be considered as a treatment option for patients with depression.
Additionally, "A couple-focused approach should be considered where the current relationship is contributing to the depression, or where involvement of a partner is considered to be of potential therapeutic benefit."
For all the other types of psychotherapy, "there is insufficient evidence on which to base a recommendation."
Structured exercise, Guided self-help (based on CBT or behavioural principles) and (within the structure of guided self help) computerised CBT are also recommended.
It also states that: "A number of common (non-specific) factors are likely to influence the effectiveness of psychological therapies. These may not be fully addressed by randomisation. Factors include the quality of the therapeutic alliance (at various stages of treatment), therapist factors such as competence, genuineness, empathy and positive regard, and patient characteristics such as prior improvement of symptoms, readiness for change and belief in the therapy."
And that: "Practitioners delivering psychological therapies should be trained to approved levels of competency, participate in continuing professional development and be registered with the appropriate governing body. They should be receiving ongoing supervision."
It was interesting to note that there were very few psychotherapists involved in developing these guidelines and there were no representatives from the UKCP. I believe that we could make some greater headway on establishing psychotherapy in Scotland, if we directed some of our group attention to these sorts of issues.
Another couple of quotes:
10.2 Recommendations for research
For many of the interventions described in this guideline, there was little or no robust published evidence. This was particularly the case for complementary and alternative therapies, nutritional therapies, alcohol reduction and self help groups. In addition to a lack of primary studies on such interventions a number of wider research themes were identified:
* validity of trial designs for psychological therapies
* dose-response studies for effective psychological therapies
* factors which contribute to drop-out
* non-specific treatment factors including patient/therapist interaction
* patient selection for psychological therapies
* long term effectiveness of non-pharmaceutical interventions
* contribution of unstructured exercise to beneficial effects on mood
* optimum type of exercise (aerobic, mixed or strength)
Hi folks
I’d be really interested in connecting with others involved in psychotherapy research. My ‘main’ job is as a researcher (I work at University of Stirling and co-direct a research centre focused on cancer and other life-limiting conditions, with a strand of work around therapy). My training is in family and systemic psychotherapy; my research training was primarily qualitative, but I am now running a randomised controlled trial (couple intervention for people affected by prostate cancer).
I am on maternity leave until Jan 2014, so hope that there will be appetite for continued conversation over the longer term with Mark and other colleagues about evidence from both qualitative and quantitative approaches.
Sorry to miss out on the forthcoming meeting in the Autumn, but hope that someone will be kind enough to post a bullet point summary of some of the issues discussed at some point after the meeting if that isn’t too burdensome?
Liz
Dr Liz Forbat
Reader and Co-Director
Cancer Care Research Centre
School of Nursing, Midwifery and Health
University of Stirling
Stirling
FK9 4LA
DD: 01786 466103
Dear All
* validity of trial designs for psychological therapies ƒ
* dose-response studies for effective psychological therapies ƒ
* factors which contribute to drop-out ƒ
* non-specific treatment factors including patient/therapist interaction ƒ
* patient selection for psychological therapies ƒ
* long term effectiveness of non-pharmaceutical interventions ƒ
* contribution of unstructured exercise to beneficial effects on mood ƒ
* optimum type of exercise (aerobic, mixed or strength) ƒ
Hello Liz
I’m just beginning a research project for an MSc in Mindfulness Studies with the University of Aberdeen (School of Education). This project is an exploration of the core principles necessary to create a safe holding space in group dialogue/ group psychotherapy’. It came about because of my own experiences in groups and a conversation I had with someone (not a client) who described the experience as “open-heart surgery with a blunt knife”.
The research will take the form of a co-inquiry with fellow psychotherapists trained in Core Process Psychotherapy, a mindfulness/compassion-based psychotherapeutic approach. I envisage that we will apply these principles and put them to the test within the dialogue as they are identified in group.
I’m not an experienced researcher but am excited by this project. I have always been a keen inquirer and my academic supervisor introduced me to relational constructionism which is the approach I am taking in this research.
Patricia
Hi Mary
UKCP members in Scotland have a lot to talk about and to decide together. That’s clear.
I am not advocating some kind of “UDI” (i.e. unilateral declaration of independence) from UKCP Central – at least, not now!
But I am anxious that we are focused on developing a Scottish group and on organising ourselves in the Scottish context to represent our profession. I am happy to involve Tim Swain and to get the benefit of his knowledge and experience. We don’t need an “outside” speaker but a few members might assist our discussion by being prepared to present briefly on their experience of research etc.
We can get some updating through The Psychotherapist magazine and through occasional emails to the membership.
We must avoid clashes with other psychotherapy events. I’m thinking of the major Joint Humanistic Conference in London on 7-8 September.
I hope that everyone in UKCP Scotland can get our date of 21st September into their diaries. Can you confirm a venue?
Kind regards
Alastair
From: ukcpins...@googlegroups.com [mailto:ukcpins...@googlegroups.com] On Behalf Of Mary MacCallum Sullivan
Sent: 18 July 2013 15:02
To: ukcpins...@googlegroups.com
Subject: Re: [UKCP in Scotland] Psychotherapy research in Scotland
It's great to hear of this serious research being done; is this another item for our agenda?
So far, we have:
May I suggest that if anyone wants to propose topics for discussion/decision-making you post them before the end of next week? It's useful, I think, to agree (as far as possible) a shape to the meeting, so that, as Alastair suggests, we get the decision-making done early in the day.
For me, the key aim of meeting is to get organised; I'm happy to use the resources of UKCP, most particularly their professional staff, so that we are not re-inventing the wheel. We now have a Public Affairs Manager (Tim Swain) whom we didn't have before – let's use him! Equally, I don't believe it helps the profession appear unified if we are in some ways out of step with the 'official' position of UKCP overall. Clearly the political, NHS and university contexts here in Scotland are very different than in England, but Wales and Northern Ireland will be different again….. I do mean 'in step', and not 'compliant'….
Am I right in thinking that an 'external' speaker would be unwelcome for this occasion?
I'm sure it will be good to have further meetings without having to involve 'London', but I, for one, have no interest and energy for being separate – at least not until the time and the larger process may determine!
For information, I'm also looking forward to having a couple of weeks 'away from my desk' in August.
Regards
Mary
From: Patricia Price <patri...@btinternet.com>
Reply-To: <ukcpins...@googlegroups.com>
Date: Wednesday, 17 July 2013 14:48
Dear All
* validity of trial designs for psychological therapies
* dose-response studies for effective psychological therapies
* factors which contribute to drop-out
* non-specific treatment factors including patient/therapist interaction
* patient selection for psychological therapies
* long term effectiveness of non-pharmaceutical interventions
* contribution of unstructured exercise to beneficial effects on mood
* optimum type of exercise (aerobic, mixed or strength)
Dear All
* validity of trial designs for psychological therapies ƒ* dose-response studies for effective psychological therapies ƒ* factors which contribute to drop-out ƒ* non-specific treatment factors including patient/therapist interaction ƒ* patient selection for psychological therapies ƒ* long term effectiveness of non-pharmaceutical interventions ƒ* contribution of unstructured exercise to beneficial effects on mood ƒ* optimum type of exercise (aerobic, mixed or strength) ƒ
Katie Banks MSc CTA PTSTA
UKCP Registered Psychotherapist
0777 3552104
www.therapysolutions - scotland.com
Dear all
Thanks Mary and Alastair for your comments about the relevance of my role. You’re right that political engagement work is my paid profession and I am employed by UKCP to offer support, advice and guidance about how we can do that most effectively. An obvious missing element at the moment is we don’t have a public policy operation in Scotland, Wales or Northern Ireland, and that is something I am keen that we rectify.
So, in a sense, my interest is narrow. I think one thing the meeting should achieve is to establish a Scotland-specific structure which enables effective engagement on public policy over the months and years ahead – and, of course, one that is led by UKCP’s Scotland members.
More widely, Mary has suggested gathering agenda items by a fixed time and then putting that together. Lydia, the events manager – who I think many will have met before – is to email all Scottish members in good time for a meeting on the 21st. Mary – perhaps it would be good to add Lydia to this mailing list so she can follow the latest?
It’s relevant to say that UKCP held an event in Cardiff earlier in the month and are beginning discussions in Wales about how we do something similar on the public policy front there. I think the exchange of ideas about public policy across all four nations improves each of them. SIGN – mentioned in an earlier thread – and NICE have some significant crossover and complementary working in engagement with these bodies is one obvious place to share knowledge and insights.
Wish you all the best and look forward to meeting those that will be attending in September.
Tim
Tim Swain
Public Affairs Manager
UK Council for Psychotherapy (UKCP)
2nd Floor, Edward House, 2 Wakley Street, London EC1V 7LT
Tel: 020 7014 9499 Website: www.ukcp.org.uk
Registered Charity No. 1058545 Company No. 3258939 Registered in England. The views expressed in this transmission, including any attached documents, are the views of the individual from whom it originates and as such should not be taken as representing those of the UKCP as an organisation, unless clearly defined as official policy.
CONFIDENTIALITY: the contents of this document (and all attached documents or files) are confidential and may be legally privileged. They are intended for the sole use of the individual to whom they are addressed and any others authorised to receive them on that individual’s behalf. If you are not the intended recipient, you should be aware that any duplication, distribution, discussion, disclosure or the taking of any action with respect to the contents of this document and its attachments is strongly prohibited and may be unlawful. If received in error please notify the sender immediately and delete all record of the document.
Dear All
* validity of trial designs for psychological therapies
* dose-response studies for effective psychological therapies
* factors which contribute to drop-out
* non-specific treatment factors including patient/therapist interaction
* patient selection for psychological therapies
* long term effectiveness of non-pharmaceutical interventions
* contribution of unstructured exercise to beneficial effects on mood
* optimum type of exercise (aerobic, mixed or strength)
Registered Charity No. 1058545 Company No. 3258939 Registered in England.
The views expressed in this transmission, including any attached documents, are the views of the individual from whom it originates and as such should not be taken as representing those of the UKCP as an organisation, unless clearly defined as official policy.
CONFIDENTIALITY: the contents of this document (and all attached documents or files) are confidential and may be legally privileged. They are intended for the sole use of the individual to whom they are addressed and any others authorised to receive them on that individual’s behalf. If you are not the intended recipient, you should be aware that any duplication, distribution, discussion, disclosure or the taking of any action with respect to the contents of this document and its attachments is strongly prohibited and may be unlawful. If received in error please notify the sender immediately and delete all record of the document.