Woody <
harro...@ntlworld.com> writes:
> On Tue 06/02/2024 17:42, Richmond wrote:
>> Abandoned Trolley <
fr...@fred-smith.co.uk> writes:
>>
>>> On 06/02/2024 16:36, Richmond wrote:
>>>> Abandoned Trolley <
fr...@fred-smith.co.uk> writes:
>>>>
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>> Whats the mystery ?
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>> In urban areas, "Antenna Support Structures" are rarely going to
>>>>>> be towers. The map (NCI) shows them as towers. But the main
>>>>>> mystery is where they are.
>>>>>
>>>>>
>>>>> So ... it shows the locations, but you are unable to identify them
>>>>> ?
>>>>>
>>>>> Whats the actual problem ? As I said, the two apps don't agree,
>>>> and cell 'towers' or 'cells' vanish from the map, or move.
>>>
>>> Theres a number of reasons for them apparently disappearing,
>>> especially if you are driving around in the area.
>>>
>>> If the sites are sectorised theres no need for them to be
>> symmetrical I am not driving. One cell in particular vanishes when I
>> walk towards it. If I am walking towards it then I ought to be
>> staying in the sector. I have my doubts about whether it exists as it
>> appears to be in someone's garden.
>>
> Q1: how do you know the cell mast/tower is (a) used by your SP and/or
> (b) your phone is registered on that site?
The app (NCI) shows a line going from me to the cell. I suppose that is
what it is meant to indicate. If I switch between 2G, 3G, 4G it shows
connections to different cells. If I walk from the front of the house to
the back it switches between a cell to the south and a cell to the
north.
>
> Q2: cell sites are pretty well never built in people's gardens - in
> fields, on local authority property, on the top large buildings yes -
> but NEVER in Joe Public's back garden.
Yes, so why is it showing a cell there? If it was an error in the data
it wouldn't vanish, so I suspect it was working something out based on
the signals it was getting.
>
> When you are close to site - even if it is sectored - because of
> signal strength you could be attached to any sector on that mast. When
> you go away from it you will find out simply by whether your phone
> continues to work or not. What is more the antennae on most masts have
> built-in down-tilt, that is if the antenna is upright the signal may
> be being projected with a downwards tilt of 5, 10 or even 15 degrees
> to stop the signal getting too far. Sometimes you might even see an
> antenna tilted backwards to throw the signal further than normal if
> required.
>
> Radio transmission can be magic and/or a black art even to those of us
> who have spent a lifetime working in the industry!
What information can the phone get from the cell? can it get distance
and direction? The phone knows where I am. If it knows the distance to a
cell it ought to be able to draw a circle and say the cell is somewhere
on it. If I move to a different place it can draw another circle, and
then it could deduce that the cell is at one of two points where the
circles intersect. (Unless I walk directly toward or away, in which case
the circles won't intersect).