Google Groups no longer supports new Usenet posts or subscriptions. Historical content remains viewable.
Dismiss

How much more fuel does air con use?

3 views
Skip to first unread message

Ken

unread,
Aug 11, 2008, 7:11:15 PM8/11/08
to
As per the subject?

Ken


Tim..

unread,
Aug 12, 2008, 4:08:25 AM8/12/08
to

"Ken" <Reply to NG only> wrote in message
news:48a0c714$0$26086$db0f...@news.zen.co.uk...
> As per the subject?

The general consensus is with something of 1.8 litres or more its cheaper to
run the a/c over about 50mph due to the increased drag with windows open.

Tim..

Willy Eckerslyke

unread,
Aug 12, 2008, 6:05:32 AM8/12/08
to

Except that we're never told how wide the windows would have to be
opened for the above to be true. In the real world, most people would
only open their windows an inch or so to cool the car at that speed, so
the effects on drag would be minimal.

Pete M

unread,
Aug 12, 2008, 1:42:52 PM8/12/08
to

Who cares?

Be hot and sticky but save 0.2 mpg, or be cool and comfy in a much
quieter car for the sake of a few pence a week.

I very rarely turn the AC off.

--
Pete M - OMF#9

BMW 325i SE Touring
Range Rover V8 Turbo

"Wait! We can't stop here, this is Bat Country"

loopy livernose

unread,
Aug 12, 2008, 3:37:28 PM8/12/08
to

"Willy Eckerslyke" <oss108...@bangor.ac.uk> wrote in message
news:6gd5irF...@mid.individual.net...

Have you ever driven far at over 50 with the windows barely open? the only
way of being able to arrive at a destination without a headache is to have
all windows 100% down!

although, talking of drag, what about in a car like a landrover freelander
(or rangerover) with the lowerable rear window? so the air has a
"relatively" unrestricted path through the car?

Just for interest, like Pete M I'd rather be cool and comfortable than
cooked and sweaty!

LL

--
Posted via NewsDemon.com - Premium Uncensored Newsgroup Service
------->>>>>>http://www.NewsDemon.com<<<<<<------
Unlimited Access, Anonymous Accounts, Uncensored Broadband Access

Bill

unread,
Aug 12, 2008, 7:05:49 PM8/12/08
to
In message <48a0c714$0$26086$db0f...@news.zen.co.uk>, Ken
<Re...@to.NG.invalid> writes

>As per the subject?
>
>Ken
>

I used to have a car that gave me mpg readings while moving and ltrs /
hour while stopped. Any way I noticed that when parked if I turned the
AC on it increased consumption by about a litre per hour.
>

--
Bill

Pete M

unread,
Aug 12, 2008, 7:50:37 PM8/12/08
to

Jeeezuz.

I used to do this as a matter of course on cars and I've never seen an
increase of more than 0.2 l/h.

Bill

unread,
Aug 12, 2008, 7:59:05 PM8/12/08
to
In message <g7t7in$cot$4...@registered.motzarella.org>, Pete M
<pete....@SPAMFREEblueyonder.co.uk> writes

>Bill wrote:
>> In message <48a0c714$0$26086$db0f...@news.zen.co.uk>, Ken
>><Re...@to.NG.invalid> writes
>>> As per the subject?
>>>
>>> Ken
>>>
>> I used to have a car that gave me mpg readings while moving and ltrs
>>/ hour while stopped. Any way I noticed that when parked if I turned
>>the AC on it increased consumption by about a litre per hour.
>>>
>
>Jeeezuz.
>
>I used to do this as a matter of course on cars and I've never seen an
>increase of more than 0.2 l/h.

Ford Mondeo, about 5 years ago.

>
>

--
Bill

Alan Mills

unread,
Aug 13, 2008, 10:18:50 AM8/13/08
to
What annoys me is the trend for manufacturers to assume that sun-roofs
are not wanted now that air conditioning is becoming (probably has
become) standard. I find that most of the time with British weather I
enjoy having the roof open on tilt and that air conditioning gives more
cooling than I want. However, it seems that fewer cars provide a
sunroof, even as an option and, if it is available as an option, it's
very expensive.

--
Alan Mills (in Devon, England)

Ken

unread,
Aug 13, 2008, 12:16:56 PM8/13/08
to

"Alan Mills" <a.m...@waitrose.com> wrote in message
news:6gg8q6F...@mid.individual.net...

Hear Hear!

But hang on a mo I am in Devon and getting plenty of rain but sun?
Ken


Alan Mills

unread,
Aug 13, 2008, 12:40:24 PM8/13/08
to
OK - sunroofs no good in this summer

Ken

unread,
Aug 13, 2008, 2:27:41 PM8/13/08
to

"Alan Mills" <a.m...@waitrose.com> wrote in message
news:6ggh3uF...@mid.individual.net...

If you have one (sunroof) get out there now - the sun is out!! Well it is in
South Devon
Ken


Willy Eckerslyke

unread,
Aug 14, 2008, 4:41:56 AM8/14/08
to
loopy livernose wrote:
> "Willy Eckerslyke" <oss108...@bangor.ac.uk> wrote in message
> news:6gd5irF...@mid.individual.net...
>> Tim.. wrote:
>>> "Ken" <Reply to NG only> wrote in message
>>> news:48a0c714$0$26086$db0f...@news.zen.co.uk...
>>>> As per the subject?
>>> The general consensus is with something of 1.8 litres or more its cheaper
>>> to run the a/c over about 50mph due to the increased drag with windows
>>> open.
>> Except that we're never told how wide the windows would have to be opened
>> for the above to be true. In the real world, most people would only open
>> their windows an inch or so to cool the car at that speed, so the effects
>> on drag would be minimal.
>
> Have you ever driven far at over 50 with the windows barely open?

Yes thanks. I have a nice car with properly designed quarter lights
which allow me to ventilate the car perfectly with no wind noise. It
also has a vent designed to waft fresh air gently into my face as I
drive, something I really miss when I drive supposedly well designed,
modern, air conditioned cars.

> the only
> way of being able to arrive at a destination without a headache is to have
> all windows 100% down!

Rubbish.

> although, talking of drag, what about in a car like a landrover freelander
> (or rangerover) with the lowerable rear window? so the air has a
> "relatively" unrestricted path through the car?

I suspect it would simply pull all the exhaust fumes in from the rear.

> Just for interest, like Pete M I'd rather be cool and comfortable than
> cooked and sweaty!

Then I suggest you buy a proper car instead of one that requires air-con
to overcome its lousy design.

Pete M

unread,
Aug 14, 2008, 8:32:36 AM8/14/08
to

Most modern stuff with AC is designed to run with the AC switched on. My
somewhat elderly Range Rover has decent ventilation, but it's still
much, much nicer to drive in summer with the AC on. My old E30 3 series
needs the AC on to keep a semi-sensible temperature in summer (Black car
with black leather.. ac is a must), and I find this to be the case in
plenty of cars.

The Bentley I often drive (and which pretty much defines 'proper car')
is another one which needs the AC to keep nice and cool inside. IIRC the
AC system in it has the cooling power of something mental like 14
domestic fridges :-)

Willy Eckerslyke

unread,
Aug 14, 2008, 9:55:27 AM8/14/08
to
Pete M wrote:

> Most modern stuff with AC is designed to run with the AC switched on. My
> somewhat elderly Range Rover has decent ventilation, but it's still
> much, much nicer to drive in summer with the AC on. My old E30 3 series
> needs the AC on to keep a semi-sensible temperature in summer (Black car
> with black leather.. ac is a must), and I find this to be the case in
> plenty of cars.

Since you've got me started, I really can't see why black cars are so
popular at the moment. It was a practical colour when things ran on
steam and you wanted to hide the soot, but nowadays all it does is soak
up the sunshine and make the driver look like a knob. Which, I suppose
is why so many choose to hide behind darkened windows.

> The Bentley I often drive (and which pretty much defines 'proper car')
> is another one which needs the AC to keep nice and cool inside. IIRC the
> AC system in it has the cooling power of something mental like 14
> domestic fridges :-)

OK, I'll give you that one as a special case.

Albert T Cone

unread,
Aug 14, 2008, 11:35:09 AM8/14/08
to
Willy Eckerslyke wrote:
> Pete M wrote:
>
>> Most modern stuff with AC is designed to run with the AC switched on.
>> My somewhat elderly Range Rover has decent ventilation, but it's still
>> much, much nicer to drive in summer with the AC on. My old E30 3
>> series needs the AC on to keep a semi-sensible temperature in summer
>> (Black car with black leather.. ac is a must), and I find this to be
>> the case in plenty of cars.
>
> Since you've got me started, I really can't see why black cars are so
> popular at the moment. It was a practical colour when things ran on
> steam and you wanted to hide the soot, but nowadays all it does is soak
> up the sunshine and make the driver look like a knob. Which, I suppose
> is why so many choose to hide behind darkened windows.

Why does it make the driver look like a knob? The absorption
coefficients of most dark colours is very similar - the only way to
reduce the heat absorbed noticeably is to drive something silver (like
every other car these days) or white, which generally look awful.

I prefer dark colours because I think they look better when clean and
don't show the muck as much when they aren't - this is important when
you are a lazy tosser like me and get round to washing your car twice a
year tops...

Willy Eckerslyke

unread,
Aug 14, 2008, 11:50:38 AM8/14/08
to
Albert T Cone wrote:

>> Since you've got me started, I really can't see why black cars are so
>> popular at the moment. It was a practical colour when things ran on
>> steam and you wanted to hide the soot, but nowadays all it does is
>> soak up the sunshine and make the driver look like a knob. Which, I
>> suppose is why so many choose to hide behind darkened windows.
>
> Why does it make the driver look like a knob? The absorption
> coefficients of most dark colours is very similar - the only way to
> reduce the heat absorbed noticeably is to drive something silver (like
> every other car these days)

We're clearly using on different roads then. The other day I made a bet
with myself that I'd count at least 10 black cars before the next town.
There were actually 18 - out of 30 cars! (I'm not talking about taxis,
this is out in the sticks, on the tourist trail towards Abersoch.)

> or white, which generally look awful.

Personal opinion, innit. Most modern cars look awful to me, regardless
of colour.

> I prefer dark colours because I think they look better when clean and
> don't show the muck as much when they aren't - this is important when
> you are a lazy tosser like me and get round to washing your car twice a
> year tops...

OK, I wasn't being all that serious before, but I really do have to
disagree with this one. Black cars show the dirt _far_ more than most
other colours.

Pete M

unread,
Aug 14, 2008, 3:49:27 PM8/14/08
to

I like black cars, but they're a nightmare to keep clean. Can't abide
white or red, don't like beige, and nice blues are hard to find on cheap
motors. Silver doesn't light my fire either.

Last car I changed the colour of went from metallic grey / blue to
Porsche Mint Green.

DavidR

unread,
Aug 14, 2008, 7:09:27 PM8/14/08
to
"Willy Eckerslyke" <oss108...@bangor.ac.uk> wrote

>
> We're clearly using on different roads then. The other day I made a bet
> with myself that I'd count at least 10 black cars before the next town.
> There were actually 18 - out of 30 cars! (I'm not talking about taxis,
> this is out in the sticks, on the tourist trail towards Abersoch.)

The thing is that you didn't really encounter 30 cars... There were loads
you didn't see because they were decked in various shades of grey.

Albert T Cone

unread,
Aug 15, 2008, 7:05:13 AM8/15/08
to
Willy Eckerslyke wrote:
>> reduce the heat absorbed noticeably is to drive something silver (like
>> every other car these days)
>
> We're clearly using on different roads then. The other day I made a bet
> with myself that I'd count at least 10 black cars before the next town.
> There were actually 18 - out of 30 cars! (I'm not talking about taxis,
> this is out in the sticks, on the tourist trail towards Abersoch.)

Ok, so I exaggerated a bit, but silver now accounts for 1 in 5 new cars.
I don't mind it, but it's an unispring choice, IMO.

http://www2.dupont.com/Automotive/en_US/news_events/article20061129.html

>> I prefer dark colours because I think they look better when clean and
>> don't show the muck as much when they aren't - this is important when
>> you are a lazy tosser like me and get round to washing your car twice
>> a year tops...
>
> OK, I wasn't being all that serious before, but I really do have to
> disagree with this one. Black cars show the dirt _far_ more than most
> other colours.

Ok, I agree with this, to an extent. My own stables currently include
bright red, black and silver specimens. The red one is actually the
worst for keeping clean, the black only slightly better. The silver
isn't bad, to be fair. Dark greys hide it very well, but white is of
course the worst.
Some sort of sandy brown colour would probably be best for hiding normal
road grime, I suppose...

Mike G

unread,
Aug 15, 2008, 8:28:52 AM8/15/08
to

"Willy Eckerslyke" <oss108...@bangor.ac.uk> wrote in message
news:6gi9e0F...@mid.individual.net...

> loopy livernose wrote:
>> "Willy Eckerslyke" <oss108...@bangor.ac.uk> wrote in
>> message news:6gd5irF...@mid.individual.net...
>>> Tim.. wrote:
>>>> "Ken" <Reply to NG only> wrote in message
>>>> news:48a0c714$0$26086$db0f...@news.zen.co.uk...
>>>>> As per the subject?
>>>> The general consensus is with something of 1.8 litres or
>>>> more its cheaper to run the a/c over about 50mph due to the
>>>> increased drag with windows open.
>>> Except that we're never told how wide the windows would have
>>> to be opened for the above to be true. In the real world,
>>> most people would only open their windows an inch or so to
>>> cool the car at that speed, so the effects on drag would be
>>> minimal.
>>
>> Have you ever driven far at over 50 with the windows barely
>> open?
>
> Yes thanks. I have a nice car with properly designed quarter
> lights which allow me to ventilate the car perfectly with no
> wind noise. It also has a vent designed to waft fresh air
> gently into my face as I drive, something I really miss when I
> drive supposedly well designed, modern, air conditioned cars.

Whether you have good ventilation or not, fresh air on a hot day
can never be as effective as a/c for giving a comfortable
interior temperature.
Mike.

Willy Eckerslyke

unread,
Aug 15, 2008, 9:10:08 AM8/15/08
to
Albert T Cone wrote:
> Willy Eckerslyke wrote:
>>> reduce the heat absorbed noticeably is to drive something silver
>>> (like every other car these days)
>>
>> We're clearly using on different roads then. The other day I made a
>> bet with myself that I'd count at least 10 black cars before the next
>> town. There were actually 18 - out of 30 cars! (I'm not talking about
>> taxis, this is out in the sticks, on the tourist trail towards Abersoch.)
>
> Ok, so I exaggerated a bit, but silver now accounts for 1 in 5 new cars.
> I don't mind it, but it's an unispring choice, IMO.
>
> http://www2.dupont.com/Automotive/en_US/news_events/article20061129.html

Which also says:
"The 2006 color popularity report sees growth of black in the North
American luxury segment with 22 percent, mirroring black’s longstanding
first place among European luxury vehicles with 37 percent."

Actually, I think it was Abersoch that skewed my findings above. I just
walked past the slipway car park here in Menai Bridge and out of 6 cars,
5 were black (including 2x Range Rover Sports and 1x Dodge Ram
Total-Taste-Bypass). It seems that black is the colour of choice for
boaty people this year.
Oh, and I don't think I've ever seen a RR Sport in _any_ other colour.
Have you?

> Some sort of sandy brown colour would probably be best for hiding normal
> road grime, I suppose...

I've just painted my Land Rover matte finish NATO Green, but that was
chosen on the price of the paint rather than it's ability to hide dirt.

Adrian

unread,
Aug 15, 2008, 9:27:22 AM8/15/08
to
Willy Eckerslyke <oss108...@bangor.ac.uk> gurgled happily, sounding
much like they were saying:

> Oh, and I don't think I've ever seen a RR Sport in _any_ other colour.
> Have you?

Unfortunately, yes, I've seen a couple of Project Khan ones.

Willy Eckerslyke

unread,
Aug 15, 2008, 10:00:46 AM8/15/08
to

<consults the google>

Holy cow, they look like something Krusty would come up with!

AstraVanMann

unread,
Aug 16, 2008, 4:44:10 AM8/16/08
to
> I used to have a car that gave me mpg readings while moving and ltrs /
> hour while stopped. Any way I noticed that when parked if I turned the AC
> on it increased consumption by about a litre per hour.

You had a car that used fuel whilst parked?

--
"For want of the price of tea and a slice, the old man died."


Adrian

unread,
Aug 16, 2008, 4:57:33 AM8/16/08
to
"AstraVanMann" <Pe...@Swerveforeskinweb.com> gurgled happily, sounding

much like they were saying:

>> I used to have a car that gave me mpg readings while moving and ltrs /


>> hour while stopped. Any way I noticed that when parked if I turned the
>> AC on it increased consumption by about a litre per hour.

> You had a car that used fuel whilst parked?

Umm, yes, most cars use fuel whilst parked, if you don't turn the engine
off...

Nick Finnigan

unread,
Aug 16, 2008, 5:18:20 AM8/16/08
to
Pete M wrote:
> Bill wrote:
>
>> In message <48a0c714$0$26086$db0f...@news.zen.co.uk>, Ken
>> <Re...@to.NG.invalid> writes
>>
>>> As per the subject?
>>>
>>> Ken
>>>
>>
>> I used to have a car that gave me mpg readings while moving and ltrs /
>> hour while stopped. Any way I noticed that when parked if I turned the
>> AC on it increased consumption by about a litre per hour.
>>
>>>
>
> Jeeezuz.
>
> I used to do this as a matter of course on cars and I've never seen an
> increase of more than 0.2 l/h.

0.2 l/h means 2kW input power, which isn't going to give a lot of
cooling for a parked car; for a large petrol engine at idle there might
be enough fuel going through anyway that the extra load doesn't add as
much as you might expect.

OTOH 1 l/h means 10kW input, which is a bit excessive.

AstraVanMann

unread,
Aug 16, 2008, 11:35:55 AM8/16/08
to
>>> I used to have a car that gave me mpg readings while moving and ltrs /
>>> hour while stopped. Any way I noticed that when parked if I turned the
>>> AC on it increased consumption by about a litre per hour.
>
>> You had a car that used fuel whilst parked?
>
> Umm, yes, most cars use fuel whilst parked, if you don't turn the engine
> off...

Weirdly, in most car parks I've ever been to, most people don't adopt that
approach.

DervMan

unread,
Aug 17, 2008, 8:09:31 PM8/17/08
to
"Alan Mills" <a.m...@waitrose.com> wrote in message
news:6gg8q6F...@mid.individual.net...


Whilst I do miss the sunroof, I'd not swap it for air conditioning; I
probably have a lower tolerance of sunlight and temperature than you,
though.

--
The DervMan
www.dervman.com


DervMan

unread,
Aug 17, 2008, 8:12:16 PM8/17/08
to
"Willy Eckerslyke" <oss108...@bangor.ac.uk> wrote in message
news:6gd5irF...@mid.individual.net...
> Tim.. wrote:
>> "Ken" <Reply to NG only> wrote in message
>> news:48a0c714$0$26086$db0f...@news.zen.co.uk...
>>> As per the subject?
>>
>> The general consensus is with something of 1.8 litres or more its cheaper
>> to run the a/c over about 50mph due to the increased drag with windows
>> open.
>
> Except that we're never told how wide the windows would have to be opened
> for the above to be true. In the real world, most people would only open
> their windows an inch or so to cool the car at that speed, so the effects
> on drag would be minimal.

The size of the opening has a disproportionate influence on the increase of
drag: an inch may make a material difference.

Besides which, opening a window doesn't cool the car, it moves more airflow
through the car, which may or may not help cool the occupants if they
perspire. Air conditioning cools and dehumidifies the air as it enters the
cabin; far more effective for proper cooling.

--
The DervMan
www.dervman.com


DervMan

unread,
Aug 17, 2008, 8:15:47 PM8/17/08
to
"Willy Eckerslyke" <oss108...@bangor.ac.uk> wrote in message
news:6gi9e0F...@mid.individual.net...

> loopy livernose wrote:
>> "Willy Eckerslyke" <oss108...@bangor.ac.uk> wrote in message
>> news:6gd5irF...@mid.individual.net...
>>> Tim.. wrote:
>>>> "Ken" <Reply to NG only> wrote in message
>>>> news:48a0c714$0$26086$db0f...@news.zen.co.uk...
>>>>> As per the subject?
>>>> The general consensus is with something of 1.8 litres or more its
>>>> cheaper to run the a/c over about 50mph due to the increased drag with
>>>> windows open.
>>> Except that we're never told how wide the windows would have to be
>>> opened for the above to be true. In the real world, most people would
>>> only open their windows an inch or so to cool the car at that speed, so
>>> the effects on drag would be minimal.
>>
>> Have you ever driven far at over 50 with the windows barely open?
>
> Yes thanks. I have a nice car with properly designed quarter lights which
> allow me to ventilate the car perfectly with no wind noise.

Oh, you mean an old car where it's designed to run with the windows open for
a trivial increase in wind noise.

New stuff is (generally) designed for running with the windows shut.

> It also has a vent designed to waft fresh air gently into my face as I
> drive, something I really miss when I drive supposedly well designed,
> modern, air conditioned cars.

That is partially how the driver sets the ventilation system up. Some cars
would dump buckets of icy cold air into ones face if you simply open the
vent. But partially closing it isn't difficult...

>> the only way of being able to arrive at a destination without a headache
>> is to have all windows 100% down!
>
> Rubbish.

Opening the windows increases the noise right by ones ear. It would give me
a headache too.

>> although, talking of drag, what about in a car like a landrover
>> freelander (or rangerover) with the lowerable rear window? so the air
>> has a "relatively" unrestricted path through the car?
>
> I suspect it would simply pull all the exhaust fumes in from the rear.

Depends on the design of the car and the opening; a suitable spoiler
(obvious or otherwise) could break the turbulence at the top of the
windscreen and resolve the issue.

>> Just for interest, like Pete M I'd rather be cool and comfortable than
>> cooked and sweaty!
>
> Then I suggest you buy a proper car instead of one that requires air-con
> to overcome its lousy design.

...and it still won't dehumidify and cool the air and therefore be far less
comfortable than something with air conditioning.

--
The DervMan
www.dervman.com


DervMan

unread,
Aug 17, 2008, 8:16:57 PM8/17/08
to
"Willy Eckerslyke" <oss108...@bangor.ac.uk> wrote in message
news:6girppF...@mid.individual.net...

> Pete M wrote:
>
>> Most modern stuff with AC is designed to run with the AC switched on. My
>> somewhat elderly Range Rover has decent ventilation, but it's still much,
>> much nicer to drive in summer with the AC on. My old E30 3 series needs
>> the AC on to keep a semi-sensible temperature in summer (Black car with
>> black leather.. ac is a must), and I find this to be the case in plenty
>> of cars.
>
> Since you've got me started, I really can't see why black cars are so
> popular at the moment. It was a practical colour when things ran on steam
> and you wanted to hide the soot, but nowadays all it does is soak up the
> sunshine and make the driver look like a knob. Which, I suppose is why so
> many choose to hide behind darkened windows.

What are you on?

It also cools down quicker too; in the winter, it absorbs more infrared thus
would be warmer than a white one next to it...

>> The Bentley I often drive (and which pretty much defines 'proper car') is
>> another one which needs the AC to keep nice and cool inside. IIRC the AC
>> system in it has the cooling power of something mental like 14 domestic
>> fridges :-)
>
> OK, I'll give you that one as a special case.


--
The DervMan
www.dervman.com


Pete M

unread,
Aug 18, 2008, 12:24:59 AM8/18/08
to

The BMW and the Range Rover both have AC and electric sunroofs, so using
this sample of one, it can't be that rare :-p

Adrian

unread,
Aug 18, 2008, 2:14:12 AM8/18/08
to
Pete M <pete....@SPAMFREEblueyonder.co.uk> gurgled happily, sounding

much like they were saying:

>> Whilst I do miss the sunroof, I'd not swap it for air conditioning; I


>> probably have a lower tolerance of sunlight and temperature than you,
>> though.

> The BMW and the Range Rover both have AC and electric sunroofs, so using
> this sample of one, it can't be that rare :-p

All my last three "main cars" have/had aircon & electric sunroofs.

Adrian

unread,
Aug 18, 2008, 2:15:08 AM8/18/08
to
"DervMan" <thede...@gmail.com> gurgled happily, sounding much like they
were saying:

> Besides which, opening a window doesn't cool the car, it moves more


> airflow through the car, which may or may not help cool the occupants if
> they perspire.

So true - but in UK weather, it's going to cool. In the Nevada desert, we
found it cooler (less ridiculously hot) with windows shut.

Willy Eckerslyke

unread,
Aug 18, 2008, 3:54:22 AM8/18/08
to
DervMan wrote:

> Besides which, opening a window doesn't cool the car, it moves more airflow
> through the car, which may or may not help cool the occupants if they
> perspire.

Eh? The air inside a closed car (on a sunny day) with no airflow is
going to be warmer than the air outside due to the greenhouse effect. So
any fresh air will be cooler, innit.

DervMan

unread,
Aug 18, 2008, 4:54:19 AM8/18/08
to
"Adrian" <tooma...@gmail.com> wrote in message
news:6gsibcF...@mid.individual.net...

Again, depends. In a dry heat, perspiring is the way to cool off. In humid
conditions, perspiring doesn't work...

--
The DervMan
www.dervman.com


DervMan

unread,
Aug 18, 2008, 4:56:08 AM8/18/08
to
"Adrian" <tooma...@gmail.com> wrote in message
news:6gsi9kF...@mid.individual.net...

The Accord too and this Saab nearly did*, but ultimately and given the
choice, I'd delete the 'roof for air conditioning.

*as in the other model we looked at did have the Saab power 'roof.

--
The DervMan
www.dervman.com


DervMan

unread,
Aug 18, 2008, 4:53:40 AM8/18/08
to
"Willy Eckerslyke" <oss108...@bangor.ac.uk> wrote in message
news:6gso4hF...@mid.individual.net...

I did make the assumption that air would be entering and leaving the car as
air conditioning needs air pumped into the interior. On a hot, humid day,
letting the hotter air escape and introducing more hot air isn't comfortable
in the slightest.

--
The DervMan
www.dervman.com


Adrian

unread,
Aug 18, 2008, 5:12:36 AM8/18/08
to
"DervMan" <thede...@gmail.com> gurgled happily, sounding much like they
were saying:

>>>> Whilst I do miss the sunroof, I'd not swap it for air conditioning; I
>>>> probably have a lower tolerance of sunlight and temperature than you,
>>>> though.

>>> The BMW and the Range Rover both have AC and electric sunroofs, so
>>> using this sample of one, it can't be that rare :-p

>> All my last three "main cars" have/had aircon & electric sunroofs.

> The Accord too and this Saab nearly did*, but ultimately and given the
> choice, I'd delete the 'roof for air conditioning.

Tricky one for me. I think it'd depend very much on the car. I like
sunroofs - especially glass.

I suspect, though, that the fact I've not bothered to look into getting
the Saab's aircon working yet - despite having owned it a year - gives me
the answer.

Willy Eckerslyke

unread,
Aug 18, 2008, 5:23:26 AM8/18/08
to
DervMan wrote:

> I did make the assumption that air would be entering and leaving the car as
> air conditioning needs air pumped into the interior. On a hot, humid day,
> letting the hotter air escape and introducing more hot air isn't comfortable
> in the slightest.

Ah yes, we had one of those last year, didn't we? Or was it the one before?

DervMan

unread,
Aug 18, 2008, 6:00:36 AM8/18/08
to
"Willy Eckerslyke" <oss108...@bangor.ac.uk> wrote in message
news:6gstbhF...@mid.individual.net...

Last year we had four weeks of ambient air temperatures high enough to make
relative humidity of >60% uncomfortable. Then throw in a snug fitting car
seat and you have sweaty backs after a brief period.

Two weeks ago we had 90%+ relative humidity in York at ground level.

But like I've said elsewhere, my tolerance of temperature and humidity may
well be much lower than yours...

--
The DervMan
www.dervman.com


DervMan

unread,
Aug 18, 2008, 6:02:58 AM8/18/08
to
"Adrian" <tooma...@gmail.com> wrote in message
news:6gsso4F...@mid.individual.net...

> "DervMan" <thede...@gmail.com> gurgled happily, sounding much like they
> were saying:
>
>>>>> Whilst I do miss the sunroof, I'd not swap it for air conditioning; I
>>>>> probably have a lower tolerance of sunlight and temperature than you,
>>>>> though.
>
>>>> The BMW and the Range Rover both have AC and electric sunroofs, so
>>>> using this sample of one, it can't be that rare :-p
>
>>> All my last three "main cars" have/had aircon & electric sunroofs.
>
>> The Accord too and this Saab nearly did*, but ultimately and given the
>> choice, I'd delete the 'roof for air conditioning.
>
> Tricky one for me. I think it'd depend very much on the car. I like
> sunroofs - especially glass.

Me too, but I like the option to shade it in the summer. The Cinquecento
had a removeable panel to provide shade.

> I suspect, though, that the fact I've not bothered to look into getting
> the Saab's aircon working yet - despite having owned it a year - gives me
> the answer.

The right sunroof is excellent; the wrong one isn't so good. For me,
sunroofs _tend_ to work at their best when reducing the cabin air pressure
by being tilted, so allowing more air through the ventilation system.
Having them wide open on a sunny day will burn me all too quickly... :-(

--
The DervMan
www.dervman.com


Willy Eckerslyke

unread,
Aug 18, 2008, 6:23:48 AM8/18/08
to
DervMan wrote:

> But like I've said elsewhere, my tolerance of temperature and humidity may
> well be much lower than yours...

Where you drive can make a big difference too. I'm lucky in that I live
near the coast and seldom have to sit in a traffic jam. No doubt I'd see
things differently if I had to battle with the M25 every day, for example.
I still believe though, that many manufacturers see air-con as an easy
solution to designing a decent ventilation system. This is based on my
inability to ever get things quite right in any modern car I've driven.
So perhaps I'm actually fussier than you after all.

Adrian

unread,
Aug 18, 2008, 6:23:37 AM8/18/08
to
"DervMan" <thede...@gmail.com> gurgled happily, sounding much like they
were saying:

>>>> All my last three "main cars" have/had aircon & electric sunroofs.

>>> The Accord too and this Saab nearly did*, but ultimately and given the
>>> choice, I'd delete the 'roof for air conditioning.

>> Tricky one for me. I think it'd depend very much on the car. I like
>> sunroofs - especially glass.

> Me too, but I like the option to shade it in the summer. The
> Cinquecento had a removeable panel to provide shade.

The XM had a sliding plastic shutter - which I closed once, and decided
it was too claustrophobic (black headlining)

>> I suspect, though, that the fact I've not bothered to look into getting
>> the Saab's aircon working yet - despite having owned it a year - gives
>> me the answer.

> The right sunroof is excellent; the wrong one isn't so good. For me,
> sunroofs _tend_ to work at their best when reducing the cabin air
> pressure by being tilted, so allowing more air through the ventilation
> system. Having them wide open on a sunny day will burn me all too
> quickly... :-(

What's even more bizarre, though, is that the Saab's is a metal slide-
only, whereas I _much_ prefer glass tiltable... The Saab's black, and the
headlining's currently out for retrim, so it gets kinda warm in there.
It's also a 3-dr, so the rear side windows are pop-outs, so I think I've
only opened 'em once or twice. You'd think that'd be the kind of mix
which would make aircon MOST valuable.

DervMan

unread,
Aug 18, 2008, 6:53:10 AM8/18/08
to
"Willy Eckerslyke" <oss108...@bangor.ac.uk> wrote in message
news:6gt0smF...@mid.individual.net...

> DervMan wrote:
>
>> But like I've said elsewhere, my tolerance of temperature and humidity
>> may well be much lower than yours...
>
> Where you drive can make a big difference too. I'm lucky in that I live
> near the coast and seldom have to sit in a traffic jam. No doubt I'd see
> things differently if I had to battle with the M25 every day, for example.
> I still believe though, that many manufacturers see air-con as an easy
> solution to designing a decent ventilation system.

To a point, it is - but it's also using readily available bits to solve the
problem of interior stuffiness. A warm interior can make for a sleepy
driver, a humid interior can mist up the windows, so on and so forth. An
effective heating and ventilation system can do many things very well; Ford
got their non-air conditioned system right in the early to mid 80s, but in
high ambient air temperatures*, it's plain uncomfortable.

Much of the time I don't *need* air conditioning to be comfortable for a
long haul trip but it certainly helps. And you're right because some cars'
ventilation systems don't appear optimised for air conditioning in that they
provide the driver with anunhelpful blast of icy air with little cabin air
circulation - this is as much true for older machines as newer ones too, but
with working air conditioning, the difference in temperature between cabin
and incoming can be far wider.

Quite by a happy coincidence, my current machine has the ability to adjust
the climate control's fan speed / temperature bias. I find many climate
control systems too keen to chuck cold air at my face in strong sunlight.
With this car, I can deliberately decelerate the fan speed, which means it
tends to reduce the temperature of incoming air *but* it wafts it at you
rather than blows it at you.

*For me, anything over ~20 degrees usually feels uncomfortable! :)

> This is based on my inability to ever get things quite right in any modern
> car I've driven.

It could be. I don't know what you currently drive, but have you tried
something similar, just updated?

> So perhaps I'm actually fussier than you after all.

Maybe! There's a certain period of adaptation needed. I've recently moved
from a first generation Saab 9-3 to a second and find the newer machines'
climate control system to be surprisingly more effective than the old -
mostly because I can adapt it to suit me, rather than the other way around.

--
The DervMan
www.dervman.com


Pete M

unread,
Aug 18, 2008, 6:54:44 AM8/18/08
to

You may well be right. I'm lucky that the E30 has one of the better
ventilation systems of the 80's, along with AC. :-)

DervMan

unread,
Aug 18, 2008, 6:56:34 AM8/18/08
to
"Adrian" <tooma...@gmail.com> wrote in message
news:6gt0t9F...@mid.individual.net...

> "DervMan" <thede...@gmail.com> gurgled happily, sounding much like they
> were saying:
>
>>>>> All my last three "main cars" have/had aircon & electric sunroofs.
>
>>>> The Accord too and this Saab nearly did*, but ultimately and given the
>>>> choice, I'd delete the 'roof for air conditioning.
>
>>> Tricky one for me. I think it'd depend very much on the car. I like
>>> sunroofs - especially glass.
>
>> Me too, but I like the option to shade it in the summer. The
>> Cinquecento had a removeable panel to provide shade.
>
> The XM had a sliding plastic shutter - which I closed once, and decided
> it was too claustrophobic (black headlining)

I seem to recall that the Cinquecento's roof lining was dead skin grey. It
was certainly darker with the shade in, but not excessively so.

>>> I suspect, though, that the fact I've not bothered to look into getting
>>> the Saab's aircon working yet - despite having owned it a year - gives
>>> me the answer.
>
>> The right sunroof is excellent; the wrong one isn't so good. For me,
>> sunroofs _tend_ to work at their best when reducing the cabin air
>> pressure by being tilted, so allowing more air through the ventilation
>> system. Having them wide open on a sunny day will burn me all too
>> quickly... :-(
>
> What's even more bizarre, though, is that the Saab's is a metal slide-
> only, whereas I _much_ prefer glass tiltable... The Saab's black, and the
> headlining's currently out for retrim, so it gets kinda warm in there.

I can imagine.

> It's also a 3-dr, so the rear side windows are pop-outs, so I think I've
> only opened 'em once or twice. You'd think that'd be the kind of mix
> which would make aircon MOST valuable.

For me, probably, no; absolutely yes. The Cinquecento and Ka had opening
rear quarter lights. They were most useful in the Cinquecento to increase
turbulence in a cross wind. :-)

--
The DervMan
www.dervman.com


Pete M

unread,
Aug 18, 2008, 8:20:07 AM8/18/08
to
DervMan wrote:
> "Adrian" <tooma...@gmail.com> wrote in message
> news:6gt0t9F...@mid.individual.net...
>> "DervMan" <thede...@gmail.com> gurgled happily, sounding much like they
>> were saying:
>>
>>>>>> All my last three "main cars" have/had aircon & electric sunroofs.
>>>>> The Accord too and this Saab nearly did*, but ultimately and given the
>>>>> choice, I'd delete the 'roof for air conditioning.
>>>> Tricky one for me. I think it'd depend very much on the car. I like
>>>> sunroofs - especially glass.
>>> Me too, but I like the option to shade it in the summer. The
>>> Cinquecento had a removeable panel to provide shade.
>> The XM had a sliding plastic shutter - which I closed once, and decided
>> it was too claustrophobic (black headlining)

One thing I can't stand in a car is a glass sunroof unless it has a
proper solid blind. You can always tell when I've been driving a car
with a glass sunroof as the blind will be shut. First thing I do when I
get in is close the blind.

I went as far as changing the blind in my Sapphire Cossie from a
semi-solid job to a proper solid one. Meant taking out the whole sunroof
cartridge to do the job, but it was worth it.

The Rangie has a glass sunroof, but the blind has only been opened to
clean the glass while I've had it.

I don't understand the whole "Light and airy" thing in cars, I'd much
rather have a car with a nice dark interior.

Adrian

unread,
Aug 18, 2008, 8:37:03 AM8/18/08
to
Pete M <pete....@SPAMFREEblueyonder.co.uk> gurgled happily, sounding

much like they were saying:

> I don't understand the whole "Light and airy" thing in cars, I'd much


> rather have a car with a nice dark interior.

Hmm. Seats or headlining?

Seats? Definitely. Ish.

But Headlining? Gawd, no. The Saab's a bit dark inside - dark grey
leather - and a new light grey headlining will cheer it up massively.
When I took the old, saggy, stained one out, leaving black paint, the
inside seemed to physically shrink.

The CX had black & grey cloth and a black headlining - the car seemed to
physically expand inside with the sunroof open.

The XM had a black headlining because it had tan leather - the other
interior colours, mid-dark grey cloth or black leather would have had a
mid-grey lining, to stop 'em being so bad.

Pete M

unread,
Aug 18, 2008, 8:53:12 AM8/18/08
to

But black headlining is great :-(

I want a black headliner for the E30, but it was a mega-rare option in
the UK, and it's option only on the Touring. Want a black carpet too,
the grey one is just 'orrible.

Willy Eckerslyke

unread,
Aug 18, 2008, 9:06:16 AM8/18/08
to
DervMan wrote:
> "Willy Eckerslyke" <oss108...@bangor.ac.uk> wrote in message
> news:6gt0smF...@mid.individual.net...

>> This is based on my inability to ever get things quite right in any modern

>> car I've driven.
>
> It could be. I don't know what you currently drive, but have you tried
> something similar, just updated?

Rover 2000TC. I could go for a 2200TC, but that's probably not what you
have in mind!

Air conned cars I've been unmoved by: wife's Mondeo; work's Focus
estate; various nondescript hire cars provided by work, Avensis estates
and the like.

>> So perhaps I'm actually fussier than you after all.
>
> Maybe! There's a certain period of adaptation needed.

Hmm. I haven't even figured out the stupid paddle thing to control the
radio on the Focus yet (but then neither has anyone else), so there's
not much for me there.

Willy Eckerslyke

unread,
Aug 18, 2008, 9:10:37 AM8/18/08
to
Pete M wrote:

> You may well be right. I'm lucky that the E30 has one of the better
> ventilation systems of the 80's, along with AC. :-)

Have their values started to increase yet? Strikes me that it's about
time for them to be recognised as the last "proper" BMW, and certainly
the last DIY friendly model.

Mike G

unread,
Aug 18, 2008, 9:26:31 AM8/18/08
to

"Pete M" <pete....@SPAMFREEblueyonder.co.uk> wrote in message
news:g8bkda$lh8$2...@registered.motzarella.org...

> Willy Eckerslyke wrote:
>> DervMan wrote:
>>
>>> But like I've said elsewhere, my tolerance of temperature and
>>> humidity may well be much lower than yours...
>>
>> Where you drive can make a big difference too. I'm lucky in
>> that I live near the coast and seldom have to sit in a traffic
>> jam. No doubt I'd see things differently if I had to battle
>> with the M25 every day, for example.
>> I still believe though, that many manufacturers see air-con as
>> an easy solution to designing a decent ventilation system.
>> This is based on my inability to ever get things quite right
>> in any modern car I've driven. So perhaps I'm actually fussier
>> than you after all.
>
> You may well be right. I'm lucky that the E30 has one of the
> better ventilation systems of the 80's, along with AC. :-)

The later E39 climate control appears equally as good. You can
adjust fan speed, and have any combination of foot, mid, or upper
airflow, with different temperatures for passenger and driver.
The only thing I dislike about the system, is that there is no
'ram air' affect. Without the fan, there is virtually no air flow
within the car. As I found out a few weeks ago when the fan
controller packed up. Had to have a window open just to get fresh
air into the car.
Mike.

Pete M

unread,
Aug 18, 2008, 9:40:12 AM8/18/08
to

Not hugely, the 'Tech 1' and 'Tech 2' cars are fetching quite large
sums, but something like my 325i touring auto isn't particularly
valuable at the moment.

There is a lot of "Scene tax" going on with them, but for a 318iS to be
worth as much as a 325i is just mental.

Chris Whelan

unread,
Aug 18, 2008, 10:08:40 AM8/18/08
to
Willy Eckerslyke wrote:

[...]


>
> Hmm. I haven't even figured out the stupid paddle thing to control the
> radio on the Focus yet (but then neither has anyone else), so there's
> not much for me there.

<Waves>

Took me about three minutes to figure out without using the handbook...

Chris

--
Remove prejudice to reply.

0 new messages