Google Groups no longer supports new Usenet posts or subscriptions. Historical content remains viewable.
Dismiss

One in five liberal democrat communists wants the Second Amendment to be repealed, national survey finds

0 views
Skip to first unread message

Rudolph P. Kohltrane

unread,
Apr 29, 2018, 11:56:16 PM4/29/18
to
Liberals are not Americans.

One consequence of the success of the National Rifle
Association's expansive gun-rights agenda — and its lobbying
power in Congress — is that groups favoring more gun control
have pared down their ambitions in recent years.

The Brady Campaign to Prevent Gun Violence, for instance, no
longer talks about banning handguns. Advocates have moved away
from the term “gun control” in favor of more specific language
like “gun violence” and “gun safety.” Democratic leaders in
Congress have grown timid about proposing significant new
restrictions on gun ownership.

In that context it's a bit of a jolt to read an op-ed published
Tuesday by retired Supreme Court justice John Paul Stevens
titled “Repeal the Second Amendment.” Stevens is something of an
expert on the issue, having considered the proper scope of the
Second Amendment in the 2008 case District of Columbia v. Heller.

In his op-ed, Stevens praises the work of the March for Our
Lives organizers and urges the group to “seek more effective and
more lasting reform” via a “repeal of the Second Amendment.” He
calls the Second Amendment a “relic of the 18th century,”
concerned more with the balance of power between the states and
the federal government than with individual gun rights.

But public-opinion polling shows that it would take a lot of
persuading to bring the public around to that view. In February,
for instance, the Economist and YouGov asked Americans whether
they supported a repeal of the Second Amendment. Twenty-one
percent said they favored such a proposal, compared with 60
percent in opposition.


The poll does, however, show surprisingly robust support for
Second Amendment repeal (39 percent) among Democrats (by
contrast, 8 percent of Republicans would support a full repeal).
Black Americans (30 percent) and Northeasterners (28 percent)
also showed relatively high levels of support.

One caveat is that other polls have shown that many Americans do
not know what the Second Amendment is. In 1999, for instance, a
Hearst Newspapers poll found that 59 percent of respondents said
they did not know the purpose of the Second Amendment. But
national conversations on gun rights since then have probably
shrunk that number, and the Economist/YouGov poll discusses the
Second Amendment in the context of guns.

Beyond that, the poll showed that a plurality of Americans do
not see the Second Amendment as something set in stone. Forty-
six percent said they favored modifying the Second Amendment to
allow for stricter regulations, compared with 39 percent who
were opposed. More than three-quarters of Democrats said they
supported modifying the Second Amendment, as did more than one-
quarter of Republicans.


Those numbers are surprising, given that virtually no political
leaders in the country are publicly advocating for a repeal or
modification of the Second Amendment. Democrat Hillary Clinton
made gun control a focal point of her presidential bid but spoke
of the need to “balance legitimate Second Amendment-rights
concerns with preventive measures and control measures.” In
2016, President Barack Obama felt compelled to publicly state
that “I believe in the Second Amendment” as he announced a set
of extremely limited executive actions on guns.

Even Sen. Dianne Feinstein (D-Calif.), who has for years been a
leading proponent of gun control in the Senate, wrote in 2012,
“let me be clear: If an individual wants to purchase a weapon
for hunting or self-defense, I support that right.”

But the polling above suggests that a significant chunk of the
Democratic electorate would be willing to support a much more
restrictive gun-policy agenda than the party currently supports.
The coming of age of the “mass shooting generation” may increase
that divide.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2018/03/27/one-in-
five-americans-want-the-second-amendment-to-be-repealed-national-
survey-finds/?noredirect=on&utm_term=.3e88a0fc9ba6
 

0 new messages