Google Groups no longer supports new Usenet posts or subscriptions. Historical content remains viewable.
Dismiss

Whatever happened to real music?

3 views
Skip to first unread message

Iain L M Hotchkies

unread,
Sep 15, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/15/96
to

[newsgroups trimmed - for the sheer hell of it]

cribbed this from best-of-usenet

thought it was appropriate

-------------------------------------------------------------

Subject: FINALLY! The Troller's FAQ!

This is a beta-test version of the Recreational Trolling FAQ!

Contents:
~~~~~~~~~

Introduction


Section 1: What is a troll?
Section 2: Design Issues
Section 3: Content
Section 4: Newsgroup Selection
Section 5: Know Your Audience
Section 6: Following-Up
Section 7: The Sucessful Troll
Section 8: Troll RFC


INTRODUCTION
~~~~~~~~~~~~

The object of this post is to bring together a definitve document to cover
the phenomena of the Usenet Troll. To many a troll is nothing more than an
annoying method of defeating the killfile whereas to the heavily killfiled,
trolling can be a virtual Godsend.

What I want this document to focus on is how to create entertaining trolls.
I have drawn on the expertise of the writer's of some of Usenet's finest
and best remembered trolls. Trolls are for fun. The object of recreational
trolling is to sit back and laugh at all those gullible idiots that will
believe *anything*.


Section 1: What Is A Troll?
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

The WWW gives this as a definition:

troll v.,n.

To utter a posting on Usenet designed to attract predictable
responses or flames. Derives from the phrase "trolling for
newbies"; which in turn comes from mainstream "trolling";, a
style of fishing in which one trails bait through a likely spot
hoping for a bite. The well-constructed troll is a post that
induces lots of newbies and flamers to make themselves look even
more clueless than they already do, while subtly conveying to
the more savvy and experienced that it is in fact a deliberate
troll. If you don't fall for the joke, you get to be in on it.


The following extract is from a broader expansion of the defining comments
given above:

In Usenet usage, a "troll" is not a grumpy monster that lives
beneath a bridge accosting passers-by, but rather a provocative
posting to a newsgroup intended to produce a large volume of
frivolous responses.

The content of a "troll" posting generally falls into several
areas. It may consist of an apparently foolish contradiction
of common knowledge, a deliberately offensive insult to the
readers of a newsgroup, or a broad request for trivial follow-up
postings.

There are three reasons why people troll newsgroups:

People post such messages to get attention, to disrupt newsgroups,
and simply to make trouble.

Career trollers tend for the latter two whilst the former is the mark
of the clueless newbie and should be ignored.

Section 2: Design Issues
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

A troll is no different to any other Usenet posting. That needs to be
stressed. Any article that you decide to write should be written with
a view to it actually being read by large numbers of people. Simply
X-posting to large numbers of irrelevant newsgroups is not creative
trolling - it is just spam and should be avoided.


The experienced troller spends time carefully choosing the right subject
and delivering it to the right newsgroup. With trolls, delivery is just
as important as the subject.


Start the troll in a reasonable and erudite manner. You have to engage
your readers' interest and draw them in. Never give too much away at
the start - although a brief abstract with hints of what's to come can
work wonders.


Construct your troll in a manner to make it readable. Use short paragraphs
and lots of white space. Keep line length below eighty characters. Use a
liberal amount of emphasis and even the occasional illustration. A good
rule of thumb is that as your troll becomes more and more ludicrous put
extra effort into the presentation - this keeps the mug punter confused.
Let confusion and choas be your goal!


Section 3 Content
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Make your subject a relevant one. Posting "Star Trek Sucks" into hk.forsale
is not going to work very well and is liable to utterly destroy your hard
earned reputation as a troller overnight.


You do not have to make the subject clear. Trolls are aimed at two audiences,
the respondees and the lurkers. The best trolls reveal their true subject
only to the lurkers. In every sense those who reply to your troll are your
tools. So choose a theme for your troll and stick to it.


Outwardly you need to appear sincere, but at the same time you have to tell
your *real* audience that this is blatant flamebait. Your skill is shown in
the easy way that you manipulate large areas of the Usenet community into
making public fools of themselves.


Section 4 Newsgroup Selection
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Choice of newsgroup is as important as the subject, tone and structure of
the troll. You want to appeal to each group you X-post into to ensure
responses from each group. A well delivered troll will anticipate what
those responses will be and thus ensure that contradictions will arise
amongst the different groups that you are setting up.


BAD:

Posting "USA Sucks" to alt.nuke.the.USA, alt.usa-sucks, aus.flame.usa

This is totally on-topic and obvious. A truly useless troll.

AVERAGE:

Posting "God Doesn't Exist" to all the alt.religon newsgroups

Here you are being too obvious. People recognise this sort of
trouble making and have usually learned not to respond to it.
However, if your troll is well written you can actually entrap
a lot of newbies. This, if executed correctly, can be exploited
to cause great offence to those more experienced troll avoiders
on the groups you are attacking. Go for it!

GOOD:

Posting an article that appears relevant to every group but with
no connection between those groups other than the fact that you've
just trolled them.


The best trolls go out to an average of around eight or nine newsgroups.
This will stop them from becoming spam as it's not quite enough to be
a real problem. However, to get by on so few groups you have to include
a couple of popular ones in the list.


When posting to say seven groups you should try to break down your theme
into seven areas - each of which will be of specific interest to just
one of those groups. You then write an eight paragraph troll with a
paragraph for each group and a spare one for yourself with which to lob
in a gratuitous insult to everyone who was dumb enough to read your troll.


It is a matter of choice whether you choose newsgroups before or after
writing the troll. Some experts claim that newsgroup selection is the
key to successful trolling and should be done first, others will write
general trolls and then apply the standard Perl script that trollers use
for Automatic Random Newsgroup Selection. (I think this script is avail-
able on the web but I haven't yet got the URL - sorry)


Section 5 Know Your Audience
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Remember that you have two audiences. The people who are going to get
the maximum enjoyment out of your post are other trollers. You need
to keep in contact with them through both your troll itself and the way
you direct its effect. It is trollers that you are trying to entertain
so be creative - trollers don't just want a laugh from you they want to
see good trolls so that they can also learn how to improve their own
in the never ending search for the perfect troll.


The other audience is of course the little people in those newsgroups
that your are attacking. Get to know them. Every newsgroup has its
smartarse who will expose your troll if given half a chance. Research
your targets and learn what their arguemnts are. Then avoid those argu-
ments like the plague. Drag them off-topic - the further off-topic the
better. Remember, you are trying to waste their time. Never take sides -
remember that your goal is not to win an arguement, rather it is to
provoke a futile one that runs forever.


If, for example you were attacking Fast Food then you should also
X-post to Healthy Eating groups, Environmental Protection Groups,
Animal Rights Groups etc....You want to try to ensure that you
have the broadest possible range of opinions as this is the easiest
way to sow confusion. The more confusion the less the likelyhood
of your troll being exposed for what it is.


It can also be shown that the inclusion of just one totally off-topic
newsgroup can have dramatic effects. The list above is taken from a
genuine troll which also included an Artifical Intelligence group, the
result of which was to draw Computer Guru Professor Marvin Minsky into
a flamewar concerning Ronald McDonald's exploitation of the disabled -
an all-time classic piece of trolling - written by a practising veggie.


Section 6 Following-Up
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

"Even if this is true......"

That represents the perfect response to any troll. The mark of a gullible
lunatic that will almost certainly believe anything you tell her (women
always make the best trollees as they have a logical reasoning capacity
of zilch). A total group embarrasment. Award yourself a Troll Gold Star
every time you get one!

Other good responses include, but are not limited to....

"Although this is on-topic....."

"I disagree...."

"Yes, but....."

"Can you provide a source for this...."


Try not to follow-up to your own troll. The troll itself quickly becomes
forgotten in the chaos and if you just sit back you can avoid being blamed
for causing it. Remember, if you do follow up you are talking to an idiot.
Treat them with the ill-respect they deserve.


You should also learn to recognise follow-ups from your fellow trollers.
Sometimes an average troll can be elevated into majestic proportions when
several trollers spontaneously join forces via the medium of the follow
up troll.


Ignore cries of wasted bandwidth! This is pure drivel that will always be
posted by the anti-troll lobby. These jerks fail to understand that trolls
are the best way to drive people off the internet thus making available
multi-mbs for the rest of us to download our porn.


Section 7 The Successful Troll
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

A good example of troll success is the famous "Oh How I Envy American
Students" troll. This troll was written by an English brick-layer posing
as an american student. He correctly posted it to all the college news-
groups and then left american students to do all the work spreading it.


His troll ran for over a year, it is known to have generated in excess of
3,500 responses (an average of 1 response every 160 minutes for a whole
year) and the greatest coup of all was when an innocent american student
lost not only her internet account but was also expelled from high school
for abuse of the computer systems. Somehow she had managed to get the blame
for causing the troll.


Section 8 Troll RFC
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Applications are requested for a standard API to the existing troller's
tool the "Automatic Random X-Post Generator" - now in pre-release beta.

Experienced trollers and recovered trollees are invited to submit items
for inclusion in this FAQ.

Mirror sites are required for the soon to open Troll WWW Site! Please
send in your favourite trolls. (min 500 verifiable follow-ups).

Suggestions are welcome for an appropriate newsgroup to post the winning
troll into after each Troll of the Month title is awarded.

Sean F. Nosal

unread,
Sep 15, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/15/96
to

Bert Jones wrote:
>
> Who put the 'bop' in the 'bop-she-wop-she-wop'? And for that matter,
> who put the 'ram' in the 'ram-a-lam-a-ding-dong'? What's more, who put
> the 'dip' in the 'dip-de-dip-de-dip'?
>
> But most importantly of all, what on earth is happening to music
> nowadays?
>
> Do you remember the old days? The smooth, soothing voice of Mr. Bing
> Crosby, the heart-wrenching intonation of Mr. Frank Sinatra. Or the
> crotch-thrusting rock and roll of Mr. Cliff Richard?
>
> Now who have they been replaced by? A bunch of jumped-up teenagers who
> wouldn't know one end of a pianoforte from the other, and who have had
> the musical training of a dog. A cocker spaniel, probably.
>
> Whatever happened to those family favourites who were guaranteed to
> brighten your day and make you smile. Like Vera Lynn, The Andrews
> Sisters, Shirley Bassey, Dionne Warwick and Leonard Cohen?
>
> They've been replaced by Ocean, Blur, Oasis Colour Shaker, Kula Scene
> and Elastica (a more highly charged sexual innuendo I could not think
> of).
>
> What on earth our we doing to the minds of our children?
>
> Take, for example, the words to a disgusting song that I heard on the
> so-called 'popular' music station. BBC Radio One, by the combo
> ‘Erasure (and I quote):
>
> "Don't go changing your emotions. Lay all your love on me.
> Don't go sparing your devotion. Lay all your love on me."
>
> Is this what we want our children to grow up with? Sex and violence. I
> can tell you, you would not be hearing this sort of smut from my
> personal favourites, those long-lost Danish popsters, Abba.
>
> As I see it, we've got a real problem in this country, and unless we
> want to end up like our lesser relations 'across the pond', as they
> say, where children from the age of three upwards rapidly turn into
> gun-toting mobsters, then we must rid Britain of this noise!
>
> I suggest this:
>
> 1) Let's put Vince Hill on the National Curriculum.
>
> 2) Make it compulsory to own at least one Harry Secombe album.
>
> 3) Ban any so-called musician who doesn't have a degree in Music.
>
> 4) And ban that awful Nigel Kennedy as well, and bring back Sir Yehudi
> Menuhin.
>
> 5) And let's get the Goons back on Radio 4 too.
>
> Britain can be Great again. But forget the three R's, what about the
> three M's: Mozart, Mendelsohn and McCartney (though, of course,
> nothing before 1970 and nothing after 1980).
>
> And then maybe our kids will be normal again.
>
> Bert Jones
>
> ------------------------------------------------------------------
> The senior citizens Internet centre
> Alzheimer’s sufferers welcome
> http://www.senile.co.uk/dribble
> ------------------------------------------------------------------
WELL THIS TOPIC IS NOT OF THIS GROUP................
But if you dont like what you hear on the radio today,JUST TURN IF OFF,
Buy some sinatra,Bing,and Bassey CDs and kick back and enjoy.
I dont like what I hear on the air waves today either...
....SO that is why i have a large collection of CDs
Pink floyd,Rush,Led Zepplin,..(3 of the best bands ever,IMHO....
OH...and Zimmer.TLK.....ROTPL....TPOO{the power of one}.
Everone should have Zimmer in there collection........
Well thats just my 3 cents....
going to get off my soapbox now...
MEETOO9

Mark Simcox

unread,
Sep 15, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/15/96
to

In article <323c0c89...@news.u-net.com>, Bert Jones
<sei...@senile.co.uk> writes
>Who put the 'bop'

This has got to be a wind up. Right ? :)

--
Mark.

Banks`s .... Bells .... Balti .... Bed .... (Bostin`)

Dave The Rave

unread,
Sep 15, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/15/96
to

In article <323c0c89...@news.u-net.com>
feed...@netvision.co.uk "Bert Jones" writes:

~ Whatever happened to those family favourites who were guaranteed to
~ brighten your day and make you smile. Like Vera Lynn, The Andrews
~ Sisters, Shirley Bassey, Dionne Warwick and Leonard Cohen?

Leonard Cohen was on Jools Holland a year or so ago; he was so boring
I changed channel to watch the adverts instead...

--
Dave The Rave

Sam

unread,
Sep 16, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/16/96
to

Yes, that's the funniest thing I've read in my life. Well done. Keep
it up, and post more and more and more.


------------------------------------------------------------------------
"Where am I" - Charlie Chuck. s...@beavis.u-net.com
http://www.u-net.com/~beavis/renstimp.htm


The Nit Nurse

unread,
Sep 16, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/16/96
to

Music is boring. I hate it. Just a lot of jangly noises - I just don't see
what the attraction is.

The Nit Nurse

unread,
Sep 16, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/16/96
to

In article <323d609...@news.hal-pc.org>, ma...@hal-pc.org (madee) wrote:

|> <><><><<> Flame #1.
|> The problem is you don't understand the basics. You hear, not see
|> music.

Problem is, you can't read plain English. Does music make one illiterate
too, as well as deaf? Maybe you should take your own advice regarding
understanding 'basics'.

|> Flame #2. A person who finds music boring probably doesn't offer much
|> her/himself.

So you're another sheep who follows the flock regarding what is and isn't
appealing? Thought so..

Fortunately I consider there to be far more to life than wandering about
with things stuck in my ear listening to a blaring cocophany - irrespective
of who's making the din. If this is your idea of 'interesting' you are a
very sad fellow indeed. I suggest you get out more.

madee

unread,
Sep 16, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/16/96
to

d...@kerrera.gla.dcs.ac.uk (The Nit Nurse) wrote:

<>In article <842813...@misc.org.uk>, da...@misc.org.uk wrote:
<>
<>|> In article <323c0c89...@news.u-net.com>
<>|> feed...@netvision.co.uk "Bert Jones" writes:
<>|>
..
<>
<>Music is boring. I hate it. Just a lot of jangly noises - I just
don't see
<>what the attraction is.
<><><><<> Flame #1.
The problem is you don't understand the basics. You hear, not see
music.

Flame #2. A person who finds music boring probably doesn't offer much
her/himself.

Tom Fisher

unread,
Sep 16, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/16/96
to

To those of you who have cable TV access, consider this:
I like "easy listening" music (my kids call it "doctor's office music")
and it's kind of difficult to find many stations that are into this in my
area. However, I discovered something by accident. Hook your receiver
antenna input to your TV cable (this might take a special thingy - get one
at any Radio Shack) and then do an auto-scan to see what stations your
receiver will pick up off the cable - you might be surprised.

Tom Fisher

Sean Clayton

unread,
Sep 16, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/16/96
to

da...@misc.org.uk (Dave The Rave) wrote:
>In article <323c0c89...@news.u-net.com>
> feed...@netvision.co.uk "Bert Jones" writes:
>
>~ Whatever happened to those family favourites who were guaranteed to
>~ brighten your day and make you smile. Like Vera Lynn, The Andrews
>~ Sisters, Shirley Bassey, Dionne Warwick and Leonard Cohen?

Try Shara Nelson, Nicolette and Portishead - it's what Aretha, Dionne
and friends would be doing if they were twentysomething and British. The
above artists also happen to be quite brilliant (although I'm still
waiting for the Suzanne Vega trip-hop album to come out),

SC 'Coming soon - uk.music.badger; the ng of the future!'

Realname

unread,
Sep 16, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/16/96
to


> Music is boring. I hate it. Just a lot of jangly noises - I just don't see
> what the attraction is.


You seem like the type of sad and lonely person who
would write to a vegetarian newsgroup to tell them how much your
enjoying your burger.

Anne.

Ron Kelley

unread,
Sep 16, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/16/96
to

d...@kerrera.gla.dcs.ac.uk (The Nit Nurse) wrote:

>So you're another sheep who follows the flock regarding what is and isn't
>appealing? Thought so..

>Fortunately I consider there to be far more to life than wandering about
>with things stuck in my ear listening to a blaring cocophany - irrespective
>of who's making the din. If this is your idea of 'interesting' you are a
>very sad fellow indeed. I suggest you get out more.

God, I love the British. They sure know how to turn a phrase.

Ron Kelley

Iain L M Hotchkies

unread,
Sep 16, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/16/96
to

In message <323d609...@news.hal-pc.org> madee wrote:

> d...@kerrera.gla.dcs.ac.uk (The Nit Nurse) wrote:
>

> <>In article <842813...@misc.org.uk>, da...@misc.org.uk wrote:
> <>
> <>|> In article <323c0c89...@news.u-net.com>
> <>|> feed...@netvision.co.uk "Bert Jones" writes:
> <>|>

> ..


> <>
> <>Music is boring. I hate it. Just a lot of jangly noises - I just
> don't see
> <>what the attraction is.

> <><><><<> Flame #1.
> The problem is you don't understand the basics. You hear, not see
> music.
>
> Flame #2. A person who finds music boring probably doesn't offer much
> her/himself.

Eee, by 'eck, this is grand. What the f*ck is this doing in
a Lion King ng? Nevermind.

I thought that the music in the LK was soooper. Especially
that Elvis Costello Tune.

Anyway, who says you can't *see* music. Never been to a
Motorhead gig? Just watch them bass bins shakin' and
shimmerin' in the light of the setting sun. Another
good album by the Jam, even if I say so myself.

Chris

unread,
Sep 17, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/17/96
to

d...@kerrera.gla.dcs.ac.uk (The Nit Nurse) wrote:
>Music is boring. I hate it. Just a lot of jangly noises - I just don't see
>what the attraction is.

I hate music as well - that's why I only buy Ocean Colour Scene stuff.
--
Chris

The Nit Nurse

unread,
Sep 17, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/17/96
to

In article <51khjc$k...@nuacht.iol.ie>, Realname <ro...@iol.ie> wrote:

|>
|> > Music is boring. I hate it. Just a lot of jangly noises - I just don't see
|> > what the attraction is.
|>
|>
|>

|> You seem like the type of sad and lonely person who
|> would write to a vegetarian newsgroup to tell them how much your
|> enjoying your burger.

I don't like burgers either. What's the difference between not liking a burger
and not liking music? Answer: None.

Or do you believe that music has some mystical quality that makes it
irrisistable to the human species - like some drug - and anyone who
doesn't
like it must be strange and lonely? Are you just another sheep dutifully
towing the (music industry) line, bedazzled by the glamour and hype?

Robert Mobbs

unread,
Sep 17, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/17/96
to

Sean Clayton (clay...@tcd.ie) wrote:

: da...@misc.org.uk (Dave The Rave) wrote:
: >In article <323c0c89...@news.u-net.com>
: > feed...@netvision.co.uk "Bert Jones" writes:
: >
: >~ Whatever happened to those family favourites who were guaranteed to

: >~ brighten your day and make you smile. Like Vera Lynn, The Andrews
: >~ Sisters, Shirley Bassey, Dionne Warwick and Leonard Cohen?

: Try Shara Nelson, Nicolette and Portishead - it's what Aretha, Dionne
: and friends would be doing if they were twentysomething and British. The
: above artists also happen to be quite brilliant (although I'm still
: waiting for the Suzanne Vega trip-hop album to come out),

Well, by your Internet site I can see you're far away
(Ireland, right?) but Suzanne Vega will be playing here in Seattle
on Wednesday, September 18 at Borders Books and Music, on 4th
near Pike (right near Westlake center). It will be a free show.
If anyone near here wants to see her, please join the crowd.

Robert L. Mobbs
Microsoft MSTE Software Engineer
t-rm...@microsoft.com
-
"Everyone wants to live at the expense of
the state. They forget that the state
lives at the expense of everyone."
Frederic Bastiat

Robert Mobbs

unread,
Sep 17, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/17/96
to

Ron Kelley (ronk...@earthlink.net) wrote:
: d...@kerrera.gla.dcs.ac.uk (The Nit Nurse) wrote:

: >So you're another sheep who follows the flock regarding what is and isn't
: >appealing? Thought so..

: >Fortunately I consider there to be far more to life than wandering about
: >with things stuck in my ear listening to a blaring cocophany - irrespective
: >of who's making the din. If this is your idea of 'interesting' you are a
: >very sad fellow indeed. I suggest you get out more.

: God, I love the British. They sure know how to turn a phrase.

Yes, but they cannot spell. I mean, "cocophony"? Plus,
we have more bombs.

Robert "We saved yer ass in WWII!" Mobbs

Iain Rowan

unread,
Sep 17, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/17/96
to

In article <dam-170996...@130.209.240.43>, d...@kerrera.gla.dcs.ac.uk
says..

>Or do you believe that music has some mystical quality that makes it
>irrisistable to the human species - like some drug - and anyone who
>doesn't
>like it must be strange and lonely?

The importance of music to all human cultures in all periods of history would
seem to indicate that it is more than a passing whim of fashion.

Iain
--
Iain Rowan iain....@sunderland.ac.uk

All half-baked opinions, wild assertions and misguided
attempts at humour are down to me, not my employer.


Ian Griffiths

unread,
Sep 17, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/17/96
to

The Nit Nurse wrote:

>
> ma...@hal-pc.org (madee) wrote:
>
> |> d...@kerrera.gla.dcs.ac.uk (The Nit Nurse) wrote:
> |>
> |> >Music is boring. I hate it. Just a lot of jangly noises -
> |> >I just don't see what the attraction is.
> |>
> |> The problem is you don't understand the basics. You hear,
> |> not see
> |> music.
> |>
> |> Flame #2. A person who finds music boring probably doesn't
> |> offer much her/himself.
>
> So you're another sheep who follows the flock regarding what
> is and isn't appealing? Thought so..
>
> Fortunately I consider there to be far more to life than
> wandering about with things stuck in my ear listening to a
> blaring cocophany - irrespective of who's making the din.

Do you genuinely think that ALL must is either "blaring
cocphany" or "a lot of jangly noises", or are you having a go at
a particular genre?

It seems pretty indisputable to me that the average baroque
string quartet is neither of these. Of course you may consider
this to be a grating dirge instead... I would suggest though
that as they stand your definitions fail to cover the complete
spectrum.

I get the impression that you are in general of the opinion that
music is just so many noises which serve no useful purpose and
are not rewarding to listen to. Is that about right?


If you do feel that way about it, don't you think it's a little
arrogant to dismiss anyone who does find music entertaining or
moving or in any sense worthwhile? I for one completely fail to
appreciate poetry of any kind, but I don't go on to draw the
conclusion that poetry is nothing more than prose which doesn't
reach the end of the line for no apparent reason. I'm just
pretty sure that I'm missing something.


> If this is your idea of 'interesting' you are a very sad
> fellow indeed. I suggest you get out more.

Or is this just a troll?


--
Ian Griffiths

Sean Clayton

unread,
Sep 17, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/17/96
to

Ian Griffiths <igri...@dev.madge.com> wrote:


( loads of musical arguments - snip)

>Or is this just a troll?

Definitely - admittedly, one that I fell for yesterday.

How would we judge this troll in a compy though - Tardfarm Bert started
it but NitNurse attracted nearly all the flames and reactions. Are we
going to have touchdowns and assists like US football or will it be
starters keepers?

Come to think of it, how will we judge this at all? By popular vote or
should we appoint Iain LMH and Illtud to adjudicate??

SC -'Coming soon - uk.music.badger; the ng of the future!'


Iain Rowan

unread,
Sep 17, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/17/96
to

In article <dam-170996...@130.209.240.43>,
d...@kerrera.gla.dcs.ac.uk says...
>
>In article <51m1od$6...@orac.sunderland.ac.uk>,

>iain....@nojunk.e-mail.ta.very.much (Iain Rowan) wrote:
>
>|> In article <dam-170996...@130.209.240.43>,
d...@kerrera.gla.dcs.ac.uk
>|> says..
>|>
>|> >Or do you believe that music has some mystical quality that makes it
>|> >irrisistable to the human species - like some drug - and anyone who
>|> >doesn't
>|> >like it must be strange and lonely?
>|>
>|> The importance of music to all human cultures in all periods of history
>would
>|> seem to indicate that it is more than a passing whim of fashion.
>
>Which would explain why the 'music' of other cultures are unappealing to
>one's own culture? I would say that 'fashion' is indeed the main driving
>force behind 'music'. Or maybe you have another explanation as to why
>Aboriginal digeridoo music hasn't quite caught on here?

I wasn't saying that any particular style or type of music was not subject to
arbitrary fashion. I was saying that the human affinity for and delight in
music is a constant which seems to have been present throughout history
and in every culture, and was often was of the most important or defining
aspects of that particular culture.

And as for the music of other cultures being unappealing, this doesn't
really square with the way musical styles propagate. African tribal music
moving with slaves to the Americas, evolving into field and work songs,
evolving into rhythm and blues and jazz, evolving into most styles of
popular music which are now drawing on a variety of other musical
influences from around the world including the recent rather sad
preoccupation amongst some dance and crusty bands for
using...didgeridoos.

Guy Barry

unread,
Sep 17, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/17/96
to

Mark Simcox wrote:
>
> In article <323c0c89...@news.u-net.com>, Bert Jones
> <sei...@senile.co.uk> writes
> >Who put the 'bop'
>
> This has got to be a wind up. Right ? :)

Well, you could probably play it on one...

Guy Barry

The Nit Nurse

unread,
Sep 17, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/17/96
to

In article <51m8t8$n...@web3.tcd.ie>, Sean Clayton <clay...@tcd.ie> wrote:

|> d...@kerrera.gla.dcs.ac.uk (The Nit Nurse) wrote:
|>

|> >Illtud's off to the Med on hols
|>
|> Are you sure -I thought he was one the proverbial reality adjustment
|> trip in his shed.

Crete (or Cyprus?) I think.

|> and Iain is up to his neck in other
|> >people's bottoms - apparently.
|>
|> Funny what summer jobs people get up to - if they haven't got resits...

Iain's a GP, not a spotty student.

The Nit Nurse

unread,
Sep 17, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/17/96
to

In article <323E92...@dev.madge.com>, Ian Griffiths
<igri...@dev.madge.com> wrote:

|> The Nit Nurse wrote:


|> >
|> > ma...@hal-pc.org (madee) wrote:
|> >
|> > |> d...@kerrera.gla.dcs.ac.uk (The Nit Nurse) wrote:
|> > |>

|> > |> >Music is boring. I hate it. Just a lot of jangly noises -
|> > |> >I just don't see what the attraction is.
|> > |>
|> >

|> > Fortunately I consider there to be far more to life than
|> > wandering about with things stuck in my ear listening to a
|> > blaring cocophany - irrespective of who's making the din.
|>
|> Do you genuinely think that ALL must is either "blaring
|> cocphany" or "a lot of jangly noises", or are you having a go at
|> a particular genre?

What makes you think that all people must dutifully like a din made by
scraping strings, bashing bits of animal skins, blowing through metal
tubes or whatever contraption is used to make a racket?
Is there some 'rule' that says all people _must_ like some form of music?

Does no one think for themselves any more and spend their life ploughing
through 'noise' after 'noise' in the belief that there must be *something*
that they 'like'? Perhaps these same people find it amazing that some people
are not only unimpressed by F1GP driving but find the entire genre of
competative motorsport incredibly boring?
Perhaps these people should drag themselves away from unrelenting MTV/Classic
FM/whatever and get out more?

The phrase 'brainwashed sheep' springs to mind.

The Nit Nurse

unread,
Sep 17, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/17/96
to

madee

unread,
Sep 17, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/17/96
to

d...@kerrera.gla.dcs.ac.uk (The Nit Nurse) wrote:

<>In article <323d609...@news.hal-pc.org>, ma...@hal-pc.org


(madee) wrote:
<>
<>|> d...@kerrera.gla.dcs.ac.uk (The Nit Nurse) wrote:
<>|>

<>|> <>In article <842813...@misc.org.uk>, da...@misc.org.uk wrote:
<>|> <>
<>|> <>|> In article <323c0c89...@news.u-net.com>
<>|> <>|> feed...@netvision.co.uk "Bert Jones" writes:
<>|> <>|>

<>|> ..


<>|> <>
<>|> <>Music is boring. I hate it. Just a lot of jangly noises - I
just
<>|> don't see
<>|> <>what the attraction is.

<>|> <><><><<> Flame #1.


<>|> The problem is you don't understand the basics. You hear, not
see
<>|> music.
<>

<>Problem is, you can't read plain English. Does music make one
illiterate
<>too, as well as deaf? Maybe you should take your own advice
regarding
<>understanding 'basics'.
<>

<>|> Flame #2. A person who finds music boring probably doesn't offer
much
<>|> her/himself.
<>
<>So you're another sheep who follows the flock regarding what is and
isn't
<>appealing? Thought so..
<>

<>Fortunately I consider there to be far more to life than wandering
about
<>with things stuck in my ear listening to a blaring cocophany -
irrespective

<>of who's making the din. If this is your idea of 'interesting' you


are a
<>very sad fellow indeed. I suggest you get out more.

<><><< Things in their ears? Wandering about? Need to get out more?
Sheep following the flock? Illiterate because I like music?
Friend, you are one mixed up person/nurse/lady?

Michael Kilpatrick

unread,
Sep 17, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/17/96
to

Ian Griffiths <igri...@dev.madge.com> writes:

>The Nit Nurse wrote:
>>
>> ma...@hal-pc.org (madee) wrote:
>>
>> |> d...@kerrera.gla.dcs.ac.uk (The Nit Nurse) wrote:
>> |>
>> |> >Music is boring. I hate it. Just a lot of jangly noises -
>> |> >I just don't see what the attraction is.
>> |>

>> |> The problem is you don't understand the basics. You hear,
>> |> not see
>> |> music.
>> |>
>>

>> Fortunately I consider there to be far more to life than
>> wandering about with things stuck in my ear listening to a
>> blaring cocophany - irrespective of who's making the din.

Music is to be _listened_ to, it's not just a background noise
to fill an empty space. The Walkman has a lot to answer for!


>Do you genuinely think that ALL must is either "blaring
>cocphany" or "a lot of jangly noises", or are you having a go at
>a particular genre?

>It seems pretty indisputable to me that the average baroque

>string quartet is neither of these.

Only if you understand it. It has been suggested that the understanding
of musical form has many links to the linguistic centres of the brain.
It seems perfectly logical (although, from my point of view, rather
hard to get to grips with) to suggest that some people will not like
baroque string quartets. I love baroque music myself but this is not an
indisputable truth for the entire human species.

I'm quite sure the appreciation of music depends significantly on the
exposure to music at an early age and the child's inclination to
assimilate what they hear. Any disinclination (which will be founded
more by chance circumstance, other distractions etc, and not by any
inate levels or lack of intelligence) may well lead to a general
dislike of quite a broad spectrum of musical styles later in life.

I may even accept that some people think ALL music is a blaring
cacophony. If they have never learnt to assimilate an understanding of
musical form (with its many mathematical as well as aesthetic
qualities) then this may well be true. Personally I think it is sad to
miss out, but I certainly don't believe that it follows that David is a
"sad" or "stupid" individual because of it - far from it.


I'm lucky in that I had a very musical upbringing, playing piano and
trumpet, and now playing the baritone saxophone. In my view I believe
that I grew rapidly out of any inclination to listen to pop music of
any form because of its shallow and vacuous musical content - having a
better understanding of music I can't stand listening to such drivel,
it's so annoying. I can't listen to "free improvisation" and other such
formless forms of jazz and other music, precisely because they have no
identifiable form, melody, direction, progression, cadence or
otherwise. Music is a form of language, and quite a complex one at
times. It has some mathematical necessities, just as language needs
some form of grammar, and has a melody just has language has
sentences. Some people seem to have an odd understanding of grammar,
and in my opinion these are the people who listen to pop music and
think that it's nice to have Bob Hoskins advertising BT in that
appalling, nauseating Cockney accent. Others will disagree with me. My
musical tastes are quite limited - I listen to little else apart from
my vast collection of Duke Ellinton and a bit of Bach. Most teenagers
now wouldn't understand Duke Ellington, because they have no
understanding of music other than the need for a constant "thud thud
thud" - they are linguistically stinted. But on the other hand my
French and Spanish are rather appalling....


>If you do feel that way about it, don't you think it's a little
>arrogant to dismiss anyone who does find music entertaining or
>moving or in any sense worthwhile?

I have to agree with that. But I don't think David was lambasting music
lovers - I thought he was just stating his own incomprehension of it. I
don't think he's arrogant.


I for one completely fail to
>appreciate poetry of any kind,

That's a great shame.

Michael

The Nit Nurse

unread,
Sep 17, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/17/96
to

In article <51m6t3$h...@orac.sunderland.ac.uk>,
iain....@nojunk.e-mail.ta.very.much (Iain Rowan) wrote:

|> In article <dam-170996...@130.209.240.43>,
|> d...@kerrera.gla.dcs.ac.uk says...

|> >Which would explain why the 'music' of other cultures are unappealing to
|> >one's own culture? I would say that 'fashion' is indeed the main driving
|> >force behind 'music'. Or maybe you have another explanation as to why
|> >Aboriginal digeridoo music hasn't quite caught on here?
|>

|> I wasn't saying that any particular style or type of music was not
subject to
|> arbitrary fashion. I was saying that the human affinity for and delight in
|> music is a constant which seems to have been present throughout history
|> and in every culture, and was often was of the most important or defining
|> aspects of that particular culture.

Yes, but now you are confusing what was essentially a method of story
telling and moralising from an age before print and literacy with what
it has mutated into, a huge industry grinding out wall to wall trash for
no other purpose than to grab some money. Do you think Beethoven thought
he was adding something to culture or was he trying to turn a fast buck by
giving the people what they wanted, viz the grandiose 1812 - guaranteed
best seller on the back of bellicose jingoism?

|> And as for the music of other cultures being unappealing, this doesn't
|> really square with the way musical styles propagate.

Methinks you are confusing the raw native music with the sanitised, refined
and westernised pap that the world of commercial music turn it into and
re-export in a manner not too dissimilar to that adopted by McDonalds -
blues being the obvious example that you cite below. Microtonal music
doesn't exactly appeal to the western ear dulled by centuries of droning
chromatic 13 note scales. Indeed, microtonal music would be dismissed as
'noise' by many western 'music lovers' just as bagpipe music is similarly
dismissed as unappealing. Is there any reason to assume that westernised
music is just as much a din to the ear attuned to microtonal?

|> African tribal music
|> moving with slaves to the Americas, evolving into field and work songs,
|> evolving into rhythm and blues and jazz, evolving into most styles of
|> popular music which are now drawing on a variety of other musical
|> influences from around the world including the recent rather sad
|> preoccupation amongst some dance and crusty bands for
|> using...didgeridoos.

Can't say I've seen it, did hear one pitiful attempt to incorporate bagpipes
- an essentially middle eastern instrument with a scale to match - into
western scale based music. It created a dreadful din called Mull of Kintyre.
I believe it was one of those Beetle chaps who did it, but it was just more
noise on the radio dial and I didn't take note.

Michael Kilpatrick

unread,
Sep 17, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/17/96
to

d...@kerrera.gla.dcs.ac.uk (The Nit Nurse) writes:

>In article <51m1od$6...@orac.sunderland.ac.uk>,
>iain....@nojunk.e-mail.ta.very.much (Iain Rowan) wrote:

>|> says..
>|>
>|> >Or do you believe that music has some mystical quality that makes it
>|> >irrisistable to the human species - like some drug - and anyone who
>|> >doesn't
>|> >like it must be strange and lonely?
>|>
>|> The importance of music to all human cultures in all periods of history
>would
>|> seem to indicate that it is more than a passing whim of fashion.

>Which would explain why the 'music' of other cultures are unappealing to
>one's own culture?

Other musical forms are appealing to many people who are able to
understand the different "grammatical rules" of other cultures' music.
For example, many traditional Eastern forms have scales with notes that
are at different intervals to the Western tempered scales. The melodies
therefore sound out of tune until one is able to come to terms with the
new intervals. People with a less musical ear aren't going to stay the
course, but for those who do, the end result is some understanding of
the new music. I don't understand Hindi not because I'm fashionable, but
because my custom is not to do so. Don't confuse the divergence of
languages with the passing of "trends".

>I would say that 'fashion' is indeed the main driving
>force behind 'music'.

Fashion is the main driving force behind pop music. The real course of
"music" as a whole, however, is driven by far from things than that.

Or maybe you have another explanation as to why
>Aboriginal digeridoo music hasn't quite caught on here?

Are saying that didjs haven't caught on because they're not
"fashionable". Is it too unhip to be seen with a didj? The term
"fashion" seems to have little to do with the use of the didj.


The Didjeridoo is a primitive wind instrument that was superseded
centuries ago by wind instruments with holes or variable length tubes
therefore capable of playing scales. The didjeridoo is capable only
playing harmonics and overtones, with the additional effects introduced
in the player's embouchure. It is a whole different technique, not
merely a fashion. Aboriginies quite simply didn't discover the trumpet
or the piano. Meanwhile, Western music is trying incorporate ideas
such as onvertones and microtones, not out of a desire to be
fashionable or hip on the world scene, but out of a desire to
experiment with new things and to extend the limits imposed by the
rigid mathematics of scales and classical harmonies. I can't equate
any of this with "fashion" as I see it.


Michael

Tony Howat

unread,
Sep 17, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/17/96
to

In message <51meoj$4...@sis.armltd.co.uk> Michael Kilpatrick wrote:

> Ian Griffiths <igri...@dev.madge.com> writes:

[snip]

Oh dear. Can't you spot a troll when you read one?

--
Tony Howat
20-20 Software Dover Associates
http://www.xargle.demon.co.uk/2020/ http://www.xargle.demon.co.uk/dover/
*New Product* WebMerge HTML tool Computer hardware at competitive prices

John

unread,
Sep 17, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/17/96
to

In article <323E92...@dev.madge.com>
igri...@dev.madge.com "Ian Griffiths" writes:

> Or is this just a troll?

...just a thought. If the Nit Nurse hates all forms of music *soo*
violently... why's he/she/it reading uk.music.alternative?

JT

--
All your dreams will come true. All my dreams came true.
Now I have a bunch of other dreams.
Sonic Youth

The Nit Nurse

unread,
Sep 17, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/17/96
to

In article <51m5ik$n...@web3.tcd.ie>, Sean Clayton <clay...@tcd.ie> wrote:

|> Come to think of it, how will we judge this at all? By popular vote or
|> should we appoint Iain LMH and Illtud to adjudicate??

Illtud's off to the Med on hols and Iain is up to his neck in other

Sean Clayton

unread,
Sep 17, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/17/96
to

d...@kerrera.gla.dcs.ac.uk (The Nit Nurse) wrote:

>Illtud's off to the Med on hols

Are you sure -I thought he was one the proverbial reality adjustment
trip in his shed.

and Iain is up to his neck in other


>people's bottoms - apparently.

Funny what summer jobs people get up to - if they haven't got resits...


SC 'Coming soon - uk.music.badger; the ng of the future!'

Simon Gray

unread,
Sep 17, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/17/96
to

In article <51khjc$k...@nuacht.iol.ie> ro...@iol.ie "Realname" writes:

~ > Music is boring. I hate it. Just a lot of jangly noises - I just don't see
~ > what the attraction is.
~
~ You seem like the type of sad and lonely person who
~ would write to a vegetarian newsgroup to tell them how much your
~ enjoying your burger.

Tee Hee - this troll contest is going to be fun.

Is Iain keeping score ?

--
[]=- Simon Gray, in Birmingham, EU <*>
// _-=__-= Don't give in to censorship - boycott The Observer
_/|] ) ___ \ & The Guardian.
(_) \___/_(___)_| http://www.mahayana.demon.co.uk/
@ @

Simon Gray

unread,
Sep 17, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/17/96
to

In article <51m8t8$n...@web3.tcd.ie> clay...@tcd.ie "Sean Clayton" writes:

~ >Illtud's off to the Med on hols
~
~ Are you sure -I thought he was one the proverbial reality adjustment
~ trip in his shed.

No, that was going to be me, but I decided against it after a combination
of advice from Julian Barkway that it wasn't all it was cracked up to
be & the announcement of this competition !

Iain L M Hotchkies

unread,
Sep 17, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/17/96
to

In message <dam-170996...@130.209.240.43> The Nit Nurse wrote:

> In article <51m8t8$n...@web3.tcd.ie>, Sean Clayton <clay...@tcd.ie> wrote:
>
> |> d...@kerrera.gla.dcs.ac.uk (The Nit Nurse) wrote:
> |>

> |> >Illtud's off to the Med on hols
> |>

> |> Are you sure -I thought he was one the proverbial reality adjustment

> |> trip in his shed.
>
> Crete (or Cyprus?) I think.

Cyprus or Shhhheeeepre (as they say on Eurovision)



> |> and Iain is up to his neck in other
> |> >people's bottoms - apparently.
> |>
> |> Funny what summer jobs people get up to - if they haven't got resits...
>

> Iain's a GP, not a spotty student.

Look, would you guys please stop talking about me behind my
back? I *used* to be a spotty student and now I am a spotty
GP (General Pillock) - see my effing webpages.

(www.hotch.demon.co.uk)

Anyway, I don't want to adjudicate. I want to take part!

I thought the rules would be quite simple.

(I gave this some thought while sitting on the toilet
this morning - then gave it some further thought
while exploring the inner recesses of someone's
sigmoid colon)

1) post your troll
2) up to 6 ngs incl um
3) a weighting can be added for less ngs
4) let it run for 7-14 days (or whatever, we can decide
this nearer the time)
5) if you follow-up your own troll, you're disqualified
6) if you muck up someone else's troll (eg. "Don't bother
replying to Nit's post because it's a troll!") then
you're disqualified and the person whose troll you
sabotaged gets your points
7) at the end of the time period, you get a point for
each follow-up your troll generated, plus any weighting
points, plus the points of any other competitors who
tried to foul up your troll.
8) I think we should crawl on our bellies to Steve Firth
and ask him to adjudicate. I know he's not keen on this
but he does appear to know something about Usenet and
he can spot a forged header at a hundred paces, which
would be useful if, say, Illtud tries to make it look
as though I have attempted to sabotage C*mmings's
troll.
9) That's enough rules - this is Usenet for f's sake.

How about it Steve?

Dom

unread,
Sep 17, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/17/96
to

>|> and Iain is up to his neck in other
>|> >people's bottoms - apparently.
>|>
>|> Funny what summer jobs people get up to - if they haven't got resits...

>Iain's a GP, not a spotty student.

And you're a nit nurse, according to your header.


--
Dom +++ Looks like someone finally *did* give a +++
+++ million monkeys a million typewriters. +++

W. ROLLINS

unread,
Sep 17, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/17/96
to

madee (ma...@hal-pc.org) wrote:
: The problem is you don't understand the basics. You hear, not see
: music.

: Flame #2. A person who finds music boring probably doesn't offer much
: her/himself.

Or you have a partial hearing loss so its just more noise much like this
thread which is massively crossposted.

BiNM

The Nit Nurse

unread,
Sep 18, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/18/96
to

|> >|> and Iain is up to his neck in other
|> >|> >people's bottoms - apparently.
|> >|>
|> >|> Funny what summer jobs people get up to - if they haven't got resits...
|>
|> >Iain's a GP, not a spotty student.
|>
|> And you're a nit nurse, according to your header.

Indeed. And...?

Iain Rowan

unread,
Sep 18, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/18/96
to
says...
>
>In article <51m6t3$h...@orac.sunderland.ac.uk>,

>iain....@nojunk.e-mail.ta.very.much (Iain Rowan) wrote:
>
>|> In article <dam-170996...@130.209.240.43>,
>|> d...@kerrera.gla.dcs.ac.uk says...

>
>|> >Which would explain why the 'music' of other cultures are unappealing to
>|> >one's own culture? I would say that 'fashion' is indeed the main driving
>|> >force behind 'music'. Or maybe you have another explanation as to why

>|> >Aboriginal digeridoo music hasn't quite caught on here?
>|>
>|> I wasn't saying that any particular style or type of music was not
>subject to
>|> arbitrary fashion. I was saying that the human affinity for and delight in
>|> music is a constant which seems to have been present throughout history
>|> and in every culture, and was often was of the most important or defining
>|> aspects of that particular culture.
>
>Yes, but now you are confusing what was essentially a method of story
>telling and moralising from an age before print and literacy with what
>it has mutated into, a huge industry grinding out wall to wall trash for
>no other purpose than to grab some money. Do you think Beethoven thought
>he was adding something to culture or was he trying to turn a fast buck by
>giving the people what they wanted, viz the grandiose 1812 - guaranteed
>best seller on the back of bellicose jingoism?

There are many thousands of people with little discernable talent and absolutely no
chance of making any money who play instruments, play in bands or ensembles,
and write songs just because they enjoy it. Do you think that Schoenberg wrote
his style of music because he thought it would sell millions? If your view was the
case all modern classical composers would be churning out endless retreads of
Vivaldi. Just because some practitioners use their talent to make a fast buck doesn't
invalidate the entire musical canon. By your argument all art is worthless, as
anyone can pull out examples of painter X or playwright Y turning a fast buck. I
doubt Shakespeare thought that he was adding anything to culture; he was
probably thinking how pleased he was that this new play Hamlet would pay for his
new extension.

>Methinks you are confusing the raw native music with the sanitised, refined
>and westernised pap that the world of commercial music turn it into and
>re-export in a manner not too dissimilar to that adopted by McDonalds -
>blues being the obvious example that you cite below. Microtonal music
>doesn't exactly appeal to the western ear dulled by centuries of droning
>chromatic 13 note scales. Indeed, microtonal music would be dismissed as
>'noise' by many western 'music lovers' just as bagpipe music is similarly
>dismissed as unappealing. Is there any reason to assume that westernised
>music is just as much a din to the ear attuned to microtonal?

So is only 'pure' native music, uninfluenced by any external influences acceptable to
you? I doubt you'd find many musical cultures where there hasn't been at least
some cross-pollination. The danger with 'world' music or 'ethnic' music is that
because it sounds different to us we automatically bestow it with positive qualities,
not knowing that to most Javanese the latest gamelan album to hit the West is an
equivalent of The Spice Girls. We often mistake difference for originality or virtue.

I still think that it is immaterial what tonal qualities the music has that somebody
likes; the fact is that an appreciation of, and a liking for music (whatever its tonality)
is a near universal (the exception of course, being you...)

>Can't say I've seen it, did hear one pitiful attempt to incorporate bagpipes
>- an essentially middle eastern instrument with a scale to match - into
>western scale based music. It created a dreadful din called Mull of Kintyre.
>I believe it was one of those Beetle chaps who did it, but it was just more
>noise on the radio dial and I didn't take note.

You of all people, judging by the other threads in uk.misc should have listened, as
it was in fact the best argument for the legalisation of the carrying of concealed
weapons in the UK ever.

Dave Budd

unread,
Sep 18, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/18/96
to

Steely Dan have just finished the British leg of their tour, so you've
missed the real music.

Interesting list of newsgroups! I've trimmed it a bit.....left soc.
retirement in as Dan fans are getting a bit long in the tooth.....

--
The campaign to save the World Service: http://www.longitude0.co.uk/save-ws
Me: Dave Budd +44 161 275 6033 fax 6040 D.B...@mcc.ac.uk
My web page: http://www.man.ac.uk/~zlsiida (officially open! not very good)
JUNK EMAIL: Storage costs money. I charge for spool space: rates on web page


The Nit Nurse

unread,
Sep 18, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/18/96
to

|> In article <323E92...@dev.madge.com>
|> igri...@dev.madge.com "Ian Griffiths" writes:
|>
|> > Or is this just a troll?
|>
|> ...just a thought. If the Nit Nurse hates all forms of music *soo*
|> violently... why's he/she/it reading uk.music.alternative?

Who mentioned violence? I'm pointing out its simply an art form and I
don't understand why there is some unwritten rule that if you dislike
that art form, you must be some sort of 'weirdo'. Are people who don't
like painting similarly dismissed?...well maybe by those who see a pile
of bricks and a dead sheep in a pickle tank as 'art'!

..and I'm reading it in uk.misc.

Michael Kilpatrick

unread,
Sep 18, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/18/96
to

tho...@xargle.demon.co.uk (Tony Howat) writes:

>In message <51meoj$4...@sis.armltd.co.uk> Michael Kilpatrick wrote:

>> Ian Griffiths <igri...@dev.madge.com> writes:

>[snip]

>Oh dear. Can't you spot a troll when you read one?

I'm not interested in trollspotting, as I haven't got an anorak.
I'm interested in replying to any comments that inspire me to
do so. If you're not interested in any of the actual contents of
my posting don't waste my time replying with dull one-liners as
above.

Michael

The Nit Nurse

unread,
Sep 18, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/18/96
to

In article <zlsiida.41...@fs1.mcc.ac.uk>, zls...@fs1.mcc.ac.uk
(Dave Budd) wrote:

|> Steely Dan have just finished the British leg of their tour, so you've
|> missed the real music.

Steely Dan - described in one review of their current live act as being
'as interesting as urban drizzle - you notice it, but don't pay much attention'

|> Interesting list of newsgroups! I've trimmed it a bit.....left soc.
|> retirement in as Dan fans are getting a bit long in the tooth.....

Probably from hanging around waiting for them to play something more
interesting than the 'lift' music they usually churn out.

"Ricky don't lose that number..ooooo!!"

"..and I'm never, going back, to my old Schoooooooool *parp* parp* paaarp*"

Is Larry Carlton still playing with them? He was the only interesting
attribute they had.

SANDARPA

unread,
Sep 18, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/18/96
to

In article <323C70...@ix.netcom.com>, mee...@ix.netcom.com says...
>
>Bert Jones wrote:
>>
>> Who put the 'bop' in the 'bop-she-wop-she-wop'? And for that matter,
>> who put the 'ram' in the 'ram-a-lam-a-ding-dong'? What's more, who put
>> the 'dip' in the 'dip-de-dip-de-dip'?
>>
>> But most importantly of all, what on earth is happening to music
>> nowadays?
>>
>> Do you remember the old days? The smooth, soothing voice of Mr. Bing
>> Crosby, the heart-wrenching intonation of Mr. Frank Sinatra. Or the
>> crotch-thrusting rock and roll of Mr. Cliff Richard?
>>
>> Now who have they been replaced by? A bunch of jumped-up teenagers who
>> wouldn't know one end of a pianoforte from the other, and who have had
>> the musical training of a dog. A cocker spaniel, probably.
>>
>> Whatever happened to those family favourites who were guaranteed to
>> brighten your day and make you smile. Like Vera Lynn, The Andrews
>> Sisters, Shirley Bassey, Dionne Warwick and Leonard Cohen?
>>
>> They've been replaced by Ocean, Blur, Oasis Colour Shaker, Kula Scene
>> and Elastica (a more highly charged sexual innuendo I could not think
>> of).
>>
>> What on earth our we doing to the minds of our children?
>>
>> Take, for example, the words to a disgusting song that I heard on the
>> so-called 'popular' music station. BBC Radio One, by the combo
>> ‘Erasure (and I quote):
>>
>> "Don't go changing your emotions. Lay all your love on me.
>> Don't go sparing your devotion. Lay all your love on me."
>>
>> Is this what we want our children to grow up with? Sex and violence. I
>> can tell you, you would not be hearing this sort of smut from my
>> personal favourites, those long-lost Danish popsters, Abba.
>>
>> As I see it, we've got a real problem in this country, and unless we
>> want to end up like our lesser relations 'across the pond', as they
>> say, where children from the age of three upwards rapidly turn into
>> gun-toting mobsters, then we must rid Britain of this noise!
>>
>> I suggest this:
>>
>> 1) Let's put Vince Hill on the National Curriculum.
>>
>> 2) Make it compulsory to own at least one Harry Secombe album.
>>
>> 3) Ban any so-called musician who doesn't have a degree in Music.
>>
>> 4) And ban that awful Nigel Kennedy as well, and bring back Sir Yehudi
>> Menuhin.
>>
>> 5) And let's get the Goons back on Radio 4 too.
>>
>> Britain can be Great again. But forget the three R's, what about the
>> three M's: Mozart, Mendelsohn and McCartney (though, of course,
>> nothing before 1970 and nothing after 1980).
>>
>> And then maybe our kids will be normal again.
>>
>> Bert Jones
>>
>> ------------------------------------------------------------------
>> The senior citizens Internet centre
>> Alzheimer’s sufferers welcome
>> http://www.senile.co.uk/dribble
>> ------------------------------------------------------------------
>WELL THIS TOPIC IS NOT OF THIS GROUP................
>But if you dont like what you hear on the radio today,JUST TURN IF OFF,
>Buy some sinatra,Bing,and Bassey CDs and kick back and enjoy.
>I dont like what I hear on the air waves today either...
>....SO that is why i have a large collection of CDs
>Pink floyd,Rush,Led Zepplin,..(3 of the best bands ever,IMHO....
>OH...and Zimmer.TLK.....ROTPL....TPOO{the power of one}.
>Everone should have Zimmer in there collection........
>Well thats just my 3 cents....
>going to get off my soapbox now...
>MEETOO9

Well, I for one am disgusted with the above message. Bert's views are
perfectly valid to me....most people will agree that this so-called
Britpop mularkey is nothing more than a relentless, raucous din.These
Gallagher boys- they are a disgrace to Merseyside with their infernal
racket.

Whatever happened to good music, such as the Rubettes, Mud and
2Unlimited; all we get to hear these days is this Blur nonsense with that
Albion guy from Colchester......bring back Billy Fury , that's what I say


Paul
(With grateful thanks to master music critics, Mr.Grimm, Mr.Crabtree, and
Mr.Hotchkies)


SANDARPA

unread,
Sep 18, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/18/96
to

In article <842813...@misc.org.uk>, da...@misc.org.uk says...

>
>In article <323c0c89...@news.u-net.com>
> feed...@netvision.co.uk "Bert Jones" writes:
>
>~ Whatever happened to those family favourites who were guaranteed to
>~ brighten your day and make you smile. Like Vera Lynn, The Andrews
>~ Sisters, Shirley Bassey, Dionne Warwick and Leonard Cohen?
>
>Leonard Cohen was on Jools Holland a year or so ago; he was so boring
>I changed channel to watch the adverts instead...
>
>--
>Dave The Rave

In which case, you missed a treat. His version of Jollity's Farm was
inspired; and I 'm only sorry I had to go to bed during Happy Talk.

Paul Sandars.


madee

unread,
Sep 18, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/18/96
to

ia...@hotch.demon.co.uk (Iain L M Hotchkies) wrote:

<>In message <323d609...@news.hal-pc.org> madee wrote:
<>
<>> d...@kerrera.gla.dcs.ac.uk (The Nit Nurse) wrote:
<>>

<>> <>In article <842813...@misc.org.uk>, da...@misc.org.uk wrote:
<>> <>
<>> <>|> In article <323c0c89...@news.u-net.com>
<>> <>|> feed...@netvision.co.uk "Bert Jones" writes:
<>> <>|>

<>> ..


<>> <>
<>> <>Music is boring. I hate it. Just a lot of jangly noises - I just
<>> don't see

<>> <>what the attraction is.
<>> <><><><<> Flame #1.

<>> The problem is you don't understand the basics. You hear, not see
<>> music.
<>>
<>> Flame #2. A person who finds music boring probably doesn't offer
much
<>> her/himself.
<>

<>Eee, by 'eck, this is grand. What the f*ck is this doing in
<>a Lion King ng? Nevermind.
<>
<>I thought that the music in the LK was soooper. Especially
<>that Elvis Costello Tune.
<>
<>Anyway, who says you can't *see* music. Never been to a
<>Motorhead gig? Just watch them bass bins shakin' and
<>shimmerin' in the light of the setting sun. Another
<>good album by the Jam, even if I say so myself.
<>><
You people in the UK are really weird.

The Nit Nurse

unread,
Sep 18, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/18/96
to

What on earth are you blabbing about now? The subject is Motorhead
and bass bins so contribute something rather than whining about things you
claim you don't understand.

ObMotorhead: Unplugged album should be in the shops soon.

Ian Griffiths

unread,
Sep 18, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/18/96
to

The Nit Nurse wrote:

>
> Ian Griffiths <igri...@dev.madge.com> wrote:
>
> |> The Nit Nurse wrote:
> |> >
> |> > ma...@hal-pc.org (madee) wrote:
> |> >
> |> > |> d...@kerrera.gla.dcs.ac.uk (The Nit Nurse) wrote:
> |> > |>
> |> > |> >Music is boring. I hate it. Just a lot of jangly
> |> > |> >noises
> |> >
> |> > Fortunately I consider there to be far more to life than
> |> > wandering about with things stuck in my ear listening to
> |> > a blaring cocophany
> |>
> |> Do you genuinely think that ALL must is either "blaring
> |> cocphany" or "a lot of jangly noises", or are you having a
> |> go at a particular genre?
>
> What makes you think that all people must dutifully like a din
> made by scraping strings, bashing bits of animal skins,
> blowing through metal tubes or whatever contraption is used to
> make a racket?

It's spot the non-sequitur time...

What makes YOU think that I said that?

I asked if you geniunely think that ALL.. hell, go and read it
again, it's still up there.

I didn't say you had to like it. What I do say is that it's
more _just_ noises. Speech is a just so many noises, just as a
book is only this wad of paper with bits of ink splattered on
the pages. Life, it's just a load of stuff that happens (H.
Simpson). If you simply can't be bothered to try and understand
it in any more depth than that, this seems to me to show a
certain lack of ambition.


> Is there some 'rule' that says all people _must_ like some
> form of music?

No, of course not. Some people are, for example, tone deaf and
unable to appreciate music. Other people presumably don't find
any great link between music and feeling.


> Does no one think for themselves any more and spend their life
> ploughing through 'noise' after 'noise' in the belief that
> there must be *something* that they 'like'?

Clearly if you've come to the conclusion that you're never going
to get anything out of it then listening to music is a waste of
time.

I don't have an argument with that particular point.

However, this is not the point you originally made which I
picked out, which was your assertion that music is just a bunch
of noises. Even if you can't hear it because you're tone deaf,
or you can't appreciate it because you're musically frigid, you
simply cannot make a convincing case that there is nothing more
to music than an unconnected mish-mash of sound; go and read
any book on composition, harmony, basic principals of music, or
even any some works on physics which deal with accoustics and
you'll see that you can anaylse and rationalise for as long as
you like about music, regardless of whether you enjoy it or not.
As far as I'm concerned, that's not the point with music - it'd
be much like trying to enjoy a stand-up comedy routine by
acquiring a transcription and analysing in detail the humour in
every joke.


The main thing I find offensive is that you seem to be
dismissing an entire major art form purely because YOU lack the
mental apparatus required to appreciate it.

> Perhaps these same people find it amazing that some people
> are not only unimpressed by F1GP driving but find the entire
> genre of competative motorsport incredibly boring?

I found motor racing very similar to jazz music - I didn't get
very much out of either until I'd done them myself, at which
point I enjoyed being a spectator much much more. In general I
find that I prefer to listen to music I've sung/played in
before. Best of all I prefer to be performing.


> The phrase 'brainwashed sheep' springs to mind.

I'm sure you're right about the examples you have in mind. But
you seem to be suggesting that anyone who watches or listens to
something you find boring must necessarily be a brainwashed
sheep.

Are you?


--
Ian Griffiths


Ian Griffiths

unread,
Sep 18, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/18/96
to

Michael Kilpatrick wrote:
>
> Ian Griffiths <igri...@dev.madge.com> writes:
>
> >Do you genuinely think that ALL must is either "blaring
> >cocphany" or "a lot of jangly noises", or are you having a go at
> >a particular genre?
>
> >It seems pretty indisputable to me that the average baroque
> >string quartet is neither of these.
>
> Only if you understand it.

Even if you don't understand it, I think it's neither blaring or
jangly. :-) A quiet gentle cacophany perhaps...


>Personally I think it is sad to miss out, but I certainly don't
> believe that it follows that David is a "sad" or "stupid"
> individual because of it - far from it.

I agree absolutely. However David seemed (to me) to be
occupying the opposite point of view - that people who do listen
to music are sad and/or stupid.


>I grew rapidly out of any inclination to listen to pop music of
>any form because of its shallow and vacuous musical content

I think that's a little unfair. The vast majority of pop music
is vacuous and shallow. I don't think all of it is.


> > I for one completely fail to appreciate poetry of any kind,
>
> That's a great shame.

Well this is what I'm lead to understand. I haven't actually
given up trying. But by The Nit Nurse's reasoning, this makes
be a 'brainwashed sheep' because I'm wasting my time in reading
and listening to text that I don't get much out of simply
because I'm going along with the popular belief that it's
worthwhile really and I should be able to find something I
appreciate somehow. This is not a line of reasoning I subscribe
to.


--
Ian Griffiths

Ian Griffiths

unread,
Sep 18, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/18/96
to

Tony Howat wrote:
>
> Michael Kilpatrick wrote:
>
> > Ian Griffiths <igri...@dev.madge.com> writes:
>
> [snip]
>
> Oh dear. Can't you spot a troll when you read one?

Well the originator of this troll has been identified as someone
other than the Nit Nurse, albeit possibly incorrectly. Said
Nurse appears to actually hold this point of view here, and is
continuing the discussion, rather than the normal approach of
leaving a single contraversial message and watching the results,
it's a point of view I've seen before and wanted to understand.

Oh darn! This message was a troll too wasn't it.

--
Ian Griffiths

Ian Griffiths

unread,
Sep 18, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/18/96
to

John wrote:
>
> igri...@dev.madge.com "Ian Griffiths" writes:
>
> > Or is this just a troll?
>
> ...just a thought. If the Nit Nurse hates all forms of music
> *soo* violently... why's he/she/it reading
> uk.music.alternative?

Dunno about you, but I'm reading this on uk.misc. I believe the
Nit Nurse is a uk.miscreant.


--
Ian Griffiths

The Nit Nurse

unread,
Sep 18, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/18/96
to

In article <323FF1...@dev.madge.com>, Ian Griffiths
<igri...@dev.madge.com> wrote:

|> The Nit Nurse wrote:
|> >
|> > Ian Griffiths <igri...@dev.madge.com> wrote:
|> >
|> > |> The Nit Nurse wrote:
|> > |> >
|> > |> > ma...@hal-pc.org (madee) wrote:
|> > |> >
|> > |> > |> d...@kerrera.gla.dcs.ac.uk (The Nit Nurse) wrote:
|> > |> > |>

|> > |> > |> >Music is boring. I hate it. Just a lot of jangly
|> > |> > |> >noises
|> > |> >


|> > |> > Fortunately I consider there to be far more to life than
|> > |> > wandering about with things stuck in my ear listening to
|> > |> > a blaring cocophany
|> > |>

|> > |> Do you genuinely think that ALL must is either "blaring
|> > |> cocphany" or "a lot of jangly noises", or are you having a
|> > |> go at a particular genre?
|> >

|> > What makes you think that all people must dutifully like a din
|> > made by scraping strings, bashing bits of animal skins,
|> > blowing through metal tubes or whatever contraption is used to
|> > make a racket?
|>
|> It's spot the non-sequitur time...

Really?

|> What makes YOU think that I said that?
|>
|> I asked if you geniunely think that ALL.. hell, go and read it
|> again, it's still up there.

Indeed. It says "Music is boring. I hate it..etc. I would have thought
that was fairly self-explanatory, don't you?
The implication from the question you pose is that there must be *some*
form of music I like since, there appears to be an element of disbelief
in the question you pose in that, you capitalise the key word 'all',
yet the first statement I made is quite clear from the outset.

|> I didn't say you had to like it. What I do say is that it's
|> more _just_ noises.

And what I said is that it is indeed just noises from people bashing, blowing
or scraping things - about as attractive as listening to industrial machinery.

|> Speech is a just so many noises,

Speech performs a function, passing on information which may be important.

|> Simpson). If you simply can't be bothered to try and understand
|> it in any more depth than that, this seems to me to show a
|> certain lack of ambition.

So tell me, do you consider a load of bricks or a pickled dead sheep in
a display tank 'art' and those who can't be bothered to try and understand
it as lacking in ambition? Indeed, does it show that those who dismiss it
as trash for the gullible to chatter over also have a lack of ambition?
Or is it, in reality, truly trash and its only the gullible and the pretentious
trying to make some 'depth' to it?
Perhaps we should listen more carefully at the next roadworks in case there
is some hidden depth to the racket coming from the machinery employed?



|>
|> > Is there some 'rule' that says all people _must_ like some
|> > form of music?
|>
|> No, of course not. Some people are, for example, tone deaf and
|> unable to appreciate music. Other people presumably don't find
|> any great link between music and feeling.

..and some people find it about as appealing as eating cold boiled
cabbage. Would it show a "lack of ambition' to refuse to continue to
stuff one's face with the product despite the obvious. Perhaps one
should continue trying to 'understand in depth' the true hidden
,meanings of cold cabbage to the point the one becomes brainw^H^H^H^H^H
a true believer and appreciative of its finer qualities?



|> > Does no one think for themselves any more and spend their life
|> > ploughing through 'noise' after 'noise' in the belief that
|> > there must be *something* that they 'like'?
|>
|> Clearly if you've come to the conclusion that you're never going
|> to get anything out of it then listening to music is a waste of
|> time.
|>
|> I don't have an argument with that particular point.
|>
|> However, this is not the point you originally made which I
|> picked out, which was your assertion that music is just a bunch
|> of noises.

Indeed. That is my opinion. You have a problem with this?

|>
|> The main thing I find offensive is that you seem to be
|> dismissing an entire major art form purely because YOU lack the
|> mental apparatus required to appreciate it.

Ahh, now we get to the nitty gritty. Anyone who doesn't like a
particular art form lacks "the mental apparatus required to
appreciate it". In other words, you MUST like it.



|> > The phrase 'brainwashed sheep' springs to mind.
|>
|> I'm sure you're right about the examples you have in mind. But
|> you seem to be suggesting that anyone who watches or listens to
|> something you find boring must necessarily be a brainwashed
|> sheep.
|>
|> Are you?

I'm suggesting that anyone who dismisses those who do not appreciate
a particular art form and find it an irritating annoyance as 'lacking
in mental apparatus" and showing a 'lack of ambition' incredibly pretentious.
You aren't employed by the Tate Gallery by any chance?

Iain L M Hotchkies

unread,
Sep 18, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/18/96
to

...movin' like a parallelogram...

Iain L M Hotchkies

unread,
Sep 18, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/18/96
to

In message <323f536e...@news.hal-pc.org> madee wrote:

> You people in the UK are really weird.

Possibly. Did anyone see Elvis Costello on the Larry
Sanders Show on Monday night?

The Nit Nurse

unread,
Sep 18, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/18/96
to

In article <323FF3...@dev.madge.com>, Ian Griffiths
<igri...@dev.madge.com> wrote:

|> Michael Kilpatrick wrote:

|> I agree absolutely. However David seemed (to me) to be
|> occupying the opposite point of view - that people who do listen
|> to music are sad and/or stupid.

I'm occupying the position that music is an irritant and is like,
say, people smoking around you as a non-smoker. I am expressing the
opinion, to continue with the smoking analogy, that those who look
on in disbelief that I should say smoking is irritating are indeed
sad/stupid people and further those that do smoke are just brainwashed
sheep. Now, there may be exceptions to this, for example those who
sample various brands like some connessieur of tobaccos, but those
type of people are fe and far between and the vast majority of
smokers are indeed brainwashed sheep swallowing whatever the tobacco
campanoes tell them to swallow. Now substitute music into that.
There will be a few exceptions but, far and away the vast bulk of music
'consumed' is what the industry pushes at its dutiful sheep.

The Nit Nurse

unread,
Sep 18, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/18/96
to

*sigh* a couple of corrections..

In article <dam-180996...@130.209.240.43>,


d...@kerrera.gla.dcs.ac.uk (The Nit Nurse) wrote:

|> The implication from the question you pose is that there must be *some*
|> form of music I like since, there appears to be an element of disbelief
|> in the question you pose in that, you capitalise the key word 'all',
|> yet the first statement I made is quite clear from the outset.

^ ^
it what my
position is.

[some missed quotes below, which were meant to give it context]

|> So tell me, do you consider a load of bricks or a pickled dead sheep in
|> a display tank 'art' and those who 'can't be bothered to try and understand

|> it' as 'lacking in ambition'? Indeed, does it show that those who dismiss it
|> as "trash for the gullible to chatter over" also have a 'lack of ambition'?

Ian Griffiths

unread,
Sep 18, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/18/96
to

SANDARPA wrote:
>
> mee...@ix.netcom.com says...
>
> >Bert Jones wrote:
> >>
> >> by the combo è–¦rasure (and I quote):

> >>
> >> "Don't go changing your emotions. Lay all your love on me.
> >> Don't go sparing your devotion. Lay all your love on me."
> >>
> >> I can tell you, you would not be hearing this sort of smut
> >> from my personal favourites, those long-lost Danish
> >> popsters, Abba.

:-)

I hadn't actually seen the start of this thread. I'm glad
someone reposted a quote of it or I'd have missed that bit.


> Well, I for one am disgusted with the above message. Bert's
> views are perfectly valid to me....

Except for where he's factually wrong, which is just amusing.

--
Ian Griffiths

Simon Gray

unread,
Sep 18, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/18/96
to

In article <51mihl$5...@sis.armltd.co.uk>
mkil...@armltd.co.uk "Michael Kilpatrick" writes:

~ Are saying that didjs haven't caught on because they're not
~ "fashionable". Is it too unhip to be seen with a didj? The term
~ "fashion" seems to have little to do with the use of the didj.
~
~ The Didjeridoo is a primitive wind instrument that was superseded
^^^^^^^^^ ^^^^^^^^^^
~ centuries ago by wind instruments with holes or variable length tubes
~ therefore capable of playing scales. The didjeridoo is capable only
~ playing harmonics and overtones, with the additional effects introduced
~ in the player's embouchure. It is a whole different technique, not
~ merely a fashion. Aboriginies quite simply didn't discover the trumpet
~ or the piano. Meanwhile, Western music is trying incorporate ideas
~ such as onvertones and microtones, not out of a desire to be
~ fashionable or hip on the world scene, but out of a desire to
~ experiment with new things and to extend the limits imposed by the
~ rigid mathematics of scales and classical harmonies. I can't equate
~ any of this with "fashion" as I see it.

Don't make the standard ethnocentric mistake of assuming 'progress' in
music, least of all on the bases of cultures, technologies, &
chronologies.

My Korg Wavestation is more recent, & more 'technological' than
a Stradivarius violin, but is it more 'advanced' than it ? Has it
superseded it ? I think not. (Conversely I would argue that the latter
is by no means superior to the former, as well)

OK, apples & oranges, you might say, try this example - a modern oboe
is a completely different instrument to a baroque oboe, but has it
superseded it ? The authentic performance lobby would certainly
argue that it hasn't.

Is a Beethoven symphony more advanced than a Perotin motet ? Is a
Perotin motet more advanced than an Indian raga ? Is a Harrison
Birtwistle opera more advanced than a Beethoven symphony ? Is a
Babylon Zoo track more advanced than a Harrison Birtwistle opera ?

Simon Gray

unread,
Sep 18, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/18/96
to

In article <842989...@diploma.demon.co.uk>
Jo...@diploma.demon.co.uk "John" writes:

~ > Or is this just a troll?
~
~ ...just a thought. If the Nit Nurse hates all forms of music *soo*
~ violently... why's he/she/it reading uk.music.alternative?

Perhaps Nit is reading uk.misc ?

Patrick Gosling

unread,
Sep 18, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/18/96
to

In article <323ef3f6...@newsbeta.dircon.co.uk>,
Big Ears. <Big...@technocom.com> wrote:
>Cyprus with his girl-friend.

I've never heard it called that before ...

-patrick

Mel

unread,
Sep 18, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/18/96
to Iain L M Hotchkies


On Wed, 18 Sep 1996, Iain L M Hotchkies wrote:

> Date: Wed, 18 Sep 1996 15:38:35 +0100
> From: Iain L M Hotchkies <ia...@hotch.demon.co.uk>
> Newsgroups: uk.misc, uk.music.alternative, soc.retirement,
> alt.fan.lion-king, alt.ph.uk, alt.music.leonard-cohen
> Subject: Re: Whatever happened to real music?
>
Has it occurred to you that most of the people on soc.retirement don't
care about what most of you call " music" and even less for your
discussion?
>


Gil the Great

unread,
Sep 18, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/18/96
to

>>Whatever happened to those family favourites who
>> blah blah blah. Point. Counterpoint. Argue argue
>> argue. blah blah blah.

Who cares?

Gil the Great

Pam Hadfield

unread,
Sep 18, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/18/96
to

In article <323f536e...@news.hal-pc.org>,
ma...@hal-pc.org (madee) wrote:
..........
:<>><
:You people in the UK are really weird.

Hey, thanks for the compliment :)

Pam

Pam Hadfield

unread,
Sep 18, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/18/96
to

In article <51l2b1$8...@uruguay.earthlink.net>,
ronk...@earthlink.net (Ron Kelley) wrote:

..................
:
:God, I love the British. They sure know how to turn a phrase.
:

<Kiss>


Simon Gray

unread,
Sep 18, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/18/96
to

In article <19960917....@hotch.hotch.demon.co.uk>
ia...@hotch.demon.co.uk "Iain L M Hotchkies" writes:

~ 5) if you follow-up your own troll, you're disqualified

Surely it should be allowed to spread it out a bit, though, say
by diverting the topic of the troll away into more obscurity ?
Kind of a multi-part-troll ?

~ 6) if you muck up someone else's troll (eg. "Don't bother
~ replying to Nit's post because it's a troll!") then
~ you're disqualified and the person whose troll you
~ sabotaged gets your points

I think we should, in the spirit of competition, be allowed to help
each other out with our trolls, though.

Stewart Brinn

unread,
Sep 18, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/18/96
to

On Tue, 17 Sep 1996 18:42:12 +0100, ia...@hotch.demon.co.uk (Iain L M
Hotchkies) wrote:

> <snipped>

>9) That's enough rules - this is Usenet for f's sake.

And how about
10) Must not involve Mike Corley

Stu!
sbr...@netcomuk.co.uk

Dom

unread,
Sep 18, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/18/96
to

d...@kerrera.gla.dcs.ac.uk (The Nit Nurse) writes:

>|> >|> and Iain is up to his neck in other
>|> >|> >people's bottoms - apparently.
>|> >|>
>|> >|> Funny what summer jobs people get up to - if they haven't got resits...
>|>
>|> >Iain's a GP, not a spotty student.
>|>
>|> And you're a nit nurse, according to your header.

>Indeed. And...?

Oh, forget it.

--
D.

W. ROLLINS

unread,
Sep 18, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/18/96
to

Bobbie Rivere (bob...@pb.net) wrote:
: Excuse me for butting in here and snipping all but one paragraph. But I am a
: little confused as I sit listening to a Beethoven Piano Concerto and enjoying it
: immensely. Unless I am misreading you, you are mistaken as to the composer of
: the "grandiose 1812 Overture." It was Tchaikovsky, not Beethoven, and I still
: get a thrill hearing all the cannons and bells that bring the overture to a
: close, no matter what his motivation for writing it. :)

Thats really nice but did you relly have to post it to so many newsgroups?

BiNM


: ********************** ***************************************************
: Bobbie Rivere Famous for "BBA" and other assorted
: Merrick, NY USA tortures, and for being a completely
: bob...@pb.net certifiable nut. Have a nice day. :)
: ********************** ***************************************************


W. ROLLINS

unread,
Sep 18, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/18/96
to

madee (ma...@hal-pc.org) wrote:
: <><><< Things in their ears? Wandering about? Need to get out more?
: Sheep following the flock? Illiterate because I like music?
: Friend, you are one mixed up person/nurse/lady?

And you just crossposted this thread to several newsgroups and only 2 of
them can be posted to from here so you are forcing me to see replies from
newsgroups I can't even read.

BiNM


The Nit Nurse

unread,
Sep 19, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/19/96
to

In article <Pine.BSI.3.95.960918...@laurel.us.net>, Mel
<me...@us.net> wrote:

And who appointed you spokesman for what 'most people on soc.retirement'
are interested in then?

Michael Kilpatrick

unread,
Sep 19, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/19/96
to

si...@star-one.org.uk (Simon Gray) writes:

>In article <51mihl$5...@sis.armltd.co.uk>
> mkil...@armltd.co.uk "Michael Kilpatrick" writes:

>~

>~ The Didjeridoo is a primitive wind instrument that was superseded
> ^^^^^^^^^ ^^^^^^^^^^

>Don't make the standard ethnocentric mistake of assuming 'progress' in


>music, least of all on the bases of cultures, technologies, &
>chronologies.


>My Korg Wavestation is more recent, & more 'technological' than
>a Stradivarius violin, but is it more 'advanced' than it ?

Probably, but I don't know what a Korg is. If it produces lots of
different sounds and effects then it is clearly more advanced than a
Strad. It is probably far more versatile and far more sophisticated
than the Strad. The technological standpoint is the only one we can
use to judge the 'advancement' of it.

>Has it
>superseded it ?

Certainly not. Electronics is no where near produces sounds that are
anything like comparable to the best "real" instruments.

I think not. (Conversely I would argue that the latter
>is by no means superior to the former, as well)

>OK, apples & oranges, you might say, try this example - a modern oboe
>is a completely different instrument to a baroque oboe, but has it
>superseded it ?

Yes, in the sense that it will be more in tune. No in the sense that
it's a mass produced piece of rubbish with little tone or character!


Michael

Dom

unread,
Sep 19, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/19/96
to

sbr...@netcomuk.co.uk (Stewart Brinn) writes:

>On Tue, 17 Sep 1996 18:42:12 +0100, ia...@hotch.demon.co.uk (Iain L M
>Hotchkies) wrote:

>> <snipped>

>>9) That's enough rules - this is Usenet for f's sake.

But still plenty of space left for dirty tricks.

>And how about
>10) Must not involve Mike Corley

Must not involve Mike Corley's methods: i.e posting the same troll
repeatedly.

--
D.

Ian Griffiths

unread,
Sep 19, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/19/96
to

The Nit Nurse wrote:
>
> Ian Griffiths <igri...@dev.madge.com> wrote:
>
> |> The Nit Nurse wrote:
> |> >
> |> > Ian Griffiths <igri...@dev.madge.com> wrote:
> |> >
> |> > |> The Nit Nurse wrote:
> |> > |> >
> |> > |> > ma...@hal-pc.org (madee) wrote:
> |> > |> >
> |> > |> > |> d...@kerrera.gla.dcs.ac.uk (The Nit Nurse) wrote:
> |> > |> > |>
> |> > |> > |> >Music is boring. I hate it. Just a lot of jangly
> |> > |> > |> >noises
> |> > |> >
> |> > |>
> |> > |> Do you genuinely think that ALL must is either
> |> > |> "blaring cocphany" or "a lot of jangly noises", or are
> |> > |> you having a go at a particular genre?
> |> >
> |> > What makes you think that all people must dutifully like
> |> > a din made by scraping strings, bashing bits of animal
> |> > skins, blowing through metal tubes or whatever
> |> > contraption is used to make a racket?
> |>
> |> It's spot the non-sequitur time...
>
> Really?

Yes: I never said that everybody had to like music.


> |> What makes YOU think that I said that?
> |>
> |> I asked if you geniunely think that ALL.. hell, go and read
> |> it again, it's still up there.
>
> Indeed. It says "Music is boring. I hate it..etc. I would have
> thought that was fairly self-explanatory, don't you?

...and you stop at the bit I was particularl objecting to:

You said: "Just a lot of jangly noises"

My argument is: it's more than just a lot of jangly noises.

> The implication from the question you pose is that there must
> be *some* form of music I like since,

No not at all. How would I know? All I'm saying is that there
is more to music than just jangly noises, and that this is
completely orthogonal to whether or not you happen to enjoy
listening to music at all.


> there appears to be an element of disbelief in the question
> you pose in that, you capitalise the key word 'all',

I'm prepared to admit that some 'music' is just noise devoid of
any appreciable structure or other discernable characteristics.
Fortunately the period for which it was fashionable to pursue
this sort of route was mercifully short, presumably because it
quickly became apparent that it's very boring.

I'd also admit that an awful lot of music (in particular but not
exclusively pop music) is formulaic, unoriginal and dull. A
good argument against its quality, although not one that you
make, presumably because it seems that music of any depth is of
no interest to you.


> |> I didn't say you had to like it. What I do say is that
> |> it's more _just_ noises.
>
> And what I said is that it is indeed just noises from people
> bashing, blowing or scraping things -

This is a pedantic but very nearly correct point. (You left out
twanging, and show an incomplete understanding of the subtleties
of most wind instruments and a disregard for synthesizers.) I'd
like to label this as point (1) separate this from your next
point, which I shall call (2):


> about as attractive as listening to industrial machinery.

This is a subjective opinion, which you can no more prove than I
can disprove.


> |> Speech is a just so many noises,
>
> Speech performs a function, passing on information which may
> be important.

The vast majority of it doesn't. That however is beside the
point, because applying the same level as pedantry as you did to
arrive at point (1), you simply cannot deny that speech is just
so many noises.

Clearly (as you observe) it has structure and meaning beyond
that. So does music.

By your use of the word 'important' you presumably wish to imply
that speech performs functions of value which music cannot. I
would claim that one of the most important functions of speech
is social. Music, too, is essential to a variety of social
activities.

While there is frequently no direct way to translate between the
two, it is indisputable that music can be used to communicate.
The lack of a direct mapping is clearly just a limitation of
language in some respects and of music in others. In the realms
that are wholey the domain of music, I would argue that there is
much of far more value than a lot of what language, in practice,
is used for. I don't understand how you could deny that when
you have already admitted that you don't understand music.


> |> If you simply can't be bothered to try and understand
> |> it in any more depth than that, this seems to me to show a
> |> certain lack of ambition.
>
> So tell me, do you consider a load of bricks or a pickled dead
> sheep in a display tank 'art'

I couldn't possibly comment on something like that which I
haven't seen. I've merely heard loads of other people's
opinions on the matter. I think most people are too ready to
leap to conclusions on subjects they haven't found out about
themselves.


> and those who can't be bothered to try and understand it as
> lacking in ambition?

Certainly.


> Indeed, does it show that those who dismiss it as trash for
> the gullible to chatter over also have a lack of ambition?

Those who have seen it and drawn that conclusion after
consideration clearly don't. Those who have drawn that
conclusion as a result of having read/heard the same conclusion
somewhere probably do, or are at least lazy.


> Or is it, in reality, truly trash and its only the gullible
> and the pretentious trying to make some 'depth' to it?

I don't know.


> Perhaps we should listen more carefully at the next roadworks
> in case there is some hidden depth to the racket coming from
> the machinery employed?

It's been done. Well, sort of. It's called music concrete...
Don't like it myself.


> |> > Is there some 'rule' that says all people _must_ like
> |> > some form of music?
> |>
> |> No, of course not. Some people are, for example, tone deaf
> |> and unable to appreciate music. Other people presumably
> |> don't find any great link between music and feeling.
>
> ..and some people find it about as appealing as eating cold
> boiled cabbage.

Presumably such as yourself. But why do you continue to be so
scathing about it. It's not as if you're just saying "this
leaves me cold, so I don't bother with it", it's much more like
you're saying "I don't like this, so nobody else should", which
is in fact the reverse of the argument you are trying to accuse
me of. (My summary of my argument would be "There's clearly
something to music". As it happens I like it but I consider
that to be incidental to the point we're discussing here.)


> Would it show a "lack of ambition' to refuse to continue to
> stuff one's face with the product despite the obvious. Perhaps
> one should continue trying to 'understand in depth' the true
> hidden ,meanings of cold cabbage to the point the one becomes
> brainw^H^H^H^H^H a true believer and appreciative of its finer
> qualities?

That would depend entirely on the context in which one finds the
cabbage, cold, boiled or otherwise.


> |> > Does no one think for themselves any more and spend their
> |> > life ploughing through 'noise' after 'noise' in the
> |> > belief that> there must be *something* that they 'like'?
> |>
> |> Clearly if you've come to the conclusion that you're never
> |> going to get anything out of it then listening to music is
> |> a waste of time.
> |>
> |> I don't have an argument with that particular point.
> |>
> |> However, this is not the point you originally made which I
> |> picked out, which was your assertion that music is just a
> |> bunch of noises.
>
> Indeed. That is my opinion. You have a problem with this?

Yes, I do. I don't have a problem with you're not liking it,
but I do find it remarkable that you can simply deny that there
is any kind of structure, pattern, meaning or content of any
kind, and that it is nothing more than noise. You only have to
look. You don't have to like what you see, but it's
indisputably there to see.

Your arguments about abstract 'art' are to some extent
misleading IMO in that the vast majority of music is not so
abstracted from anything much. With work involving animals in
formaldehyde, one can easily argue that it's not art because it
doesn't conform to any recognised form of art. One can come up
with equivalent examples of 'music' if necessary. On the other
hand a painting is pretty clearly a painting, and similarly if
you pick a piece of music at random, the chances are it will be
pretty clear that it's a piece of music, and easily identifiable
from white noise, roadworks, favorite workshop sound effects
etc.


Do you like any form of art?

If this is just a specific instance of a general dislike you may
have for art, then obviously my position becomes much harder to
defend: it's very much easier to justify music as an art form
than it is to justify art as a whole, I believe.


> |> The main thing I find offensive is that you seem to be
> |> dismissing an entire major art form purely because YOU lack
> |> the mental apparatus required to appreciate it.
>
> Ahh, now we get to the nitty gritty. Anyone who doesn't like a
> particular art form lacks "the mental apparatus required to
> appreciate it".

Spot the non-sequitur again:

> In other words, you MUST like it.

Anyone who doesn't appreciate a particular artform clearly lacks
whatever is required to appreciate it. Surely that's not a
contentious statement - it's a tautology! But you seem to
conclude that it implies some kind of abnormal deficiency.
That's your reading, not mine.


> |> > The phrase 'brainwashed sheep' springs to mind.
> |>
> |> I'm sure you're right about the examples you have in mind.
> |> But you seem to be suggesting that anyone who watches or
> |> listens to something you find boring must necessarily be a
> |> brainwashed sheep.
> |>
> |> Are you?

Should I take it from your failure to answer this question that
you really do think this? If so then that is, as you later put
it, incredibly pretentious.


> I'm suggesting that anyone who dismisses those who do not
> appreciate a particular art form and find it an irritating
> annoyance as 'lacking in mental apparatus"

I still don't see how you can deny that. I think the assertion
is so transparently true to be, as I said, tautologous.

Are you saying you DO posess the mental apparatus to appreciate
and enjoy music? If you do, but simply choose not to use it,
then I think either you are

> showing a 'lack of ambition'


As for your assertion that I am being:

> incredibly pretentious.

where is the pretence? What am I pretending to be?

Or are you using 'pretentious' in the broader Oasis sense of the
word?


> You aren't employed by the Tate Gallery by any chance?

Nah.

--
Ian Griffiths

Ian Griffiths

unread,
Sep 19, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/19/96
to

Michael Kilpatrick wrote:
>
>
> but I don't know what a Korg is.
>
> si...@star-one.org.uk (Simon Gray) writes:
> >Has it superseded it ? [strad. violin]

>
> Certainly not. Electronics is no where near produces sounds
> that are anything like comparable to the best "real"
> instruments.

A modern tenor trombone produces sounds that are not really
anything like comparable to a "real" sackbut (probably a good
deal further apart than the best electronic synthesis you will
find of either manages to get to its "real" equivalent), but has
effectively superceded it. Sackbuts are very occasionally used
and it's always to perform period works with authentic
instruments.

I think you make a valid point, but I'm not sure it's relevant.
I think this is because Simon's question was not really a
particularly meaningful one to ask. Musical instruments don't
very often supersede one another (the trombone/sackbutt thing
being relatively unusual; the one was effectively an evolution
of the other) as the set of musical instruments just tends to
grow. Both a Korg and a strad are valid and useful instruments.
There's no reason why we should need to chose one and discard
the other. They both have their own appropriate uses.


> >OK, apples & oranges, you might say, try this example - a
> >modern oboe is a completely different instrument to a baroque
> >oboe, but has it superseded it ?
>
> Yes, in the sense that it will be more in tune. No in the
> sense that it's a mass produced piece of rubbish with little
> tone or character!

I think that's a little unfair. Not every oboe being produced
at the moment is mass produced. You'll probably have to pay at
least one (possibly a few) order(s) of magnitude more for one
that isn't but you can certainly get them. I know people who
make musical instruments by hand today, and the instruments they
make are mostly undeniably modern instruments (trumpets in this
case).

I don't know about oboes, but clearly the trombone has succeeded
its predecessor. The two sounds very different. A sackbut is a
very harsh sounding instrument, and will lend a medieval flavour
to any ground it's played in. This is typically not required.
There may well be space to use it in modern music, but in
practice it doesn't happen.


--
Ian Griffiths

madee

unread,
Sep 19, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/19/96
to

d...@kerrera.gla.dcs.ac.uk (The Nit Nurse) wrote:

____ Well Lady, Ole Mel has been around and participating in this
newsgroup a hell of a lot longer than you and for that reason, if no
other, has the right to express his opinion of you and the trashy lot
you rode in with. What happened - wear out your welcome everywhere
else?

madee

unread,
Sep 19, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/19/96
to

rmo...@handel.seattleu.edu (Robert Mobbs) wrote:

<>Ron Kelley (ronk...@earthlink.net) wrote:
<>: d...@kerrera.gla.dcs.ac.uk (The Nit Nurse) wrote:
<>
<>: >So you're another sheep who follows the flock regarding what is
and isn't
<>: >appealing? Thought so..
<>
<>: >Fortunately I consider there to be far more to life than
wandering about
<>: >with things stuck in my ear listening to a blaring cocophany -
irrespective
<>: >of who's making the din. If this is your idea of 'interesting'
you are a
<>: >very sad fellow indeed. I suggest you get out more.
<>
<>: God, I love the British. They sure know how to turn a phrase.
<>
<> Yes, but they cannot spell. I mean, "cocophony"? Plus,
<>we have more bombs.
<>
<> Robert "We saved yer ass in WWII!" Mobbs
<> Microsoft MSTE Software Engineer
<> t-rm...@microsoft.com
<> -
<> "Everyone wants to live at the expense of
<> the state. They forget that the state
<> lives at the expense of everyone."
<> Frederic Bastiat
<><>< Time for some of you people to stop cross posting.<><><

John

unread,
Sep 19, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/19/96
to

In article <dam-180996...@130.209.240.43>

d...@kerrera.gla.dcs.ac.uk "The Nit Nurse" writes:

> |> ...just a thought. If the Nit Nurse hates all forms of music *soo*

> |> violently... why's he/she/it reading uk.music.alternative?
>

> Who mentioned violence? I'm pointing out its simply an art form and I
> don't understand why there is some unwritten rule that if you dislike
> that art form, you must be some sort of 'weirdo'. Are people who don't
> like painting similarly dismissed?...well maybe by those who see a pile
> of bricks and a dead sheep in a pickle tank as 'art'!
>
> ..and I'm reading it in uk.misc

I meant violent in the sense intensely & passionately, rather than the
literal meaning of fist-meets-face-of-music-lover. As for the ng, thank
you for clearing that up.

JT
--
All your dreams will come true. All my dreams came true.
Now I have a bunch of other dreams.
Sonic Youth

MissCP

unread,
Sep 19, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/19/96
to

In article <dam-190996...@130.209.240.43>,

d...@kerrera.gla.dcs.ac.uk (The Nit Nurse) writes:

> Has it occurred to you that most of the people on soc.retirement
don't
>|> care about what most of you call " music" and even less for your
>|> discussion?
>
>And who appointed you spokesman for what 'most people on soc.retirement'
>are interested in then?
>
>

OK group, lets vote. I for one do not enjoy reading the latest posts to
this topic,
but defend nit pickers right to waste my time anyway. Next?

Charlotte Tillman "Mis...@AOL.com"
Family Day Care Provider of
Miss Charlotte's Place in
Northern Virginia

Iain L M Hotchkies

unread,
Sep 19, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/19/96
to

posted to uk.misc only

In message <324136c...@news.hal-pc.org> madee wrote:

> ____ Well Lady, Ole Mel has been around and participating in this
> newsgroup a hell of a lot longer than you and for that reason, if no
> other, has the right to express his opinion of you and the trashy lot
> you rode in with. What happened - wear out your welcome everywhere
> else?

It may just be me but I can't get the image of a horde
of angry geriatrics stubbing away at their keyboards
in frustration.

W. ROLLINS

unread,
Sep 19, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/19/96
to

The Nit Nurse (d...@kerrera.gla.dcs.ac.uk) wrote:
: And who appointed you spokesman for what 'most people on soc.retirement'
: are interested in then?

Please Nit Nurse, you have never contributed to the conversation in
soc.retirement and I have never contributed in
uk.misc,uk.music.altternative alt.fan.lion-king,alt.ph.uk or
alt.music.leonard.cohen and I don't like music because I can't hear the
middle frequencies so even Rhapdody in Blue sounds like Rap to me. I used
to play Clarinet and Oboe in orchestra and drums in a rock band but I'm
more than a little tired of assholes like you crossposting your shit to
newsgroups I can't even subscribe to if I want to and adding in
soc.retirement because it means I have to read posts from dickheads like
you that would be happier if usenet consisted of only one newsgroup so
you could spam to them all at once.

Now I've got to warn you as required by law. I retired from the Navy as a
Chief and I can cuss you so hard it will peel the chrome off your bumper
and I will if you keep crossposting this bullshit. You have no right to
subscribe me to newsgroups I do not care to read. I do not read any of
the groups this is crossposted to except soc.retirement and I've got
nothing better to do than make your life miserable if you continue to
force me to read replies I can't answer.

I don't mind discussing music within my newsgroup selections because I
remember what it was like but I'll be damned if I'll let you decide what
newsgroups I read.

Normally at this point I'd tell you to go fuck yourself but you obviously
don't have the equipment for it.

Is that clear enough?

You are a spammer. You deserve no respect and will get none.

BiNM


madee

unread,
Sep 20, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/20/96
to

Ian Griffiths <igri...@dev.madge.com> wrote:

PLEASE DISCONTINUE CROSSPOSTING THIS MESSAGE TO NEWSGROUPS
WHERE IT IS NOT WANTED.

The Nit Nurse

unread,
Sep 20, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/20/96
to

In article <32418e8d...@news.hal-pc.org>, ma...@hal-pc.org (madee) wrote:

|> Ian Griffiths <igri...@dev.madge.com> wrote:
|> <>
|> <>--
|> <>Ian Griffiths
|> PLEASE DISCONTINUE CROSSPOSTING THIS MESSAGE TO NEWSGROUPS
|> WHERE IT IS NOT WANTED.

PLEASE DISCONTINUE CROSSPOSTING COMPLAINING MESSAGES, ABOUT LOW VOLUME
CROSSPOSTING, TO NEWSGROUPS WHERE IT IS NOT WANTED. THE BEST SOLUTION IS
NOT TO READ THE MESSAGES IF THEY DON'T INTEREST YOU PERSONALLY, JUST AS
YOU WOULD NOT READ A NEWSPAPER ARTICLE IF IT DID NOT INTEREST YOU, RATHER
THAN WRITING TO THE EDITOR COMPLAINING THAT HE PUBLISHED AN ARTICLE
WHICH DIDN"T INTEREST YOU. IN ADDITION, PLEASE GET YOUR CAPS LOCK KEY
FIXED, IT APPEARS TO BE BROKEN.

HOPE THIS HELPS

>

Michael Kilpatrick

unread,
Sep 20, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/20/96
to

Ian Griffiths <igri...@dev.madge.com> writes:

>Michael Kilpatrick wrote:
>>
>>

>A modern tenor trombone produces sounds that are not really
>anything like comparable to a "real" sackbut (probably a good
>deal further apart than the best electronic synthesis you will
>find of either manages to get to its "real" equivalent), but has
>effectively superceded it.


More's the pity!


>> >OK, apples & oranges, you might say, try this example - a
>> >modern oboe is a completely different instrument to a baroque
>> >oboe, but has it superseded it ?
>>
>> Yes, in the sense that it will be more in tune. No in the
>> sense that it's a mass produced piece of rubbish with little
>> tone or character!

>I think that's a little unfair. Not every oboe being produced
>at the moment is mass produced.


True, but stripping it of its generalisation I will stand by the point.
Look at saxophones. I play a 1928 Conn baritone - rather out of tune with
itself, rather tired action, and a few dents here and there. It cost
me UKP1200. I would _never_ pay UKP3500 for a brand new Japanese baritone
saxophone. I don't want something that sounds like a drainpipe, however
perfectly in tune and smoothly running that drainpipe happens to be!


Michael


madee

unread,
Sep 20, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/20/96
to

mkil...@armltd.co.uk (Michael Kilpatrick) wrote:

<>Ian Griffiths <igri...@dev.madge.com> writes:
<>
<>>Michael Kilpatrick wrote:
<>>>
<>>>
<>
<>>

<>Michael
<>
YOUR CONTINUAL CROSS POSTING IS RUDE AND INCONSIDERATE.
IF YOU DON'T KNOW HOW TO USE THE INTERNET STOP! YES I KNOW
I AM SHOUTING.

<>>>>
Cross Posting is a social evil equaling incest<>>>>>>

K. Quinn

unread,
Sep 20, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/20/96
to

ma...@hal-pc.org (madee) wrote:

>YOUR CONTINUAL CROSS POSTING IS RUDE AND INCONSIDERATE.
>IF YOU DON'T KNOW HOW TO USE THE INTERNET STOP! YES I KNOW
>I AM SHOUTING.
>
><>>>>
>Cross Posting is a social evil equaling incest<>>>>>>

.This from the man who just crossposted his message to a
whole load of groups. What a silly billy.

********************************
"I'm so hungry I could eat my earwax - and we
all know how horrid that tastes - right kids?"
- ph...@leeds.ac.uk -

Sean Clayton

unread,
Sep 20, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/20/96
to

d...@kerrera.gla.dcs.ac.uk (The Nit Nurse) wrote:

>
>Iain's a GP, not a spotty student.

Oi! Leave out the complexion references...what happened to student
solidarity anyway?

SC 'Coming soon - uk.music.badger; the ng of the future!'

Ian Griffiths

unread,
Sep 20, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/20/96
to

madee wrote:
>
> [entire message quoted for no obvious reason...]

>
> PLEASE DISCONTINUE CROSSPOSTING THIS MESSAGE TO NEWSGROUPS
> WHERE IT IS NOT WANTED.

OK, but how am I to know? I picked up on this thread a while
after it was started. Which newsgrounds don't want it. I would
guess at alt.fan.lion-king, and I don't know about alt.ph.uk.
What else?


--
Ian Griffiths

Ian Griffiths

unread,
Sep 20, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/20/96
to

madee wrote:
>
> d...@kerrera.gla.dcs.ac.uk (The Nit Nurse) wrote:
>
> <>And who appointed you spokesman for what 'most people on
> <>soc.retirement' are interested in then?
>
> ____ Well Lady,

I think his name's Dave.


> Ole Mel has been around and participating in this newsgroup

Which would that be?


Would the people who keep complaining about the presence of this
thread in 'their' newsgroups please TELL US which newsgroups
they consider themselves to be posting from. With a cross post
you can't tell!


Just for the record I'm cross posting from uk.misc, from my
point of view.


> a hell of a lot longer than you and for that reason, if no
> other, has the right to express his opinion of you and the
> trashy lot you rode in with. What happened - wear out your
> welcome everywhere else?

There's no need to be offensive. Do you not realise that from
the point of view of a uk.misc reader, it looks like a perfectly
ordinary thread was running for a while before lots of strange
people from bizarre groups like alt.fan.lion-king and
soc.retirement invaded it with inexplicable tirades about
unwarranted invasions. Looks like hipocrisy. Obviously once
you've spotted that it's a cross-post thing, then it becomes
clear what's going on. But as crossposts are not affiliated to
any one group, who are you to tell those in some other group
that they are wrong?

--
Ian Griffiths

Ian Griffiths

unread,
Sep 20, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/20/96
to

Michael Kilpatrick wrote:
>
> Ian Griffiths <igri...@dev.madge.com> writes:
>
> >A modern tenor trombone produces sounds that are not really
> >anything like comparable to a "real" sackbut but has

> >effectively superceded it.
>
> More's the pity!

You really think so? Except in so far as a reduction in variety
is something of which to be wary, I'm not convinced that it's so
great a loss. Maybe as a trombonist I'm just biased...


> >Not every oboe being produced at the moment is mass produced.
>
> True, but stripping it of its generalisation I will stand by
> the point. Look at saxophones. I play a 1928 Conn baritone -
> rather out of tune with itself, rather tired action, and a few
> dents here and there. It cost me UKP1200. I would _never_ pay
> UKP3500 for a brand new Japanese baritone saxophone. I don't
> want something that sounds like a drainpipe, however perfectly
> in tune and smoothly running that drainpipe happens to be!

So are you saying that nobody makes saxophones that sound any
good any more? I'm not a saxophonist, so I wouldn't know, but
I'm a little surprised. I'd far rather have a ageing Conn
trombone (or indeed a Blessing, which is what I actually have,
with a nice rose brass bell) than a brand new Yamaha. But I
think I'd prefer a new Conn even more... A brand new one might
not have the character of an old one, but this is not least
because brass instruments acquire character as they are played -
the changes are very definitely tangible. And I think that's
part of the fun.


I think the main point of contention here is that you are (I
think) claiming that no modern instruments have the same
character as good instruments made a long time ago. If we just
factor out the issue of how instruments change purely by virtue
of getting old, I disagree. You can get new instruments now
that are every bit as good as the new instruments being made in
1928.

(Stradivarious would appear to constitute an exception here -
AFAIK the techniques used in making these violins and 'cellos
are no longer known, and so a modern instrument cannot compare.)

If on the other hand you consider the properties that are purely
down to maturity in an instrument as being central to your
argument, then I think I probably agree.


Basically I would claim that large numbers of cheap instruments
have always been made, and it's only the exceptionally good
examples that stay around for ages, and so we get a
diproportionately good set of examples of old instruments.


--
Ian Griffiths

SANDARPA

unread,
Sep 20, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/20/96
to

In article <19960918....@hotch.hotch.demon.co.uk>,
ia...@hotch.demon.co.uk says...
>
>In message <dam-180996...@130.209.240.43> The Nit Nurse wrote:
>
>> In article <323f536e...@news.hal-pc.org>, ma...@hal-pc.org
(madee) wrote:
>>
>> |> ia...@hotch.demon.co.uk (Iain L M Hotchkies) wrote:
>> |>
>> |> <>
>> |> <>Anyway, who says you can't *see* music. Never been to a
>> |> <>Motorhead gig? Just watch them bass bins shakin' and
>> |> <>shimmerin' in the light of the setting sun. Another
>> |> <>good album by the Jam, even if I say so myself.
>> |> <>><
>> |> You people in the UK are really weird.
>>
>> What on earth are you blabbing about now? The subject is Motorhead
>> and bass bins so contribute something rather than whining about things
you
>> claim you don't understand.
>>
>> ObMotorhead: Unplugged album should be in the shops soon.
>
>...movin' like a parallelogram...

I've heard a demo of the new Motorhead:Unplugged album on Radio 2-Rocking
"Jimmy" Young, I think. Lemmy's never sounded better; such a faithful
rendition of their rare stuff such as "Always On My Mind", the "Deadwood
Stage" and the legendary "Yellow Submarine".

Cool funkers! Lemmy-King of the Horlicks drinkers.

PAS.


Anglo Waste

unread,
Sep 20, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/20/96
to

FUCK YOU AND YOUR FUCKING CROSSPOSTING!!!!!!!!!!!

Michael Kilpatrick

unread,
Sep 20, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/20/96
to

Ian Griffiths <igri...@dev.madge.com> writes:

>Michael Kilpatrick wrote:
>>
>> Ian Griffiths <igri...@dev.madge.com> writes:
>>
>>

>> ..........Look at saxophones. I play a 1928 Conn baritone -


>> rather out of tune with itself, rather tired action, and a few
>> dents here and there. It cost me UKP1200. I would _never_ pay
>> UKP3500 for a brand new Japanese baritone saxophone. I don't
>> want something that sounds like a drainpipe, however perfectly
>> in tune and smoothly running that drainpipe happens to be!

>So are you saying that nobody makes saxophones that sound any
>good any more? I'm not a saxophonist, so I wouldn't know, but
>I'm a little surprised.

Well, it's entirely subjective of course, but yes, I am saying so -
I've never liked the sound that Selmers (old or new) made, and the
Bueschers and Conns are no longer produced as they were then, The
modern trend in saxophone sound is harsh and thin with no tone at all -
a cutting edge for projection, but nothing of colour or quality behind
it. A lot of it is in the mouthpiece as well, of course. Metal
mouthpieces with a small square chamber just don't produce the sonority
or creaminess of an older ebonite MP with a larger rounder chamber.

Because the saxophone has a relatively low profile in classical music
it is on popular music where one's attention is drawn to the
instrument. You need to listen to some modern popular music featuring
a saxophone, and then compare it with the beautiful richness of tone of
Johnny Hodges (Duke Ellington orchestra) in the forties, or other
similar artists.


Modern baritones and baritone mouthpieces are an extreme example. If
you've ever heard Harry Carney (Ellington again) you'll know just how
hollow and harsh the modern sound is in comparison.


>I'd far rather have a ageing Conn
>trombone (or indeed a Blessing, which is what I actually have,
>with a nice rose brass bell) than a brand new Yamaha. But I
>think I'd prefer a new Conn even more...

As far as Conn saxophones go, they ended production in the US in the
fifties (I believe) and started producing in Mexico. Some of the classic
Conn Crossbar characteristics were lost in this change (the rolled tone
holes for example). The Conn Crossbar is hence a very sought after
instrument.

> A brand new one might
>not have the character of an old one, but this is not least
>because brass instruments acquire character as they are played -
>the changes are very definitely tangible. And I think that's
>part of the fun.

>I think the main point of contention here is that you are (I
>think) claiming that no modern instruments have the same
>character as good instruments made a long time ago.

Well, the vast majority that I know of and have heard.

>If we just
>factor out the issue of how instruments change purely by virtue
>of getting old, I disagree. You can get new instruments now
>that are every bit as good as the new instruments being made in
>1928.

Not if the 'old style' is out of fashion, you don't!

Michael

Simon Gray

unread,
Sep 20, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/20/96
to

In article <324178...@dev.madge.com>
igri...@dev.madge.com "Ian Griffiths" writes:

~ I think you make a valid point, but I'm not sure it's relevant.
~ I think this is because Simon's question was not really a
~ particularly meaningful one to ask. Musical instruments don't
~ very often supersede one another (the trombone/sackbutt thing
~ being relatively unusual; the one was effectively an evolution
~ of the other) as the set of musical instruments just tends to
~ grow. Both a Korg and a strad are valid and useful instruments.
~ There's no reason why we should need to chose one and discard
~ the other. They both have their own appropriate uses.

I was making the point that to talk of the didjeridu being 'primitive'
& having been 'superseded', as if there is such a thing as 'musical
progress', was a highly patronising ethnocentric comment.

--
[]=- Simon Gray, in Birmingham, EU <*>
// _-=__-= Don't give in to censorship - boycott The Observer
_/|] ) ___ \ & The Guardian.
(_) \___/_(___)_| http://www.mahayana.demon.co.uk/
@ @

Simon Gray

unread,
Sep 20, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/20/96
to

In article <51ug12$g...@Usenet.Logical.NET>
ang...@cyberspace.org "Anglo Waste" writes:

~ FUCK YOU AND YOUR FUCKING CROSSPOSTING!!!!!!!!!!!

FUCK YOU HARDER & YOU BEING A FUCKING DEPRAVED & CORRUPTED KNOBCHEESE !!!!!!

MissCP

unread,
Sep 20, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/20/96
to

Please remove soc.retirement from this thread. 10 cross postings seems
excessive and most of the participants would rather not be a part of the
uk music discussion newsgroups. Thanks in advance

Matt Robinson

unread,
Sep 20, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/20/96
to

In article <uAFQyUpd...@dircon.co.uk>

hadf...@dircon.co.uk "Pam Hadfield" writes:
> In article <323f536e...@news.hal-pc.org>,
> ma...@hal-pc.org (madee) wrote:
> ..........
> :<>><
> :You people in the UK are really weird.
>
> Hey, thanks for the compliment :)

Yeah, right now I'm saving to become eccentric =)

Matt
--
n,
_/ | _ "On the ragged edge of the World
/' `' / I'll roam.
<~ .' And the home of the Wolf
.' | Will be my home."
_/ | -- Robert Service
_/ `.`.
/ ' \__ | | Ma...@machine.demon.co.uk
___/ /__\ \ \ http://www.machine.demon.co.uk
(___.'\_______)\_|_|
/ \
| \

MissCP

unread,
Sep 20, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/20/96
to

Please remove soc.retirement from this thread. Cross postings number 10
newsgroups now and that seems rather excessive.

Iain L M Hotchkies

unread,
Sep 20, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/20/96
to

In message <51ug12$g...@Usenet.Logical.NET> Anglo Waste wrote:

> FUCK YOU AND YOUR FUCKING CROSSPOSTING!!!!!!!!!!!

charming

> In article <Dy1Aq...@aston.ac.uk>, SAND...@aston.ac.uk wrote:
> >In article <19960918....@hotch.hotch.demon.co.uk>,
> >ia...@hotch.demon.co.uk says...
> >>
> >>In message <dam-180996...@130.209.240.43> The Nit Nurse wrote:
> >>

> >>> In article <323f536e...@news.hal-pc.org>, ma...@hal-pc.org
> >(madee) wrote:
> >>>

> >>> |> ia...@hotch.demon.co.uk (Iain L M Hotchkies) wrote:
> >>> |>
> >>> |> <>
> >>> |> <>Anyway, who says you can't *see* music. Never been to a
> >>> |> <>Motorhead gig? Just watch them bass bins shakin' and
> >>> |> <>shimmerin' in the light of the setting sun. Another
> >>> |> <>good album by the Jam, even if I say so myself.
> >>> |> <>><

> >>> |> You people in the UK are really weird.
> >>>

> >>> What on earth are you blabbing about now? The subject is Motorhead
> >>> and bass bins so contribute something rather than whining about things
> >you
> >>> claim you don't understand.
> >>>
> >>> ObMotorhead: Unplugged album should be in the shops soon.
> >>
> >>...movin' like a parallelogram...
> >
> >I've heard a demo of the new Motorhead:Unplugged album on Radio 2-Rocking
> >"Jimmy" Young, I think. Lemmy's never sounded better; such a faithful
> >rendition of their rare stuff such as "Always On My Mind", the "Deadwood
> >Stage" and the legendary "Yellow Submarine".
> >
> >Cool funkers! Lemmy-King of the Horlicks drinkers.
> >
> >PAS.

--
Iain Hotchkies ambition: polymath
currently: jack of all trades
www.hotch.demon.co.uk corollary: master of none

Emily Kelly

unread,
Sep 20, 1996, 3:00:00 AM9/20/96
to

Simon Gray <si...@star-one.org.uk> wrote:
:In article <51ug12$g...@Usenet.Logical.NET>
: ang...@cyberspace.org "Anglo Waste" writes:
:
:~ FUCK YOU AND YOUR FUCKING CROSSPOSTING!!!!!!!!!!!
:
:FUCK YOU HARDER & YOU BEING A FUCKING DEPRAVED & CORRUPTED KNOBCHEESE !!!!!!

Oh dear me, what a pity. Here you have all the opportunity in the world
to make a definitive statement, tell all of us what you really think of
Mr. "Anglo Waste", and this is all you can come up with? For one thing,
it's awfully derivative.

:--

: []=- Simon Gray, in Birmingham, EU <*>
: // _-=__-= Don't give in to censorship - boycott The Observer
: _/|] ) ___ \ & The Guardian.
:(_) \___/_(___)_| http://www.mahayana.demon.co.uk/
: @ @

Er, Phil, I think you've been lending out your velocipede to rather the
wrong element, don't you?

Emily "and everyone please note followups" Kelly
--
Emily Harrison Kelly "Usenet is not a boat."
eke...@acpub.duke.edu --Angus Johnston, AFU

For the AFU FAQ: http://www.urbanlegends.com/afu.faq/

It is loading more messages.
0 new messages