"Jeff Layman" <Je...@invalid.invalid> wrote in message
news:ttpo81$8g7u$1...@dont-email.me...
I've read all three books and watched the first two series so far - we need
to start watching the third series.
My wife, who can remember the plots of the books better than I can, was
confused when certain parts of the TV story were moved around from one
book/series to another - the character of Will Parry was introduced a lot
later in the books than in the TV version, and there were other
rearrangements of events. We both commented that Series 1 and 2 rather
overdid the Magisterium - there were lots of "oh no, not the Magisterium and
it persecutions again". It's a fine line between overdoing it, and not
explaining sufficiently well how all-pervasive the Magisterium was and what
a group of utter bastards they were.
It will be interesting to see what Series 3 is like. We were utterly
captivated by the description in the book of the elephant-like creatures
which travelled around by gripping spherical seed-pods between their claws
and moving on "wheels". I do hope the CGI team have done justice to those
creatures.
Philip Pullman came in for a lot of flak from people who believed in
religion that it painted religions (plural) in a very bad light. I loved his
response, in a biography of him: "I think what I would say to the people who
criticise me for besmirching their religion and telling children that they
should all go out and be Satanists is simply this. What qualities in human
beings does the story celebrate and what qualities does it condemn? And an
honest reading of the story would have to admit that the qualities that the
story celebrates and praises are love, kindness, tolerance, courage,
open-heartedness; and the qualities that the story condemns are cruelty,
intolerance, zealotry, fanaticism. Well who could quarrel with that?"