On 15/05/2022 14:52, Brian wrote:
> Stephen Duppe <
shud...@REMOVE.yahoo.co.uk> wrote:
>> Recently the FSA issued advice that food items may be offered for sale
>> labelled as "sunflower oil" (a product that has become scarcer owing to the
>> Russo-Ukrainian war) which do not actually contain any sunflower oil.
>>
>> See for example this notice at
food.gov.uk:
>>
>>
https://www.food.gov.uk/news-alerts/news/fsa-and-fss-advise-consumers-on-
>> substitution-of-ingredients-in-certain-food-products-to-avoid-food-supply-
>> disruption
>>
>> What statutory or prerogative authority is the FSA exercising when it
>> allows such false labelling?
>>
>> And how does false labelling "avoid food supply disruption"? If sunflower
>> oil is short as a result of the war, then it's short. Labelling can't
>> change that.
>>
>> Stephen
>>
>
> Besides the misleading of consumers, which is serious in itself, it could
> be dangerous for those with allergies.
>
> I’m no expert on allergies but, for example, if a person can consume / use
> sun flower oil but has a nut allergy and buys “ sun flower oil” which is
> actually one of the nut oils, the consequences could be fatal.
It is much more likely that they will cut it with rapeseed oil (which is
generally better tolerated for allergies than sunflower oil).
Provided that the oils are well filtered there is very much less of a
problem with them than with the original whole plant material.
>
> While responsible companies may well add suitable labels / warnings, not
> only are there always unscrupulous ones, the nature of such ingredients
> make tracking use difficult in places like restaurants etc.
>
> Someone hasn’t thought this through.
I think they have made a pragmatic decision to keep food on the shelves.
If you think this is dodgy practice how about the lethal doses of PCBs
in chickens in Belgium when a dodgy feed merchant was cutting fats in
its feed with waste transformer oil PCBs with dioxin as an impurity. It
was mysteriously killing chickens on some farms.
Dioxins made all the headlines but the PCBs are more dangerous.
The scientist who blew the whistle on this scam was prosecuted by their
government for spreading alarm. In fact he was absolutely spot on.
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/11896663/
Bit like with Edwina Curry...
--
Regards,
Martin Brown