In article <
slrnkfb...@realh.co.uk>, Tony Houghton wrote:
> when I discussed this before someone said their S2
> has UMS as an option built-in, even after upgrading to Jelly Bean.
I think that was I ... but I seem to have misled you. My S2 is still on
ICS.
My Note 10.1 table is on JB, and that does not have UMS ... well, it
sorta seems to, but although I can see top-level folders on the phone
from a desktop file manager (Nautilus in Gnome 2 is what I've tried) I
can't see inside the folders (?).
It may be that what I'm seeing is actually MTP with some of the client
support missing -- I believe it's not all standard in Ubuntu Lucid ...
but I haven't had the time or the inclination to look into that. ... I
might a have a play later, as it's clearly of interest ...
It doesn't work from here (XP) either, though here I get a message
telling me that software support is missing from the client (PC) and
suggesting that I install Kies (which is execrable ... but is actually
installed!)
> I assumed, perhaps wrongly, that the lack of UMS is something they
> introduced for newer devices than the S2, so the Tab 2 range isn't
> likely to support it.
I believe the issue is that UMS requires the volume to be unmounted on
the phone, whereas MTP and PTP can be used without unmounting the flash
volume from Android.
If MTP actually worked without requiring special client software it
might be an acceptable solution ... though I gather the MTP interface
doesn't give as much information about the files on the device, nor as
much control over them.
Wikipedia tells me that MTP support is built-in in Windows Vista (and
later?) but only in XP if Windows Media Player 10 (or later?) is
installed. (Windows Media Player is NOT installed here.)
The section headed "Drawbacks" in WP is also interesting ... good
reason to want good old-fashioned UMS, if you ask me!
Cheers,
Daniel.