Google Groups no longer supports new Usenet posts or subscriptions. Historical content remains viewable.
Dismiss
Roof valley repair
324 views
Skip to first unread message
Jethro
Nov 4, 2011, 1:27:12 PM11/4/11
to
During a downpour yesterday, I noticed that (despite me cleaning them in
August) our back guttering was overflowing. A little trip up a ladder
confirmed the cause ... the sodding 90degree route the gutter takes (at
the corner of the "L" our bungalow is shaped like). Anyway, cleaned it
our (where does it all come from ?) and noticed that the cement of the
valley at the join of the 2 roofs (the angle of the "L") was loose.
Not knowing any roofers, and not being happy with the last one we used,
it looks like phoning around again.
Is the best repair to rake out old mortar, and replace with fresh stuff ?
Or is there a more modern solution ?
Given the length of the run is about 4m, and I would want both sides
done, in the absence of any other problems, would a days work be a good
estimate ? 2 days ?
August) our back guttering was overflowing. A little trip up a ladder
confirmed the cause ... the sodding 90degree route the gutter takes (at
the corner of the "L" our bungalow is shaped like). Anyway, cleaned it
our (where does it all come from ?) and noticed that the cement of the
valley at the join of the 2 roofs (the angle of the "L") was loose.
Not knowing any roofers, and not being happy with the last one we used,
it looks like phoning around again.
Is the best repair to rake out old mortar, and replace with fresh stuff ?
Or is there a more modern solution ?
Given the length of the run is about 4m, and I would want both sides
done, in the absence of any other problems, would a days work be a good
estimate ? 2 days ?
Andrew Gabriel
Nov 4, 2011, 3:26:57 PM11/4/11
to
In article <QfVsq.15932$604....@newsfe05.ams2>,
Half a day for a pro.
The pointing is really just to stop water being blown under the
edges in a strong wind. The valley should otherwise be waterproof
without any pointing, although failing pointing might cause water
to be rerouted back under the tiles. After relaying my valley but
before I had pointed it, I had an enormous down-pour, and nothing
came through - turned out to be a good test.
--
Andrew Gabriel
[email address is not usable -- followup in the newsgroup]
The pointing is really just to stop water being blown under the
edges in a strong wind. The valley should otherwise be waterproof
without any pointing, although failing pointing might cause water
to be rerouted back under the tiles. After relaying my valley but
before I had pointed it, I had an enormous down-pour, and nothing
came through - turned out to be a good test.
--
Andrew Gabriel
[email address is not usable -- followup in the newsgroup]
Kipper at sea
Nov 4, 2011, 8:16:17 PM11/4/11
to
ample time to do the job. trying to stick new mortor to lod donst work
especaly on roofing work. the mortor is there to support the small cut
tiles from dropping down out of alignment.
js.b1
Nov 5, 2011, 11:17:59 AM11/5/11
to
On Nov 5, 12:16 am, Kipper at sea <keith.ra...@ntlworld.com> wrote:
> No good just pointing, needs taking out completly, 3/4 day should be
> ample time to do the job. trying to stick new mortor to lod donst work
> especaly on roofing work. the mortor is there to support the small cut
> tiles from dropping down out of alignment.
Indeed, remove old, put in new.
> No good just pointing, needs taking out completly, 3/4 day should be
> ample time to do the job. trying to stick new mortor to lod donst work
> especaly on roofing work. the mortor is there to support the small cut
> tiles from dropping down out of alignment.
I think SBR can be added to the mix to aid bonding/waterproofing,
Screwfix do Cementone for about £20 per 5L. I think it is more
commonly used for multiple pour post foundations (or three poor with
rebar as I did "oops, run out again" :-)
What is the latest you can do re-bed ridge tiles re weather?
My mother has almost all the pointing out in the SW facing diagonal,
pointing at a SW facing road, exposed to SW prevailing wind. I know
there is a problem with water penetration from the stench when
drilling the box room ceiling and there is loft insulation over every
room except the SW corner box room so the insulation people knew. No
tiles out, but it does not take much water ingress and sagging felt to
load the eaves.
Calvin Sambrook
Nov 6, 2011, 5:56:51 PM11/6/11
to
"Jethro" <krazy...@googlemail.com> wrote in message
news:QfVsq.15932$604....@newsfe05.ams2...
What a coincidence, during a downpour at 4am the other night I was woken up
by water pouring through the bedroom ceiling, or rather by my partner who
couldn't ignore the dripping sound any longer, not nice. We have the same
valley arrangement, in our case formed when an extension was added at 90
degrees to the original roof. It wasn't obvious at first what had happened
but after stripping back the tiles it turned out that the original battens
had been cut flush to the wood forming the base of the valley so some of
them were unsupported for up to 600mm and the heavy concrete tiles had made
them sag over the years so pulling the lead into a low spot.
Two of us spent about 4 hours fixing it, stripping the tiles off one side,
adding wood to support the battens, refitting and repacking with fresh
mortar. Ours is a house so access was 5m up a ladder, yours will be easier
I guess. Our tiles are simply clipped over the battens so removal is
trivial, other fixing methods may slow you down (place the cut tiles to one
side on the same row so you know which one came from where when you refit).
Strip form the top-down and refit from the bottom-up. Given that we were
fixing a design problem as well as repacking I reckon you could do both
sides of a valley in a day, easily, provided you don't hit any major snags
like broken tiles etc.
BTW you won't get a roof ladder into the valley area (if you think about it
the ladder length would need to vary as you moved up) so you'll be walking
on the tiles. For safety's sake we slung a line over the roof and tied it
off on the other side of the house. If you have a climbing harness you can
clip on at a length which would stop you going over the edge but even if you
don't it at least provides you with a hand hold.
Oh, and one more thing to consider, there's nowhere to put a cup of tea on a
roof.
news:QfVsq.15932$604....@newsfe05.ams2...
by water pouring through the bedroom ceiling, or rather by my partner who
couldn't ignore the dripping sound any longer, not nice. We have the same
valley arrangement, in our case formed when an extension was added at 90
degrees to the original roof. It wasn't obvious at first what had happened
but after stripping back the tiles it turned out that the original battens
had been cut flush to the wood forming the base of the valley so some of
them were unsupported for up to 600mm and the heavy concrete tiles had made
them sag over the years so pulling the lead into a low spot.
Two of us spent about 4 hours fixing it, stripping the tiles off one side,
adding wood to support the battens, refitting and repacking with fresh
mortar. Ours is a house so access was 5m up a ladder, yours will be easier
I guess. Our tiles are simply clipped over the battens so removal is
trivial, other fixing methods may slow you down (place the cut tiles to one
side on the same row so you know which one came from where when you refit).
Strip form the top-down and refit from the bottom-up. Given that we were
fixing a design problem as well as repacking I reckon you could do both
sides of a valley in a day, easily, provided you don't hit any major snags
like broken tiles etc.
BTW you won't get a roof ladder into the valley area (if you think about it
the ladder length would need to vary as you moved up) so you'll be walking
on the tiles. For safety's sake we slung a line over the roof and tied it
off on the other side of the house. If you have a climbing harness you can
clip on at a length which would stop you going over the edge but even if you
don't it at least provides you with a hand hold.
Oh, and one more thing to consider, there's nowhere to put a cup of tea on a
roof.
Jethro
Nov 7, 2011, 5:16:33 AM11/7/11
to
someone elses problem ... I really struggle with heights - even on a
bungalow !!!
However it's nice to have a rough benchmark to be able to filter out any
workman who try to take the piss, and say it's a weeks job etc etc ...
0 new messages