Google Groups no longer supports new Usenet posts or subscriptions. Historical content remains viewable.
Dismiss

is 10Mbs fast enough for home gaming?

0 views
Skip to first unread message

Me

unread,
Mar 17, 2002, 7:15:23 PM3/17/02
to
I have 2 pcs currently connected with 10/100 nics via a crossover cable.
I've just bought a cheap secondhand (£10) 10Mbs hub. how much slower will
this be than the direct cross over link that I currently have?

At the moment I can play castlewolf, and unreal, and medal of honor 2 people
super smooth. When I put the hub on and try to play 3 people will things
craw? Should I scrap the idea of 10mbs and get 100mb hub?

cheers


Luke Wakeling

unread,
Mar 17, 2002, 7:32:26 PM3/17/02
to
> I have 2 pcs currently connected with 10/100 nics via a crossover cable.
> I've just bought a cheap secondhand (£10) 10Mbs hub. how much slower will
> this be than the direct cross over link that I currently have?
1/10th the speed.

> At the moment I can play castlewolf, and unreal, and medal of honor 2
people
> super smooth. When I put the hub on and try to play 3 people will things
> craw? Should I scrap the idea of 10mbs and get 100mb hub?

For a 3-person game you should have a problem. I've played upto 8 player
games on a 10Mbps LAN before. The time you will notice the speed is if you
are downloading maps from the server - this can take ages.

Luke


Ian Clark

unread,
Mar 17, 2002, 8:07:21 PM3/17/02
to

"Me" <n...@nohotmail.com> wrote in message
news:3c953...@news.greennet.net...

> I have 2 pcs currently connected with 10/100 nics via a crossover cable.
> I've just bought a cheap secondhand (Ł10) 10Mbs hub. how much slower will

> this be than the direct cross over link that I currently have?
>
> At the moment I can play castlewolf, and unreal, and medal of honor 2
people
> super smooth. When I put the hub on and try to play 3 people will things
> craw? Should I scrap the idea of 10mbs and get 100mb hub?
>


10Mb is Fine.

If you think that for broadband Internet for example Cable Modem broadband,
you are only required to have a 10Mb Ethernet card. 100mb is not necessary.

And also that Online gaming is not a problem through a 512Mb CM and 10Mb
NIC-Damn good fun infact :o)

As has already been mentioned, where you would notice a major increase is in
File transfer. - And that is only viable if using an NT or *Nix based OS.

Win9x and ME are just pants for File transfer :o)


Me

unread,
Mar 18, 2002, 6:38:08 AM3/18/02
to
cool, so 10mbs should be find for gaming huh?

Funny but the other day I had pings of 1-5 with unreal betwen my xp machine
and a buddies xp latptop via crossover cable and when I do the same between
my xp and win 98 machines I get 60-70 ping. is that expected.

also, how do I check to see what speed 10 or 100 my cards are connected at?

cheers for all the info guys...

"Ian Clark" <sparh...@hotmail.com> wrote in message
news:a73ek5$id4rq$1...@ID-110861.news.dfncis.de...

Luke Wakeling

unread,
Mar 18, 2002, 7:05:05 AM3/18/02
to
"Me" <n...@nohotmail.com> wrote in message
news:3c95d...@news.greennet.net...

> cool, so 10mbs should be find for gaming huh?
yep.

> Funny but the other day I had pings of 1-5 with unreal betwen my xp
machine
> and a buddies xp latptop via crossover cable and when I do the same
between
> my xp and win 98 machines I get 60-70 ping. is that expected.

To ping my W9x box from a linux box I get a maximum of about 750us
(microsecs) which is so fast the windows can't measure it (reports >10ms).
So I wouldn't trust windows to report it correctly. Also if you're playing
across the internet then you'll be lucky to get anything less than 100ms so
I wouldn't worry about it.

> also, how do I check to see what speed 10 or 100 my cards are connected
at?

Look at the lights on the cards. Or I think XP shows the speed in the
network properties.

> "Ian Clark" <sparh...@hotmail.com> wrote in message
> news:a73ek5$id4rq$1...@ID-110861.news.dfncis.de...

[snip]


> > File transfer. - And that is only viable if using an NT or *Nix based
OS.

but don't games which autodownload use their own transfer protocol?

> > Win9x and ME are just pants for File transfer :o)

it's quicker to FTP!

Luke


Conor Turton

unread,
Mar 18, 2002, 9:34:43 AM3/18/02
to
In article <3c953...@news.greennet.net>, n...@nohotmail.com says...
It will be the same. Ping times etc exactly the same. As games send
minimal info (Counterstrike is 7k/sec tops) and you can run a 16 player
DFLW server from an ADSL connection which is 1/40th of your hub speed
then you are OK for a good few dozen players.


--
_________________________
Conor Turton
conor_...@hotmail.com
ICQ:31909763
_________________________

/|ndy |<avanagh

unread,
Mar 18, 2002, 3:44:37 PM3/18/02
to
Soni tempori elseu romani yeof helsforo nisson ol sefini ill des Mon,
18 Mar 2002 00:15:23 -0000, sefini jorgo geanyet des mani yeof do
uk.comp.home-networking, yawatina tan reek esk "Me" <n...@nohotmail.com>
fornis do marikano es bono tan el:

>I have 2 pcs currently connected with 10/100 nics via a crossover cable.

>I've just bought a cheap secondhand (Ł10) 10Mbs hub. how much slower will


>this be than the direct cross over link that I currently have?
>
>At the moment I can play castlewolf, and unreal, and medal of honor 2 people
>super smooth. When I put the hub on and try to play 3 people will things
>craw? Should I scrap the idea of 10mbs and get 100mb hub?

10 is easily fast enough, but the price of an 8-port 10/100 switch is
only about Ł40 now.


deKay
--
o /|ndy's Lofi Gaming -- www.lofi-gaming.org.uk o
/ Emulation * News * Reviews * Museum * Speccy \
-[ My computer runs at 3.5MHz and I'm proud of that ]-
\ Fave game this week: Golden Sun (Gameboy Advance) /
o May the chuntey be with you! o

Me

unread,
Mar 18, 2002, 2:42:33 PM3/18/02
to
thanks guys. I'm really impressed with the amount of info you gave me. I'll
put everythig to the test in the next week or so when I get the hub.

cheers,
jason
"Conor Turton" <conor_...@hotmail.com> wrote in message
news:MPG.17000b598...@news.claranews.com...

0 new messages