Starfleet Academy seems to have been more decisive than the average Trek series, but I personally really enjoyed the first season and am looking forward to the second, bittersweet tho it may be. (As a DS9 fan, Episode 5 broke me.)
While fans were hoping the show would get the four-season run it seemed to be designed for, there was a feeling of inevitability given Paramount's current ownership and their worldview; Star Trek and MAGA simply don't mesh, plus science fiction is expensive to make (although Paramount Skydance seems to have enough money to buy an entire freakin' studio/media conglomerate). Part of me wishes Paramount would either go all in on Trek and let the franchise be what it needs to be, or sell it to another studio - although I'm not entirely sure who would be the best shepherd of the Trek IP right now; Warners is a non-starter, Disney wouldn't take it on because they've already got Star Wars, Amazon's sitting on Stargate and who knows what else...I guess that leaves Netflix and Apple?