Why poetry?

110 views
Skip to first unread message

blo...@fthamiltonhs.org

unread,
Feb 13, 2013, 8:45:20 AM2/13/13
to transition...@googlegroups.com
In the article, "Why Poetry?" by Mark Polonsky, what is his most efective argument for reading poetry?
 

loudonstudent

unread,
Feb 20, 2013, 10:23:32 AM2/20/13
to transition...@googlegroups.com
Testing a reply!

JUN HAO FENG

unread,
Feb 21, 2013, 3:19:02 PM2/21/13
to transition...@googlegroups.com
I think the most effective argument for reading poetry in the article, "Why Poetry?" by Mark Polonsky is that “ It might reveal a new perspective, dazzle your mind’s eye,
broaden your inner vision”.  In the article, Mark had said that poetry expand our mind which means it helps us to accept and learn a variety of things.  So, we won’t be trapped inside a box when we encounter an obstacle.   Mark also compare poetry to yoga, and I think he is absolutely right.  Poetry give us many perspective on a certain topic, and this give us a new insight and a better understanding over a this topic.  This is exactly like yoga.  Yoga stretch our body and poetry stretch our mind.  Whenever we are reading a poem, there will always be a surprise for us.  We will find something new, something we never think about before in the poem.  Thus, our view of the world is broaden by poetry.

ZHAO FENG TUNG

unread,
Feb 21, 2013, 4:20:23 PM2/21/13
to transition...@googlegroups.com
He was telling that the poem is not something you read a novel or newspaper and we have to read it slow and more times to understand what is the words mean. He saying that we know only the poem basic not the whole body like a children know how to swim but they do not how to swim well, so i think the most effective argument in the article is the poem have many meaning in there and we have to find it by yourself.  

JIA YIN HUANG

unread,
Feb 21, 2013, 5:00:30 PM2/21/13
to transition...@googlegroups.com
 The author's most efective argument for reading poetry is everything in the world which can make us imagery something or touch our feeling all can call "poetry". Read the poem not like read newspaper or norvels, we need separet to many pices to look at it. We need pay more attentiona to really understand the poem's theme or most inportant message.In page 3 the author said " A poem requires patience. that is why the first and most essential tool in our toolkit is patience." here reveals the author's opinion if we want to really understand the poem we need read once twice third and so on. Many deeper message hide behind the words. In differents ways to look at or think about the poetry, you will get more closer to the real theme.

HAI LUN MEI

unread,
Feb 21, 2013, 5:19:45 PM2/21/13
to transition...@googlegroups.com

      I think the most effective argument is patience and imagination.  If we have these two points to read poetry, we will understand it and no mistake. If we just read one time or two times, we cannot understand, we need read more times to feel and experience. We cannot because of it is hard to understand or something, so, we don’t keep going to read, that’s so terrible, we don’t understand the poetry forever. Imagination is also important, when we read poetry, we should imagine the poet’s feeling and poetry’s poetic. If the poetry have literary techniques, we need to imagine what is that mean and why poet will use it. Patience and Imagination are also important to us when we reading poetry, if we bring these two points to read, we can understand, we can do it.

YING ZHOU

unread,
Feb 21, 2013, 6:26:54 PM2/21/13
to transition...@googlegroups.com
Mr.L
      The most effective argument : poetry is like music, contains rhythms which may affect your mood and spirit. Poetry contain words, and these words cast little spells as they sing in people' mind.Both poetry and music engage people' imagination, people must have imagination for music or poetry to derive interest.

JIA HUANG WEI

unread,
Feb 21, 2013, 7:38:20 PM2/21/13
to transition...@googlegroups.com
      His most efective argument for reading poetry is poetry expands the mind ;Poetry uses the strongest language contracting with prejudice and bigotry to express us the expassion of things ,once we have a expanded thinking , we would like to think in ways that widely open without circumscribing its possibilities.

KUNJUN JIANG

unread,
Feb 21, 2013, 8:05:58 PM2/21/13
to transition...@googlegroups.com
  I think the author of "Why Poetry" is telling us that reading a poem can help our understanding, fancy and our mood. We need inner peace and patience to know the meaning of the poem. You have to use your fancy to imagine the scene of the poem.  Use patience to read the poem again, again and again to understand it's meaning. And our mood will change during the reading of the poem, we can feel the emotion of the author when he is writting the poem.

XIAOYAN ZHANG

unread,
Feb 21, 2013, 11:04:37 PM2/21/13
to transition...@googlegroups.com
      In this article "Why Poetry?" by Mark Polonsky, the most effective argument for reading poetry is patience. The author said that the patience is the first and most essential tool in our poetry. Some poetry is indigestible, very hard to connect the word to word or sentence to sentence, so you need to go back to read more times until
you get the message from the words or  sentence. You need patience for that to read and comprehend the poetry. In the last page, the author states the patience is to poetry as electricity  is to the vacuum cleaner. We need patience to read a poetry, like author said it will light up your imagination in some way.

ZHI YI ZHANG

unread,
Feb 22, 2013, 6:08:39 PM2/22/13
to transition...@googlegroups.com
 THe author think the most efective argument for reading poetry is need to be Patient,use the time to understanding the deep meaning of the poem.All the think cant not just pop out from you heat.every poetry is "time" plus the "knowledge" to build the understanding of deep meaning.

PANG YEN WU

unread,
Feb 22, 2013, 6:21:24 PM2/22/13
to transition...@googlegroups.com
The most efective argument for reading poetry in the article"Why Poetry"by Mark Polonsky is that the poetry using the descrition of the poems to let us know the good part of the poetry and those stuff is written in the article like patience i think this author is the poem lover because he use those words to written the thing in the article make me feel like i want to read the poem right now so i think that the power of it and in the article it also said that Poetry is an imagination machine. Good poetry, given patience, lights up your imagination in some way. It surprises you, tickles you, gives you a nudge, or even awes you. It might reveal a new perspective, dazzle your mind's eye, broaden your inner vision.i think this shot paragraph can tell us when you read the poem how will your felling be and the picture eill come out from your brain so the poetry is the powerful stuff for the reading perrfisior .

YUWEI LIU

unread,
Feb 24, 2013, 4:10:31 PM2/24/13
to transition...@googlegroups.com
I think the most effective argument is ponder and image. Because when we read some  very difficult poem. We can't understand, what mean is the author really wants our to know. then we need to read again and again. Except of that, when we read the poem, we can try in our mind to image the scene. It will be help us easy to understand the poem's really meaning.

CUI JIN LU

unread,
Feb 26, 2013, 3:43:17 PM2/26/13
to transition...@googlegroups.com
    
In the article, "why poetry?"by Mark Polonsky,his most effective argument for reading poetry is patience.Patience is very imoprtant for your reading and doing something.You need to carefully read again and again. Then,you will find the hidden in the meaning of the words.If you get the poem,you will feeling different,and it will affect your mood and your spirit.So,I think his most effective argument for reading poetry is pantience.

MING SHI ZOU

unread,
Feb 27, 2013, 7:34:13 PM2/27/13
to transition...@googlegroups.com
         I think the most effective argument are patience and writing technique. When we read an article or poetry, we can't do not understand the article or poetry to give up, We should be patient to read more times about the poetry, to find the author want to tell us what message through poetry. The patience to read a poem is very important key. A beautiful poem, read several times, this to our English writing ability have greatly improved. And a beautiful, full of connotation of the poem, it contains the author's cultural deposits. Use many writing technique to improve the level of poetry, such as metaphor, personification, imagination, etc. And writing technique will also help us to understand the theme of the poetry.

XIN YANG

unread,
Feb 27, 2013, 10:30:24 PM2/27/13
to transition...@googlegroups.com
I did it already, and I have sent it to you.But now I cannot find the answer.

YIWEN JIANG

unread,
Feb 28, 2013, 4:27:38 PM2/28/13
to transition...@googlegroups.com
Poetry is important to us like air,poetry is important because it allows a creative way to express own feelings and poems show us that there are so many ways to express and convey the human condition. So poems can inspire us to think about something is important of the human race.
Reply all
Reply to author
Forward
0 new messages