Error 30 FPS for PAL...

[Kazik]

Hi, 

Creating DVD with PAL option (script below) creates the file animenu1-1.mpg (the file for spumux) with 30/FPS. 
The value 30/FPS is for NTSC and isn't correct for PAL. 
Temporary I found for PAL the solution - I changed (forced) in the todisc file the values as follow:

< TV_STANDARD=ntsc
> TV_STANDARD=pal

< PIXEL_AR="10:11"
> PIXEL_AR="59:54"

< FRAME_RATE=29.970 
> FRAME_RATE=25 

< ff_frame_rate="30000/1001"
> ff_frame_rate="25/1"

< VIDSIZE=720x480
> VIDSIZE=720x576


#!/bin/bash

export LANG=en_US

tovid  disc \
        -menu-title "" \
        -overwrite \
        -files  \
                001.mpeg \
                002.mpeg \
                003.mpeg \
                004.mpeg \
        -titles \
                "Title 1" \
                "Title 2" \
                "Title 3" \
                "Title 4" \
        -out ../out \
        -pal \
        -aspect 4:3 \
        -noask \
        -loop 1 \ 
        -menu-audio-fade 3 \ 
        -menu-length 45 \
        -background background.jpg \
        -bgaudio menu.wav \
        -playall \
        -button-style rect \
        -align south \
        -keepfiles \
        -keep-files \
        -3dthumbs \
        -dvd


Regards,
Kazik

[grepper]

Hi Kazik. Sorry for your trouble. Read on for the fix:)

On 19/05/14 03:05 PM, Kazik wrote:
> Hi,
>
> Creating DVD with PAL option (script below) creates the file animenu1-1.mpg (the file for spumux) with 30/FPS.
> The value 30/FPS is for NTSC and isn't correct for PAL.
> Temporary I found for PAL the solution - I changed (forced) in the todisc file the values as follow:

Just add ff_frame_rate="25/1" in the "pal" section, so it should read:

elif [ $TV_STANDARD = "pal" ]; then
VIDSIZE="720x576"
TILE_ARRAY=("${TILE_1333[@]}")
FRAME_RATE=25
ff_frame_rate="25/1"

I'm not sure how that got removed because it used to work afaik, perhaps
a botched commit was made. If you could test it it would be great, I've
attached the diff to current svn version. Anyway, I'll commit the fix asap.

snip
>
> Regards,
> Kazik

all the best,
grepper

[grepper]

Okay, its committed to current svn. Please do test though.

all the best,
grepper

[Kazik]

OK - solved. After applying your patch animenu is 25/FPS.

Thanks for your hard job,
Kazik

[Marc Grondin]

just want to say thank you to you grepper for still supporting this great software after all these years.

Marc Grondin

--
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "tovid-users" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to tovid-users...@googlegroups.com.
For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/d/optout.

[grepper]

Great, thanks very much. Just out of interest Kazik, why do you export
LANG ? Is it because of the printf issue? I thought r3497 commit fixed that:
http://code.google.com/p/tovid/issues/detail?id=85

But perhaps there is another reason you need en_US in your script ...

all the best,
Robert

[grepper]

On 20/05/14 02:15 PM, Marc Grondin wrote:
> just want to say thank you to you grepper for still supporting this
> great software after all these years.
>
> Marc Grondin

Thanks Marc, its always nice to hear feedback like that :)
I don't really have much time to devote to it any more so I have tried
to just stay with bug fixes and staying up with ffmpeg and avconv
developments.

I would have released 0.35 a long time ago but since makemenu had been
removed in svn I had wanted to adjust todisc so it would work without
transcode, cutting down on dependencies for static menus. I just haven't
had time. Perhaps I will just release it.

all the best,
Robert

[Kazik]

W dniu środa, 21 maja 2014 00:11:34 UTC+2 użytkownik grepper napisał:

On 20/05/14 02:01 PM, Kazik wrote:
> OK - solved. After applying your patch animenu is 25/FPS.
>
> Thanks for your hard job,
> Kazik

Great, thanks very much. Just out of interest Kazik, why do you export
LANG ?

I use Linux in the Polish language. Translation of some system messages on the Polish language is inaccurate. English system messages sometimes give more information.

Kazik

[grepper]

Ah, okay, just wondered. Thanks.

Cheers,
Robert