Coros Heart Rate Monitor Accuracy

0 views
Skip to first unread message

Casio Bauman

unread,
Aug 5, 2024, 2:06:39 AM8/5/24
to thornnegfuncwa
ButI also used a COROS APEX 2 Pro watch as a comparison point, a Garmin Forerunner 955, and a Garmin chest strap (HRM-PRO Plus). In other words, plenty of competitive options here to see how things handled. And, I got my wife involved too with her running interval workouts.

(Note: All of the charts in these accuracy portions were created using the DCR Analyzer tool. It allows you to compare power meters/trainers, heart rate, cadence, speed/pace, running power, GPS tracks and plenty more. You can use it as well for your own gadget comparisons, more details here.)


It looks to me like there is some signal issue when pairing the COROS HR Monitor with a non-COROS watch so I would love to see if your further testing confirms this issue. Not sure why there is such a difference compared to pairing to a COROS watch.


Dear Ray, I noted that when out its cold, near 10C the strap doesnt works good, not only on intervals of one minute but even on long runs, i see various spikes in the graph, even if i wear longsleeve shirt. Did you notice it?


Once the armband is added in the Coros app, on my Garmin Forerunner I had to go into Settings > Sensors & Accesories > Add new. Now I just throw it on my arm before my run and my watch automatically connects to it.


Hey thanks for coming back with a reply.

I have paired it with the COROS phone app, but it registers no activity. I paired it with Strava and the pairing worked, but I wonder if i have to start the activity on Strava itself on my phone to make it work rather than what I have been doing which is letting it link to my Garmin then starting my activity from Garmin. I hope that makes sense?


Thank you Ray for the review! Quick question: when paired with a Garmin, how can you see that the HR recording was indeed made with the Coros? Reason I am asking is that I do not find any hint in the activity details; in contrast to some recent Garmin products like the HR Pro, it is also not shown in the device section of the activity. Best, Marcel


Wanna save some cash and support the site? These companies help support the site! With Backcountry.com or Competitive Cyclist with either the coupon code DCRAINMAKER for first time users saving 15% on applicable products.


Heart rate (HR) remains one of the most used metrics in the sports community to measure intensity. It is a relevant tool to use and monitor for multiple purposes, from clinical assessments to sports performance. While there are two main ways to measure HR during exercise, they each present their pros and cons in practical settings. Now with our new COROS Heart Rate Monitor, we have taken the best of both worlds to create a reliable and comfortable tool to assist you in your training journey.


While the new COROS Heart Rate Monitor uses optical sensors, the area from which they are taking the measurements varies, which is truly where the game-changer comes from. This new tool now has taken the best of both worlds, optical and ECG sensors, by keeping their strengths and therefore attenuating their weaknesses.


Heart rate is a reflection of how much your body is working at any given moment. However, the body has to follow a strict chain of reactions before you can actually see a difference in your heart rate. If you suddenly start a 400m sprint, your muscles will send a signal to your brain requiring more oxygen, which will then send a signal back to the heart to increase pumping and bring hemoglobin (transporter of oxygen) to the working muscles. This whole process takes about 20-30sec to notice at the heart level. If you take a measurement at the wrist, far away from the heart, this delay is even longer as you are waiting for the blood flow spike to reach this point.


Cadence lock is an unfortunate event that occurs when the optical sensors in the watch capture your cadence instead of your heart rate. This incident is often due to the noise created by external factors (e.g., your cadence) as well as the low blood volume at your wrist. When wearing the COROS HR Monitor around your biceps, you reduce the noise and increase the blood volume, therefore limiting chances of creating cadence lock in your data!


Although chest straps use a more sophisticated way (ECG) to capture HR, they remain highly uncomfortable to wear regardless of the activity. With the Heart Rate Monitor's soft fabric band, you will forget you are even wearing it and therefore focus on what is truly important- your training.


Not to mention all the actionable insights that your heart rate data gives you during the recovery phase of training too; your heart is essentially your engine, and to understand it is to master your fitness.


The heart of the COROS monitor is its latest generation multi-channel optical sensor, designed to provide accurate, reliable data on your heart rate. The optical sensor works by measuring blood flow in the capillaries beneath your skin.


While this can sometimes be challenging on the wrist (due to sweat, and skin color for example), the bicep location offers the sensor optimal blood flow, resulting in accuracy equivalent to that of a traditional chest strap.


This is particularly beneficial for runners as it removes the need for manual pairing, saving precious time before a run. It also eliminates the risk of forgetting to switch your monitor on, ensuring every beat is counted from the moment you hit the road or trail.


Each of these features adds to the overall enjoyment of user experience, making the COROS Heart Rate Monitor an efficient and user-friendly device for runners seeking to monitor their heart rate accurately and comfortably without the added complication of a convoluted user setup.


For one, my breathing always felt constricted especially when running at high intensities, and secondly if I was running an ultra marathon or marathon for that matter then the HR band would end up slipping down to my waist due to sweat and my body composition changing after running at a high intensity for more than 3 hours or so, and tightening it during a race would become a real annoyance.


Personally, I have never experienced any inaccuracies with on-wrist heart rate monitors, this includes when using brands such as Garmin, Suunto, Apple watch, and Polar but I have always gone for the premium models which were of course more expensive.


In my experience most of the runners who report having inaccurate wrist based heart rate data comes down to how well secured the watch is on their wrist, how sweaty you get, and how quickly you swing your arms.


I personally love the Coros heart rate monitor. It pairs with my Garmin, Suunto, and Coros watches. I used to wear the Garmin HRM pro+ heart rate monitor but it would irritate and rub my skin raw on my chest. I also hated changing the battery. The Coros hrm is rechargeable, easy to put on and very lightweight. I forget I have it on!


I thought it was a chest strap until it arrived, and I realized there was no way my entire torso would fit in there. So once I figured out where it was supposed to go, I read the directions and slid it on. The best place for Optical Heart Rate sensors is having the sensor on the outside of your arm. I wish they explained this more because I had no idea until I googled it.


The best spot to wear the heart rate monitor is for the optical heart rate sensors to be on the outside of your upper arm (your bicep). The goal is to avoid situations where your heart rate monitor bumps things (like your chest, side of the body), which is why wrist-based heart rate is usually inaccurate.


The circular array of 5 sensors is used by many chest and bicep-based heart rate monitors (including Polar and Apple). Did you know optical heart rate sensors use light to measure blood flow in capillaries under the skin? The top of your wrist is a great spot for a watch, but it is hard to gather that information due to a lack of blood flow. Wearing a heart rate monitor on your arm allows more blood flow and more accurate data.


Coros says: their latest generation multi-channel optical sensor provides high signal quality. It is protected in a tough, scratch-resistant cover and will deliver reliable and accurate heart rate data for years.


Renowned for making some of the best sports watches, Coros has moved into the heart rate monitor market with the launch of the Coros Heart Rate Monitor. This excellent device is one of the best heart rate monitors around, mainly due to how easy it is to use: Just slip it on your arm and it turns itself on, links with your watch and starts tracking.


The band has no buttons, instead turning on automatically when you put it on and then turning itself off when you take it off. The rechargeable battery lasts for 38 hours of active tracking, or up to 80 days in standby mode.


Over the course of that long run, which was almost five hours, the Coros monitor was so comfortable as to be unnoticeable, and it stayed connected to my watch and delivered reliable readings throughout.


You will still get slightly more reliable results using one of the best chest straps, like the Polar H9 or H10, and with chest straps like the Garmin HRM-Pro Plus you can also get extra stats like running dynamics.


Nick Harris-Fry is a journalist who has been covering health and fitness since 2015. Nick is an avid runner, covering 70-110km a week, which gives him ample opportunity to test a wide range of running shoes and running gear. He is also the chief tester for fitness trackers and running watches, treadmills and exercise bikes, and workout headphones."}), " -0-10/js/authorBio.js"); } else console.error('%c FTE ','background: #9306F9; color: #ffffff','no lazy slice hydration function available'); Nick Harris-FrySocial Links NavigationSenior writerNick Harris-Fry is a journalist who has been covering health and fitness since 2015. Nick is an avid runner, covering 70-110km a week, which gives him ample opportunity to test a wide range of running shoes and running gear. He is also the chief tester for fitness trackers and running watches, treadmills and exercise bikes, and workout headphones.

3a8082e126
Reply all
Reply to author
Forward
0 new messages