I'd love to take credit for all this, but a friend of mine came up with this theory so I'm just gonna cut and paste since she's much smarter than me anyways
I can totally see the Trading Spaces scenario going on here. Jacob and
'friend' in a centuries long chess game to each prove their point (and
possibly off the other). Jacob for free will, hope in humanity and the
‘variable’ and the Man in Black (Esau, Randall Flagg - ha!) for fate,
the evilness of man and ‘the constant’. The time travel brings a
progressive ‘cycle’ into the mix, with the hope that with each try our
characters get closer to ‘getting things right’. For all we know, this
may have happened many times over already. This is the idea behind
Stephen King’s The Dark Tower series (an influence on the writers) and
also hinted at with the original name of the show - “The Circle”.
Ultimately, all the rest of the characters then fall into being pawns
for this game, as Jacob blatantly points out to Ben (crushed now by the
realization that he, Richard, and even Widmore and Hawking are all
small fry in this game). It’s a long con. The hope is one little change
can cause a ripple that alters the outcome. Juliet setting off the bomb
last night can be just that.
The statue looks like a combo,
having the body of Sobek and the head of Taweret, the ancient Egyptian
goddess of maternity and c
hildbirth, protector of women and children.
Does destroying the statue explain why women can no longer give birth
on the island? Also, in the Book of the Dead, Taweret was seen as a
goddess who guided the dead into the afterlife. She’s a deity with a
double role in birth and death (or rebirth of souls into their life
after death). The statue being a hybrid of Sobek and her makes sense
since they were sometimes consorts. Though from looking, both of them
seemed to have gotten around quite a bit.
There are as many
biblical references in this show as Egyptian. In the bible, Jacob and
Esau are twin brothers and bitter rivals. God loved Jacob and hated the
other. Jacob conned his brother out of his birthright. Benjamin is
Jacob’s last son (and his mother died in childbirth). Aaron is a
descendant of Jacob and the first high priest. Lost’s Jacob willingness
to just die is also very Christlike. Maybe he has a long con himself
and sacrificing himself (Ben being Judas) is part of the plan. These
and the Egyptian myths all touch on huge themes and mirror each other
in many aspects.
Thoughts?