Yeah right, I'm pretty sure that might have been what was screwing me up:
A. I had exported my tests from Eclipse, but I never actually modeled my
Eclipse file structure in my ant project, even though I had compiled in
Eclipse, so I was messing around with the compiled file to try to get
my class file to run in my new file structure
B. I had compiled with JRE7 in Eclipse. I changed my JRE system library to JDK1.7 and then compiled using that.
When I compiled using the JDK and changed my project directory to look like my Eclipse workspace, and didn't change the compiled file, everything worked.