Hi John,
Because of the person I am, I've obviously scored them all out of 5. My mind changes constantly though. I just looked at my list again and thought 'how on earth did I not give All About Eve five stars?!
My biggest take aways were:
1. How good the award winners usually are. Yes they sometimes get it wrong, but the films are usually still good. How Green Was My Valley may have beaten Citizen Kane, but it's still a great film I'd recommend to anyone. I scored 49 of them at 4* or better and only 14 as 2* or worse.
2. Most have aged really well. I was blown away by how good the first winner, Wings was, and I was dreading a 30s war film, but All Quiet on the Western Front was not only a remarkable achievement in film making but was a really great, nuanced look at war. In some ways some of the films that have aged the worst are the 80s melodramas, Chariots of Fire, Out of Africa and Kramer v Kramer none of which did a lot for me. (I remember loving Chariots as a kid but boy has it aged poorly.)
3. They are really, really long. So many were pushing 3 hours. We complain films today are too long, but I challenge anyone complaining about length of films today to sit through three hours of The Great Ziegfeld or Patton.
As to favourite? I think Parasite may well be my favourite when all is said and done. But all of my five star ratings: It Happened One Night, Casablanca, The Apartment, In the Heat of the Night, Godfather part II, Silence of the Lambs, Moonlight, Parasite, Lawrence of Arabia.
Worst was probably Patton or Around the World in Eighty Days.
Alex